Protection gaps, cat losses and the E&S space

Business Insurance
4 followers
4 Video Views·Dec 22, 2025
Featuring Lindsay Shipper from Beazley
Insurance Business TV was recently in San Diego
attending the WSIA Annual Marketplace Conference.
Whilst there, we caught up
with leading insurance professionals
who addressed some of the top challenges
the industry is facing today.
Yeah, I think as we move more
into an era of specialization,
I think it's really incumbent upon brokers and carriers
to be working together to identify
where those coverage gaps are.
There's an increased need for collaboration and education,
quite frankly, of our clients.
And I think we're all in an era
of escalating exposures as well.
So we're seeing exposures that 10, 20 years ago
we didn't see.
So some of the things that come to mind for me are cyber.
There's never gonna be one policy
that off the shelf provides everything that a client needs.
So identifying where those potential gaps are
between a property policy and a cyber policy,
for example, is critical.
I think another opportunity for us is environmental.
As we see pollution regulations and laws,
climate change regulations change globally, quite frankly,
it's changing the liability and the onus on the client
and how our policy is gonna respond to that
and where do we potentially need some amendments
within those policies,
which I think is also a huge opportunity, quite frankly,
for the ENS world specifically
is because we have more flexibility
and more specialization to tailor those coverages
to what clients need.
We aren't beholden by the off the shelf file forms
that maybe some of our admitted counterparts would be.
I think it's the collaboration aspect.
So we work in silos.
We so easily silo ourselves.
So I say, well, I'm in property underwriting,
so I don't need to know anything that's happening
with any other line of business
or I'm in cyber underwriting
or I'm in environmental underwriting and we silo ourselves.
So I think it's breaking down those silos.
I think it's also making sure
that we're increasing collaboration with our brokers.
It's not an adversarial relationship.
We both depend on each other
to ultimately deliver the product that the clients need.
So having a conversation with a broker
and not being afraid to say,
I think that this client might have some exposure here
and I don't know that the policy picks this up,
what other policies does this client provide
and where can we identify some of those potential gaps
and then what products are available out there
or quite frankly, what products need to be developed
that also offers an opportunity for brokers
and carriers to partner together to develop those products.
Yeah, I think the one that everybody keeps talking about
is that secondary perils
are not secondary perils anymore, right?
So 10 years ago, convective storm
wasn't a driver of the market,
but at this point, convective storm, wildfire and flooding
are all major drivers and they're much higher frequency.
So the traditional cap perils that you would look at
of earthquake and named storm,
those happen very infrequently.
Obviously the severity is quite high,
but what we're seeing
with some of those so-called secondary perils
is both a frequency and a severity issue.
The cap modeling tools that we've traditionally relied on
haven't necessarily caught up yet.
They're still trying to figure out
how do you identify where the convective storm exposure is
because it is quite frankly,
significantly more erratic and volatile.
We know where hurricanes are gonna hit.
You don't necessarily have that same level of confidence
in convective storms.
I think we've also seen with things like the winter freezes,
our reliance on the energy grid
and quite frankly, the fragility of the energy grid
is something that hadn't historically
been taken into account in underwriting.
So how do you look at a client's dependence on energy
and the potential long-term business interruption exposure
from something like a winter storm
specifically after what we saw in Yuri in Texas,
but even again, convective storm, wildfire,
all of those are things that the industry now has to look at
from both a frequency and a severity basis.
Well, I think when you look at events
that are happening in areas
that you never thought about before.
So I'm from Atlanta.
Nobody, I grew up going to the mountains of North Carolina.
Nobody ever would have expected Hurricane Helene
to cause the damage that it caused
in Western North Carolina.
That was an area, it's a mountainous area.
You wouldn't think that you would be subject
to that level of hurricane-based flooding,
but they were and they are.
And quite frankly, their infrastructure
was not set up for it.
Florida, for example, their infrastructure
is set up to endure hurricanes.
Even California, their infrastructure is set up,
their construction codes are set up to endure earthquakes
because we're seeing more and more events
that are impacting areas that aren't prepared for it
and that don't have the necessary infrastructure.
It's a real challenge to underwrite it
because you start thinking about
some of the other long-term impacts too.
What is the impact on valuation
when you see demand surge or labor surge
and you can't get materials into Western North Carolina,
for example, because the roads are all gone?
So what does that do to the business interruption loss
that you underwrote to?
What does that do to the property valuation
that you underwrote to?
And so how do clients accurately value their risks
when they are in some of those areas
that they wouldn't necessarily expect a risk,
but now they've got to prepare for it?
And how do underwriters underwrite to that risk?
I think we've got a real seat at the table now, right?
So the ENS market,
we're now about 10% of the premium volume
in the property insurance market,
which has almost doubled since 2020.
Again, that gives us a real seat at the table.
And I think the biggest lever that we have
is that specialization
and the fact that we are able to tailor our coverages
to what those clients need.
Again, as we're seeing more volatility in risks,
more volatility in losses,
clients are having to look at risks differently.
We're seeing admitted markets make some decisions
to pull out of certain geographies
because of the volatility.
And that's where ENS carriers can really come in
and make a clear difference.
