CNN commentator and strategist @scottjenningsky joins host Shabbos Kestenbaum to break down U.S. immigration policy, the Minnesota Medicaid fraud scandal, and why he believes Western civilization is under real pressure—from mass migration impacts to campus radicalism. Jennings explains how Europe’s crisis reshaped politics, why assimilation matters, what’s alleged in Minnesota’s Somali fraud cases, and the policy levers the U.S. can use to protect civil society and the rule of law.
What in the hell is happening in
Minnesota?
>> People in the Somali diaspora in
Minneapolis have defrauded billions of
dollars. Even worse, a lot of it gets
sent back to Somalia and winds up in the
hands of an al-Qaeda offshoot. I know it
sounds crazy, but it's absolutely true.
This has nothing to do with race. It has
everything to do with corruption. They
do more for illegal aliens and for
violent criminals than they do for
law-abiding American citizens. We are
climbing out of a deep hole. I do not
get it. You were here to represent the
interests of the United States of
America and the American people. And
you're sipping my ties and playing yatsi
with Kilmer Rogo Garcia in El Salvador.
I don't understand.
And welcome back to the brief. We are
joined today by Scott Jennings. Scott is
a conservative political strategist,
commentator, and writer of the new book,
A Revolution of Common Sense: How Donald
Trump Stormed Washington and Fought for
Western Civilization. But perhaps most
importantly, Scott, I'm not the first
one to say this, but you are the only
reason to keep watching CNN. Thank you
so much for joining us today.
>> Well, I'm glad to be here. Thanks for
your uh compliments, and it's an honor
to have the seat at CNN to inject a
little common sense into some of these
conversations.
>> So, uh Scott, the the great scholar of
our days, Mahmud Khalil, the student
agitator at Columbia University, uh he
has repeatedly called for the
eradication of Western civilization. At
the same time, you have someone like
Charlie Kirk who just a few days before
he was killed said that Islam is
incompatible with Western civilization.
You make the case in your book that
Donald Trump has sort of in many ways
restored Western civilization. So I
guess before we get into the specifics,
can you define for us within the ongoing
political and cultural context? What is
Western civilization? What is it that
we're fighting for?
>> Well, it's not a place on a map. It's a
set of ideas that was born in Jerusalem
and Rome and Athens. And it's the
civilization that gave us the
university, the Bible, the Constitution.
It's the civilization that gave rise to
250 years of the American experiment.
It's all of our values. It's all of the
belief in free speech. It's all of the
belief in human liberty. That's what we
live under here in the Western world.
And I think there's a lot of people out
there who believe, I'm one of them, that
Western civilization is under threat.
And there are ideologies in this world,
and you just mentioned it, that are
fundamentally at odds with what we would
just colloquially call the West. And I'm
not sure if President Trump knew he was
signing up for this or not, but he is
the leader uh of the country that is
leading the fight for the West. I think
Europe's been overrun. I think it's uh
impacting their domestic politics, and I
think we have a lot of people in our
country today who would love to see the
downfall of the West and by default a
downfall uh of the American experiment.
So, I just I honestly just don't think
we're arguing about politics as usual
anymore. We are arguing about
fundamentally the future of the West and
whether our children and grandchildren
are going to live under that western
civilization framework or whether we're
going to live under ideologies that are
much darker and I think the the enemies
of human liberty.
>> I agree with that answer, but as sort of
as I look at Western civilization, I
think as many young people do as well,
we look at threats like radical Islam,
we look at threats like a disengaged
electorate political polarization. it
seems like there very much are still
these threats. So, I guess I'm curious,
what more does the Trump administration
need to be doing, not only to safeguard
Western civilization, but to also build
upon the progress that they have
achieved um since uh Trump's second
administration?
>> Well, they have to continue to be a
beacon in this world, sounding the alarm
about the threats to the West. They
actually started doing it the other day,
their national security strategy memo
that came out. They warned Europe about
uh the eraser of their own civilization
in Europe and those were stark terms and
it got a lot of people's attention but
it's absolutely true. You know Europe's
been overrun with this mass migration
crisis
>> and it has warp their domestic politics
and there are even pockets in the United
States where mass migration and
importing people from other countries
that don't really fundamentally believe
in the American experiment has warped
local politics. We've seen that in
Dearbornne Michigan. We've seen it in
Minneapolis. We even see it on the
streets of New York City. Sometimes on
October the 7th, on the second
anniversary of October the 7th, you had
people in the streets saying, "We didn't
go far enough. We have to have another
October the 7th." They're saying that in
the United States, we see people on
college campuses fmenting anti-Western
sentiment and anti-American sentiment
every single day. It's the only reason
they came here. And so, I think what
they need to do is to continue to
accelerate looking at these populations,
people that we brought here, and ask
hard questions. Why are you here? And
what are you doing? You're a guest in
this country. You don't have to be here.
You're a guest here. And if you're only
here to fment the downfall of our
civilization and of our country, you can
go back home and you're welcome to do
that back wherever you came from, but
you're not going to do it in America.
So, I think I would continue down this
path. I would continue warning the rest
of the world about the gathering threats
against the West. And they just need to
ignore everybody who is criticizing them
for it because they are dead right about
this.
>> Yeah. By the way, I'm glad you mentioned
bring them back home because something I
never really understood about someone
like Congresswoman Ilhan Omar or Rashida
Talib is when they said that we have to
bring Mahmud Khalil back home. Well, by
deporting him back to Algeria or Syria,
we literally are deporting him back
home. But but I digress. Um I'm glad you
mentioned Minneapolis because I sort of
see the current scandal with the Somalia
fraud, the largest pandemic fraud in
American history, as this clash of
civilizations and cultures that you're
just that you have just been describing
kind of perfectly. So number one, on a
very rudimentary level, can you educate
myself, educate our viewers what in the
hell is happening in Minnesota? And then
sort of on a fundamental level, is it
America's responsibility to be letting
individuals immigrate to this country
with objectively differing cultural
attitudes and norms?
>> Let me take the second one first. No, we
don't have to let people in. They're
guests in our country. Visas and other
programs that let people in. We're not
bound to do it. We don't have to do it.
We don't have to do any more of it. uh
through the goodness of our hearts,
we've done it. But some of these people
that we've let in have no interest in
assimilation. And by assimilation, I
mean embracing the United States of
America, what we stand for, the way we
do it. They try to import their culture,
they try to import their political
culture into our country, and they're
just fundamentally incompatible. So on
the second question, no, we don't have
to do this. I think if people come here
and they love America, they've coming
here because they love democracy, they
love free speech, they love the American
experiment, that's fine. But bringing
people here who don't and want to bring
about its downfall, that is not fine.
Regarding Minnesota, uh, let me just sum
up by saying there are layers upon
layers upon layers of corruption
scandals where people in the Somali
diaspora in Minneapolis have defrauded
taxpayers, state and federal taxpayers,
a lot of it through the Medicaid
program. And we're talking about huge
amounts of money, billions of dollars.
And so you're setting up sham companies.
You're putting in fake u requests for
people to be on certain programs. the
money comes in, you know, one of them
was an autism program. They don't
they're not have autism, but they're
getting paid through. Anyway, all this
money changes hands. Then even worse,
the money that's being stolen, a lot of
it gets sent back to Somalia and winds
up in the hands of al-Shabaab, an
al-Qaeda offshoot. So effectively, you
have American taxpayers having their
money laundered through Minneapolis back
to Al-Shabaab. And boy, I mean, I know
it sounds crazy. It's like the craziest
political mad libs you could ever come
up with. But it's absolutely true.
People are being indicted. People are
going to jail. Tim Walls is out there
punishing whistleblowers. Ilhan Omar and
her people are somehow involved in it.
Keith Ellison, the attorney general.
You've got a whole bunch of people in
Minneapolis, Minnesota, Democrats who
have fallen in line with this and
allowed this to happen. Billions of
dollars, US taxpayer dollars. And I have
to say, Donald Trump and Dr. Oz at the
Centers for Medicare Medicaid Services.
I mean, they're saying, "Look, we're
going to investigate this, but we're not
going to continue to send money there if
it's going to be stolen through fraud
and sent back to terrorists in Somalia."
I know the Treasury Secretary, Scott
Besson, is also investigating this now.
And thank goodness because what we've
heard from Minnesota is, "Well, we
didn't want to ask too many questions
because we didn't want to look racist,"
which is the the the craziest, you know,
sort of a kick the can or punt the ball
here. We didn't want to look racist, so
we we weren't really allowed to say
anything about it. Folks, this has
nothing to do with race. It has
everything to do with corruption, and it
has everything to do with people that we
let into the country committing fraud
against the taxpayers of the United
States. Period. Full stop. And it needs
to be dealt with now.
>> So, I think on an ideological level,
certainly there's an agreement as it
pertains to deporting illegal
immigrants. In fact, just this week, the
State Department under the leadership of
Marco Rubio announced that they have
revoked more than 85,000 student visas.
Let's be honest though, between you and
me, even though our audience is going to
be watching this too, how realistic is
it for Donald Trump to be mass deporting
millions of illegal immigrants? I know
it was a slogan certainly during the
campaign. Certainly, I remember at the
Republican convention holding signs
saying mass deportations on day one, but
we've seen actually that as the charts
stand now, Barack Obama has deported
more illegal immigrants than than Donald
Trump. Do you see especially with the
the blowback that sanctuary cities like
Los Angeles, New York City, Boston have
against ICE ICE officers that we can
actually achieve mass deportations as a
practical political strategy?
>> Well, they have deported quite a few
people. I mean, they're it's not like
they're sitting on their hands. And
also, what never gets reported are the
number of folks who have selfported. I
think like a million and a half people
self-epported
uh because they didn't want to deal with
being deported by the Trump
administration. They just went home. So
that's also a good thing. But you do
raise a critical question. How do you
get people out who came here illegally
when the system is set up and
specifically designed to do everything
it can to keep them here? I look at the
case of Kilmer Abrego Garcia, who I
comment on heavily in my book. This is
the so-called Maryland man who is not
from Maryland, but he is from uh El
Salvador and he is an MS-13 gangbanger
and he was somehow involved in
trafficking human beings and he did beat
his wife and he did have an existing
deportation order and he did receive due
process and he did see like 20 judges
and on and on and on and on and on. He's
still here. He has not been deported
yet. Now, the Trump administration's
trying to get the guy out, but if it's
that hard to get one person like Kilmer
Abrego Garcia out, it's a fair question
to ask, how do you ever get everybody
else? And so I think the American public
needs to understand they asked Donald
Trump to clean up the immigration system
to close the border, but we are living
in a bureaucratic regime that fights and
and a and with a one political party
that is fully dedicated to stopping you,
stopping Trump from deporting people who
have broken our laws. And you called it
blowback. I think the only blowback that
we're seeing is based on the propaganda
that we're getting about this whole
thing. You know, routinely in my job at
CNN, I hear all kinds of nonsense. Oh,
they're illegally deporting US citizens.
They're disappearing children. They're
zip tying this. None of this stuff is
true. None of this stuff is true or it's
greatly exaggerated or they're leaving
out key details or whatever. But this is
fomenting some uh you know, public
opinion out there. But I still think
honestly as a political matter,
immigration is still Trump's best issue.
People said clean it up. He did close
the border. We've had ner and illegal
crossing for seven months. They are
getting people out as fast as they can.
Uh but I I agree with you. It's not
happening fast enough, but it's not
their fault. It's a system that is
designed to keep these people here for
as long as possible. I mean, they're
trying to wait him out. They want him to
go away and get a Democrat back in the
White House so they can keep these
illegal immigrants here and bring back
more. I mean, that's the thing. If we go
back, the borders will swing wide open
again.
>> So, I just have to ask them because you
mentioned Kumar Brigger Garcia. What
does it say about the state of the
Democratic party and sort of the leftist
ideology broadly speaking that you have
a senator like Chris Van Holland of
Maryland who's actually you know meeting
with him while he's being detained
sipping margaritas together and you
don't see a lot of accountability within
the Democratic party against this type
of political theater. Do you see that
the Democratic party is just as weak as
they were under Kla Harris's leadership
or is there going to be some type of
political evolution whereby they can
actually uh uh create some type of of
comeback in 2026 and in 2028?
>> Well, you called it political theater.
I'm not sure it's theater. I mean, I
think the the core ideology of the
Democratic party is more than theater.
It is we want you to do as much as
possible to get and keep illegal
immigrants in this country. We want you
to do as much as possible to coddle
violent criminal people in this country.
They do more for illegal aliens and for
violent criminals than they do for
law-abiding American citizens. Period.
You mentioned Chris Van Galand. So this
guy Alrego Garcia, you know, is living
illegally in Maryland. And Chris Van
Holland, I promise you that guy has
never done as much for a single American
citizen in Maryland. He's never spent as
much time thinking about a single
Marylander than he has Kilmer Abrego
Garcia. But that's what the Democratic
base demands of these people. They I I
don't get it. I do not get it. You are
here to represent the interests of the
United States of America and the
American people and you're sipping my
ties and playing yatsi with Kilmergo
Garcia in El Salvador. I don't
understand. It's not even like this guy
was a desirable immigrant, right? It's,
you know, okay, what if he had been a,
you know, a physicist or some kind of an
engineer or somebody who had invented a
cure for a drug? Okay, maybe we have a
conversation about whether we want him
here. MS-13, human trafficking, beats
his wife, breaks all kinds of laws, and
this is who you're fighting to have live
in the state of Maryland. I don't get
it. And so, I don't think it's theater.
I think it's what their base demands.
And if they win elections uh and they
get back in power, that's what their
debate their base is going to demand
that they do. Keep all the Kilmergo
Garcia of the world and American
citizens be damned. I think that's what
their future is if Democrats win
elections.
>> Wow. Well, well said. I I want to get a
little uh uncomfortable just for a
moment. I think it's easy for those of
us on the right to attack the left and
certainly the mainstream Democratic
party, but let's talk internal for a
moment. Where do you see the threats
facing the conservative movement and in
particular those nefarious actors who
are hijacking the conservative movement?
I'm not going to mention names, although
feel free if you would like to mention
those names, but those who are seeking
to hijack the conservative movement,
those who are seeking to hijack the MAGA
movement. How big of an internal threat
is this, not just to conservatives, but
also on a pragmatic level for the
Republican party as they seek to be
competitive in the midterms and then
later in 2028?
>> Well, it it is a threat. Uh, it's a
threat to conservatism. It's a threat to
the Republican party. It's a threat to,
you know, our political future. And
people like Nick Fuentes, I think you
need to understand, they're not
conservatives, okay? They're not
Republicans. I mean, this kid was out
campaigning against Donald Trump in
2024. 2024.
Uh, and I believe they are provocators
who have been sent here to try to divide
and destroy the conservative movement.
And my message is really a couple of
things. Number one, we're a political
party. We're not a sponge. We don't have
to soak up everything we come in contact
with.
>> You know, if we were having a Republican
party meeting and somebody oozed in
under the door and said, "Hey, I have an
idea. Let's uh let's raise all taxes to
100%." We'd beat them up and throw them
out. So, if somebody oozes under the
door and says, "Hey, I got a great idea.
Let's worship and idolize Hitler and
Stalin and you know let's uh be hateful
against our Jewish brothers and sisters
and let's cheer on the worst elements of
our of our history and society. We are
under no obligation to absorb this. We
are not a sponge. We are a political
party and it has nothing to do with free
speech. Free speech has to do with
government coercion. These people are
welcome to be hateful and they are
welcome to be morons but they are not
necessarily welcome to be Republicans if
we don't want them to. Okay? We don't
have to soak up their ideas. It's not a
free speech issue. It's a question of
what kind of speech do you want to be
associated with.
>> And so I just I think it's a threat. I
think we have to speak out against it.
And more than anything, I think our
political leaders have to have enough
courage to understand who you who you do
and who you don't want to be associated
with. And to me, uh, it's going to be
far more hurtful to be live. You can't
live in fear of these guys. Like, you
know, the one one instinct would be,
well, I'm afraid. I don't want to lose
their followers. Well, let me tell you
something. There's some people you don't
want because you take on followers like
that and you lose your soul, you lose
your heart, you lose your moral compass,
you lose the moral high ground and you
lose a lot more people on the other end
when you start squeezing that balloon.
>> Well, well said. I want to transition
though. Those are the threats
internally. Externally, we've seen the
zoron monification of the Democratic
party specifically highlighting the
issues of affordability to varying
degrees of success. While it is true,
and you highlight this in your book,
that there have been incredible
successes against DEI, this cultural
class of preserving American identity,
are you not concerned that should the
Trump administration or the conservative
movement not focus more on those issues
of affordability, cost of living, the
housing crisis, that the successes that
the Trump administration have been able
to build, well, the pendulum is just
going to swing all the way back left?
Should the Republican party not take
those issues as seriously or at least in
the eyes of the voters of the American
people, they're not taking it as
seriously? Well, it's a good question
and any political party that's in
charge, you know, the first and top and
issue every day you have to think about
is the economy. It's what most people
vote on. It's always the top issue. It
is the top issue right now. Regarding
affordability, first of all, we cannot
allow the contours of the debate to be
defined by people who propped up Joe
Biden and took prices to the moon. Okay?
I'm not going to be lectured about
affordability by people who are out here
claiming to me that there was no
inflation under Joe Biden. I'm not I'm
just not going to be lectured. And I I
was on TV the other night with somebody.
It was going off and I said to her,
"Well, I know all of human history began
10 months ago, but let me take you back
in time the four years prior to that.
What happened to prices?" And the and
the reality is this. The Democrats spent
too much money. Prices went to the moon.
Now they're skyhigh. Inflation rates
have somewhat normalized, but prices are
still inching up a little, but we're
nowhere near in terms of inflation rates
what we were during Biden. That's
absolutely true. Trump is right about
that. He's also right about the fact gas
prices are low. But I think in terms of
the debate, you cannot let them get away
of defining the terms of the debate
without acknowledging what they did to
the American people under Biden. That's
number one. Number two, there are things
uh that are going to happen, I think, in
2026 that they're going to be able to
campaign on. If gas stays low, if energy
inputs stay low, other things will
follow. That's good for agriculture.
It's good for all kinds of things.
Number three, if you talk to Scott
Besson, he will tell you he thinks we're
going to have a boom in 2026. He thinks
they have rescued the American economy
and we are on the brink of a of a boom
in job creation and wage growth in this
country because of the structural
changes and the taxation and the
regulatory changes they made in 2025. I
hope I hope all that is true. But as a
final piece, I will just say we're going
to have to be honest with the American
people. Prices are not going to be what
they were in 2017. You're not going to
see deflation. What you want to see is a
low rate of inflation, but a higher rate
of wage growth. You want wages to grow
faster than inflation. And we're there.
It's incremental, but we're there. And
we have to keep that going. We have to
expand that ratio over time. But you got
to be honest. Trump had this thing
humming along in 2017, 2018, 2019. COVID
hits, Biden comes in, they take prices
to the moon. That's where we are right
now. And we're, you know, climbing out
of a deep hole. I said the other day,
are we really going to turn the economy
back over to the people with the shovels
who dug the hole, or are we going to
stay with the guy who's trying to build
you a ladder to get out of it? And it's
a tall ladder because the hole was deep.
And so I hope they put it in net stark
terms and not let these Democrats get
away with defining a debate around
affordability when they're the ones who
wrecked it in the first place.
>> Right. Let me just ask one one last
question. um you are the the really sole
voice of sanity and normaly at CNN and
I'm just curious because ever since Elon
Musk took over Twitter now X he quite
famously said you are now the media
right the fact that anyone has access to
information to social media they can
have their own social media accounts
where do you see the role of traditional
mainstream media like CNN or Fox News or
other organizations in the era of the
the podcast verse in the era of social
media how relevant do you see it in the
years ahead
>> well it's still relevant I mean it's
still a huge platform And especially
during breaking news times, people still
still turn on CNN to see what's going on
and they should. Uh, and I think CNN's
been smart to platform some debates. You
know, we started doing a debating show
last August, that Abby Phillips show
that I'm on a lot at 10:00. I think
that's a positive thing. There's a role.
I just think what we have to realize is
there's a lot more competition out
there. You know, it's not just a couple
of cable news channels and the networks.
You've got all kinds of people online
and on social media doing all sorts of
quality journalism, quality political
content and they're talking about things
in an authentic way and that's what's
attracting audiences. So, I think I
still think there's a place for it. I
still think it's relevant. I think one
of the reasons the debating show has
succeeded is because most of it is
unscripted. It's actual authentic
conversation and authentic debate. And
it seems to me that's what audiences
want right now out of media, but also
out of their politicians. And so if I
were giving them any advice, it would be
more authentic, unscripted content
featuring people who can tell the truth,
who know the news, and who can debate in
good faith. That right there, I think,
is a sweet spot. I mean, the the 10:00
show is like the only debating show on
television. And everywhere I go, I hear
two things. I love you and I love the
debates. I don't agree with you, but I
love the debates. The commonality is the
debates. And people, you know, people
get the news all day. You can, as you
mentioned, you can get in a lot of
places, but where are we getting our
debates? It's a country founded on
debates. We love debates. We're
Americans. We love to argue. And if you
can do it in an entertaining and good
faith way, it's a real winner for CNN or
anybody else. So, I I think there's a
role for it. Uh but, you know, you have
to be honest about where the the
mainstream media is. The Gallup poll,
confidence in institutions survey shows
uh low confidence in the media right
now. It can be restored uh but it's
going to have to take a change in
attitude, I think, uh within the
industry. That's why I think what CBS
did, bringing in Barry Weiss, you know,
who's not a conservative, she's like
center left, but she believes in the
truth more than she believes in
narratives. And I and I and she believes
in platforming voices from all sides of
a debate and from around the country. I
mean, she believes fundamentally that we
can tell the truth and have healthy
debates and give everybody uh, you know,
a seat at the table here that news
organizations do not have to be run for
and by people who have one narrow
ideological view. She's, you know,
getting people out of their bubbles.
That is a great thing. I think that's
what our debating show is. We're popping
bubbles a little bit and more of that in
my opinion would anure to the benefit of
the mainstream media.
>> Yeah. Well, well said, Scott. This has
been an incredibly illuminating
conversation. And just on a personal
level, before I let you go, I was an
American student on a college campus
after October 7th, and there were very,
very few in the media landscape who were
saying much of anything pertaining to
the treatment of American Jewish
students on college campuses. you of
course were a a single exception and an
incredible voice of clarity and moral
reasoning. So on behalf of many many
people who are very excited to know that
I'd be speaking to you today. Really
thank you uh for being our champion uh
through this complex and difficult time.
So Scott Jennings, please buy his book,
A Revolution of Common Sense: How Donald
Trump Stormed Washington and Fought for
Western Civilization. Until next time.