Huge Submerged Walls Found in Brittany France

Ancient Mysteries
240 followers
Last month I did a video on submerged megalithic structures in Brittany,
France, because I was surprised to see that the amount of underwater Neolithic monuments
is almost as impressive as the sheer volume of them on land. Brittany was an absolute hive of
activity during the Neolithic and is even home to the tallest menhir ever to be found in Europe,
but sea level changes during the Holocene mean that a lot of sites sit partially or
completely underwater. And Brittany isn't the only place with underwater archaeology resulting
from sea level change. You might remember the submerged megastructure found in the Baltic Sea
that dates back to around 10,000 years ago. This week a new study came out examining a 120 meter
Mesolithic wall and several other structures submerged off the Ile de Seine in Brittany.
When exactly were these structures built and what were they for? Stay with me to find out.
Brittany is home to the Carnac alignments which are made up of thousands of standing stones,
the original purpose of which is unknown. Many stone alignments, stone circles, passage tombs,
dolmens and other megalithic structures can be found throughout the region. There's also
evidence for the reuse and remodeling of sites with one former stone alignment having been
erected over a Mesolithic hut. Several late Mesolithic shell middens have also been found
along the current coastline. So the area has a long history but the transition from the Mesolithic
when hunter-gatherers there had a mostly maritime diet, to the Neolithic when the
megalithic monuments were built, took place between 5500 and 5000 BCE. The timeline we are
looking at with this latest discovery. This new study can currently be viewed in HAL Open Science
and is due to be published in the International Journal of Nautical Archaeology. The story started
in 2017 when retired geologist Yves Fouquet carried out a morph tectonic analysis of lidar data and
noticed structures on the ocean floor of the Ile de Seine or Seine Island. From 2022 to 2024
archaeologists then examined the site and confirmed that human-made granite structures were indeed
present there at depths of nine meters under the water. Since 10,000 years ago relative sea level
has risen by about 25 meters in western France, albeit not uniformly with the most rapid changes
having taken place over the first 2,000 years following the last glacial period. This means that
a lot of land became submerged during the Mesolithic and Neolithic periods. Although much
work has been done on submerged prehistoric sites in Brittany, until this recent discovery no
archaeological sites have been noted off the coast of Seine Island or its neighbouring mainland. On
the island itself the earliest structures date to the Middle Neolithic and on the nearby mainland
several Mesolithic sites have been found on the edge of the cliffs. Eight field operations were
carried out between 2022 and 2024 which amounted to 59 dives at the site in total. Four structures
labelled as TAF-1, TAF-2A, TAF-2B and TAF-3 were identified 1.9 kilometers west of Seine Island
and covering a distance of 600 meters. Toul Arfat-1 or TAF-1 which is short for that is a
120 meter long granite wall oriented east-west which closes off the upper section of a valley
oriented northwest-southeast. Its width varies along its length averaging 20.9 meters and its
height ranges between 2.1 meters in the north and 1.4 meters in the south. So this is a huge
structure. It's made up of two sections, a 90 meter long part labelled as TAF-1A that forms a
barrier between the two sides of a valley and whose underwater depth varies between 6.5 and 7.1 meters
and a 40 meter long part TAF-1B that sits at depths ranging between 5.7 and 6 meters. Structures
TAF-2A and TAF-2B are 90 meters to the northwest of TAF-1 and sit at the southern end of a 100
meter wide valley which is oriented northwest-southeast. TAF-2A acts as a barrier for 50 meters of the valley
and varies in height between 0.8 and 2 meters. Its width ranges between 6 and 16 meters.
TAF-2B forms a 29 degree angle with TAF-2A and stretches for 50 meters to the southwest.
It also partially bars the valley. TAF-3 is 330 meters to the east of TAF-1 and is 80 meters in
length. It's oriented east-west and also acts as a barrier but for an elongated depression
rather than a valley. Its height varies between 0.3 and 1.7 meters and its width ranges between
10 and 23 meters. Around 300 meters east of TAF-3 there are five stone structures that have
been labeled as YAG-1, 2, 3A, 3B and 3C. YAG-1 and YAG-2 sit on the western and eastern edges
of a northwest-southeast oriented valley respectively. YAG-3A and YAG-3B sit inside
this valley blocking it off at different depths. YAG-3B forms a dam measuring 48 meters in length
with a width of 10 meters. YAG-3C is around 40 meters west of YAG-3B and is perpendicular to
the slope on the western flank of the valley. All of these five structures have characteristics
that suggest they were fishweirs. Fishweirs were common during the Mesolithic and have been found
in Ireland, Denmark and Germany. They've also been found in intertidal areas in Brittany and Normandy
by analyzing aerial photographs and satellite images. TAF-1 is made up of four types of blocks
monoliths, large slabs, small slabs and boulders. TAF-2A is also made of blocks reinforced by
monoliths and this is interesting because there are no similar structures to the TAF features at
these depths in western France and such construction techniques can be considered as complex.
Fishweirs found on the Molenne archipelago 40 kilometers to the north have architectural
similarities but are much smaller. Since TAF-1 and TAF-3 are dams joined to rocky outcrops they do
bear a resemblance to fishweirs classified as type A and type B albeit much larger.
TAF-2A and TAF-2B are supported only at one end which classifies them as type D however such
weirs are only found in sedimentary environments which is not the case here. The TAF structures are
not that eroded given the hydrodynamic conditions and many storms they will have experienced over
the years. Even the monoliths are still vertical which does suggest that they are firmly anchored
potentially at their base meaning they could stand as high as three meters. These monoliths have not
been sampled but their morphology is similar to the megaliths on Seine island that are made up of
pophyritic granite. Seine island has two menhirs next to each other which are referred to collectively
as les corseurs meaning the talkers. They stand at 2.3 meters and 2.8 meters in height.
Since the TAF structures are larger than any ancient fishweirs to have been discovered so far
in Brittany the authors of the paper suggest two other possible functions. The first is that they
started out as smaller fish traps which were then continually added to over several centuries
as the sea level rose. This would also explain why different kinds of architecture are used in TAF-1.
The YEG structures look much more like fish traps and were built higher up on the former foreshore
so were likely built later when the sea level was higher. A second idea is that they had a
protective function damping the swell coming from the north. This could also explain why TAF-2 and
TAF-2b do not completely cut off the valley. The 50 meter wide gap between these structures is too
to have functioned as a sluice but may have served as an entry point to the sheltered water behind
the walls. Since no organic elements could be found on the surface of the structures the researchers
could not carry out radiocarbon testing so in order to date them they analyzed relative sea
level rise. The great depth of the walls means that they were initially constructed during the
period when sea level rise was at its most rapid so between 6000 and 5000 BCE. Construction dates
for each feature were calculated based on their hypothesized function and are set out in this table.
So this gives the earliest date of 5950 BCE for TAF-1a if it functioned as a protective wall
and the most recent date of 3650 BCE for YAG-3c which was likely a fish trap. Since the structures
are anchored to rocky outcrops it's possible to calculate how long each of them was operational.
The researchers did this by working out how the coastline changed assuming that the tidal range
had stayed roughly the same. They found that the TAF walls were likely in use for around 700 years.
Researchers over the years have suggested that stone fish weirs represent a technical evolution
during the transition from the Mesolithic to the Neolithic. These huge stone structures could only
have been built and maintained over long periods of time by the collaboration of large groups of
people so imply that a sedentary lifestyle was already underway. Evidence for early Neolithic
farmers in Brittany dates back to the beginning of the 5th millennium and shell middens have been
found there the day to the late Mesolithic. Some of these habitats were quite close to one another
so it's likely that Neolithic people arrived in the west of Brittany from the east and met the
local hunter-gatherers at the end of the 6th millennium BCE. The authors of the paper discussed
that the origin of megalithism in Brittany isn't really known. Some of the oldest megaliths are
found in areas where both the early Neolithic farmers and the maritime hunter-gatherers met
one another. It's possible, considering the size of the TAF structures, that the trend of building
megalithic monuments emerged from Mesolithic groups. Perhaps these monuments played more of
a practical role, just as the fish weirs and potential protective walls did, than has previously
been understood. The authors also point out that in Brittany there is a legend which talks about
the lost sunken city of Ys. This was supposedly located to the west of the Bay of Doronenes,
which is 10 kilometers east of Seine Island. It could be that such legends are rooted in the
memory of a time when sea level was lower, even if other elements of the story are much more
fantastical. I mean, just look again at how much bigger Seine Island was just 8,000 years ago.
It's quite reasonable that such significant changes to the local environment
were commemorated in oral histories. Anyway, that's it. Thank you for watching. Let me
know what you think about these structures in the comments and I'll see you next time.
