Misconceptions Ep. 9 - No Animal Husbandry

Ancient Africans
8 followers
Jan 1, 2026
Hello everyone, it's Jabari here, and welcome to episode 9 of Misconceptions.
Africa is a place full of wild animals and seemingly untamed wilderness.
In fact, I feel like it's safe to say that here in the West, Africa's animals are more
popular than any city, event, place, media, or even human being that hails from the continent.
With such a wide array of wild animals of all shapes and sizes and colors, shouldn't
we expect most if not a large part of our current domestic animal species to have originated
here?
And what about the mass extinction of megafauna and the Quaternary extinction period?
Why did so many large animals die off elsewhere in the world, but not Africa?
Were humans in other parts of the world simply just better hunters, or were there other factors
at play?
Today, we will clear up these misconceptions, as there are several reasons why Africa has
a relatively wide variety of animal life and why there is such a popular belief that no
African animals were ever domesticated.
So first, let's do the easy one, which is the false notion that Africans never domesticated
any animals.
The donkey, for example, was domesticated in Northeast Africa as early as 5,000 years
ago, and cats are believed to have been domesticated several times in the same region independently
just much earlier.
As well as in the Near East due to the vast sedentary lifestyles that took hold in the
region as early as the year 7500 BCE, it is believed that this dense concentration of
human activity and the resulting filth would have attracted rodents and birds, much like
it does in the present day actually, which would have also attracted wild cats to these
areas for the plentiful source of food.
The guinea fowl is a domesticated animal from Sub-Saharan Africa, and though it's not
known when it was domesticated, it was known in ancient Greece since the year 400 BCE.
Other animals that entered Africa from other parts of the world have been present on the
continent for several millennia, with the oldest stone remains of domestic sheep, for
example, dating back to over 9,000 years ago.
Despite some of these animals not really being initially domesticated in Africa, the select
of breeding giving them the immunity and hardiness to resist African climate and diseases is
an entirely different feat in and of itself.
African cattle, for example, experienced so much selective breeding over the millennia
that they are very distinct from Eurasian breeds, so much so that it's not fully known
by geneticists if they were independently domesticated or not.
This fact is especially evident when early war trekkers could not keep their European
breeds of livestock alive in southern Africa, while local breeds of the Bantu people thrived.
African cattle breeds among many animals such as dogs and chickens all tend to follow this
same model and it is thus important to keep a focus on African mastery of these animals
on their continent rather than where the species originated thousands of years ago.
This is the same trend followed by most of Europe's animals, as a matter of fact.
Just as with African livestock, they have their origins in the Near East.
Isolated instances of taming have also contributed to the misconception of African domestication.
Hannibal, among other great conquerors of the past, are known to have utilized elephants
for warfare.
This is often cited as proof that African people simply lacked the intuition necessary
to master their own animals.
However, there are two important reasons why this is false.
The first reason being that black Africans actually did indeed utilize elephants for
warfare, or more specifically, the people of the Kingdom of Kush.
Secondly, these elephants were most likely either imported from Asia, which has an indigenous
population of a much smaller and more docile species, or the North African elephant, also
known as the Atlas elephant, which has been extinct since Roman times and was even smaller
than the Asian elephant.
The sub-Saharan African species of elephant would not only be too large and cumbersome
to transport across the Sahara, but also most likely be too dangerous and aggressive to
tame.
This is why the Asian elephant is typically used for circuses and movies, like the ones
used in the 1937 live-action Tarzan movie, which was just an Asian elephant with large
fake ears attached to it to make it look like an African elephant.
Europeans attempted to domesticate the zebra all throughout the 19th and 20th centuries,
with one notable example being the Zebra Cavalry used by the Germans in 1911, but we'll talk
about that more later.
It wasn't just foreign peoples who took advantage of wild animals either.
The King of the Benin Empire that once existed in what is now modern-day Nigeria would regularly
be seen parading around his court with tamed leopards on leashes.
Despite all of these instances, the fact remains that all of these animals were tamed from
the wild and not domesticated.
And that's because some animals just can't be domesticated.
And I'd even go as far as to say that most can't.
Jared Diamond, author of Guns, Germs, and Steel, states that out of over 100 possible
candidates for large animals, only 14 have ever been domesticated, and nearly all of
He also states that strict criteria is required for domestication, such as short growth periods,
high fertility rates, calm temperament, and a relative tolerance of human presence.
Very few animals have all of these traits, and thus are unable to be domesticated.
The difficulty domesticating African animals rests almost exclusively in the temperament
category, with African animals typically exhibiting more anxiety, aggression, and paranoia than
their counterparts in other parts of the world.
As covered earlier when comparing African and Asian elephants.
Scientists have demonstrated that even when born, raised, and bred in captivity, this
pattern remains consistent, confirming that these characteristics are innate from a genetic
level, and it is thus theorized that these behaviors are a response to human presence.
With Africa being the birthplace of mankind, many of today's species have evolved alongside
us.
Animals that were not aggressive or easily spooked quickly succumbed to early human hunters
and eventually fell extinct.
Those that did manage to remain were able to do so because of how they reacted to human
presence, with a sharp fight or flight response.
This rule even reverses on occasion, with African wildcats for example being easily
domesticated, but European wildcats being impossible to domesticate, despite their similarities.
In the overwhelming majority of cases however, it's the other way around, with African animals
being the ones that cannot be domesticated.
A classic example being horses and zebras.
Zebras display extreme aggression, panic under the slightest amount of pressure, and are
unpredictable by nature.
They have even been known to attack humans.
And unlike horses, once they bite, they do not let go.
Like at all.
They can even kill a human with a single kick.
They also hold the title of being responsible for more injuries to zookeepers than any other
animal.
That's right, more than lions, tigers, cheetahs, and other large predatory animals.
In fact, the differences between horses and zebras are more than just behavioral, but
also biological.
For example, zebras demonstrate peripheral vision that is far superior to that of horses,
allowing them to see a wider range of their surroundings, and thus are incredibly difficult
to catch or tame, let alone domesticate.
Even lions have been shown to get spooked to the point of abandoning their kill from
the mere sound of a calm and neutral human voice, which goes hand in hand with the tradition
of saying, hey bear, when trekking through the woods.
The sound of a human voice will scare away any potential predators.
Other animals like the dodo bird did not fare very well because of their lack of fear of
man when they first arrived.
A similar process would have most likely taken place when early man first began populating
the other continents.
In Africa, reactions of extreme aggression, evasion of humans, and heightened senses are
a direct result of millions of years of evolution alongside humans and earlier hominids, with
natural selection favoring animals that expressed these traits.
Those that lacked them were more likely to be killed by humans and thus wiped from the
gene pool.
Oh yeah, and just to clear something up, Africa actually did experience a mass extinction
during the Quaternary event too, with several species dying off at the same time as mammoths
and other megafauna did elsewhere.
Just as with other historical references, Africa simply doesn't receive as much attention.
Human overhunting was more than likely just one of multiple factors that led to this event,
and there is no definitive consensus as to why it happened.
Anyway, back on topic, if the species was not completely wiped out, the survivors were
the ones with the genetic and behavioral advantages necessary to survive.
Africa also hosts countless species of non-human predators as well, which certainly contributed
to this trend of animal behavior in an already relatively harsh environment.
This can be observed outside of Africa too.
Deer, for example, run very, very, very far away from humans, and have even evolved to
duck and dodge arrows through pure reflex the moment they hear the sound of a bow release.
We humans kill adult animals at 14 times the rate seen in the wild, and we even kill predatory
species up to 9 times more often than they kill each other.
Animals like wildcats have never really been a target for humans, and thus their fear of
us is restricted to just a quick flee while viewing us from afar, yet at a still relatively
close distance.
Animals like birds, fish, and large mammals will get as far away from the human as they
possibly can.
To present, Africa continues to host the world's most aggressive animals, with hippos being
responsible for more deaths per year out of any other mammal on Earth.
Despite their deceptive appearance of being gentle, lazy, and slow creatures, after hippos
are African elephants and African lions.
With rapid human population growth, climate change, and modern firearms, Africa's animal
species are now declining at an alarming rate.
Perhaps with the rapid growth and development and subsequent stability of African nations,
better measures will be taken to protect the diverse animals that evolved alongside our
ancestors in the past.
Thanks for watching guys, and always remember, we don't come from nothing.
