After World War 2, the Royal Australian Navy embarked on a strategy of blue water operations centered around aircraft carriers. But the aircraft strategy for the Royal Australian Navy wasn’t to last with the HMAS Melbourne being decommissioned in 1982. Could Australia have continued to operate a carrier battle group for its defence and projection of power?
Support this channel by joining our Members & Merch shop at https://peacemaker.fashion for ad-free early access, exclusive military fashion discounts, and more perks.
____________ Disclaimer ____________ Original footage and recreated scenes may not be 100% accurate to the event being described but has been used for dramatic effect. This is because there may not have been original footage of a particular event available, or copyright prevents us from showing it. Our aim is to be as historically true as we can be given the materials available.
Copyright disclaimer under fair dealing sections ss 40/103C, ss 41/103A,ss 42/103B of the Copyright Act which includes research, study, criticism, review, and reporting of news. Copyright remains with the respective owners. These videos are made for educational purposes only.
The Australian Military Aviation History Association is a not-for-profit association with the intent of recording, preserving and promoting Australian military aviation history.
After World War II, the Royal Australian Navy embarked on a strategy of blue water operations
centered around aircraft carriers. They acquired two light fleet carriers, HMAS Sydney and HMAS
Melbourne from the Royal Navy. The Royal Navy loaned a Colossus-class light aircraft carrier,
the Vengeance, to the Royal Australian Navy from 1952 to 1955 as a temporary replacement
for the delayed HMAS Melbourne, which finally entered service in 1955. But the aircraft
strategy for the Royal Australian Navy wasn't to last with the HMAS Melbourne being decommissioned
in 1982 and sold for scrap to the Chinese in 1985. Could Australia have continued to
operate a carrier battle group for its defense and projection of power? During World War II,
the aircraft carrier emerged as a game changer. The Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor and the
American response proved that the aircraft could change the course of a naval battle.
By integrating aircraft into a naval force, the range, effectiveness, and defensive capability
of a force is massively increased. In World War II, navies without this projection of power
would suffer the consequences. Even the Royal Navy, once the greatest seafaring force,
was confronted with this reality following a series of successful Japanese naval attacks in
As such, it was decided that the Royal Australian Navy should be equipped to compete with carrier
forces or at least demonstrate good defense from them. However, the war would be over before such
aircraft carriers would be delivered to Australia. Nevertheless, the aircraft carrier remained an
important long-term purchase. The order was placed for two aircraft carriers of the Royal
Navy Majestic class. The first was the HMS Terrible, launched by the Royal Navy in 1944.
She was purchased by the Royal Australian Navy in 1947, following its completion,
was commissioned in 1948, and renamed HMAS Sydney. The second carrier was the HMS Majestic, launched
in 1945 by the Royal Navy, and purchased by the Royal Australian Navy in 1947. Renamed HMAS
Melbourne, the ship was finally commissioned for Australian use in 1955. At the time, the Melbourne
was the third aircraft carrier produced to feature an angled flight deck, a development considered
truly cutting edge for its time. However, due to the prolonged wait for the Melbourne to be completed,
a third aircraft carrier would also serve the Royal Australian Navy. That carrier was the HMS
Vengeance, a Colossus class carrier which would retain its namesake during Australian Navy service.
The Vengeance, although never seeing active service, had been completed before the war's end
for use in the British Pacific Fleet as part of the 11th aircraft carrier squadron.
The Vengeance was loaned to the Australian Navy in 1952, compensating for the delay of the Melbourne
and would remain in service until she was returned to the Royal Navy in 1955. While in service,
a number of aircraft would operate from the Vengeance, including Royal Australian Navy
Hawker Sea Furies and Fairy Fireflies. Like the Vengeance, the Sydney also carried a variety of
Sea Furies and Fireflies, usually 12 each. This was complemented initially by two Supermarine Sea Otter
rescue aircraft, which were not attached to any squadron. The Sea Otters were later dropped from
carrier service during the Korean War. The Sydney was deployed to the Korean War in August 1951
to keep a Commonwealth carrier presence in the region, as the Royal Navy's HMS Glory was
undergoing refitting in Australia. Setting sail on August 31st, she would travel to Korea alongside
the HMAS Tobruk, first stopping in Rabaul and performing several aerial demonstrations.
Once near Korea, she came under the command of the US Navy's 7th Fleet, where Royal Australian
Navy aircraft were used for strikes against North Korean supply lines. During this period,
she set a record for a light carrier, with 89 aircraft sorties in one day, with 31 aircraft
in the air at one point. During her time near Korea, the Sydney would operate a US Navy Sikorsky
Dragonfly. Not only was this the first US Navy equipment to be used by the Royal Australian Navy,
but it was also the first helicopter to operate from an Australian ship. During an interesting
incident on October 26th, 1951, an Australian Firefly from the Sydney was shot down deep
within North Korean territory following a strike on a railway tunnel. Roughly 120 kilometers inland,
the crew of the Sydney feared that a rescue would be impossible as the evening set in,
as it would be at the limit of a helicopter's range and flying in the dark would be difficult.
Nevertheless, the US Navy Sikorsky crew volunteered to head in, and at 4.22, they took off. According
to reports, the aerial observer was quickly taught how to operate an Owen submachine gun before
taking off. Meanwhile, Australian Navy Fireflies had been providing cover for the downed crew,
but as evening set in, they were ordered to return to the carrier. However, two of the aircraft would
turn around on their way back after noticing the Sikorsky heading in. At half past five,
the Sikorsky arrived, picking up the crew as the aerial observer opened fire with his submachine
gun, supported by two Fireflies also opening fire. Flying back, all three of the aircraft were
dangerously low on fuel, but all returned safely, with the Fireflies landing on the Sydney and the
Sikorsky landing near Seoul with the help of truck headlights to locate the airbase.
This was the longest helicopter rescue recorded during the entire Korean War.
This incident provided additional motivation for Australia to purchase its first helicopters,
the Bristol-Sycamore. The Sydney would continue serving in Korea until January 25th, 1952,
when she was relieved by HMS Glory. The Sydney would later operate during the Vietnam War,
supporting the first Australian task force, earning it the nickname the Vung Tau Ferry.
From 1965, the Sydney would transport troops, vehicles, and supplies to Vietnam. This would
continue through until November 1972. Due to the Sydney's reallocation as a troop transport,
this would leave the Melbourne as the only properly operational Australian aircraft carrier.
Not long after, on November 12th, 1973, the Sydney was decommissioned from service.
There would be no replacement for her, leaving the Melbourne as the only carrier in Australian service.
During her service life, the HMAS Melbourne carried upwards of 20 fixed-wing aircraft at a time,
peaking at 27 fixed-wing aircraft during the early 1970s. In its early years, the carrier was home
to the de Havilland Venom, operating as fighter by the Navy's 808 and 805 squadrons, and the Ferry
Gannet, operating in an anti-submarine role by the 816 and 817 squadrons. By the late 1960s,
the Melbourne would be operating two new types of aircraft, the Douglas A4G Skyhawk and the Grumman
S2 E-Tracker. The Skyhawk was operated by Navy 724 and 805 squadrons as a multi-role aircraft
modified for better air defense for the Royal Australian Navy, while the Tracker was operated
by 816 and 851 squadrons in its standard anti-submarine role. Alongside these aircraft
were the Westland Wessex anti-submarine helicopter, later replaced in 1972 by the Westland Sea King.
The air group was usually made up of 10 helicopters, 4 Skyhawks and 6 Trackers.
As it was for the Sydney, the Melbourne would also be sent to the Vietnam War,
however her role would be limited. Although there were plans to utilize Melbourne more
fully in the Vietnam War, her primary operations were escorting the Sydney in its role as ferry.
Being the only operational aircraft carrier in Australian service, the Navy had decided
to limit its actions around Southeast Asia. During its life, the Melbourne was involved
in two deadly incidents. The first took place on February 10th 1964, when the carrier collided
with the Australian destroyer HMAS Voyager, killing 82 of the Voyager's crew. Then, on June
3rd 1969, the Melbourne collided with a US Navy destroyer, the USS Frank E. Evans, resulting in
74 fatalities for the Americans. Both incidents were the byproducts of strange circumstances,
which led to superstition around the Melbourne. The Melbourne would live on, serving with the
in 1982. Since the Melbourne was first commissioned, there had been discussions
surrounding her replacement, should she need one. Proposals included purchasing a larger carrier.
Both the Americans and British responded favorably, with the Americans offering an
Essex-class carrier and the British offering the HMS Hermes. Australia would not have needed
to purchase either, with the only price being the refitting required to make the carriers
compatible with Australian aircraft. However, it was decided that the operational cost and
manpower would be too high, and both offers were turned down. Following decommission,
the Melbourne was to be converted into a floating casino. However, this plan fell through,
and it was decided to sell the carrier to a Chinese wrecking company in 1985.
In an interesting turn of events, the carrier, after being towed to China, was studied by the
The research was part of a plan to develop effective aircraft carriers for the Chinese Navy,
while providing a platform to train aviators of the People's Liberation Army Naval Air Force
in carrier flight operations. Few anticipated this use of the carrier, as China at the time
was not seen as capable of developing aircraft carriers for themselves. Reports of these events
vary, with some claiming the Chinese government made the purchase through the China United Ship
Company. However, Rear Admiral Zhang Zhong remembers the carrier as a surprise arrival.
The Navy had not realized that such a purchase had been made until the giant ship arrived at port.
Upon arrival, Navy personnel were sent to look over the ship, with many saying that it was the
largest warship they had ever seen. Despite being stripped of important electronic components,
several other pieces of intact equipment remained, including the steam catapult
and landing system. It has been said that the research of the Melbourne
helped convince the Chinese government to invest into a carrier development program,
which had been spearheaded by the People's Liberation Army Navy Admiral Liu Huaqing,
but had failed to receive the necessary funding until these events transpired.
The Melbourne remains the most iconic of three aircraft carriers Australia operated,
and is commemorated in various ways at Sydney's Royal Australian Navy Base at Garden Island.
The decommissioning of the Melbourne marked a change in the way the Royal Australian Navy
operated. While smaller ships would still allow for the movement of men, equipment,
and even helicopters, the aircraft carrier was truly unique in its ability to project air power.
There would have to be alternate strategies for the Navy and Air Force,
but would they result in the same level of effectiveness in the defense of Australia?
Japan's decision to deploy the F-35B variant of the Joint Strike Fighter from its Izumo-class
warships is said by some to be a game-changer, as these ships will essentially become small
aircraft carriers. Could Australia do the same with its Canberra-class amphibious assault ships,
the HMAS Canberra and the HMAS Adelaide? The idea of flying F-35Bs from the Canberra-class
vessels has been around for almost a decade, with Japan's recent decision sparking further debate
about Australia's need to project power and support expeditionary forces beyond the range
of land-based air cover. The Canberra and Adelaide are larger than Australia's previous
aircraft carrier, the Melbourne, and have the necessary infrastructure, including a ski jump,
to operate short take-off and vertical landing aircraft. The acquisition of conventional F-35A
jets opens up the possibility of acquiring F-35Bs for operation off the current landing
helicopter docks from these ships. Both in theory and practice, the U.S. Marine Corps
have already optimized the effectiveness of the F-35B on its own large amphibious assault ships.
The F-35B offers clear operational advantages. Even a small force of these jets could provide
air support for joint task forces, perform fleet air defense, offer close air support for ground
forces, and carry out intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance missions. The F-35 is at the
pinnacle of aerial dominance for Australia, and is well-suited for underprepared airfields
across Southeast Asia. As a carrier-based aircraft, it offers a projection of power
in the regions that is currently unavailable. This capability would also enhance support for
Allied F-35B operators when coordinating in the region. However, the Canberra-class amphibious
warships are designed to conduct amphibious warfare. Converting the Canberra and Adelaide
to operate as an aircraft carrier for jets would be costly and impact their amphibious capabilities.
There would be limitations operationally from the ship compared to a dedicated aircraft carrier,
and the F-35B variant has limitations in terms of speed, range, and weapons payload compared to
other F-35 variants, especially when operating in full stealth mode. Additionally, the carrier
would require a task force of surface ships to provide protection, as with any carrier group,
and in the case where there is no coalition force providing that protection.
Today, the aircraft carrier is all but a distant memory for Australia.
Given increased geopolitical tension, dialogue regarding the necessity of Australia-possessing
aircraft carriers has once again emerged. Despite its costly nature, there is a strong
case to be made for the aircraft carrier battle group. However, the debate continues
as to how Australia's air and sea power can best serve her in defence.