Perfect Butter Chicken at Home

Feast Your Eyes
64 followers
#Indian dish #Butter Chicken
#Recipe: https://www.joshuaweissman.com/recipe
This is the best butter chicken recipe
I've ever written in my life.
And you can make it.
Anyone can make it.
This butter chicken is an iteration of two recipes.
I always felt like I had a pretty decent
butter chicken recipe, if I'm being honest.
Then I went to India and I learned a few tips and tricks
from a buddy of mine, Chef Saransh.
Shout out to him.
This butter chicken is the perfect marriage
of all the flavors you want and more maximized
while taking all of the effort that it takes
to make a really good butter chicken
and trying to minimize it down to the least amount of effort.
It's still quite a bit of work,
but it's something that anybody can do anywhere.
So that being said, let's make this, shall we?
We're gonna start by making a simple green chutney.
Then we'll marinate our chicken with all the secrets
that I learned from my trip to India.
Next, we'll skewer it and grill the chicken over charcoal.
Then we'll make our beautiful curry gravy perfumed
with the perfect set of spices.
And then we'll serve that along basmati rice,
fresh homemade garlic naan, and of course, our chutney.
This is not mandatory, but I would really recommend
that you have this on the side.
It is an amp up that I think everybody is missing
with their butter chicken,
and that is a nice basic green chutney, very simply done.
Two cups of fresh cilantro leaves, three cloves of garlic,
one teaspoon of toasted cumin seeds,
one teaspoon of kosher salt,
a one-inch knob of peeled ginger,
and three, really any green chili.
I want it spicy.
I have three Thai chilies here, although they're Thai.
I get it.
Bird's eye chilies, serrano chilies,
but we have three Thai chilies here for heat and flavor.
If you can look past the heat, it is so worth it.
And then we're gonna add a splash of cold water.
So you're gonna blend this on medium speed.
Work your way up to high.
Now, if it's so chunky that it's not blending,
add just a little splash of water at a time until it does,
and blend until as smooth as possible.
Now, once that's done, blended and smooth,
you can then transfer that to the serving bowl.
Do not breathe this in directly.
It is spicy.
Now we have a beautiful green chutney.
You can blend this even finer than I did.
You can also add more cilantro if you want it thicker.
I like mine a little bit on the runnier side
because it's easier to spoon on top of my butter chicken.
Now, let's make what you came here for.
We're done with chicken breasts.
No more chicken breasts ever again.
All chicken breasts should be put in a cannon
and shot into space outside of the atmosphere into oblivion.
Chicken thighs are the new norm.
This is one of the best parts of this butter chicken.
It adds so much flavor.
You can't really overcook it.
If anything, the more you cook it, the better it gets.
But separately, it's just like texturally better.
So we have a pound and a half
of boneless, skinless chicken thighs,
which we're going to cut into one-inch cubes.
You can go a little smaller if you want,
but be aware that they are gonna get skewered.
Now, we're gonna add two teaspoons of kosher salt
and one tablespoon of lemon juice,
one teaspoon of grated ginger, fresh, please, dear God,
and one medium-sized garlic clove, also grated.
All right, now you're gonna mix all that together
until it's coated evenly and thoroughly combined.
This is the first marinade.
There are two marinades.
This is gonna sit for at least 30 minutes in the fridge
or up to two hours.
You could hypothetically skip the marination part,
but this is the part where all of the salt
can sort of start to penetrate the chicken
before it gets the full marinade.
Normally, you'll see things like Greek yogurt
used in a butter chicken, and it needs to be thickened
in order for it to be used as a marinade.
Otherwise, it's too loose, too watery.
It's not gonna be quite the right flavor or texture.
But we're not gonna use Greek yogurt, nope.
Today, we're gonna use one cup
or 145 grams of whole milk yogurt.
To get it more thickened, there are two things you can do.
The first thing, and the most important thing,
is taking a clean tea towel,
dumping your yogurt out directly into the tea towel,
which I know seems a bit weird,
carefully gathering all the sides,
and you sort of have like this sack of yogurt.
Now, at this stage, you can get some kitchen twine,
and I like to make mine extra long,
and then you're going to wrap that around the top,
sort of pulling it taut,
and you're gonna go around a couple times.
Tie that just to make a basic knot.
It doesn't need to be perfect.
So now, if we hold the long end,
kind of hangs there, kind of dangles there a little bit.
You can already see that this is leaving some moisture
wherever you put it.
That's good.
If you have an S-hook, great, or a kitchen sink faucet,
you can hang it on literally anything.
The point is you need to hang it on something
for two to three hours or, best case scenario, overnight.
What's gonna happen is the whey from the yogurt
is gonna drip out and you're gonna end up
with a much thicker hung yogurt.
Or you can just use extra besan flour,
which we'll show you in the marinade now.
This yogurt has hung overnight.
So you can see that it's almost solid.
You can now hold it.
It's breakable, but it's also still quite creamy.
So we'll put that in there.
If you hang it like this and it's this firm,
you don't need to add any besan flour at all.
But if you're in a rush,
you don't wanna hang the yogurt, totally fine.
You're gonna add one and a half
to three teaspoons of besan flour.
I'm not gonna add any to this
because the only point of that is just to thicken it.
It's not needed for this.
So to make our marinade,
you have your hung or thickened yogurt.
And to that, you're gonna add many spices.
Two and a half teaspoons of Kashmiri chili,
one teaspoon of turmeric powder,
two teaspoons of lemon juice,
one teaspoon ground cumin,
one teaspoon of meti or fenugreek leaves,
one teaspoon of coriander powder,
one tablespoon of garam masala,
and two teaspoons of fine sea salt.
Two more things.
A two inch knob of fresh grated ginger,
two cloves of grated garlic.
I know there's a lot guys, I know,
but I'm telling you,
we wanna make the best butter chicken of our lives.
You're gonna have to trust me here.
And then finally, one teaspoon of mustard oil.
If you can't find it, you can omit it, totally fine,
but it does add a really unique flavor.
Now whisk that together until thoroughly combined.
Now you can see how thick this is.
You're gonna take your chicken
that's been marinated in the first marinade,
now it goes into the second.
And then you're just going to massage
that mixture into your chicken.
You can see how thick this marinade is
in comparison to other marinades.
Even marinades I've done in the past,
I felt were a little too liquidy because of the yogurt,
but by hanging that yogurt and adding all these spices,
now you have a really concentrated flavor
that's still gonna give you that yogurty flavor
without diluting these beautiful spices.
Now, once that's tossed together,
your chicken should look like this.
By the way, I just wanna add,
you can also skip the marination part
if you absolutely have to.
You're gonna lose out on some of the flavor in the chicken
because this is the part where the flavor
penetrates the chicken.
You don't like that word, I don't care.
It's the only word that makes sense here.
That said, if you are gonna marinate it,
at least two to three hours,
or ideally, in a best case scenario, overnight,
make sure you wrap it in plastic wrap
and set it in your refrigerator.
Once your chicken is finished marinating,
you're going to skewer it.
There are many ways you could precook this.
You could have seared this in the pan
before you did all that other stuff,
and you're welcome to do that,
but the way to maximize the flavor
is to either broil or grill it.
So you can skewer it with metal skewers like this.
You don't have to do this perfectly.
We just need to get these bad boys seared off
and get some flavor on them.
Then just repeat the rest of your chicken.
Once you have all your chicken skewered beautifully,
we're going to take these out and grill them.
You have two other options.
You could broil them, or you could sear them in the pan
before you add the rest of your ingredients.
These are gonna finish cooking in the sauce anyway,
so we just need to get some color on them.
We're going to grill or broil for two to three minutes,
flip, grill or broil for another two to three minutes,
and then you can do that on a third side
to try to get some even grilling and char on all sides.
Yeah!
At this point, my chicken is actually fully cooked
and yours might be too.
With our chicken done,
we're moving on to arguably the star of the show,
our curry sauce, also called gravy.
We have a large saucier.
You can also use a pot or a large deep pan of some sort.
Heat it over medium heat
and you're gonna add two tablespoons of ghee.
That's clarified butter.
You're going to melt that completely.
Now, once that's fully melted and hot,
you're going to add one small diced yellow onion,
a one and a half inch knob of ginger, finely chopped,
and seven whopping cloves of finely chopped garlic.
You're going to add a touch of salt to taste.
Give that a toss to coat
and you're just going to saute that, stirring frequently,
so all those vegetables are beautifully softened,
about three to four minutes.
Once that's cooked and softened,
you're going to add various spices.
We're going to add anywhere from two to three teaspoons
of granulated sugar.
Don't get mad at me, okay?
It adds a sweetness.
I like it.
F*** you.
Admit it if you got a problem with it.
Two teaspoons of coriander powder,
half a teaspoon of cumin powder,
half a teaspoon of turmeric powder,
one teaspoon of Kashmiri chili,
one teaspoon of garam masala,
and a hefty pinch of salt to taste.
Now, give it a stir
and you're just going to continue to saute that
over medium heat for about 30 to 60 seconds
or until those spices are nice and toasty.
You're going to know
because they're going to get super fragrant.
They're going to darken just slightly,
not blacken, but darken just slightly.
Now, this is the key to this.
This is going to help prevent you from having to cook this
for like an hour, hour and a half, like Sriracha's recipe.
I love Sriracha.
I modified this slightly to make it faster,
easier while still maximizing that flavor.
So we have one tablespoon of tomato paste.
Why tomato paste?
Because it's already pre-reduced.
It's already maximized tomato-y flavor
being added to this without us having to add
a bunch of reduction time.
So we've already skipped some of our reducing
a little bit here.
Stir that in, saute for about one to two minutes
or until it darkens slightly.
You're going to add a 14 ounce can of crushed tomatoes.
You could add fresh,
but I find that using a can of crushed tomatoes,
you have the most maximum perfectly in seasoned tomatoes
that you can get.
And they're already slightly cooked down a little bit.
Followed by one and a quarter cup of water
and one tablespoon of meti, which is fenugreek leaves.
Now you're going to increase the heat to medium,
bring that to a boil, then reduce the heat to low,
and then bring to a simmer.
This is an optional add, but I like to add it.
One cinnamon stick, which you can add it in this state,
or you can also optionally slightly burn it.
And that just adds a little extra depth of flavor.
You're going to take a cheesecloth,
you're going to add that cinnamon stick,
followed by six cardamom pods and five whole cloves.
You're going to wrap that up nice and tight.
And then you're going to use a little bit of kitchen twine
and then tie that off at the top
so it doesn't escape the bag, make a knot.
Now at this stage, you can trim any excess on this
and you have a little tea bag of spices to add.
Again, this is optional, but if you did make it,
that'll go directly in there.
And you're just going to let that simmer
for about 10 minutes, up to 15.
After 10 minutes, I'm going to take the bag out
and then transfer to a blender,
pouring carefully because this is very hot.
Nothing on my white shirt.
Let's go.
The goal here is to get this as fine as possible.
You can use a stick blender, you can use a food processor.
Also, by the way, guess what?
You don't have to blend it at all,
but blending it will give it a beautiful texture.
And I like to do that.
Blender top, and then you're going to blend this
on high speed until smooth as possible.
I take that out.
Oh yeah.
That's going to go back into your pot or pan
or whatever you're using.
Look at that.
Now we're going to bring that back up
to a light simmer over low heat.
Mine is a touch too thick,
so I'm adding a half cup of water.
This next part is not a necessity,
but a secret that Siraj taught me.
You're going to add another two tablespoons of ghee to this,
but here I have it melted.
You're going to place that bowl of melted ghee
into your pot.
And then optionally, but recommended,
we have a hot piece of oak lump charcoal.
We're smoking the ghee.
So you're going to carefully place this into that.
It's going to immediately smoke,
and you're going to cover it.
And you're just going to let that sit
and smoke for about one to two minutes
or until the smoking stops.
Once it's done, you'll take this off.
It'll be nice and smoky.
Ooh, so nice.
You'll take your charcoal out
and you'll strain that ghee
through a fine mesh strainer into your curry.
And you're just going to stir that in.
The chicken's done.
This is simmered.
We're now adding a half cup of heavy whipping cream.
Stir that in.
And again, bring that up to a boil over medium-high heat.
Reduce the heat to low to a simmer.
Let that simmer for about a minute.
Add your chicken.
Simmer for five more minutes
just to make sure that chicken's cooked
and let the flavors marry.
Okay, the butter chicken is essentially done.
It smells ridiculous.
Now at this stage, I really prefer to add this.
I know there's already a lot of fat in this.
Who cares?
This is not a diet food.
What I like to add is one to two tablespoons
of cold, unsalted butter to this.
While it's still hot, the heat is off.
It's no longer simmering.
You take the unsalted butter.
This is not necessarily traditional.
It's just a little chef-y.
You add the butter in
and you're going to mount it with the butter.
So you're going to keep it off the heat
and you're going to continuously stir,
letting that butter emulsify into the sauce.
And it's just going to make it a little bit more velvety,
a little bit more buttery, a little bit more creamy.
You don't need to toss it aggressively.
Just a nice, gentle stir.
Now that that's in there,
last thing to do is always, always, always taste.
Does it need more salt?
This is your only chance.
Mine needs just a little bit more.
This is your chance to make sure
that it's seasoned properly with salt.
You worked so hard on this.
Stir that in.
Final taste.
Here we go.
Is it there?
I think she's there.
Beautiful.
Now, we plate.
To serve this, each bowl will get your butter chicken
ladled in there with plenty of fresh chicken pieces.
Optionally, you can drizzle that
with a little bit of heavy cream just for visuals
and also a little richness.
Top with additional kasuri methi,
two fresh cilantro leaves,
and then, of course, serve it with your rice,
chutney, and fresh garlic naan.
Cheers.
Symphony of flavor, of texture, of just overall beauty.
Butter chicken is just one of those things
that transcends a singular language or culture.
You feed this to anybody and they're going to want to,
I don't know what they're going to want to do.
I would be careful who you feed this to
because they might fall in love with you.
It is so perfectly textured.
It's creamy.
The balance of acidity and sweetness and saltiness
and all the spices coming together
to make some sort of beautiful storyline
like Pixar cooked it up for an Emmy Award-winning masterpiece
but in the form of a dish.
So, so good, and that's without anything else.
You can make fresh naan, which we have a recipe for,
fragrant basmati rice,
and then, obviously, you have your lovely
green spicy chutney, which, to eat that,
you would just drizzle a little bit on there and enjoy.
I'm very proud of this butter chicken recipe,
and I wouldn't have been able to make it
and perfect it the way that I have
without the help of Chef Saransh.
Thank you so much.
We had so much fun with him while we were in India,
and this was a fun little thing to bring back home
to share with you guys.
Obviously, slightly modified,
and it's still really f***ing good.
So subscribe.
The link's in the description.
Click that to get the recipe.
Love ya.
Bye.
