While not all conservatives or liberals align with every right-wing or left-wing position, it's essential to recognize the fundamental differences between these ideologies. Dennis takes us through twenty more examples including American exceptionalism, border policies, and our collective identity, to illuminate the stark divide between the right and the left. By doing so, Dennis helps viewers determine their position on the political spectrum.
I will now tell you how wide the gap
between right and left is. Have you ever
been to the Grand Canyon?
Welcome to the Master's program. I'm
Dennis Prager. This is part two.
There's so much to say. It's in two
parts.
Differences between right and left. I
want to repeat what I said at the
beginning of part one. Not every
conservative holds every conservative
position. Not everyone on the left holds
every left-wing position I am about to
describe. I understand that. But it
applies to the great majority of people.
And one more very important opening
point. Liberals do not hold most of the
left-wing positions that I am
delineating here in this series of
differences.
Liberals
mostly hold the values or positions that
I actually describe as conservative.
They vote left, but they think
conservative.
This is not to convince anybody to vote
left or right. That is not the purpose
at all. My purpose is to make clear what
is not clear to people because you so
often hear, "Oh, that which unites us is
so much greater than that which divides
us," which just isn't true. And it
certainly isn't true today in America.
It might have been true 100 years ago,
but it is not true today.
And that is why this is so important.
the place of God and religion in
society.
The left-wing view is that these should
both be entirely private matters. It's
fine if you believe in some religion and
practice it and take its values, but it
has no place in the public sphere.
So, they want both a secular government
and secular society.
The right-wing or the conservative wants
a secular government and a religious
society.
So they agree on government but they
don't agree on society. The general
belief is as George Washington put it in
his farewell address that which
society's values rely upon is religion.
And if it weren't for religion and he
meant basically biblical religion what
we would call Judeo-Christian values.
And that is the basis of what George
Washington believed would be the basis
of a moral society. That is the
conservative position and it always has
been. One proof I have is that there are
three mottos in America. I call it the
American Trinity. They're on every coin
and they are liberty,
e pluribus unim from many one and in God
we trust. That's a big deal. and god we
trust is a motto of the United States of
America and has been for much of its
history.
As I pointed out in part one from the
Declaration of Independence of the
United States, we are endowed by our
creator with inalienable rights.
Not every founder of the United States
was a believing Christian. Not all
believed in the in the Christian
Trinity. That is true. But they all
believed in the supreme being, the
creator or God.
Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson,
two of the least traditionally Christian
leaders of the founding of America, they
actually designed a great seal of the
United States. And the design was the
Hebrews, the Israelites, the Jews
leaving Egypt. That is how Bible
centered Jefferson and Franklin were.
The Liberty Bell has a verse from the
Bible, from the Old Testament.
Yale University's insignia is in Hebrew.
The role of the Bible in in American
life
h has no peer. It was the central text.
It was how you taught children values.
Love your neighbor as yourself.
pretty pretty central that that comes
from the Bible. So that's a huge
difference. The importance the
indispensable significance of God and
religion and the the desire to get rid
of at least religion on the part of many
on the left.
The worth of the human fetus.
This is probably the most controversial.
I will try to be as uncontroversial in
my presentation as possible.
I am not talking about law. I am talking
about the worth of the human fetus. I'm
not talking about pro-choice or or
pro-life or should abortion be legal. I
am merely talking about the view of that
creature known as the human fetus or the
unborn baby whatever term you wish to
use on the left and on the right. They
have extremely different views of it.
on the left,
that creature, that human fetus
has no intrinsic worth.
The mother determines 100%
whether it is infinitely precious or
worth nothing.
As far as slavery, women who have
unwanted pregnancies and aren't allowed
to make those decisions are somewhat
enslaved themselves to uh birth um
fetuses that they uh did not want
whether for whatever reason.
>> While the baby's inside of your body,
you have the right to decide what to do
with it because it resides in your body
because it is a part of you because it
is not yet its own autonomous thing. By
forcing women to share their bodies with
fetuses to keep them alive, you are
actually suggesting that fetuses should
have more rights than any other person
in the world.
>> And by the way, I've often thought about
this. If a pregnant woman, the mother,
wants to give birth to that baby and a
criminal comes along, shoots her during
a holdup and kills the baby, he is in
fact prosecuted for homicide, the murder
of a of a human being. That means that
if she wants the baby, the baby is fully
human. If she doesn't want the baby, the
baby isn't worth
a pretzel.
I'm not being cute. It isn't worth a
pretzel. It is. It It's like a growth, a
pimple.
It You don't have to believe in God. I'm
not even referring to God or religion
here to understand that. That that's
just doesn't make moral sense. If she
wants it, then it's murder. if it's
killed. If she doesn't want it, then
it's nothing if it's killed.
But that is the left-wing position.
The worth of the unborn human is
completely created by the mother.
The right-wing position is that at some
point this creature, whether it is at
conception, heartbeat, or at viability,
is a human being, is a full human being.
The mother therefore cannot be the one
who determines its worth.
American exceptionalism
The left position is that the very term
is chauvinism.
It is unhealthy at the very least
bragging
and the right-wing position is that it
is an historical reality that America
has been exceptional.
As noted in part one, the French made
the Statue of Liberty, but they gave it
to the United States of America. Because
this was, as one American famous song
puts it, sweet land of liberty.
This is the United States historically.
It has been exceptional.
with regard specifically to liberty.
This was the land that people came to to
strike it out on their own. To fail or
to succeed, but to do it on their own,
unencumbered by the society.
And many did succeed as is well known.
American exceptionalism is not a
bragging right. It is either true or not
true. The left says it is not true. The
right says it has been true. By the way,
it is not guaranteed to remain true.
Right now, at the time of this video, I
hope it changes in the future. I pray it
does. But right now, America is not as
exceptional as it was.
In fact, America is now exporting many
bad ideas to the world, which is a first
in American history.
the greatest threat to the world on the
left. It is the quote unquote
existential threat of global warming,
climate change as it is now referred to
often. And existential, please remember
what existential means. It means the
existence of the existence of the world
of biological life on earth certainly
human life is threatened by the
increasing temperature on the earth's
surface and the earth's oceans etc.
That is the left position. That is the
greatest threat. On the right the
greatest threat is human evil.
Again, quite different.
Most people on the right, most
conservatives do not deny that the world
is getting warmer. They deny that it is
worth changing the world and crushing
its economies
because it's an existential threat. They
do believe it is happening, but not an
existential threat. and that it is a
pipe dream that the world will be able
to power itself on sun and wind alone.
In this regard, if the left advocated
nuclear power, most conservatives would
be on board completely. And nuclear
power has no carbon footprint. It is
completely what is now called clean
energy. And it is a puzzle as to why
people do not support nuclear power when
that is such an obvious answer.
If you believe that climate change poses
an existential threat to the world.
The reason each gives for the Middle
East conflict between Israel and its
neighbors.
The left says it is because Israel is
expansionist and builds settlements on
the West Bank, the place where
Palestinians mostly live. Although they
actually mostly live in in Jordan, but
that's another another story. But I'm
just saying that for accuracy sake. So
they live there and the view on the left
is that is the reason the primary reason
for the Middle East conflict.
The conservative says no the primary
reason for the Middle East conflict
is that the vast majority or if not the
vast majority a great many Muslims want
to see Israel destroyed.
They do not believe that a Jewish state,
even though it is only the size of New
Jersey, belongs in the Muslim Middle
East. That is Iran's position at the
time of this video. And they say
constantly, "Our aim is to annihilate
Israel, and it will only take one atom
bomb because the place is so small."
That is what they say. It is the only
country in the world threatened with
annihilation regularly.
That is the reason that conservatives
believe there is no peace in the Middle
East or a lack of peace in the Middle
East.
The proof of this that it's not a matter
of Israeli settlements on the West Bank,
for example,
is that if Israel's neighbors announce
tomorrow, we are giving up the struggle
against Israel.
We are disarming and declaring ourselves
pacifists.
What would happen
if Israel did the same? If Israel
announced tomorrow, we are disarming and
we are becoming pacifists. What would
then happen?
In the first case, there would be peace
the next day. In the second case, Israel
would be destroyed the next day.
If Israel gave up its arms, it would be
destroyed. If Israel's enemies gave up
their arms, there would be peace,
guns.
At least in America, the difference is
pretty clear.
The left believes that except for police
and other maintainers of peace and like
the military
and perhaps some sportsmen for hunting
and and sport shooting, nobody should
have a gun.
That is the ideal as the left sees it.
And the right sees it as a
constitutional right. And that the best
way to preserve liberty is for the
government to be aware at any time that
if it becomes a tyranny people will
resist. That is the reason in fact the
primary reason why guns are even allowed
by the US constitution.
so that people can protect themselves
against criminals and protect themselves
against tyranny.
The first thing every tyrannical regime
ever does is take away guns from its
citizens.
That's just a fact. But for the left,
the ideal is again a strong government.
And if people have guns,
that is a problem. By the way, it is a
problem. I I I I I fully acknowledge it.
There's a problem if people have guns,
if a lot of people have guns, and it's a
problem if no one has guns. I think one
can be sophisticated enough to
understand that. So the mature
individual has to decide which is the
greater problem. If you are absolutely
certain that people will not have to
defend themselves
either against the tyranny or against
the criminal, then the position that
there should be no guns makes sense.
What if you're not sure that people will
never have to protect themselves?
And anyway, it's academic.
There there are hundreds of millions of
guns in America.
Since they can't be confiscated, it it
wouldn't it wouldn't happen.
To the extent that they would be
confiscated,
all you would have is bad guys with
guns, which I don't think either side
would want.
The next difference, race.
On the left, race is intrinsically
significant, and on the right, it's
intrinsically insignificant.
How's that for clarity? Yes. On the
right, race blind is an ideal. Is the
moral ideal. I don't give a damn about
your color. It means nothing to me. It's
as important to me as the color of your
shoes. That is the conservative
position. The left-wing position is it's
an extremely important thing about you.
Liberals believe what conservatives
believe. Liberals believe that race
doesn't tell us anything about you. What
does it tell us about you? Think about
it. If I know that somebody is, let's
say, black, do I know any other thing
about them? Name one thing I know about
the person.
You know nothing correct.
Do you know their personality? You know
their brains? Do you know their
kindness? Do you know their ethics?
Do you know their passions?
You know nothing. You literally know
nothing about a person if you know his
or her color. So how could it be
significant?
racial, ethnic, and gender diversity at
universities.
For the left, it is essential. For the
right, it is far less essential than
intellectual or ideological
diversity.
If everybody on campus is of the same
ideological persuasion, but they're all
different ethnicities, races, religions,
etc., What difference does it make?
You're not you're not hearing any
different ideas. You're not being
challenged, which is a big part of the
ideal of a university is to
intellectually challenge you, make you
think.
So, one wants ideological diversity and
one wants ideological
non-diversity but ethnic and racial
diversity.
the primary problem facing black
Americans.
For the left, it is white racism or even
white supremacy,
systemic racism, as they say constantly.
And for the right, it is the breakdown
of the black family.
You choose, but at least my job is to
tell you what the big differences are.
My view, I I this is my view is that
white racism plays an a an infinite
decimally small role in the life of most
black Americans. It played a big one in
the past, no question about it, but it
doesn't today.
The biggest problem is that about 80% of
black children are born to a mother who
is not married to the biological father
and very frequently the father is not
even in the home.
Show me a child raised with a father in
his life constantly in his life even
after divorce but constantly in his
life.
and one who also has a a religious life.
And I will show you a person of any
color who is very likely to succeed in
life.
This is a very big difference. Again,
the primary problem facing black America
is it white racism or is it the
breakdown of the family?
Next, the purpose of art
for the left. The purpose of art is to
challenge the status quo, to break new
frontiers. It is to confront the viewer
or the listener with something that is
new and different.
For the right, the purpose of art is to
elevate, inspire the viewer, the
listener.
That is not the case on the left. They
sort of laugh at that idea.
I mentioned scatological art when I
talked about the consequences of
secularism. I know I didn't mention this
one. You should look this up. Actually,
it's almost unbelievable. Some artist
nailed a banana into a wall at a museum
and it became a pretty popular piece.
People would stand next to it for
selfies. See, I would have thought that
that just sort of like mocks the public.
But I think mocking the public is a big
part of modern art and modern music. I
was at a concert my junior year in
England. I was in Leeds, England. So
they had a piece a modern piece of music
which was what's called a tonal. I won't
bother explaining except it doesn't
follow the tonality of any key.
Worse it was a woman singing
solo along with a piano
and it went something like this. I
promise I'm not exaggerating.
And uh I knew I was being played with.
And here I was 20 years old. And when it
was over, I applauded because I didn't
want to insult the singer. But when the
composer came out, I booed.
And the the English are very reticent.
And they looked they turned around at
me. this young American kid. I don't
think they knew I was American. And they
gave me this look and I just looked at
them and said, "Did you like it?"
The conservative is not in love with the
new. If the new is great, the
conservative loves it. but new for new
sake when there is so much great that
isn't new. I believe it is our job in
every generation to give to the next
generation the greatest that previous
generations have produced.
Keeping with this theme
English playwright
for the left there is no such thing.
It's all a matter of opinion.
I've had this argument on my radio show
ever since I began 40 years ago where
people say, "Who are you to tell me
Shakespeare's better than Batman comics?
I like Batman comics. You like McBTH."
Who's to say which is better? So, there
is no such thing as the greatest English
playwright. That's why the University of
Pennsylvania took down the English
department took down the mural of
Shakespeare.
He was just a dead white English male.
And so they preferred someone who was
not white, not European, and not male
and not straight. And they put up a
mural of a lesbian, nonwhite poet.
So do we measure art by the artist
or do we measure art solely by the
greatness of the art? Another left right
difference.
The next difference, cultures.
For the left, all cultures are equal. To
say that any culture is better than
another is to engage in fascism,
chauvinism, or even white supremacy if
you say that it's a European culture. As
the New York Times music critic Anthony
Thomasini wrote a few years ago, who are
we to say that a Beethoven symphony is
any greater than and then he listed
Indonesian folk music?
Well, I'll tell you the answer to that
with with no insult to Indonesian folk
music.
And that is that in Indonesia they have
a symphony orchestra that plays
Beethoven
and they do in Japan and they do in
Korea and they do everywhere
because the whole world thinks Beethoven
wrote some of the greatest music ever
written as much as they may adore their
own music.
I'm a Jew. I love Jewish music but it's
doesn't compare to Beethoven.
And that's just in the artistic realm.
What about judging society in the moral
realm? Are all societies equally moral
in their achievement? Of course not.
It's not chauvinism and it is certainly
not racism to say that the west made
something better when it comes to human
rights and when it comes to free
elections and when it comes to women's
dignity. Yes, the West was better and
has been better. That's that's just a
fact. It's not a boast.
Not all civilizations are equal.
America's founders, to the left, they
were white, rich slave owners.
To the right, they were some of the
greatest men who ever lived in history.
They founded the freest country, the
greatest experiment in liberty in human
history. which is why so many people
have wanted to move to America and did.
You judge people in the context of their
age. You don't judge them by today.
And in the context of their age, these
were giants.
Yes, many of them own slaves. And all of
them thought it was it was a wrong thing
to do, which is to their credit because
most people justify what they do.
Whereas in the case of the founders,
they didn't.
They knew what they were doing is wrong,
which doesn't make them hypocrites.
It makes them intellectually and morally
honest sinners.
H if only all of us would be that
honest.
The purpose of judges.
On the left, it is to pursue social
justice and advance social justice. And
on the right, it is to advance and
pursue justice.
Social justice has almost nothing in
common with justice, which is why the
left has created the term. If social
justice meant the same thing as justice,
it would be a useless term. Social
justice is not justice. Social justice
is if two people are in your courtroom,
one is poor and one is rich. Social
justice says give the verdict to the
poor guy because he needs the money much
more than the rich guy. Justice says you
give the money to the one who is correct
in this case. You pursue justice.
It's not the same as social justice.
National borders
to the left. It is a relic of the past,
the chauvinist past, a racist past.
And to the right,
it is indispensable for the survival of
a nation.
We see this battle in the United States.
We see this battle in Europe.
How sacred are national borders?
The difference between right and left on
this is the difference between perhaps
the survival of a country as that
country or not.
It is one thing to allow a certain
number of people in legally to help them
out
and even help the country out if it
needs more workers for example.
But it's quite another to have
essentially open borders. You have a
right to protect your home against
people coming in who have not been
invited
and so does your country.
The view of illegal immigrants on the
left, these are simply undocumented
migrants.
They are they should be welcomed in vast
numbers and should not even be called
illegal immigrants. On the right, it is
beautiful to have immigration, but it
must be legal.
That's pretty clear
a difference between left and right.
Here's one that'll uh surprise you.
Hate. You'd think, oh, if there's one
thing left and right would agree on,
it's they both hate hate. Well, not
true.
Berkeley City Council in California many
years ago voted that Berkeley would be a
no- hate zone. And I said on my radio
show, I can no longer visit Berkeley. I
hate evil. I hate rape. I hate murder. I
hate torture.
There's a place for hate. Depends what
you hate.
Death penalty for murder.
On the left, it is always wrong. No
matter how many people a murderer has
murdered, no matter how many he's
tortured,
no matter anything he has done,
he should not be put to death. And on
the right, there is the belief that some
people do indeed merit and should be put
to death. This is a very large
discussion, but this is a difference.
It is interesting a call I once received
>> from a woman and she said as follows.
You know Dennis, I've always disagreed
with you about capital punishment.
But a month ago, my brother was murdered
in cold blood and now I agree with you.
I want to see that murderer put to
death.
So, of course, I extended to her my
deep, deep sympathy on the murderer of
her brother. It's a true trauma
to lose a loved one to murder.
But I didn't stop there. I said, "I have
to say though,
your call is is troubling
because in effect, what you're saying to
me is Dennis,
when everybody else's brother was
murdered, I was against the death
penalty, but now that it's my brother,
I really want to see it enacted."
And she admitted that's true. To her
credit,
there is some deep, deep colossal
injustice
on planet Earth
when you keep every single murderer
alive. Not every murderer should be put
to death. It has to be premeditated. It
has to be beyond a doubt,
etc., etc.
But some people have lost the right to
live.
I I think that that should be obvious.
If if I take your bicycle, why should I
be allowed to keep mine?
You have no bicycle and I have one even
though I stole yours.
Why is that not true about a life? I
take somebody's life, but I can keep
mine.
Anyway, it's worthy of its own
discussion, but at the very least, it is
certainly a left-right difference.
What should a person's primary identity
be?
For the left, it is world citizen.
For people on the right,
their primary identity should be
national and or religious,
not world citizen. We're all world
citizens by definition, but that is not
our primary identity. Our primary
identity, if you're American, is
American. If you're uh Belgian, it's
Belgian, etc., etc. And religious
for religious people, their religious
identity is even greater than their
national identity. I am a Christian. I
am a Jew. And I am a member of this
nation.
But for the left, world citizen. Here's
a great example. The most famous cartoon
character ever is Superman. Superman
just a few years ago was depicted in the
comic strip that he is renouncing his
American citizenship. He is now going to
become a citizen of the world.
Superman was founded by liberals and
then it was taken over by people on the
left or or leftists if you will. The
liberals who founded who created
Superman, I think it was in the 1930s,
loved the United States of America and
they made him a proud American.
His motto was truth, justice, and the
American way. By the way, that has also
been dropped.
So he's now a world citizen.
The problem is people need other
identities. World citizen doesn't mean
anything. Isn't there a series of
concentric circles that that make our
identity real? And and by the way, a
good real, it's a good thing.
My family, then then my community, then
my country, my religion,
then the world. Of course, you should
care about the world. But if that's your
only identity, there's something wrong.
It sounds nice, but it doesn't mean
anything. It just means that you'll want
to give a lot of power to world
institutions.
The international ideal
on the left. It is an international
authority imposing its will upon the
countries of the world. Whether it's the
World Health Organization
or it is the World Economic Forum or it
is the United Nations,
it doesn't matter. But it should be an
international body or in Europe the
European Union on the members of the EU.
But the right by definition does not
trust power.
The more power anyone has, the greater
the likelihood for misuse. As Lord
Actton put it a long time ago,
well-known phrase, power corrupts, and
absolute power corrupts absolutely.
You don't want gigantic power in
anyone's hands.
And whether it's the United Nations or
it is the United States government,
that is the reason the United States,
which was until recently the freest
country in the world, was created to
give states so much power. The US Senate
gives states equal power even though
they have such different populations.
In America, the president is not elected
by popular vote, but by the vote of each
state. Because the founders of America
did not want to give massive power over
to a federal government
and not over to even the majority in
every instance. It didn't trust people
with too much power.
And that therefore is the fear of
conservatives with regard to Brussels in
the EU and the United Nations around the
world.
That's a big deal. that difference
and we are going to feel that one more
and more acutely. It seems as time goes
on
as people are more and more convinced by
the left
that a world body is good for them. The
nation state is is almost a dirty word
on the left, but on the right it is the
preservation of a culture, a language,
a way of life,
and ultimately hopefully
liberty, which is the animating impulse
of the conservative.
This is a lot to digest.
The bottom line is there are huge
differences between left and right.
Obviously, there are political
implications to this two-part video, but
I don't mention the word Democrat or
Republican once cuz it transcends any
given political moment. These go to the
heart of the human condition, these
differences.
I hope you'll review this. I hope you'll
make a list and see where you come down.
You may be surprised.
I'm Dennis Prager and this is the
master's program.
Heat. Heat.
Heat.
Heat.
Heat.
Heat.