California’s electricity rates are far higher than most of the country, and that gap did not emerge from a single decision or moment. It developed over time as the state responded to real challenges, with effects that became clearer only years later. In this episode, we speak with James Boyd, a former California Energy Commissioner. Drawing on decades of public service, he explains how the state arrived here, and how growing pressure on the grid may influence the choices ahead.
00:00 - Intro 01:13 - High Utility Rates and Wildfire Impact 03:28 - Historical Decisions and Climate Policies 08:47 - Challenges with Renewable Energy and Biomass 15:08 - Future of Utility Rates and Policy Recommendations 18:25 - Impact of AI and Data Centers on Energy Demand 24:57 - Policy Recommendations and Personal Commitment
Electricity rates in California are double the national average and they might be rising from
here. Our guest today is Jim Boyd who's the former California Energy Commissioner and former CARB
Director. He's here to tell us why the electricity rates in California are rising and what's coming
next. There's past practices that have built an expensive base that just has continued itself to
get larger and larger. The long-term contracts were expensive and they added a new level to the
base of California rates and regulation. So that adds to this stacking up over time of
decisions that are made. I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
Jim, it's great to have you on. Welcome. Thank you very much. It's a pleasure to be here and
a pleasure to meet you. We want to talk to you about the California and utility and energy.
You're an expert in this space. You've spent a lot of time in the state. You have a lot of
experience with what's happening. The rates are a lot higher than the rest of the nation. It's almost
double. Why is that? The last time I looked it was about 96% higher than the rest of the nation
and that's an average across the whole state. PG&E is 104% higher than it used to be 10 years ago.
There are a lot of current analyses of what's wrong with California. I'll start with them but
I think there's past practices that have built a base on an expensive base that just has
continued itself to get larger and larger. Currently the number one thing on most people's
analyses that I tend to agree with is the wildfire situation. Utilities are damaged by
wildfires. Their infrastructure gets burned and it's expensive to replace and they have to replace
it. Infrastructure costs go into the rate for electricity and rate payers pay for it.
Utilities have been found to have started way too many wildfires through their equipment being too
close to trees and something happens and a fire starts. Their wires are maybe a little old and
they are easily knocked down or they break and they start a fire. Their transmission system as
well as their distribution systems are aged. I won't say they haven't kept up with them but one
wonders a little bit. But they start fires, they have to pay for replacing their own and then they
pay monstrous liability costs because they're found guilty of starting the fires. In all of this
then I think they've all come to realize our infrastructure is old and so they are replacing
infrastructure like crazy. That costs money. All infrastructure costs are passed on to rate payers.
That's one thing that private utilities get permission to do. A fact is a fact. Probably
there's some profit built in there every time the rates go up too but that is number one perhaps.
Secondly might be the cost of some of the decisions that California has made in the past
a few years have added in the climate area perhaps that they've added additional costs.
It's a price people thought they were willing to pay as they have for instance in the air quality
battle of the Air Resources Board for decades. The non-partisan, the citizens even wanted clean air
in California. California did push the envelope very hard but they never did anything that wasn't
a proven technology, not a sounds academically good technology. Let's push for it. So those costs
are kind of significant. In finishing the list recently again the volatility in natural gas
has become very significant. I've seen it get very significant in years past. That's adding a cost to
the price of electricity because we have a lot of gas-fired power plants. I think those kinds of
things are the current things that are piled on to what was already known as kind of expensive
electricity in California. In the late 1990s the Public Utilities Commission felt there was a
with the market system in California and they went to work on a new approach.
They came up with plans for a different kind of a market operation in California.
Now I wasn't an energy commissioner. I wasn't involved in it. I was watching it from the
grandstands of sitting over at the Air Resources Board which I did and you know energy when you're
in the Air Resources business. I saw the PUC and the Energy Commission going at each other.
The PUC was pushing this idea. The Energy Commissioner analyzed it. Commissioners or
the Energy Commission didn't think it was viable. The PUC won. The administration adopted that
approach. The legislature got it and they took it over and they ended up with a piece of legislation.
When I was chief of staff of the resources agency and the energy advisor to the secretary of
resources I was asked to look at the thing. I read the law three or four times and said
I don't see how this can work. What the legislature done is crudely taken a design for a horse
and turned it into a two-hump camel. I mean they had made an impossible thing but nobody saw it
initially. I think the Energy Commission did but a few of us actually warned the governor's office
something's wrong here and we even went to work on maybe there's something can be done about it.
Those kinds of people in the private sector always find ways to beat the system as you probably
remember from those years. So this was the Enron days right? This was the Enron days. The guys who
allegedly figured out how to beat it on the back of napkins as they flew home early in the whole
seeming collapse of the system and the system did collapse eventually and California took
great strides and did a lot of work to try to save the ranch. I mean to me it got down to
saving the ranch. I was unfortunate to be in the room when the governor chief of staff said
Wall Street has just called the governor and said they're going to advance money to the utilities
for two more days and that's it and it's kind of like my god the lights are going to go out.
So I had worked along with the Department of Water Resources. They knew about power.
They were energy deficient for the project but they knew a tiny little bit and suddenly they
were told you got to save it you know and so the Department of Water Resources bought and sold the
electricity for the state during that period of time working with the utilities but financed it.
Earlier when it looked like the wheels were coming off and electricity got a little short
somebody asked the Department of Water Resources can you buy a little more electricity than you
need and then sell it back on a daily basis through the market to those that are really
on the fringe of having a serious problem. Anyway that kept the the ranch from burning down let's
say i.e the state going into a major disaster however eventually what had to be done which
was forbidden in the law is long-term contracts. The long-term contracts which were done when the
price was still high. The state offered less than the market was but not that much less. DWR to me
were heroes in this whole process but those contracts were expensive and they added a new
level to the base of California rates and regulations because they were long-term they
had to be paid but truly that that was the mortgage that saved the ranch as far as I'm
personally concerned. So that adds to this this stacking up over time of decisions that are made
within the last 10 years the Energy Commission made a decision after the Air Board said
made its decision 90 degree left turns all transportation is going to be fueled by
electricity. The Energy Commission said all electricity can be furnished by renewables
and basically solar and wind and to me they brushed off the other renewables that were being
worked on one of which is biomass to electricity using wood waste particularly forest waste but
ag waste in California that kind of wood waste is huge because California's monstrous producer
of agriculture nuts orchards nut trees orchards etc etc they have to burn that every year that
contributes to air pollution. If the forest type people burn the huge piles of slash that pile up
in the forest that is serious air quality so you can burn that you can burn it in controlled
process and you can make heat and generate electricity. That was the only
renewable source of electricity that worked the first time Governor Brown in his very first term
in office way back in the 70s was interested in renewables they wanted to wind they wanted to do
solar they wanted to do other renewables the only one that worked at that point in time worth a darn
was a biomass to electricity in the 80s we had 60 some odd of those plants today we got 20
23 because there's no policy embracing it but anyway they they passed up opportunities
to do things that might have helped. So you mentioned it worked the biomass how did it work
was it financially viable or did it generate a lot of electricity? It generated electricity it
solved other problems that weren't really really accounted financially in the equation for instance
get biomass out of the forest you finally begin to adhere to the trying to get healthy forests in
California which leads to the very thick forests that we do have and leads to easy fires rather
than making it difficult to start a fire there's a monstrous societal cost associated with that
and because of the millions we pay to fight fires the millions we pay for the damage done afterwards
I thought after three or four of the big fires in years past we'd really get on to that but there
are there are oppos there's opposition to that there's policy oppositions within government
then the environmental community never liked the idea they were fearful you know you're going to
injure the habitat and I would come back with you're going to burn the forest and and burn
down the habitat that you're trying to protect and kill the animals you're trying to protect so
those are societal costs that that we've never figured out a way to pay for. Can you tell us how
there is natural biomass both in the forest and what I describe to you every year in California
in the ag industry that is taken out of the forest out of the fields and taken by truck normally to
a plant that's been built to burn the wood waste control the air pollutants there from generate
heat generate steam turn a generator and that can be baseload power that can be 7 by 24 if you want
it that way renewables my original concern about the renewables solar and wind they're intermittent
you have to have the sunshine or the wind yes and when they're not going to be there and sometimes
you you know you predict night and day but you don't predict clouds and storms and this that
the other one it comes to solar and the wind can vary that wind doesn't blow every day etc so you
have to have following power you have to have another power source which in many cases turned
out to be a gas fired combustion turbines a jet engine in effect a turbine engine to quickly natural
gas fire to come on and off to to fill those voids so there's a cost associated with that
unfortunately there's a lot of negativity and anxiety right now even in a beautiful place like
california i'm constantly running to people that are facing depression even they have a lot of
things materially no matter what you and your family are going through right now there is still
hope imagine surrounding yourself for two hours with pure beauty amazing music colors that we
don't see in this world anymore and a message of hope and inspiration shen yun is coming back
to california i've been going to the show for the last 14 years and every time i go i see smiles on
the people's faces when they're leaving the theater and the expressions are in a way that
it's hard to explain but there is this joy coming from inside and i want you guys to experience that
if you want to take a break from all the negativity and anxiety that's out there
make sure to give yourself this experience it will really lift your soul shen yun is currently
performing in northern california and soon will come to la area and southern california
make sure to get your tickets right now before they sell out performance that each and every one
is what you've been waiting for
get tickets now at shenyun.com from where you sit from with all your experience do you think
the utility rates they're going to go up or do you think they're stabilizing at where they are
or could they come down i don't think they're stabilizing except for the fact that there
there has been one legislative action suggesting the design of the rate system
change some the trouble with it is it's academically looks real pretty to transfer
costs from the electricity consumption tranche and move it to the fixed costs because there are
some things that don't have to vary some infrastructure is just there and maybe could
be a base rate could be established do you think it's gone too far i went back to the leaders of
both those agencies who i knew well the airborne in particular and said why are you eliminating
some of the stepping stones to the future we're all seeking in the plans that both agencies had
created prior to the last two 10 years i'd say but probably spent 10 years each on coming there
are all kinds of other alternative transportation fuels that could have been used in the interim
and improved air quality and climate to some degree the same is true when you talk about
energy there's other things in energy there's we had a real program going on a renewable
eliminating the methane emitted in massive concentrations of cattle a lot of methane there
a lot of talk about that and we got the farmers and we got financial assistance in trapping that
methane and eventually getting it into the natural gas pipelines of california where it worked we
went from one farmer doing just for himself or one pipeline to groups of farmers creating a
central point and setting it all the pipeline a bad financial situation in california about 2008
kind of hit that kind of hard but there's never been any policy support for it since except in
maybe the last year or so it's caught on in the nation and other places in the world
and so it has a chance to come back so you're looking for what's going to happen that might
come back a lot of talk about nuclear small nuclear is getting attractive to a lot of people
and you'll find agencies new agencies one of which i'm doing pro bono work for called the
new california coalition energy water home the home crisis and perhaps one other goal and they're
fairly new and just getting kind of started but they seem to have the horsepower and the smarts of
maybe doing things about things and and i'm part of the energy working group which is working on
things for the future and a lot of the members are talking about small nuclear quite a bit
i believe in the ever-accelerating pace of technology but you've got to wait till the
time is really right and you don't alienate the industry you mentioned the grid and so there's
the movement towards electric cars and then we also have the movement with data centers and
the need for power the data centers that were beginning to be built anyway now suddenly pushed
by ai you're right and ai is pushing so hard that it may breathe life back into small nuclear if
they can really prove um its safety and into other renewables such as biomass because suddenly
companies are wanting to self-power themselves almost or or get these data centers but they're
huge consumers of electricity ai is moving so fast and it's totally dependent on power centers
for for the data centers for to feed the ai effort um that could be a turning point but
you kind of have to wait to see you're really on the threshold before you decide that's going to
save us and one thing about nuclear the one thing that bothered me two things bothered me
in my term of that was the nuclear waste fission technology great we've been using it in first
with the bombs and then with electricity and we still got plants going but um all the power plants
in the united states have uh dry storage on the sites of the plants because the united states
government never facilitated the construction of a viable nuclear waste facility there is a
waste facility that was was directed to be in nevada at the on the grounds of the nuclear
test facility that was a political decision that a scientific decision the science studied by a
whole panel of people for many years was the safest place to put that kind of high-level
nuclear waste is deep deep deep in granitic foundations guess where they all are in the
united states on the east coast guess how much congressional and senatorial horsepower those
few states have because nobody wants them they didn't want them and somebody said put it out in
nevada where that nuclear test stuff is i've been inside the yucca mountain plant california sued
even before i came into the nuclear business um over the threat of groundwater that slopes into
basin does definitely slope into california and that made them nervous they argued that
that has been proven as a safe site i've been in it drips drips like crazy leaks gonna put
stainless steel shields over the casks i question now i'm not the expert that the
nuclear energy commission was and who who was there showing it to me and telling me it's safe
but um it's never been built that's too bad because in europe like finland they ran such
a program that the people wanted in their backyard because they saw the economic benefits
of having the employment in their area um lifetime because they're gonna watch that
they didn't say not in my backyard but that's because the government ran a real
cool program of proving it before getting people excited anyway we don't have that
solved so you go to fusion i thought fusion was just around the corner also as everybody has felt
we don't have it yet i've seen the livermore facility before it worked i mean as it was being
built fantastic idea i'm cognizant of the one in europe each of them have proven in milliseconds
or maybe a few seconds that they can do it and maybe someday they'll come up with and that's
just like having a sun in your own backyard so to speak that it gives you perpetual heat
and no significant waste see there's hope but the technologies are out there that they're coming
and what have you but don't i mean some people are beginning to say well we'll just you know
small nuclear is gonna gonna do it yeah okay it's kind of prove it to me but i don't disbelieve it
but it's nuclear is dangerous stuff to play with so you mentioned at the time um we kind of
prioritized climate initiatives over cost of living but you said it wasn't that much
and then when the fires hit or is it a lot the policy part well when you say all your electricity
is going to be by renewables which turned out to be intermittent i think that was very premature
in that maybe not premature for them alone but then come up with a package that has them
their intermittent power that comes in with other more economical ways to back them up and then just
keep building that over time i don't think we did that just like with saying all electric
transportation oh i'm i like that idea um but i i think it was too soon the grid has always been
under trial i mean it's been taxed very hard consistently as our economy grew as um life grew
with five televisions in every house and etc etc and the grid has gotten old and so everything's
happening at once i mean as we discussed earlier it's not just rebuild the grid because the fire
takes it down or really get in deep trouble because your grid started the fire etc it's
because it's strained and it's getting older and that's a a infrastructure improvement which goes
into the cost of electricity that the citizens bear from the from their utilities and pg&e
has been hit harder because they're more deeply in forests and and that's why they're their
transmission their their cost of electricity in the last 10 years has gone in excess of 100
edison's about in excess of 80 and san diego's and just in excess of 70 well some of that
correlates with geography do you have any recommendations for the policy makers that
are there right now with all the experience that you have in this space i retired
but i can't let go of this i will admit so i'm working with the new california coalition because
i've exhausted myself talking to the few policy makers who haven't retired themselves by now
in my lifetime but in this past year i have been fortunate to just happen to find myself
in meetings even out of the country that that i've had california legislators in it
some of them the new crew crop as well some of them extremely recently and i get the sense
they're getting the picture maybe i've contributed a little bit just by talking about the past
and opportunities lost or the things that were done our veterans even are saying of either party
both parties saying we're beginning to get it you actually are still volunteering you said you still
you have retired and on my mother's side i'm probably a fifth generation californian i like
california i went to uc berkeley see i was born before world war ii started so i've lived through
a lot and yeah you can get real dedicated to california i'm very close to my favorite place
in the universe like tao i just happen to be on the nevada side now maybe we're helping the
nevada governor not make some of the mistakes that have happened in california the thing about
california it really well the human race sometimes doesn't address issues until emergency has occurred
but then they come back and and do it big time i don't know what the emergency has to be in
california i saw it after the first three or four fires see the first consulting work i ever did
after i retired was for biomass energy there were a couple counties in northern california that had
done a lot of work on their own it was very impressive uh research this that and the other
they got they got it but they weren't they weren't getting any policy report support
um and even felt that the little bit of aid they get from from the state um might be threatened
because they're they're pushing this real hard because they're worried about their forest northern
california is really heavy in forest i went to battle on it and i just got i mean i won't tell
the stories but i i cannot believe the it's kind of like out of sight out of mind all of a sudden
after putting a good part of your life into doing this kind of stuff so yeah i'm i'm desperately
trying to live into the next generation where i will see it turn around and i think it can but
it's going to take some real stuff which is why i am giving my time to the new california coalition
they have biomass energy as one of their priorities they see it as something that's
that's left behind they're talking about nuclear but they haven't you know they haven't embraced it
it's just another energy source we want to look at but so there are things going on but it's going
to take a while jim boyd former california energy commissioner it was great to have you on
california insider my pleasure thank you for listening let us know your thoughts on electricity
rates in california and are we using all the potential tools that we have for power generation
you can always email us at siamakacaliforniainsider.com or comment
we read all of your emails and comments i'm siamak khorrami this is california insider
we'll see you next time