California’s Response to Forever Chemicals

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
219 Video Views·Dec 17, 2025
Forever chemicals, known as PFAS, are added to many products for their nonstick and water resistant properties. But with their growing presence in drinking water and the human body, what impact are they having on everyday life once health and cost are taken into account? In this episode, UC Davis environmental health scientist Dr. Scott Bartell explains the science behind PFAS, while Senator Ben Allen and Environmental Working Group’s Bernadette Del Chiaro walk through the failed attempt to phase these chemicals out of common products. Cookware industry representative Steve Burns shares the industry view on nonstick cookware and affordability.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Water rates are going up in California. One of the key reasons is because of PFAS,
or forward chemicals. Water agencies in California have to spend millions of dollars
to purify the water from PFAS and forward chemicals. Recently, there was a big battle
in California state over cookware. There were proponents that wanted to ban Teflon cookware
because of PFAS. And the critics of this bill said that this will drive the cost of this type
of cookware higher. Today, we sit down with all sides of this issue to understand what is PFAS
and forward chemicals. And was it the right decision from the governor to veto this bill?
25 million Californians drink water, get water from their local city or county water district
that is contaminated with PFAS chemicals. A fluoropolymer molecule hundreds or a thousand
carbon atoms long is too large to penetrate a human cell membrane. It's not toxic.
I'm Siamak Karami. Welcome to California Insider.
We want to talk to you about PFAS, which is forever chemicals that has become a major concern
for California. And water agencies are asked to purify and clean up PFAS if possible. And there
have been some laws in California that got vetoed and some laws that have passed. Can you tell us
what's going on with PFAS in California? PFAS are very, very complex. So let's start by saying
this is not a simple story. You really have to get into some details to understand what's going on
here. But PFAS are actually a mix of different types of chemicals. There's over 10,000 different
types of PFAS chemicals. And at least a few hundred of those seem to be commonly used. And
we're still learning a lot about many of these chemicals. That being said, there are a few of
these chemicals, particularly the longer chain PFAS chemicals like PFOA, perfluoroactanoate,
or PFOS, which are basically known and understood now to be really bad actors in terms of being
toxic and bad for our health. They've been associated with cancers, with decreases in
immune function, new studies kind of showing problems with liver function associated with some
of these chemicals. And so it's become clear in the last couple decades as we've learned more about
these chemicals that they're actually harmful at levels we have currently in the environment.
They're called forever chemicals because the carbon-fluorine bonds that kind of define this
chemical class are really one of the strongest bonds in chemistry and they're really hard to
break down. They don't really break down easily in the environment. So once they're there, and they're
in a lot of places right now, in soil and water and the food chain, once they're in our
environment, in our food chain, you would have to wait hundreds and hundreds of years for them to
sort of break down naturally. And so it's a real challenge for how we do it. How did they get into
the environment? Can you give us a quick background? These chemicals are actually, they don't exist in
nature. They are only man-made. And so they didn't start to be produced until really about the 1950s.
And they're incredibly useful in commerce and in all kinds of consumer products. So they're used
to make everything from non-stick coatings for cookware, to dental floss that glides easily
between your teeth, to being used in paints. They're used to treat fabrics like carpeting to make them
stain resistant. They've been used in fast food containers to make sure the grease doesn't soak
through the paper or the cardboard quickly. In pizza boxes, for example. So they've been so
widely used for so long without really any regulation, that as the chemical producers
made them, lots of that material was released into the environment. Some of that tends to fall
around locally, around those industrial sites that manufacture. Some of it actually though is
really transported long range throughout the globe. So you can measure these chemicals in
the Arctic and the Antarctic. You go anywhere in the world, you'll find these now because they've
been unfortunately produced without sort of emissions controls for so long. There is initiatives
in California to clean up the water. Are they in the water system? Yeah, so we found these actually
in many water systems around the country. They're not actually routinely monitored. Currently there
are no requirements for like regular monitoring of these. But for the first time, the U.S. EPA
required in about 2013 to 2015, all large public water systems around the country to test for these
chemicals. And that's when we really discovered that this is a widespread problem in terms of
contamination. Since then, because that was about a decade ago, additional studies,
one by the U.S. Geological Service, USGS, has estimated that as much as half of the water
systems in the country are probably contaminated with PFAS. And some recent estimates from some
independent researchers put that number even higher. What does that mean for us that may not
understand? It's a problem because these chemicals are toxic. We know, particularly for the long
chain ones, which are often the ones that are present in these water systems around the country,
including California, that are associated with higher risks of like kidney cancer,
testicular cancer, certain conditions like ulcerative colitis have been associated with
them. This is a problem that so many people, of course, drink water that have PFAS chemicals with
them. We think we could actually substantially reduce the burden of many of those diseases if
we cleaned up the water, which is why there's a big effort now to try to do that. You mentioned
agriculture. Is it in the food as well? Yeah, unfortunately, these work their way in the food
chain, again, because they just are almost everywhere in the environment, in our soils.
That means they get taken up by crops. And so when we either eat the vegetables or we feed
vegetables to livestock and eat the livestock or animal products, those are all routes of exposure.
And our scientists who study this problem think that most people get exposed primarily
through diet. But if people are actually working with PFAS chemicals for their job and getting
exposed that way, that's probably their main route of exposure. Or for people who have PFAS in their
water, particularly at sort of double-digit concentrations above about 10 or 20 parts per
trillion in their water, I believe that's probably, and others agree with me, that that's probably
the predominant source of exposure for those people. Now we go to Senator Ben Allen, who had
actually proposed a bill to tackle PFAS upstream in certain products like ski vacs and cookware.
We were hearing from water agencies and sanitation agencies and others, public health experts,
that were saying, look, we are now having to spend exorbitant amounts of money just to filter out
this chemical. It's ending up in our environment. And so we're having to spend all this money to
filter it out of our water systems just to meet basic Clean Water Act standards. And so please,
could you do more to reduce the amount of this chemical that's out there in the environment?
And so we first introduced a bill that basically sought to phase out this chemical,
PFAS, over time, products that have successfully been banned in other states. But we had a track
record of success. So we could point to the other states and say, hey, these products have
been phased out of the market. There's alternatives out there. The world hasn't ended.
It's interesting. There was a whole bunch of products that were in the bill. But the one
issue, the one product that ultimately ran into some tension was, as you mentioned, Teflon and
pots and pans. And Minnesota has successfully phased out the use of PFAS-filled pots and pans.
And they're doing just fine. People have been able to cook and go out to dinner. And there's
lots of alternatives out there that are much safer for both the human health and the environment.
But I think he was just concerned. There were various restaurateurs, some that were very
supportive of this, some that were not. And I guess they launched a pretty aggressive campaign
along with the pots and pans industry to push the governor to veto the bill. One of the questions
comes down to this whole discussion about affordability. If we phase out a particular
product that people use, does that increase costs for regular people? The problem, of course, is
that right now, costs are being borne by regular folks. We are all spending more and more on our
water bills than ever before because our water agencies and our sanitation agencies have been
spending more and more money on increasingly expensive filtration equipment to try their best
to get these chemicals out of the water stream just to be able to comply with the Clean Water Act.
And that cost is being borne by regular people as their water rates go up. The problem with
water rates, of course, is it's not something that people often have right in front of their face.
If you're an HOA, it's often covered by the HOA. If you are a renter, it's oftentimes rolled into
your rent. Your rent keeps going up and up and up, but you don't see your water bill. Oftentimes,
homeowners have their water bills on auto pay. And so people just realize that at the end of
the month, their take-home income is smaller and smaller and smaller as we continue to raise rates
and fees and increase people's costs in all sorts of different ways. And so the affordability
challenge on a topic like this is that we're all paying the costs of these environmentally
damaging products through our increased rates. So you were saying that we're going to have to
pay for this on the water side of things. We already are. And so we're trying to find ways
to get less and less of this chemical product being pushed out onto the market. If there are
good feasible alternatives, we should be moving toward those. In so doing, reducing the amount of
this chemical pollutant that's out in the environment, which will then in turn reduce the
costs for our water agencies and our sanitation agencies that keep having to spend more and more
money to filter it out. And of course, they're always passing the costs of that new equipment
on to all of us. So that's the motivation behind trying to phase out those products that
are chock full of this chemical, where we know there's good alternatives out there.
Do you think in California, we're going to have them contained in the next few years?
There are other states leading the way. Unfortunately, California has been behind
a bunch of these other states. There are other states leading the way, and they're pushing
industry to phase out PFAS in various products. We know that it's going to take billions of
dollars and a ton of work to clean up the PFAS that's already out there in the environment.
And that's why we keep hearing so much pushback from our water agencies and our
sanitation agencies and local governments on this issue. We're not trying to jam up
important products for people. We're trying to push industry to continue doing the research
and development necessary to effectuate the transition away from these dangerous chemicals.
There's some really good news. Shen Yun is coming back to California. If you haven't
seen Shen Yun, make sure to check it out. This show is amazing. It's showing what China used
to be before communism. And I've been going to it every year. It's reviving this ancient culture
that's been lost. If you have heard something negative about the show, just be mindful that
the Chinese Communist Party has been trying to shut them down since their inception. They're
showing what China used to be, and they're trying to revive the traditional culture
of the Chinese people. The Chinese Communist Party has been trying to eliminate this culture. And now
Shen Yun has been growing across the globe, and they're performing everywhere in a lot of
different countries. Let me show you a quick trailer for what Shen Yun looks like this year.
Each and every is what you've been waiting for. Shen Yun. Get tickets now at ShenYun.com.
We also talked to proponents and the critics of this bill as well.
The water agencies in California are mandated to purify the water and take these PFAS out of it.
Can you tell us more about that? We have federal and state laws to limit human exposure through
drinking water. And so all of our drinking water agencies, the water purification agencies,
are tasked with removing these chemicals from our drinking water before it hits our tap.
Some are able to do that and others aren't. And in fact, 25 million Californians right now
are drinking water that is contaminated with PFAS coming out of the tap. It is costing us
millions to billions of dollars to clean up our drinking water from PFAS.
A way more cost-effective thing to do is to get it out of the waste stream altogether.
And that's what SB 682 was trying to do, is let's get it out of the waste stream so
our water agencies aren't tasked, aren't the sole providers of safety. Let's get it out of
the water supply altogether so we don't have to clean it up. It's important to mention the
healthcare costs. Americans are getting sicker than ever before. And part of that is because
we are being exposed to a toxic soup of chemicals, PFAS being chief among them because of their
ubiquity and because of their persistence in the environment. 99% of Americans, including
newborn infants, have PFAS in our bodies right now. The problem with PFAS is that the way the
interacts with living organisms is it causes a whole host of health problems. It is known to
cause cancer. It causes immune system disruption. It causes liver damage. It causes things like
higher cholesterol. There's all sorts of ways in which this chemical, when it enters the body,
disrupts the living organism. And this is true with animals that we share the planet with as well.
And because we have been using this product for decades now and because it has this quality,
this durability, but also it is known and used to be repellent of heat, water, and oil.
So it creates things like packaging that doesn't stick to the food. We use it in packaging,
food packaging, so that you could open the thing up and the package doesn't stick.
We use it in solvents and paint thinners. We used to use it in California in firefighting foam
because it is heat resistant. We used to coat clothing with PFAS. These are some of the uses
in other states that haven't banned it. But anything that's water repellent or water resistant
has probably been sprayed and coated with this class of chemicals. It is now everywhere.
I'll tell you an interesting and really heart-wrenching story. There's a girl named
Amara Strand from Minnesota. She recently died of cancer. She died at the age of 20.
She grew up in a small town in the suburbs of the Twin Cities, where one of the largest
manufacturers of PFAS has its headquarters. Well-known contamination of PFAS in the drinking
water in the community. The high school that this young woman went to had unusual high numbers
of cancer among the kids. And she fought very hard for Minnesota legislature to pass a law
to ban the non-essential uses of PFAS. And in her honor, thankfully, the Minnesota
legislature did that in 2021. Since then, other states have also followed suit. Colorado, Maine,
to name just two more, have taken steps to say we don't need these chemicals in our everyday
products. If there's better alternatives, we don't need to keep using them, and we're going to ban
them. This is what California was trying to do with SB 682, authored by Southern California
Senator Ben Allen, was to ban the non-essential uses. And one of the most high profile of those
was non-stick cookware. The reason the governor vetoed that is he said that there's no alternative.
And we've heard from some experts in the industry that it will cost a lot to make the change, or
there might not be any alternatives. Have you guys thought about that? Yeah, it's simply not true.
You do not need to cook with Teflon in order to fry up an egg. There are multiple options out on
the market that are just as affordable as Teflon skillets. There are cast iron skillets, there are
ceramic cookware, and there's stainless steel. All three of those options are easy to cook with,
are totally affordable. And the thing I'm so offended by this idea that somehow it's okay
for poor people to get contaminated by PFAS because it's cheap. I mean, it's not only not
true because these other types of products, the ceramic, the cast iron, and the stainless steel
are just as affordable, just as easy to get your hands on in any Walmart or Target or wherever
you go shopping. But it's also this idea that we need to expose lower income American families to
PFAS chemicals just to keep cookware affordable. It's a false choice and it's wrong on so many levels.
You are kind of the voice of the industry. Can you tell us what's happened?
We formed an alliance of cookware companies last summer, so about 18 months ago. And the reason we
did that was the cookware industry historically hasn't had to advocate or engage in the political
process. As you would imagine, since they create the products that prepare your food,
they're very, very focused on health and safety issues, on compliance.
Nonstick cookware is between 60 and 70 percent of what consumers want in the United States.
So we came together, as I said, 18 months ago, and we had to hurry up and try to catch up
to the states around the country that were looking at not just cookware, by the way,
they're looking at banning a range of issues, a range of products. The rug under your feet,
a lot of outerwear, women's products, cosmetics. A lot of things in the house today contain PFAS.
PFAS is a family. It's a group of chemicals. And depending who you ask, you'll either be told
there's 12,000 PFAS chemicals or there's 15,000 PFAS chemicals. It's a huge, huge grouping.
In that grouping, there are a handful, I'd say six or eight, that are well known to people around
the country, certainly to toxicologists and chemists as being harmful. They are proven to
be connected to harm to the human body, forms of cancers, liver, et cetera.
Over on the other extreme, but still falling under the PFAS label, is Teflon. Teflon is a
trade name. What it really is, it's called a fluoropolymer or PTFE. A fluoropolymer molecule,
hundreds or a thousand carbon atoms long, is too large to penetrate a human cell membrane.
It's not toxic. It's inert. It doesn't seek out any other chemical or molecule with which to bind.
And most importantly, because most PFAS today gets into humans through drinking systems,
through drinking water, a fluoropolymer cannot dissolve in water. So we in the cookware industry,
however, we've become the face of this issue for reasons we don't quite understand.
And people have said, no, we'll let the fluoropolymer stay with medical devices.
And a matter of fact, the other industries that use fluoropolymers are the oil and gas sector,
huge amounts there, aerospace, every Boeing, every Airbus jet, Lockheed Martin, automotive,
consumer electronics. Fluoropolymers are everywhere. But all of those other industries
are deemed essential industries. Ours is not considered to be an essential industry,
although I would argue. Is it because it's touching food and it's too close to us?
It's too close to us. And there's an emotional reaction. And I get that. I'm a father. I have
children. I cook for my wife and my kids. And if I thought something in my kitchen was dangerous,
the first thing I would do was object, throw it out and say, you know, how could this be?
I've never seen a study. I've been doing this for 18 months now. As I said, I haven't seen a
single study which said, no, PTFE, fluoropolymers, Teflon are bad. They're toxic. They have to go.
What's the impact if these bans go through? Can your industry replace the Teflon with something
else? 60 to 70% of every pot and pan sold is a nonstick Teflon pan. Why? They're cheaper.
They're cheaper than every other option out there. And they last longer. A Teflon pan can go 7,
8, 10 years easily. The closest alternative is a pan that's called a ceramic pan.
Ceramic isn't what the name suggests to a lot of people. It's actually
a soul gel. It's a chemical. It's not the ceramic. No, it's not the big ceramic that you fire in a
kiln that we all grew up with as kids, right? I wish it was. It's a very sophisticated silicon
gel that's put into the middle membrane, if you will, of a pan. And when the heat comes up from
the stovetop, it will leak up to the top and it becomes a slick surface. It's nonstick.
Everybody loves it. We've talked to restaurants who throw them out after two months
because it evaporates. It's a finite property, right? So after two months, three months,
that effect is gone. That's the shortest period. But I would say typically,
one, maybe two years, compared, as I said, to seven or eight years for Teflon.
So now we have an issue with every, say, I'll take the conservative, every two years,
a frying pan is going into the landfill, out the window, out the window, out the window,
where Teflon pans, which are cheaper to begin with, remember, they'll last for a dozen years.
We can't get away from nonstick. People like it. It works. Our position is nonstick Teflon is safe.
Why are we looking at all these other alternatives? Because you haven't proven the null
hypothesis that it's not safe. And that's what we've been doing around the country.
We lost in Vermont. We lost in Rhode Island. We lost in Maine. There's six states that have banned
cookware. It's very difficult to be all over the country at once. And that's why the veto here in
California, which everybody looks to, including the European Union. And so we feel that we now
have the ability with this outcome in California to take that to other states and say, listen,
there is no state elsewhere that's got more technical people, more scientists, the EPA,
the Department of Toxic and Substance Control, DTSC. These are professional people. And if the
state of California is going to say, this is okay, everybody else should at least listen.
And that's really what our ask is. How much influence do you think California has over
other states when it comes to policies like this? A lot. Most states, and I spend time,
right, in some of these state capitals and, you know, there'll be part-time legislatures,
they'll have a staff of three. And I'm saying this with affection, right? This is perhaps,
you know, more states should do that. More efficient. But here in California,
we've got thousands of state workers. And again, the ones who are in this part of the state
apparatus, the state government, they are PhDs. They're very smart. They're very passionate
people. I trust them. So again, just to be clear, I'm not claiming that any of them
came to this conclusion to veto the bill. That was the governor. But all of them had the
opportunity to weigh in as the bill moved through the state senate over to the state assembly,
right? There was multiple touch points and multiple testimony.
The amount of exposure that we get from different products is very different.
For example, ski wax. There are several studies really documenting that people who work with ski
wax, particularly like who are, you know, waxing skis during the winter season as part of their job
have measurably higher PFAS levels in their blood, right? So when we go sample those people,
we see that the levels go up at the start of the ski season and continue to increase as they're
continuing to wax skis and then fall off in the off season when they're not waxing skis.
So for example, I'm a skier and I have close friends who are. I advised my ski buddy about
a decade ago to not be waxing his skis like in a closed garage where he's going to be breathing
in those fumes because we know that's a hazardous exposure. There was a potential
law that got vetoed by the governor about the cookware. Can you tell us about that?
Yeah, cookware is an interesting contrast to ski wax because even though we know that PFAS
chemicals are used to manufacture the non-stick coatings on cookware, and again with changing
formulations over time, we haven't actually been able to document any difference in blood
concentrations for people who use Teflon pans or non-stick pans versus people who don't.
That's not on my top five or 10 list of things I worry about in terms of ways people are exposed.
Again, you know, diet is probably the biggest exposure for many people, but it's hard to
intervene on the diet because these materials are, you know, kind of everywhere in the environment
and work their way in the food chain. But water is an interesting one or occupational exposures
because those are settings in which we do know how to control people's exposure. For example,
the ventilation, right, is one way people who must work with PFAS, you know, can use respirators. They
can be in facilities that are properly ventilated in order to reduce those exposures. People who
have water that's contaminated with PFAS, if they're on a public water supply that's contaminated,
we can actually, you know, intervene either at the water system level, which we're doing here
in Orange County, California, which has been very effective to...they're installing new water
systems basically at the system level to remove the PFAS before it's piped out to people's homes.
It's one way to intervene, but people can also take action on their own. If they know they have
PFAS in their water supply, they can use filtration products at home that are very effective. For
example, like BritaFilter or other granular activated carbon filters that you can just buy
over-the-counter at Target or Walmart or Amazon are pretty effective at removing at least the
long-chain PFAS and many of the short-chain PFAS. And as long as you're replacing those filters
regularly, as the instructions in small print tell you to, those should remove actually most
of those PFAS that we know are the most harmful ones from the water supply. How did you get into
studying PFAS? I've been doing environmental health research for a long time. My whole career
really I've devoted to understanding toxic chemical exposures and how they affect our health.
In my first faculty position at Emory University in Atlanta around 2004, 2005, a colleague, Kyle
Steenland, walked into my office. This is someone I respect very much, a very eminent researcher in
our field. And he said, hey, so I have this interesting project I'm working on. Do you want
to get involved? And I had not heard of PFAS chemicals. I don't think Dr. Steenland had either
at that point. This is something that was not on the radar in our field, even among people who
specialize in understanding how people are exposed to toxic chemicals. So when was this? Around 2005
roughly speaking, so about 20 years ago. And I think it's fair to say that most scientists had
not heard of these chemicals at that point in time. He was drawn into this project through
a lawsuit filed by a community in West Virginia, Parkersburg, West Virginia, against DuPont,
which is one of the main manufacturers of PFAS chemicals, because local residents had discovered
that their water supply was heavily, heavily contaminated by PFOA, which is one of the
bad actors that we know a lot about the toxicity about now. People didn't know much about what the
health effects were, but they were worried because, in fact, the way this lawsuit started was a farmer,
Wilbur Tennant, had been looking for a lawyer to represent him because he was right next to
an outflow from DuPont factory that was clearly contaminated. It was frothy, it looked strange,
and many of his cows were dying. They also had strange maladies affecting their organs,
and blackened teeth, and things that he'd never seen before. So he knew something was wrong,
he was pretty sure DuPont was responsible. And so he spent a while looking for a lawyer to
represent him. Nobody would take the case, but then fortunately he found a lawyer who did take the
case. And that's really how a lot of the information about PFAS chemicals started to come to light.
That lawyer really doggedly dug into what was happening there, what were these chemicals,
which he hadn't heard of either. Nobody really knew outside of very small circles outside of
DuPont and 3M what these chemicals were. And eventually the lawsuit settled with the
stipulation that the settlement from DuPont would fund scientific studies into exposure
and health effects of this chemical PFOA. What was it like studying these chemicals
when there's no...how did you guys find out that these chemicals are harmful and these are the
chemicals? Yeah, it's a great question. So even at that time there was some evidence that they were
potentially harmful because some of the animal experiments came to light. It turns out that
DuPont had known from their own animal experiments, intentionally dosing like rodents with these
chemicals, that they could cause a lot of health issues. But those information weren't widely
shared. Only a small circle, even within EPA, was aware of this data because it was
filed under confidential business information. And so most EPA employees and scientists weren't
actually able to see the results of those tests. At the time that you started studying this, did you
ever think it would be this widespread? No, no. In fact, I thought this was just a weird industrial
chemical that was used maybe at this one site. I think I'd heard, you know, they produced it in
Minnesota too and a couple other places. But I honestly thought this was just limited to a few
hot spots around the country where, you know, of course workers at those facilities but also
communities, you know, immediately surrounding those facilities might have some unusual
exposures and water contamination. And I think I wasn't disabused of that notion and really until
the EPA sampling campaign for drinking water came out. And I think a lot of my colleagues,
it was the same experience that really wasn't until about 2015 or 2016, about 10 years later,
after we had really finished most of our studies of health effects in this West Virginia community,
that we actually started to realize, hey, this is not just a few isolated spots. This is
all over the country and in fact all over the world. What motivated the EPA's campaign to look
into the water? Do you remember that? I think it was a number of issues. I think, you know, it's
starting to become clear, right, that there was long-range transport of these chemicals out of
the facilities. So it wasn't just causing local water contamination, even though that was the worst
situation. It was also clear at that point by the early 2010s that the emissions from these
facilities, some portion of those were carrying, you know, thousands to tens of thousands of miles
up in the atmosphere to all over the place. It was also clear at that point they started doing
testing of people's blood. We have a nationally representative sampling campaign
called the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, NHANES, that the CDC runs
and that's been going on for a long time. But as part of that activity, what they actually do is
take blood samples from several thousand people around the U.S. in a way that's designed to be
representative of the whole U.S. population. And from those tests, around the same time in the
early 2000s, we started to learn that almost everybody has these chemicals in their body.
Yeah. And so, you know, seeing that nearly 100 percent detection rates of these chemicals
was very alarming to a lot of people. And so I think that also motivated the EPA to
understand, you know, where are these chemicals coming from? How are they getting into our bodies?
And, you know, knowing that some of the early studies, like our West Virginia study,
that water was a predominant source, I think that helped motivate them to say,
hey, let's look around the country and see where else we find it.
Did they get cut from a lot of these companies? Are the major ones cut off now? Or are they
still producing? 3M, which is one of the largest producers of PFAS chemicals historically,
has publicly announced that they intend to stop manufacturing PFAS entirely by the end of this
year, by the end of this month, right, 2025. So they've announced they're no longer going to be
in the business, I think because they faced so many lawsuits as a result of all the contamination.
Other companies are still producing those. But I should add that two of the worst chemicals,
the ones we know the most about the toxicity and have been linked, for example, to cancer and some
of the other health conditions most clearly, PFOA and PFOS, which I mentioned earlier,
those two chemicals were voluntarily phased out of production in the U.S. in the 2000s to 2010s.
And so at least those two we think aren't produced anymore in the U.S. and also phased out of
production in other parts of the world. Three of the chemicals, PFOA, PFOS, PFHXS, which is another
chemical, are actually part of the Stockholm Convention as well, which really restricts or
bans production of those chemicals in all the signatories, which is most of the countries
of the world, but does not include the U.S. or North Korea or Israel or a few other countries.
You mentioned 10,000 plus chemicals and some of them are very dangerous,
like a few of them that are very dangerous. What happens to the others that are not dangerous?
They just don't get dissolved in the environment? Well, so they're all persistent, right? So that's
one thing this class has in common. So whether they're the short chain, the long chain, the
older ones, the new chain, they're very stable compounds in the environment. And so they all
take a long time to break down and we're going to be, you know, whatever gets contaminated and
it gets put out there into the world now is still going to be there in 100 years and 200 years,
regardless of which of those chemicals are. When I say more dangerous for PFOA and PFOS,
what I really should phrase it as, those are the two we know for sure are dangerous because
we started studying those early because those were two that were most commonly found in people's
blood. So we knew that not only are they out there in the environment, but they're actually
accumulating in people's bodies. And so we started our health studies basically with those two
chemicals. Since then, we have expanded, scientists have expanded over the last decade,
particularly our studies beyond those two chemicals, especially after they got phased out
and started to look at the other PFAS chemicals that those were replaced with. And we're still
learning about the toxicity of those, but there's enough evidence to say at least several of those
that also accumulate in people's bodies have similar toxicity to the original two that we
started with. And this isn't too surprising because they have very similar chemical structures.
They just have slightly shorter chain lengths for the carbon chains that's the backbone of
the chemical. And so we expect them to behave somewhat similarly biologically. Some of those
replacements are excreted more quickly from the body, others not necessarily so. And so we're
still trying to understand that. The Stockholm Convention covers actually three PFAS chemicals,
but also over 30 other persistent organic pollutants, which are basically chemicals like
DDE, some of which have been banned in the U.S. or in other countries. Like fertilizers and this
type of thing. Yeah, but particularly focusing on the ones that have the characteristics that we're
most worried about for causing long-term human health problems. And those characteristics are
that they're persistent in the environment, they don't break down easily. For example, DDE, DDT,
we can still find in food and in the environment, even though they stopped production 50 years ago
in the U.S. And so anyway, this convention, this treaty covers, I think about 34 chemicals that
fall into this family of persistent organic pollutants. But the U.S. is not part of it.
No, U.S. chose not to ratify. The Congress chose not to ratify that. And I understand and respect
our desire to have autonomy as a country. And I think there have been actions taken to try to
restrict that voluntary agreement for the manufacturers to stop producing PFOA and PFOS,
I think came basically under threat of lawsuit from the U.S. EPA. So if the companies had not
voluntarily agreed to that, they would probably force some regulation here. And so I think in some
ways, the steps that we're taking in the U.S. to try to address this problem aren't necessarily all
that different from what's going on in other countries under the Stockholm Convention. But
the Stockholm Convention certainly gives a framework, right, in which scientists sort of
take a lead role in assessing what are the sort of riskiest chemicals that we really want to sort
of restrict use on. UCI Professor Scott Bartel, it was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you very much. Let us know what you think about the PFOA situation in California. You can
always email us at siamak.californiansider.com or comment. We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Khorrami. This is California Insider. We'll see you next time.
