NTD's legal correspondent Arleen Richards provides a review of some of the Supreme Court’s most talked-about cases in 2025. Several hot-button issues addressed this year include transgender rights, presidential authority, and the First Amendment. -- 📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
Next, NTD's Arlene Richards brings us a
review of some memorable Supreme Court
cases and decisions during the past year
and a preview of what to expect in 2026.
Take a look. As we look back at the
Supreme Court's docket in 2025, there
have been a number of cases that took
center stage in the news this year. The
court issued around 67 opinions in the
2024 to 2025 term, which ended in June.
And before they left for the summer, the
justices granted review of 32 cases with
two more added on since they returned in
October. In addition, the court issued
20 decisions from its emergency docket
during the summer. Several hot button
issues addressed this year include
transgender rights, presidential
authority, and the first amendment. On
the merits docket, in which the rulings
are final and the issues will not go
back to any lower courts, a case that
stands out address judicial authority.
CASA versus Trump involves an executive
order on birthright citizenship which
eliminates a year'slong practice of
giving automatic citizenship to babies
born in the US. But the issue presented
to the court was whether federal judges
had the authority to universally
restrict the president's executive
orders. The Supreme Court said federal
judges only had the authority to provide
remedies that are tailored specifically
to the parties involved in the case,
which means the solution would not apply
to individuals or entities that had not
filed a claim. President Trump applauded
the decision.
>> But in recent months, we've seen a
handful of radical left judges
effectively try to overrule the rightful
powers of the president to stop the
American people from getting the
policies that they voted for. So, what
does that mean for the cases that
challenge executive orders? An attorney
explained to ABC News.
>> You're going to see more lawsuits filed
and more lawsuits with class action
allegations because no more can you find
one judge in one obscure county to issue
a nationwide injunction. Instead, you're
going to has to have to ask a judge to
certify a class and uh follow those
procedural rules, which are cumbersome.
The justices left open some narrow
pathways to universal restrictions where
no other remedies would work. Another
hot button issue this year, transgender
rights. The justices heard a few cases
on this topic, but a case that stands
out is United States versus Scetti. The
court ruled that a Tennessee law
prohibiting medical professionals from
providing gender transition drugs to
minors was legal. An ACLU attorney who
challenged the law said it violated the
14th amendment.
>> We think it's quite obvious that the law
does classify based on sex and that the
court in this case had to do a lot of
back flips uh to get around the the
logic that they use that the case uh
that the law um doesn't classify based
on sex. The Skirmedi ruling didn't
settle broader questions about
transgender rights or other state bans.
The court is expected to address more
transgender rights issues in that case
as well as in others, including a case
about transgender students participating
in girls sports. In Alabama, parents
sued a public school for the right to
opt their children out of instruction
that uses LGBTQI inclusive story books.
The school board had ended its opt out
policy when it received numerous
requests. Oral argument in this case
lasted two and a half hours with Justice
Brett Kavanaaugh at one point saying to
the school's attorney, "This is a tough
case to argue." And I guess I'm just not
understanding the whole uh goal I think
of some of our religion precedents is to
look for the win-win to look for the
situation where you can respect the
religious beliefs and accommodate the
religious beliefs while the state or
city or whatever it may be can pursue
its goals. Other significant first
amendment cases before the court
involved commercial websites publishing
sexually explicit content and the
eligibility of religious charter schools
to receive state funds. Another avenue
for relief is through the shadow docket.
The court makes decisions on these
matters outside of the regular case
docket such as over the summer during
their recess. The Trump administration
submitted several emergency applications
during the recess, many involving
appeals of lower court rulings that
block significant executive orders. The
Supreme Court's orders on this docket
have largely been in favor of the
administration. For example, the court
allowed for the administration's global
tariffs to temporarily remain in place
while the case waits for a final
decision. In November, they heard
arguments on whether the president
overstepped his authority when he
imposed sweeping tariffs on foreign
nations. Several justices were skeptical
of arguments on both sides. What could
the remedy be if the government loses?
Justice Amy Coney Barrett said the
reimbursement process could be a mess.
The final decision on this case is
likely to be a close call, but the court
hasn't always ruled in Trump's favor.
Just recently, the majority denied the
administration's request to keep
deployed National Guardsmen in Illinois.
They ruled that the administration must
first use the military to enforce
federal law. Next year, the court will
decide several cases that could expand
or stifle the president's power, making
it one of the most significant terms in
decades. Arlene Richards, NTD News.