Watch/Sir Liam Fox, Former Minister of Defense in the United Kingdom, answer all questions of legislators and experts regarding his speech on the topic "IS PRESIDENT PUTIN TO BE BELIEVED?", at the recently concluded 29th Parliamentary Intelligence- Security Forum- Madrid, Spain
Outstanding. Thank you, sir Liam. Do we
have a question
for the presentation? I'm Arta Dada from
Albania and last week there was a very
important meeting of the political
council between EU countries and larger
with the participation of Turkey,
Azerbaijan, Armenia,
the prime minister of United Kingdom and
of course Zeleleski was also
participating.
So the European Union and uh the main
leaders of it
reconfirmed reaffirmed their
determination to assist and help and
continue with the support for Ukraine.
Do you think that European Union is
drawing lessons from the past as you
mentioned Crimea
and uh are you optimistic that they are
doing their job because we know the
region of Western Balkans is in the
vicinity of Ukraine and of course people
are concerned about this conflict which
is going to the end because there were
voices that it would not last and
practically it is lasting and is
becoming even more serious. Of course,
we are doing the job in Albania and
other countries in the eastern uh side
of NATO, but do you think the European
Union itself is doing enough by of
course adding some more of the
uh sanctions
to Russia? Thank you very much. Oh,
thank you very much. Um it's an
excellent question. When the sanctions
were imposed in 2014, Russia moved most
of its assets to Europe rather than the
United States because they believed that
there would not be sufficient European
solidarity in the face of Russian
aggression. And the thing that does make
me feel optimistic is how solid we have
been right across the West in dealing
with Russia's aggression.
We've so far spent between
uh Europe and uh uh I mean broader
Europe, not not just the EU uh but
including UK, Norway, Turkey. We've
spent 282 billion supporting uh Ukraine.
There's 300 billion more assets sitting
there if we want to use them. It will
take quite a degree of political will to
do that. But I think what has been
encouraging uh has been the fact that
there's been such an understanding that
our failure of deterrence up till this
point cannot continue and faced with the
necessary defense of freedom and rule of
law and democracy. This is the time we
actually have to stand together because
I do believe as I was saying that
there's a growing awareness that Putin
will not stop. Anything that gives Putin
reassurances that he can have a
strategic pause but start again at a
later date will simply guarantee further
instability uh and death and destruction
on the European continent. This is the
point at which we have to make a stand.
And so far it's been extremely good. I
just hope that the United States
um doesn't decide for whatever reason
that it doesn't want to be part of the
coalition that stands against tyranny
and aggression in support of
international law and freedom.
Thank you. Very quickly, if you could
please. Yes, sir. Sir Lamb, I'm Senator
Kletan, ex foreign minister of Romania,
working hard at the time with my
colleague counterpart and friends
William H and for a certain period with
the defense secretary Michael Fallon. Um
because you have mentioned also Romania
plus the Republic of Moldova as possible
items of interest of Russia. I entirely
agree with your assessment. We know the
profile. We don't have any fundamental
expectations about possible fundamental
changes on the profile of power in
Kremlin starting with Putin. So this is
why I and we considered that u we should
continue to do and to uh uh continue to
promote uh our assessment and uh
position. It was me that I proposed in
on 3rd of March 2014 in Brussels. Uh
Katy Ashton was the high representative
chairing the meeting of the foreign
ministers of EU. And I propose not to
express uh serious concerns but to
condemn Russia for the crime of
aggression and the illegal annexation of
Crimea and to continue to do our job
because we know what is the profile of
Russia. This is why this year we will
adopt at the European level a special
tribunal for assuring the accountability
for the crime of aggression and we need
to continue. But the key element from
our perspective in Bucharest as is to
ensure and to asssure and to work hard
that the transatlantic relationship will
continue to remain solid and this is a
long-term process and this is the key
element for us. Thank you.
When I was the UK's defense secretary
and Robert Gates was the American
defense secretary,
we used to have a routine at NATO which
you might describe as bad cop and worse
cop when one would talk about the
implications of European states not
maintaining their defense budgets. And
that was augmented by the fact that we
would say in the long term you can't
expect American taxpayers to continue to
carry the burden of European defense as
well as defense in Asia and the Americas
and so on. Uh the European nations
didn't take notice of that in the first
Trump term. They've taken notice of it
in the second term and that's a good
thing. I think it will strengthen the
alliance as a whole that European
nations carry a bigger share of their
burden. My worry is that it's not just
about money. It's about what they do
with the money and about how uh capacity
and capability is built. Uh rather than
countries trying to pretend that they
can have full spectrum defense
capabilities on a small budget. But I
think it's key politically as you
mentioned that we don't allow Putin to
develop any cracks around the periphery
of our wider alliance which is what he
does try to do. He's tried to create an
arc of instability around NATO from the
high north to the Baltics to the Balkans
to the Caucuses and he will continue to
do that because his behavioral pattern
doesn't change. And what I would say
perhaps as a on a slightly optimistic
note is that people say that Russia has
survived the sanctions intact. It
hasn't. There are big cracks appearing
in the Russian economy and the longer
the conflict goes on, the bigger the
contradictions inside the Russian
economy become. It's had growth because
it has pumped money against its own
fiscal rules into the armaments and into
the armed forces. That always produces
growth if you're looking at technical
OEC definitions of growth. But in the
longer term, it's unsustainable. And we
must not uh become fatigued at the
length of the time this conflict has
taken because this is an existential
battle and we have to win it.
Yes sir.
Yes sir. Quickly if you could. Thank
you. Uh your excellency, how do you see
the Chinese position in this conflict?
Would you think that China would like to
see a peace soon in the European battle
or prefer that it pdur in time?
China would like to see the West
weakened. It would like to see the
alliance that we have fractured um
because that's in the long-term
interests of China. And while our
biggest weakness is that we tend to
think in electoral terms of four or five
years and Putin
doesn't have to bother about his
electoral cycle,
um the Chinese don't think in electoral
cycles at all. So if they can have a
gradual fracturing, a gradual weakening,
a gradual tearing apart of the
intellectual and political coherence
that has made the West strong and
wealthy, then it will do so. Not overtly
in the way that Russia does because
they're much more subtle than the
gangster regime in Moscow, but the
danger is there even if it's presented
in a more subtle form.
Thank you. Sorry for my English. I don't
know if I can ask my question in French,
but I will try in English. Contrary to
what I heard from every presentator
uh from the African perspective, we are
seeing uh the the the the influence of
Russia increasing and the
the influence of Europe decreasing and
the economic in Europe decreasing the
inflation increasing in Europe. So when
you said that uh we have to keep going
fighting is it the only way to solve
this issue
you know
we are a new threat with China for
instance you have a new threat with how
you say the Cuba and some African
country under influence of Russia. So do
you think keeping this war, feeding this
war is in the advantage of Europe and
even Ukraine with all those death and so
on because
since maybe the beginning of the war in
2023
they said that in one year Russian will
collapse in two year Russian economy
will collapse but is what it's not what
we have seen all over the world. So well
there are two questions there if I may.
The first is that we are not feeding the
war. We are defending a sovereign and
democratic state against a brutal
tyranny that tries to uh impose its
will. And let's let me let me give you
an African analogy to that. Uh Putin
says they are allowed to own Ukraine
because it was once part of the Soviet
Union. supposing France turned around
tomorrow and said we want to occupy
Algeria because it was once part of
France. What do you think the
international reaction would be to that?
So let's be very clear that this is a
colonial action by Russia and it
surprises me that a number of African
countries who complain about the legacy
of colonialism are not more vocal in
their criticism of what is a clearly
colonial policy being operated by
today's Kremlin.
the
the second part of your question which I
have much more sympathy with is what is
the what has been the western
alternative to China's belt and road
policy and the answer is pathetically
little. Um, I was the UK's candidate to
be the director general of the World
Trade Organization
and I felt that one of the one of the
changes we needed to make particularly
for African countries was to call it the
World Trade and Investment Organization
because one of the things that we could
do is to help African countries become
much more attractive to foreign direct
investment and become masters of their
own destiny by that method. And we need
to do much more in the west to have a
strategic alternative to Chinese belt
and road that's been missing from our
diplomatic armory in recent times. And
one of the ways that we can do that is
to actually allow African countries to
develop in a way that makes them more
attractive to the massive amount of
international capital that could be uh
helping to take Africa forward in a way
that is in line with what the countries
want and not what Beijing wants and not
leaving African countries with a legacy
of debt and useless infrastructure which
is what a lot of them are finding
They're left with with Belton Road.