Did Akhenaten really die in his 17th regnal Year? Here's the ACTUAL evidence.

Museum of European Antiquities
22 followers
Hello, my name is Guy de la Bedmoire, historian and writer, and welcome to my channel. This is
another of my fairly random videos, but today it's about a very interesting topic from Egypt,
ancient Egypt. And you'll see I've posed the question there, did Akhenaten circa 1352 to 1336
BC really die in his 17th regnal year? And below that is a subheading, evolution of a factoid.
What's a factoid? A factoid is something that comes up as an idea, a hypothesis, a theory,
however tenuous. And what happens to it subsequently is it gradually evolves into a fact.
You find other books, other authorities repeating it over and over again until everybody takes it
for granted that that's what really happened. Now, Egyptology and archaeology are absolutely
full of factoids. That's because the nature of the evidence is that it's relatively limited,
often very controversial, often sometimes very dubious. And the consequences of incompetence
and unsubstantiated theorising in ancient Egyptology or archaeology is not air crashes
that kill people or terrible medical disasters. The result is that you can get away with a
surprising amount of academic incompetence in these subjects. So let's just have a look at
this a little closer. Now what I've quoted here is Professor Ronald Ridley of the University of
Melbourne. Now he wrote a brilliant book about Akhenaten in which he pointed out, and I've
quoted him here, there is no statement in Amarnan studies which cannot be contradicted. Now Amarna,
of course, is the adjective or name applied to Akhenaten's reign. We'll talk a little bit more
about him in just a second because the modern name of the site where Akhenaten established
There is no statement in Amarnan studies which cannot be contradicted. And that's because just
about every single piece of the evidence is dubious in some way or other. And he's absolutely
correct in that observation. And when I wrote my own book, Bearers of the Sun, I tried my best
at every point to find out what the evidence really was. And you know what? Most of the time
it turned out to be like sand running through my hands. Often the evidence didn't seem to be
there at all. Or if it was, it was so much vaguer than you might have got the impression from many
books that when he broke it down, often it just didn't really seem to be the basis for very much
at all. Let's take this book here, Cyril Aldred's Akhenaten, King of Egypt. Now it's broadly
speaking a very good book, although I suppose today many people would regard that as being
well out of date. Akhenaten, of course, by some people a heretic bearer, others would regard him
as a revolutionary or a visionary. Whatever he was, he was certainly enigmatic. Akhenaten,
who reigned in the middle of the 14th century BC towards the end of the 18th dynasty, was the
son of Amenhotep III. And we know that what he did very shortly after his reign was develop
the cult of the Akhenaten, the being of the sun, at the expense of all other cults in Egypt. Now
that wasn't a new idea, it had already been around, certainly under his father,
but Akhenaten turned it into something very much more significant. And really,
the question, of course, is how long did it last? But over the next two decades at least,
Egypt was turned upside down. Now the quote from Cyril Aldred here is the death of Akhenaten
probably after the grape harvest in his 17th regnal year. What a wonderfully poetic and
evocative statement. And you know what, it almost sounds like Cyril Aldred had access to a notice
that had been stuck on the palace wall announcing the death of Akhenaten in the latter part of his
17th regnal year, which would be in the, around about the middle of the 1330s BC. And what is
the evidence for that? Now the thing is that Aldred didn't provide any reference for that
statement. Even though the book is fairly well referenced, there's just nothing there.
And if you look in loads of other books about Akhenaten, you will find exactly the same thing.
There's nothing there. The references just aren't there. And I'm not going to name them because
there are lots of, you know, otherwise competent books on Egyptology, particularly about Akhenaten.
Believe me, I've hunted through as many as I possibly could. They don't just get the reference
wrong. And I have to say, as you'll discover, even when I finally thought I'd tracked it down,
I got it wrong to begin with. But these books don't even have that. They just don't have the
reference. And we're going to find out what the evidence is. Now if you turn to this book, which
is William Murnane's, the late William Murnane's book of sources on the Armada period, there's
very little in the way of actual hieroglyphics in it. It almost entirely consists of English
translations. And you will find on page 207, this little inscription in translation, which
consists of two lines, one partially overlying the other. And the first bit of it, in hieratic,
which is the cursive form of Egyptian, it supposedly says Regnal year 17, honey. And
then it appears to have been partially overridden with Regnal year 1, wine. And the whole basis of
this is to say that this must be Akhenaten's Regnal year 17. And therefore, because it's
been replaced by Regnal year 1, that must be one of his successors, probably Tutankhamun.
And therefore, it's been concluded from that, that Akhenaten died in his 17th Regnal year,
and was replaced by Tutankhamun around that time. Well, of course, you can see straight away,
there is no name of the king. So let's be perfectly blunt about that. No kings are named
on this piece of evidence. But it's not wholly unreasonable to suggest that it probably is
Akhenaten, because it says Regnal year 17, and because it was found in Armada. Now that broadly
fits with some of the other evidence for Akhenaten's reign. But it doesn't say anything
about him dying. And it ought to be perfectly obvious to anybody with an ounce of intelligence
or imagination that just because that jar was used in the 17th Regnal year to contain honey,
it might have lain around for some time before it was reused. In other words, there's absolutely
no guarantee that it was reused immediately to have wine put into it. So you can see that this
is already a fairly suspect piece of evidence. It might amplify or embellish the theory of Akhenaten
dying around that time. But it is absolutely not possible to conclude from this that Akhenaten
only reigned for 17 years. Now, let's just put a few things into picture here. Over on the left,
what I've got here is a map of the Armada area. So it's roughly between where Memphis was and
where Thebes was, halfway between. This was Akhenaten's new city, built on the east bank
of the Nile. The royal tombs over here. Extensive evidence. Excavations have gone on in bits and
pieces around here. Also the clearance of the tombs. There's noble tombs down here. There are
other noble tombs up there. And the royal tomb is over here. There's also some evidence on the
west bank. And this is one of the boundaries stele. And that's on the west bank of the Nile
that demarcated the territory. So as I said, a lot of excavations there over the last century
or more. And amongst those have been various bits of evidence, which include dockets on wine jars
and vessels that help give us an understanding of the sort of length of reign that might have
taken place while Akhenaten with his queen Nefertiti there, adoring the solar disk while
they reigned there. However, there's so much I could say about Akhenaten here. I'm not going to
do so because that's all for another time. And I've got other PowerPoints about this now. But
by around year 14 into the reign, his daughter, his second daughter, Nefertiti dies.
Akhenaten and Nefertiti appear to have had six daughters. What you can see here in the drawing
there is Akhenaten followed by Nefertiti and then their eldest daughter Nefertiti. And they appear
to be mourning before a statue, which is a representation of Mekhetaten. And this is from
the royal tomb. And there's no question about from other inscriptions in there, in this little annex
to the royal tomb that she had been buried in there. That's quite important because Mekhetaten's
death didn't really fit into the Atenist ideology. And because they disbanded, that's the right word,
all the old traditional funerary gods. And recreating the theology of death and the
afterlife is itself a very difficult topic to understand in the Akhenaten period. And no doubt
was for them at the time too because, you know, this man probably a fanatic, possibly mentally
unbalanced in some way. Certainly he was obsessed. He probably really hadn't envisaged this long-term
outcome just despite the building of the tombs. But anyway, there's no question about the fact
that she died. And around about that time, possibly after year 12, Queen Tiye, his mother,
the Dowager Queen of Armenhotep III, and quite clearly from other evidence a dominant figure
at Armana, she just disappears from the record. So we have to assume that she died. And we know
from the evidence of fragments of what appeared to be her sarcophagus and other bits and pieces
from the royalty that she was probably at least initially buried there. But relatively recently
we have this. Now this I've just clipped out here, a grab from the academic journal. You can see it's
12 years ago. The year 16 graffito of Akhenaten and Abu Hines. Now this is a very important piece
of evidence. It's fully published and it's a very good example of how the appearance of one
single new piece of evidence can change everything. And there is the graffito at the top. Now typically
it's written right to left. It does appear to be in hieroglyphics and as with all academic
conventions in Egyptology, it then gets redrawn in hieroglyphs and properly and then printed out.
So if we go down to here you can see this little bit here is very important, possibly quite hard
for you to see there, but this gives us the date. Now those first three symbols, those
indicate regnal year. What looks like an upside down U is 10 and then there are
some vertical stripes, six of them. So that 10 plus six, that's the 16th regnal year.
And then it goes on for the first month etc. So it clarifies the date a bit more. But
if we just have a look closely we've got, and you can see there, there's the regnal year rather
more clearly laid out. And then the first month of the inundation, which is that March land there.
And then day 15, you've got 10 and 5, 1. So there we are, that's all clarified. It's royal titles
and we've got over here Neferkeperu Re Wa Indre, which is the throne name for Akhenaten. And there
is his birth name Akhenaten on the next line. These are all very standard sort of titles here,
and here we have Nefernefer Neferneferu Aten, which is Nefertiti. So this is brilliant isn't
it? Because what it actually tells us pretty unequivocally, and this is a good example of
unequivocal evidence, relatively so, we can see that Nefertiti and Akhenaten are alive,
at least officially, in year 16. And that is a genuine, and we'll discuss this in a little bit
more detail in a second, termless post-crime. We know that both of them can only have died
later in that year or afterwards, unless this is completely fictional. But that doesn't seem
to be very likely. So just to recap there, we've got the regnal year date up here,
we've got the two names of Akhenaten there and there, and then we have Nefertiti and her titles
down here. So that's all tremendous stuff, and that's very good. But what about the 17th regnal
year? Now, when did he really die? Was it really the 17th regnal year that there's the relief from
Amarna of Akhenaten and Nefertiti, and there they are in one of the royal's noble tombs,
being propelled along in chariots in one of their parades through the city. So,
you know, it was all quite a sort of dynamic, vivid sort of place. But we know that,
of course, Akhenaten disappears from the scene. Now, I've got to admit, when I was going through
trying to create my book, I was just determined to try and track down this wretched poacher
with the 17th regnal year in inscription. Now, I made a mistake, I freely admit that I did. So I
found this in the Petrie Museum in London, and I thought this was it, because it starts off
with 17th regnal year. Very difficult to read, and I was entirely wrong, as I recently discovered,
in believing that that was the one. Nevertheless, it doesn't actually alter the principle
of the true meaning of the graffiti. I have now actually tracked it down. Well,
not the original poacher, but I have tracked it down. And this is it. So here we are. It's
Pendlebury and Cerny, the city of Akhenaten, the central city in the official quarters,
volume three. And you can find the text for that, and the plates. You can find them online,
and, for example, sources like the Internet Archive. There's the title page of the book.
Now, this is a drawing which appears in the book of the actual graffito. So we'd have to have a
closer look at that now. This is the very one. There's no photograph of the actual poacher,
and I have got no idea where that poacher is now. So what we've got, once again,
those three symbols there. Haq Esb, is sort of what it says, and that is regnal year. There's 10,
and there are seven ones. So that's 17. So it's the 17th regnal year. And then we have Biti.
Now, that is a bee, and it's, of course, also symbol of the king of Lower Egypt.
But here it's used in a typical hieroglyphic way to represent an idea. And, of course,
bees are easily associated with honey. So there you are. So Biti. So 17th regnal year, Biti.
So it suggests that the jar that this was once, this sherd was once part of, was indeed
used in the 17th regnal year, and had honey in it. And then it's got down here,
and it's not entirely clear from the drawing, because this looks like a drawing of the edge
of the sherd. So, in fact, this later inscription appears to be just below it, but you'll see that
it's broken. Now, that means that it is a reasonable reconstruction to say that this
is regnal year, because you can see it's the same as that. And then there's the stroke for one,
that's bigger because there's only one digit. And then we have the feather hieroglyph, which
represents what we sometimes call the letter I. And the word for wine is erup, or it's
transliterated as I-R-P, erup. So, again, it's not a totally unreasonable supposition, is it,
to say that that's wine. But there is the evidence. Now, I reiterate what I said earlier.
There is nothing about Akhenaten here. There's nothing about Tutankhamen. And we have absolutely
no way of knowing how much time elapsed between the jar's use for containing honey and then for
containing wine. It quite obviously could perfectly easily have lain around for some time. Now, just
in Pompeii, I have seen amphorae reused right up until the time of the eruption in AD 79,
but which are actually types belonging to the mid-first century BC. In other words,
they've been lying around in Pompeii for as much as 120, 130 years. Now, that's not going to be
the case in Armana, because Armana, Akhenaten City, was not occupied for that long. We know
it wasn't. The whole place was given up. There's no subsequent building there. The place becomes
a sandblown, windswept ruin and the site is abandoned, which is what makes it such an
invaluable archaeological deposit. So the likelihood is there isn't that likely to be
that much time between those two. But, if we take the example of a couple of instances in the
Middle Kingdom of Egypt from an earlier period, where the Turin Canon, I think it's called, gives
the lists of reigns for kings in that period. But the actual physical evidence in at least two
instances, in the form of dockets like this for those two kingdoms, actually are much shorter,
much earlier in the reign. Just because you haven't got a docket or a graffito for later dates
in a way, doesn't mean it didn't happen. So you can see that at every level this piece of evidence
doesn't really hold up beyond the most tenuous supporting of the idea that Akhenaten probably died
within a few years of that critically important year 16 quarry graffito. Now that's something that
really ought to be obvious to Egyptologists, archaeologists and historians alike. But yet,
as I said, in book after book of Akhenaten you will find it being repeated as a fact,
in this almost poetic way, that he died as the year drew to a close, as the grapes were gathered
in in the 17th year. Now this all comes down to this key archaeological concept of terminus
post-quem. Now it's so basic, it's so elementary, yet it has staggered me over the years working
in this subject. How many people, but even professionals, seem willfully not to understand
this. I remember once being on a time team day when the great, famous and lovely man,
was looking at a coin that we found and he said, now we've got a date, he said. Now we've got a
date. No you don't have a date, mate. What we had was a terminus post-quem. It was a time after which
everything in that deposit could have happened. And it could have been decades, generations later.
It is just marks. A coin like that, or a docket like the one that I've just mentioned from
except the difference is the coins actually date themselves in an absolute sense. Just because we
have the 17th year doesn't tell us the actual chronological date that was, so that's a sort
of separate issue. But they both give us a date after which something must have happened, except
of course that in Akhenaten's case it doesn't even name him. So the real one, the one, the real
terminus post-quem for Akhenaten is that year 16 quarry inscription because it names him and it
names Nefertiti. That is the terminus post-quem for Akhenaten. So the only true statement you
can make about Akhenaten's death is that he died later in the 16th regional year or after it.
That's it. It probably wasn't more than a few years. It may only have been one year,
but you can't prove it and it's not a statement of fact. What we end up later with, of course,
is KV55. Now I've posted a video about this before. KV55 in the Valley of the Kings 255.
This is the wrecked and ruinous tomb that contained the remains of a male body. It doesn't matter to
me who that body is. What's clear to me is that all we're left with here are fragmentary traces
of what that tomb was. And those fragmentary traces suggest to me that ultimately Tutankhamen
used it as a depository for Akhenaten, for Nefertiti and another T. All three of those
bodies may subsequently have been removed. T's certainly was and she's probably the elder lady
found in the cat world cache in Tutankhamen alongside the body known as the younger lady,
who may or may not have been Nefertiti. Whether this remaining body in 255 was Akhenaten or not
and the so-called mysterious Menkaure, his relative, brother, son, nobody knows for certain.
It's a very shadowy figure. It doesn't matter to me because we can't possibly tell who it was.
But what we can tell from the other evidence in the tomb, like the magic bricks, for example,
the presence of Ti's shrine, which had clearly been bought from Amarna,
the fact that this is a male body suggests to me that that was probably what it was originally,
but only probably. We can't prove it. It's impossible to do so. But what is certain,
of course, is that Akhenaten and Nefertiti died at some point because we do know for a fact that
Tutankhamen became king. But really the question is just how long time, how much time? So there we
are. That's looking again. There we are. That is, if you're ever reading a book about Akhenaten,
you see, oh, Akhenaten died in the year 17, 17th regnal year, and we know that for a fact. Well,
you now know that we don't know that for a fact. We just know that there was a potsherd found at
Amarna that names an unnamed king's 17th regnal year and another unnamed king's first regnal year.
And what you make of that, frankly, is up to you. But armed with that information,
you're going to be a lot better informed than you might have been. And I now certainly am,
too. And I don't ever get a chance to reissue Pharaohs of the Sun. It won't change the points
that I made in the accompanying note, but I will be able to supply a correct reference for the
potsherd. There you are. If you have been, I hope you've enjoyed listening. Thank you very much
indeed.
