1087: When William The Conqueror died - The 1088 Norman Rebellion

The Ancient Beliefs
23 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 28, 2025
It's 1088, and this is Rochester Castle in Kent.
William the Conqueror has finally died,
and on his deathbed he's pardoned his psychotic half-brother, Odo of Béxar.
Odo is holed up inside the castle,
but because he no longer owns it, he's had to break in.
He's also trapped in here because one of his nephews
has helpfully surrounded the place with siege towers.
We're here because William the Conqueror decided to break with protocol
and name his second-oldest son King of England,
and not his oldest, as is more usual.
That move didn't just almost cause a civil war.
It started one, a war that would rumble on for 13 years
through rebellions, invasions and political murders,
until it finally ended in a hunting accident
that was almost certainly nothing of the sort.
The traditional historian's view is that this was a nearly civil war
called the 1088 Norman Rebellion.
I'm going to tell you today, though, that this was the first spark in a conflict
that lasted 13 years and involved brothers going to prison,
politically motivated murders and several invasions of England by Scotland.
This is the first event in what you might call
the Norman War of the Brothers.
On September 9, 1087, William the Conqueror died in Rouen in Normandy.
He had three sons.
Immediately, they turned his will into a feud
that would tear Norman England apart for more than a decade.
To his eldest, Robert Curthoes, by the strict rules of primogeniture,
he gave what had been given to him by his father.
Robert became Duke of Normandy.
By this stage, William the Conqueror had been King of England for some 21 years,
and so he gave his second son the titles and lands that he controlled there.
So his second son gained a higher title, King of England,
over the one that was given to the eldest son, Duke of Normandy.
The youngest son, Henry, well, he just got some cash.
And if you think you've had rows in your family before,
trust me, they've got nothing on this one.
This wasn't just a dispute over money and titles.
This was the opening shot in a conflict
that would define Norman politics for the next 13 years.
You could see it as separate events, the 1088 Norman Rebellion,
the 1091 Scottish Invasion, the 1093 Battle of Annick
and the 1095 Earl's Revolt.
Or you could see it for what it really is.
One long, brutal power struggle
over who actually had the right to rule England.
The Norman War of the Brothers had begun.
William the Conqueror died in France at the Prairie of Saint-Gervais in Rouen.
The events surrounding exactly what happened are a little confused
because historians have two main accounts and they differ slightly.
But glossing over a lot of the nuance, a few days before he died,
William sent his second son, William Rufus, back to England with a letter.
The letter was to be delivered to the Archbishop of Canterbury, Lanfranc,
with strict instructions that William Rufus
was to be made William II, King of England.
Importantly, Lanfranc was told to support William Rufus in this.
And that's key because William made a second bequest
that on his death, certain prisoners were to be released.
One of those prisoners was William's half-brother, Odo,
the former Earl of Kent and the Bishop of Bayeux.
Now, if the name Odo of Bayeux is ringing a bell with you,
that's because he was this guy, a key figure at the Battle of Hastings,
immortalised in the Bayeux Tapestry,
and also likely the man who commissioned the tapestry in the first place.
When it comes to Odo, you've just got to accept
that sometimes a medieval bishop felt the need to get out onto the battlefield
and batter people's skulls in with a mace.
He was a somewhat violent man.
It was a common streak in that family.
For a while, while William had been king,
Odo had been the second most powerful person in the country.
Slight hiccup, in 1082, Odo was disgraced and imprisoned.
Now he was to be released.
Well, kudos to Odo.
The popular myth is that he was the one who came up with the workaround
on the whole thou shalt not kill nonsense
by declaring a bludgeoning through armour with a hefty mace
didn't qualify because it didn't draw blood.
That's not true, according to modern historians.
His particular legal workaround is these days more usually believed
to be drawing a distinction between killing and murder.
Just know that he wasn't entirely opposed to either,
should the situation have required it.
And now Uncle Odo was free and he was not a happy man.
After all, he had once been the richest man in England
behind William the Conqueror.
When he went to jail, he lost his title of Earl of Kent.
He lost his power and position.
He lost the strategically important city of Rochester.
More on that in a minute.
And like the other nobles, he was in a bit of a jam.
Most of the nobility in England at this point were Normans,
and that meant that they controlled lands back in France,
now under the control of Robert, the brand new Duke of Normandy,
and also here in England under King William II.
We must act now. The threat is imminent.
Your plan is too risky.
Who were they to support?
Whichever side they went with,
they risked immediately losing their lands under the control of the other.
And it was pretty clear to everyone that a civil war was about to happen.
At which point, if you backed the wrong side,
you risked losing everything.
The nobles clubbed their heads together and came up with a solution.
The answer was obvious.
Reunite Normandy and England once again under a single ruler.
Unfortunately, that would mean that one of the brothers, in some sense,
would have to go.
For those wanting a summary of the plot thus far,
William has died in Rouen,
and there was a little bit of a fuss at his funeral.
Check out the extra section at the end of this video for more on that.
Robert Curthoes, the eldest son, got Normandy.
He was cross he didn't get England as well.
William the Conqueror's half-brother, Uncle Odo,
rock-hard alpha male warrior of Battle of Hastings fame,
was released from prison, and he was spoiling for a fight
because while he was in jail, he'd lost his earldom of Kent,
and he wanted it back.
Meanwhile, William Rufus had been made king,
forcing every Norman aristocrat in the country
to decide which side of his family feud they were going to be on.
And then there's the youngest son of William, Henry Beauclerk.
He was kind of annoyed because all he'd got was a wedge of cash,
and hey, in the ensuing power grab that was about to happen,
maybe he could squeeze out a little bit more if he played his cards right.
And that would be good because right now he'd got no land.
This was the recipe for the Norman Rebellion of 1088,
and the opening shot in the Norman War of the Brothers.
It was about to be a brutal one.
You'll recall that the other Norman aristocrats
were all trying to decide which of the three sons of William to support
in order to reunite the kingdom.
Fortunately, here was Odo.
Not only was he the boy's uncle,
not only was he somebody that everybody looked up to,
but he was also a man who had a propensity for violence
that would make the Kray twins go,
steady on there, mate.
In the summer of 1088, only one question mattered.
Everyone wanted to know, which brother would Odo support?
There was a personality trait in that family,
something in their collective gene pool,
something you might describe as a little bit aggressive.
It was at this point of your William Rufus
that things got considerably worse.
Uncle Odo got together with another half-brother of his
and William the Conqueror's, Robert, Count of Mortain,
who was the Earl of Cornwall.
How important was he?
Well, in this scene from the Bayeux Tapestry,
which, remember, was likely commissioned by Odo himself,
you can see three people.
Above them are their names.
From left to right, that's Odo,
then William, then Robert.
That Robert on the right is Robert, Count of Mortain.
William may have been Duke of Normandy,
but Odo and Robert were the king's right and left hands.
William Rufus now had both his uncles
and his eldest brother, Robert Curthoes in Normandy,
gunning for him.
Let's be honest, his position was particularly dicey.
This was William Rufus's baptism by fire.
The man who would later become known for his political cunning,
his brutal efficiency, his terrifying ability to crush rebellions
before they properly started.
Well, in 1088, he was barely king, he was untested,
and he was facing two of the most dangerous men in Norman England
and an older brother with a legitimate grievance.
He was about to learn some very hard lessons
about how power actually works.
Fortunately, Archbishop Lanfranc was on the case,
and that man was a genius.
He had his orders from his longtime friend
taken from the letter and he followed them.
First, he rallied the church.
The bishops fell in line behind William Rufus.
Next, he taught William II the way to rally
what nobles had yet to declare for his older brother.
If we look in the Doomsday Book,
we'll see that of the ten largest land-holding families in the country,
six of them declared for the rebels.
The fate of the realm hangs in the balance.
What looked like an absolute disaster,
with Lanfranc's help, William II turned on its head.
If these men had lands, you could appeal to the lesser lords
by offering to carve them up
and hand them back out to anyone who remained loyal.
Next, he got the downtrodden and somewhat oppressed
Anglo-Saxon population on his side.
He promised the Anglo-Saxons lower taxes and relaxation of laws.
Populism may be a dirty word these days,
but for William II, there was strength in numbers
and it gave people a stake in his victory.
This was the education of William Rufus.
Rally the church, buy loyalty with promises of confiscated land,
use populism to build an army.
These were lessons he would never forget.
And by 1095, when the Earls rose against him again,
he would deploy every single one of them with devastating efficiency.
Thus, as summer came, the two sides drew ready to tear the nation apart.
The rebels prepared to lay waste to the lands of William II
and his supporters.
The rebels' strategy was that Odo and his co-conspirators
would begin the fight in England,
while Robert would lead an invasion force from Normandy.
They fortified their own castles and then stopped them with provisions.
Next, they waited for a response from the king.
If, for some reason, William didn't get drawn into a fight,
they intended to plunder neighbouring territories,
reducing the nation to absolute anarchy.
The king would have to respond,
while also keeping an eye over his shoulder
for the impending arrival of Robert's main force when he landed.
William Rufus knew Odo had taken Rochester,
the castle that had once been his,
that strategically vital crossing point
on the road to London, Canterbury and Dover.
It was now the rebel headquarters.
Time now for a quick breather to talk about Rochester Castle.
This is Rochester Castle in Kent.
It stands on the east bank of the River Medway,
and in terms of historical importance,
it doesn't come much bigger than that.
The road that you see behind me, going over the bridge,
is the original Watling Street.
In one direction, it leads up to London.
In the other, it leads down to Canterbury,
the religious heart of the nation,
and from there on to Dover, the country's main port.
Whoever controls this castle, and therefore that bridge,
controls the main arterial route from London down to Calais.
The structure you can see here, the keep, is from the 12th century.
More on that in the extra section at the end of this video.
The building that you can see just poking over the walls?
That's Rochester Cathedral.
I'm sure I'll do a fuller video
on both Rochester Castle and Cathedral in the future.
The two of them, and whoever controlled them,
played important roles in various conflicts throughout English history.
But that's for another day.
Right now we're interested in the original castle that was on this side,
put in place by William the Conqueror
as part of his original programme of castle building across the nation.
At that time, it had been given to Odo of Béxar.
Odo, you'll recall, had just been released from prison
and he wanted his castle back.
Well, now he had it.
William Rufus marched on Rochester.
But before the king could arrive, word reached him that Odo had fled.
The wily bishop had abandoned Rochester
and joined his half-brother and Robert of Mortain at Pevensey Castle.
This wasn't cowardice, this was strategy.
Odo and Robert were waiting for Robert Curtose's invasion fleet
from Normandy to land at Pevensey Beach,
just as William the Conqueror himself had done in 1066.
William Rufus changed course immediately.
He would deal with both of his uncles at once.
A new siege was laid at Pevensey.
And now William Rufus's luck began to change,
because Robert, Duke of Normandy's soldiers, never arrived.
Some sources say that bad weather delayed them setting sail from Normandy.
Others that the rebels had rallied to Curtose because he was impetuous and weak-willed.
And this, ultimately, was their undoing, as he vacillated.
Whatever the reason for Robert Curtose's delay,
his lack of arrival on time gave William II exactly the advantage he needed.
For six weeks, William Rufus personally led a siege on Pevensey by land and sea.
Nothing went in and nothing came out.
In that aching summer heat of 1088,
he starved the men inside while taunting them.
Anyone in the garrison who wasn't a Norman knew
their lives would be infinitely better with William II in charge.
Both Odo and his half-brother Robert, Count of Mortayn, were known to be brutal men.
The Count of Mortayn was known to repeatedly beat his wife,
on one occasion so heavily that the canonised founder of Savogne Abbey
threatened to dissolve his marriage if he didn't repent.
For six weeks, Pevensey's powerful defences resisted every attack.
But their perseverance was slowly ebbing.
And still there was no sign of the new Duke of Normandy,
who was known for his short temper and viciousness.
Were these people really worth dying for?
These people who were traitors to their rightful king?
Forced to the point of starvation with no sign of reinforcements from France,
the rebels agreed to a truce.
The garrison stood down. William's uncles were captured.
But the rebellion wasn't over.
Rochester still held out, and William Rufus had a plan.
He forced the captured Odo to swear an oath.
He'd return to Rochester, order the garrison to surrender,
and then he'd leave England forever.
It was at this point that things got considerably worse.
A small royal escort was assembled.
Odo, under guard, was sent to the walls of Rochester Castle
to deliver the king's command.
What happened next became one of the strangest moments of the entire rebellion.
When Odo arrived at the gates and called for surrender,
the garrison inside looked at their former commander.
They saw his face. They saw the guards around him.
And they understood immediately. This man was speaking under duress.
The chroniclers say Odo's countenance ill-agreed with his words.
The Rochester garrison refused.
More than that, they sallied out.
They overwhelmed the royal escort,
and they dragged Odo back inside the castle walls.
They'd freed him. William Rufus was enraged.
He marched on the city and besieged it,
building two rival siege or counter-castles nearby.
He surrounded the town and strangled the local garrison's control of the land
and their access to water.
The siege began in May 1088.
That summer was hot.
Inside the castle walls, the situation grew dire quickly.
The flies and disease were intense.
The garrison held out for weeks, their honour as soldiers intact.
But eventually, starvation and disease did what William's armies could not.
Rochester capitulated.
And what could have been an utterly devastating and bloody conflict
evaporated almost overnight.
Those barons who'd remained loyal urged restraint by the king.
William Rufus listened. He confiscated all of Odo's properties,
and the man who'd previously been the second most powerful person
in the entire country was banished to Normandy.
But he didn't execute him.
He didn't blind him. He didn't mutilate him.
In 1088, Rufus was still learning.
By 1095, when the earls rose against him again,
he would have learned that mercy to rebels was a luxury he couldn't afford.
William of Orr would discover exactly how much Rufus' approach to traitors had evolved.
Afterwards, Odo remained in the service of Robert Curthose over in Normandy
and eventually joined the First Crusade.
He died on the way of Palermo in Sicily in early 1097.
He's buried in Palermo Cathedral.
So if you're ever there, drop by and say hi.
And that was it, the Norman Rebellion of 1088.
It lasted between three and six months,
depending on where you put the start and the end dates.
But it wasn't the end of the Norman War of the Brothers.
It was just the beginning.
The question of who truly had the right to rule England
and whether Normandy and England should be reunited under one crown,
that question wouldn't be settled for another 12 years.
There would be more rebellions, more invasions and more bloodshed.
And in 1100, in the New Forest,
William Rufus would take an arrow during a hunting accident.
His younger brother Henry, the one who'd only got cash in 1087,
would seize the crown while William's body was still warm.
The Norman War of the Brothers would finally be over.
But in 1088, William Rufus had won his first battle.
It learned how to buy loyalty, how to use siege warfare
and how to turn populism into military strength.
It also learned something else.
That showing mercy to rebels
just meant you'd have to fight them again later.
The 1088 Norman Rebellion,
a surprisingly deep and often overlooked little piece of the past.
Now, if you enjoyed all of that, stay with me,
because I've got a deep dive coming up
on some of the extra details that I couldn't fit into the main story.
There are so many cool extra little anecdotes
that I wanted to drop into today's story about the 1088 Norman Rebellion,
and I just couldn't fit them in there without ruining the flow of the story.
So, are you sitting comfortably? Because here come the extra bits.
You can think of it as a little bit like a director's cut version.
First up, when I say there was a little bit of a fuss around William's burial,
a little bit of understatement there.
People aren't stupid.
When William died, everybody knew that the way it split his lands up
meant that there was going to be trouble.
Everyone who'd been at his deathbed left the body at Rouen
and hurried off to attend to their own affairs.
Eventually, the clergy arranged for the body to be shipped to Caen,
where it would be laid to rest in keeping with William's original requests
in front of the high altar of the Abbey Oom.
It's still there to this day.
The funeral was attended by the bishops and abbots of Normandy,
as well as his son, Henry.
It was disturbed by the assertion of a citizen of Caen
who alleged that his family had been illegally despoiled
of the land on which the church was built.
After hurried consultations, the allegation was shown to be true,
and the man was then suitably compensated before proceedings could continue.
Side problem, all of this had been taking some time,
and William's corpse had been getting a little bit ripe.
It was bloating and bloating,
and so now when they tried to lower it into the grave,
it was too big for the space.
Never mind. Those attending decided to give it some welly
and ran the body into the tomb using some poles.
It was at this point that things got considerably worse.
The bloated body burst open, spraying everyone present
and spreading rotting guts and stench throughout the entire building.
A cool side-note, but you can understand why it distracted
from the main plot in the other story.
Rochester was once a city, but unfortunately no longer.
I'm not going to go into the enormous details
behind the political wranglings that led to that unfortunate circumstance.
I've got a link in the description below to a video by Tom Scott
that covers the entire topic fully.
When I'm talking about Odo,
and I'm describing him as a little bit of a violently lager-loutish guy,
it's easy to think that I'm being flippant, and obviously I am.
But also not so much.
This scene that you can see now is from the Bayeux Tapestry,
and it shows Odo rallying Duke William's troops
during the Battle of Hastings.
The words above it, the Latin titularly, reads as follows.
Hic Odo, episcopus, Bacolumum tenens, confortat puros.
Let me translate that for you word for word into English,
no snark from me.
It means,
here Bishop Odo holding a club gives strength to the boys.
Now, some of you will say the puros could be more literally translated as children.
Others would say it means something a little bit more colloquial,
something along the lines of lads.
However, the point stands.
The Bishop of Bayeux was a somewhat violent man.
That may partly explain why he backed Robert
over the more charismatic and political William Rufus.
But saying that among historians is controversial and speculative at best.
Between 1087 and 1089,
William Rufus asked Gundulf, the Bishop of Rochester,
to build a new stone castle on the Medway River.
It was Gundulf that established the current extent of the castle
that you see here today.
And indeed, on his statue,
you can also see a model of the castle in his hands.
Gundulf's work, though, was very important.
Remember, by the time all of the power squabbles were over,
William II only got to reign for 13 years,
from 1087 until 1100.
So, in a way, it was the youngest brother, Henry Beauclair,
who wound up at the top of the pile
by becoming Henry I, King of England.
The Norman War of the Brothers didn't end with William Rufus triumphant.
It ended with him dead in the New Forest
and Henry seizing the crown while his brother's body was still warm.
Some might call that poetic justice. Others might call it murder.
Partly because of Gundulf's work
and partly to keep such a strategically valuable castle
out of the hands of any one individual among his nobles,
in 1127, King Henry I gave the castle to the Archbishops of Canterbury
in perpetuity.
It was under them that Archbishop William de Corbiel built the massive keep
that still dominates the castle to this day.
Rochester Castle, because of its size, because of its location,
because of its strength and its ownership,
then became a key fighting point in the First Baron's War,
the Second Baron's War and the Peasants' Revolt.
It was also a symbolic win for the Royalists in the English Civil War,
all of which I'm sure I'll talk about at some stage in the future.
