PMQs: Keir Starmer takes questions in parliament – watch live
Dec 17, 2025 #Keirstarmer #Politicians
who are concerned about data security
What reassurance can this minister provide
that their data will be safe with this new system
The data will be safe It will be a fragmented system and
it will have the highest
possible data security standards attached
Shadow Minister Lincoln John welcome
Thank you Mr Speaker Last
night in the Strangers
Bar I bumped into a very influential Labour
backbencher who told me with great authority
that digital ID simply isn't going to happen
This is good news of course because it'
s going to cost £1.8 billion we haven't
got and it's deeply unpopular in the country
So why doesn't the Secretary of State
Give us all an early Christmas present and simply
announce that she's ditching the policy today
Mr Speaker I can only offer the
Honorable Gentleman Christmas advice not
to drink in Strangers Bar unless it's to
people who are already there
We have top it all Zoe honestly
If I may briefly Mr Speaker this Government
is committed to giving women and girls from
all walks of life the chances they need to
get the jobs and opportunities of the future
Last week I met British women tech founders in
San Francisco and this week we held the first
meeting of our new Women in Tech Taskforce to
give opportunities to
women to grow our economy
And build a better future for Britain
Zoe frankly
Molly Rose Foundation's latest report
makes it clear that grieving families
are deeply concerned that Ofcom
Molly Rose Foundation's latest report makes it
clear that grieving
families are deeply concerned
that Ofcom has relied on voluntary measures such
as geo-blocking to deal with pro-suicide forums
Can the Secretary of State explain what steps her
government is taking to ensure
Ofcom moves beyond voluntary
compliance and uses its full
Online Safety Act powers to
require removal or blocking of suicide-promoting content
I thank the Honourable Lady for her question I think this is a
serious issue We need to make
swifter and stronger progress on this
I regularly meet with Ofcom and their Chief
Executive Indeed I met with them yesterday
And I want to make sure we don't have the
delays and we have the stronger action
This is a point I will bring up in the future
The space sector is a critical enabler in enabling
our security our ability
to counter Russia and defend
Europe Can the Secretary of State explain how she
is working with
the new National Armaments Director
And the Ministry of Defence to develop a more cohesive approach
to the space industry
that delivers national security and economic
growth Thank you for the question Mr Speaker
Space is fundamental to many civil and defense
requirements It's vital that we collaborate
closely across government and with our allies
At the European Space Agency Council of Ministers
Just last month we committed £1.7 billion
of funding focused on Just-Act growth
and national security Julie
Lopez Shadow Secretary of State Thank you Mr Speaker
Ministers are making very big claims about the
pharmaceuticals deal with America to make up for
the billions lost in life sciences investment
under Labour But life
sciences firms are telling me
Unless the government reveals what's actually in this
deal those claims are completely hollow So can the
secretary of state reveal because she couldn't tell
us two weeks ago how much
this deal is costing the NHS
And when will she publish the
full legal text so that we know the
details of what the most favored nation mitigations actually are
I may have to offer the Honourable
Lady a mince pie because she's
talking baubles This deal will deliver faster
access to new medicines for NHS patients
And it will deliver the security and stability
that our world-leading pharmaceutical sector
needs including 0% tariffs on
their exports to America for
three years We are also updating the NICE guidelines
For the first time in 20 years a significant deal that the ABPI has
welcomed It's a pity the Honourable
Lady continues to act like Scrooge
If we're making Christmas jokes I
think this deal is all tinsel and
no tree Mr Speaker The problem is Labour trumpets about these deals
And then it's completely vague about what's actually been agreed
Just like the US-UK tech deal
we've now found out from President Trump
that he's put that deal on hold
So despite all that golden carriage action in
September despite the Prime
Minister honking on about
his negotiating skills can the Secretary of State
confirm the Prime Minister has actually nailed dow
None of the key details
on pharma no zero
tariff pact on steel and no deal on tech
We have signed a ground-breaking US-UK tech
partnership deal that has
delivered over £30 billion of
investment into the UK
alongside our biggest ever
investment into research and
development Four AI growth zones
Delivering 13 000 jobs in North
Wales South Wales
the South East and
the North East Our plan to upskill
7.5 million workers in AI skills
And backing great British scientists That's a record I am
proud of It's a pity she remains
the ghost of Christmas past
o source-language elements proper nouns preserved correct punctuation
and natural flow Everything seems to align The final
translation should read as if it were originally written in English
maintaining the formal tone appropriate for the context
Mr Speaker the anti-
Semitic terror attack
on Bondi Beach was sickening It has had a
profound impact around
the world including on
Jewish communities here
in the United Kingdom
These incidents are not isolated We think of
the appalling attack at
Heaton Park earlier this
year And these incidents are chillingly focused
on some of the holiest
days in the Jewish calendar
Mr Speaker I have been
in contact over the last
few days with the Community
Security Trust the
Home Office and the Chief
Rabbi about security for Hanukkah events here in the United Kingdom
Last night we held a Hanukkah reception
in Downing Street where I reaffirmed our
fight against the poison of anti-Semitism
We will use all of our
powers to make sure
Jewish communities are safe
and secure as they should be
Mr Speaker may I also take this opportunity to wish
you all the staff in
Parliament every member
and their families
across the House a very happy Christmas
and a little festive
advice to those in reform If
mysterious men from the
East appear bearing gifts
This time report
it to the police
Mr Speaker this morning I had meetings
with ministerial colleagues and others In
addition to my duties
in this House I shall
have further such meetings later today
Thank you Mr Speaker I associate myself
with the Prime Minister's condemnation of the
horrific attacks in
Australia We must be clear
that anti-Semitic terrorism
is always an outrage
Mr Speaker at Christmas time many across our country will
be thinking of Bethlehem
where the situation remains
extremely difficult The
Government's important scheme
for students from Gaza with scholarships to study
the UK expires on 31
December but a number
of scholarship holders and their children
have not yet been permitted to leave
Gaza If this scheme closes these brillia
Palestinians will lose
their university places
and we will lose their talent Will the Prime
Minister extend the UK's existing scheme into
next year to prevent
this from happening Can I
Thank her I know that Gaza's students face
huge challenges in taking up their places
and we're considering solutions for those
yet to arrive But I do
want to be clear I wa
To be able to take up their places and
continue their education in the United
Kingdom I'm proud we 've
also created the
medical evacuation scheme for children
From Gaza and last week I met some of those
who've been brought to the United Kingdom
for specialist treatment in the NHS Mr
Speaker we continue to
focus on aid into Gaza
And I'll make sure my Honorable
Friend is kept updated on the
next steps for students
Leader of the Opposition Camille Belmont
Mr Speaker can I thank
the Prime Minister
for his words on antisemitism What
happened at Bondi
Beach was an atrocity
but words of solidarity are not enough
We know the evil we
face Islamic extremism
is a threat to Western
civilisation It abuses
our democracies and
subverts our institutions
It is incompatible with British values
So it is not enough just to
protect Jewish communities
We must drive Islamic
extremism out of this country
Mr Speaker I would also like to send my best wishes to our armed forces to the
emergency services and
to everyone who will
be working over Christmas And I would also
I would like to take
this opportunity to
wish you Mr Speaker the House staff and
all members of this
House including the Prime Minister a very Merry Christmas
Mr Speaker it is the Prime Minister's
second Christmas in Downing Street and
by his own admission
he's not in control
He says nothing happens when he pulls
e levers Does he blame
himself or the levers
Mr Speaker I just want to set out what we've
achieved this
week We're setting out
our violence against
women and girls strategy
tomorrow That is
specialist support for
abuse victims
and the 999 calls
experts Sorry Prime Minister
I expect better from you
A former officer we expect
the standards of a good officer Prime Minister
The next lever
was 500 jobs
protected at Grangemouth
To safeguard the
plant's future Next lever was Erasmus
scheme which is being
announced later on today from January
2027 The next lever
Mr Speaker the Employme
Rights Bill
The biggest in workers' rights in a generation
I have a whole list more Mr Speaker
I could go on for a very long time
I'm not sure exactly what
that had to do with the
question Mr Speaker The
fact is the Prime Minister
promised economic growth promised economic growth
but the only thing that's grown is the deficit
His list of broken promises He promised to
reduce unemployment but
yesterday unemployment hit
its highest level since
the pandemic It has gone
up every single month
since he came into office
Why is that
Mr Speaker the
facts are these 350
000 people more people are in work
this year We've got
the lowest inactivity
rate for five years We are taking
A number of measures to
address this particularly
with the young
unemployed I would remind
them that under their watch unemployment
averaged 5.4% higher
than it is today You too
Mr Speaker I don't know what planet the Prime Minister
is living
on but unemployment
has gone up every single month under
him Youth unemployment record levels
Graduate recruitment at an all-time low He
promised that he wouldn't
increase taxes on working
people but he has Last
year he increased national
insurance Last month he
froze income tax thresholds
So will the Prime Minister
finally be honest and admit he broke
his promise on tax Mr Speaker I
'm very proud that in the Budget we had record
investment into our public
services we stabilised
The economy and we bore down on the
cost of living They voted against
all those measures But Mr Speaker
it is the season of goodwill Let me
Congratulations to the
Leader of the Opposition
She has broken her own record since last
week Last week 21 former
Tory MPs had walked
away to reform She has broken that record
Because this week it's gone to 22
The former Vice-Chair has
now gone So the question is
who's next
It's hard to name
anyone Mr Speaker it's
hard to name anyone
because according to
the Shadow Transport
Secretary the Shadow
Cabinet is full of he says non-entities
That's all of you
He should know
The Prime Minister is talking about non-
entities as he looked
at his Cabinet A bunch
of turkeys they could
fit right in a Bernard
Matthews factory And he is one to talk
Last week his MPs were
calling him a caretaker Prime Minister After what he's
done to the economy they should be
calling him the
undertaker Prime Minister
Let's look at what else he's promised
The Prime Minister
gave his word that he
would help pubs Yet
they face a 15% rise
in business rates because of his budget
Will the Prime Minister be honest and admit
his taxes are forcing
pubs to close The Prime
Minister she knows very
well that the temporary
relief that was put in place during Covid has
Come to an end That
was the scheme they
put in place We supported it but it was
always a temporary scheme coming to an
end We've now put in place a £4 billion
Transitional relief We've
also taken other measures
creating hospitality zones greater licensing
freedoms and tackling late payments We're also
bearing down on the cost
of living Mr Speaker so
More people enjoy a drink or a
meal out Freezing
railfares freezing
prescription charges £150 off energy
bills driving wages up What
did they do
In relation to each of those Mr
Speaker They voted against each
and every one of those measures
what pubs has he
been speaking to
They have been barred from all of them
Let's look at another broken promise
I don't know why they're shaking their heads It's not my fault they'
ve got nowhere to
drown their sorrows
Let's look at another
broken promise
He promised to end
the doctors' strike
He gave the doctors a 28.9% pay rise
What did he get in
return This morning
They've gone on strike for the third
time in the middle of
winter in the middle
of the worst flu crisis
in years Mr Speaker
this shouldn't be allowed We already
Banned strikes by the police and
the army Why doesn't he put patients
first show some backbone and ban
doctors' strikes
Mr Speaker let me be
Clear about the strikes They're dangerous and
utterly irresponsible My
message to resident doctors
is don't abandon patients
Work with us to improve
conditions and rebuild
the NHS They left the NHS
Absolutely on its knees waiting lists
through the roof and
confidence rock bottom I
take no lectures from them on industrial
harmony More days were
lost to strike action
They have spent more on
their wealth than any year since the 1980s
Of course he's not
going to ban doctors
' strikes He doesn 't
have the power
The trade unions didn't just buy him
They can shake their
heads all they like We
all know who's running
their party and it 's
not him The trade unions didn't just
buy him for Christmas they bought him for life
And this matters for all those people
out there facing a
difficult new year The
Prime Minister has lost control It's
not the levers that don't work it's him
He's breaking every
promise he has made
He promised to bring down unemployment
It's up He promised he wouldn't
increase taxes They're up He promised
To end the doctors' strike They're
on strike again Mr
Speaker he said his
main mission was economic growth but
the economy is shrinking With a year
Like that is it any
surprise that all his MPs want for Christmas
is a new leader
Mr Speaker we've got
the Muppets' Christmas
Carol here The defections are happening so fast that by Christmas the Leader of the
Opposition is going to
be left at home alone
And the Member for Runcorn is clearly dreaming of a white Christmas But Mr
Speaker we know what
the Leader of the
Opposition wants for Christmas Her lis
To Santa is this Dear
Santa please freeze the
minimum wage Please push
hundreds of thousands
of kids back into poverty
and scrap maternity
leave Merry Christmas from the Tories
Mr Speaker what we're bringing is cheaper
mortgages new rights for workers and
lifting half a million people out of
poverty We've achieved more in 14 months
an they achieved in 14 miserable
years Thank you very much
Mr Speaker
Ukraine is facing a fourth Christmas
of war and loss A
Ukrainian family I me
Last week they spoke
movingly of the help and
support they had received
from our community
in Newport but also of the real pain of separation
from loved ones still in Ukraine
Serving near the front line
Will the Prime Minister join me in paying
tribute to the bravery of these families
and those that support them
And can he also take this opportunity
For them in giving the
House an update on what more
we can do from this Government
to support our
Ukrainian friends Prime Minister Can I heartily agree with
her British families have
shown incredible kindness
and hospitality
We have been updating our
allies on frozen Russian
assets to support Ukrainians
in their hour of need
Today Mr Speaker
I can announce that we are issuing a
licence to transfer
£2.5 billion from
the sale of Chelsea
Football Club That 's been frozen those funds
since 2022
My message to Abramovich
is this The clock
is ticking Honour the commitment that you made and pay
up now And if you don'
t we're prepared to
go to court so every
Penny reaches those whose lives have
been torn apart by
Putin's illegal war Sir
Ed Davey leader of the Liberal Democrats
Thank you Mr Speaker Can I wish you
May everyone in the whole
house and the whole country
have a merry and peaceful Christmas And can I join
the Prime Minister in expressing our horror at the appalling anti-Semitic
terror attacks on Bondi Beach
On the first day of Hanukkah Our thoughts
and prayers are with the families and
friends of all those who have been killed
and injured in this
senseless act of violence
And our thoughts are with the entire Jewish community
Mr Speaker I'm sure
we've all heard British Jews
explain how they no longer feel safe
in this country
Many of us have friends who volunteer
To put on stab vests and stand
guard outside their
synagogue and at
Heaton Park in October we saw why
Anti-Semitism is
real It is poisonous
We must all work together to stamp it out
The Board of Deputies
have called for a comprehensive
government strategy
to tackle anti-Semitism
So will the Prime Minister commit
to that today and set out
What concrete steps is he taking to make sure
Jewish people are safe in
Britain Prime Minister Can I thank him
for raising
this really important issue
and it is really important
that we have actions
That match the words
we have expressed in
response to these horrific
attacks The actions
we've taken so far
are increasing the
funding for Jewish
security up to £28 million
I'm pleased to do that but I'm
sad to do that Having to pay more
money to provide
security for people
to be at their place of worship
And going to school is a sad thing for
this country to have
to do I've ordered
a review of protest and hate crime laws
to stop protest from breeding hatred
We're looking at new police powers to deal
with repeat and targeted protests and we've
launched a review and training to tackle anti
-Semitism in the NHS
There are other steps tha
We're talking to the community about taking action
but all of those actions have already started
Fred Davies Thank the Prime
Minister for that answer and
I hope he will look at the proposal from the Board
of Deputies I think
we can work across this
House to end the scourge of anti-Semitism Turning to the NHS Even
before today's irresponsible strike
by the resident doctors
Patients were facing a
terrible winter crisis
Thousands have been left
on trolleys in hospital
corridors for hours No
privacy no dignity some
even sorting themselves
because there's no response
There have been some tragic
cases where people even
died on those trolleys
and were left undiscovered
for hours And the expectation is that this
could get worse So will the Prime Minister make
Is this his number one
priority to end this crisis
With a mass vaccination
program to stop people so
many people ending up in
hospital with this virus and
funding the social care
places people need to leave
Hospital when they'ready
Can I say how unacceptable the conditions that
some are enduring in our
hospitals are and there'
s no excuse and it is our
number one priority On
vaccinations we've had
over 17 million patients
Vaccinated this year That's an increase from
last year but I want to
drive that up again next
year because vaccinations make such a difference
both to patients and to those who are staffed
Within the hospitals
and of course with
action on social care Thank you Thank
you Mr Speaker and Merry Christmas to
you and all your fantastic staff Prime
Minister 2025 has been a momentous
year for Darlington Britain's best
town but there is much more to do I
met a lovely woman while door knocking
Recently she has been working 12-hour night shifts
at a care home in the town Her
colleagues are on minimum wage and many
care workers across the town aren't even paid
Time and a half for working
on Christmas day Like
so many others in her profession she wants the
system fixed not for herself
but for her residents
I believe that starts with radical improvements
To care workers' terms and conditions
Prime Minister this
workforce of mostly women does essential
skilled and exhausting
work without fuss fanfare
and still without fair pay
They deserve better What
Can I tell the Darlington care workers
will improve for them by this time
next year at Christmas Can I thank her Carers are incredibly
skilled workers My
Sister is one of them and I'm very proud of
them and her for their invaluable work I'm
pleased that we've increased the carers
allowance earnings limit
by the largest amount
Amount since it was introduced
and we're providing £
500 million to fund the
first ever fair pay agreement
through the Employment Rights Act which was passed
yesterday to make sure care workers are properly
Recognized and rewarded
Stephen Flynn
It is indeed the season of goodwill
So with that in mind I don't intend
It is indeed the season
of goodwill so with that
mind I don't intend on
asking the Prime Minister
about his broken promises on energy bills
the thousand jobs being lost in the North Sea
the fact that Peter Mandelson is still a member
of the House of Lords I won't even
ask him about the chaos engulfing
the Labour Party his budget and
indeed his own
leadership No Mr Speaker
I simply want to wish the Prime
Minister a happy Christmas
How does he intend on spending
his final one in Downing Street
I'm going to get an
update from the Chancellor
on Grangemouth in just a minute He 's
clearly not interested in Grangemouth
You would have thought
on a day like this
That he'd want to welcome
the £120 million investment
into Grangemouth It's a
landmark investment protecting 500 jobs
and hundreds more
across Scotland's supply
He can't even bring himself to mention
it Mr Speaker that's on top of the
typhoon defence jobs in Edinburgh and
shipbuilding jobs on
the Clyde and after
For decades of SNP rule they're totally
out of ideas They can 't
even welcome the
Grangemouth news
Scotland deserves change
next year with Anas Sarwar Thank you
Mr Speaker
In 2020
My constituents John
and Karen Rowlands
lost their son Andrew
in a road collision
He was just
18 years old and a passenger
Like too many others Mr Speaker
The driver of the car should never have
been on the road He
was underage unlicensed
and uninsured and bought the car on social
media using cash Can
the Prime Minister tell
How can bereaved families like the
Rowlands have a
meaningful say in our road
safety strategy and
ensure the right checks are in
place to prevent future tragedies
Prime Minister May I
send the condolences
of the whole House to Andrew's
family It's an awful
case and every life
lost to dangerous driving is a tragedy
In terms of the range of
measures that we're taking
to protect young drivers they include penalties
for driving uninsured and unlicensed and measures
to reduce the risks posed
by unroadworthy vehicles
And in terms of the influence
of her and her constituents I'd be very
happy to set up an
appropriate meeting
for her constituents Ben Macguire
Thank you Mr Speaker and I thank
the Prime Minister
for confirming a
Cornwall only devolution deal since
my last PMQ In 1988 over 20 000
North Cornwall constituents were poisoned by the
South West Water Authority
In a recent BBC documentary
strong suggestions were made of a cover-up by the
Thatcher Government None of
those victims have ever bee
Properly compensated and today South West Water
poisoned my constituents
with impunity with their
constant sewage dumping
Christmas swims across Cornwall
have been cancelled again while constituents like
William Howells from Padstow
has been hospitalized
Will the Prime Minister please meet with me
to finally deliver justice
to all water poisoning
victims and make sure
this never happens again
The Prime Minister is right to remind us of
what was a terrible
scandal and I will ask the
Water Minister to meet
him and his constituents
to discuss it Here in the public are right
To be furious that companies are still
polluting our seas lakes
and rivers Mr Speaker
we've taken action banning bonuses for bosses
in six polluting companies changing the law
So that those who hide sewage bills
can be locked up and issuing almost
£30 million in fines to clean up
waterways We're clearing up the mess
The mess that the
party over there left like everything else
Thank you Mr Speaker The
West Midlands car industry
is world famous and this Government backs our
automotive sector We got
a US trade deal and when
criminals shut down
production at Jaguar Land Rover
We backed the supply chain
Brilliant companies like J H
Lavender in my constituency
What a contrast with
the Member for Clacton not here as usual
who said
I predict that this will be the most significant development in the field this year
That the workers of the West
Midlands and the
entire country need a
Labour Government and can't afford
the economic vandalism of Reform UK
Apparently the leader of Reform is in the
lounge He likes an early
getaway at Christmas
to get to his place
in France Mr Speaker he
lobbied for economic
sanctions against his ow
He showed no concern for British workers and had
zero patriotism when he was in the United States The
difference is our US deal
secured the best deal for the
car industry and provided
certainty for the workforce
At JLR There's more good news for
the car industry this week because Nissan is now
building its new electric
LEAF in Sunderland
That's the difference a
Labour Government makes
Sir Julian Smith
Compliment the Prime
Minister on the work he's
done regarding Ukraine and wish him well over
Christmas on that topic Mr Speaker pubs are
at the center of rural
communities in areas suc
as North Yorkshire They
are under more pressure
than ever before Could I
urge the Prime Minister
and the Government to look again at the rates
issue and to look at how
to relax the transitional
Relief for those
pubs many of which are
otherwise going to
close Mr Speaker it is
an important sector At the heart of
this challenge is the
end of the temporary
The relief that was put in place during the
Covid crisis and that's why we put in place the
transitional measures and
investing half a million
into our hospitality support
scheme to help rural pubs
Diversify On issues like the cost
of living we've taken a number of
measures to make it easier for people
to go out and enjoy themselves in pubs
And we'll always look at what measures
we can put in place to support pubs Thank
you Mr Speaker People across Lichfield
Burntwood and the Villages will be looking
Looking forward to a very happy new year not least
because of this Government's commitment to the
Midland rail hub project which will revolutionise
rail travel across the West
Midlands and further afield
We are all really eager to see a better service
between Lichfield and Birmingham as soon as
possible though so will the Prime Minister join
my campaign for a more regular service on the line
Cross city line and can he
confirm that rail commuters
will benefit from frozen fares because of this
Labour Government Well Mr Speaker the hub means more
regular services for up to
15 stations across the region
That's vital after the Lichfield to Birmingham
service was slashed under
the previous government
The construction will create around 13 000 jobs and we're delivering them
as quickly as possible
with Network Rail awarding design contracts
this week Mr Speaker we're also freezing
rail fares that's the first time that's
happened in 30 years
saving his constituents abou
£90 a year on the commute to Birmingham
Andrew Stirling Thank you very
much Mr Speaker as
the ghost of Christmas
past scoops up the Prime Minister
From his slumber in number 10 this year I
wonder what he will show him on Christmas
Eve maybe it would be the devastated
family farmer putting up the for sale sig
On the yard or the children hugging
each other as their independent school
closes or any of the
100 000 hospitality
workers who have lost their jobs
or the millions of families that are trying
to work out how they
will pay their tax bill
to fund the ever-growing welfare state So is
it no wonder that the
ghost of Christmas future
He has given up on this the Prime
Minister and all that is left is
for him to get his
bag of coal
from Santa and his P45 from his own MP
Happy Christmas I saw that the
honourable member was asking the
public to suggest questions
for today I actually put in a bid Mr Speaker
I filled it in I assume
he missed the questio
I said he should ask
about the 6 000 well
-paid high skilled jobs we've secured in
his constituency building titles to an 8
billion deal with
Turkey I'm disappointed
at he didn't want to talk
about good well-paid jobs in
his constituency secured by this Labour Governme
Mr Speaker
just days before Christmas
heartbroken Derbyshire families and
staff have learned that the reform-
led council is closing 8 care homes
Including Rowthorn
in Amber Valley
and that comes just days after
learning that the council's cost
saving claims were entirely fabricated
Does the Prime Minister
agree with me that when
reform talks about doge
what they're actually talking
about is cutting vital public services and will he
join me in urging Derbyshire
County Council to think aga
It is deeply concerning to hear about the
closure of 8 Derbyshire
care homes by the reform
-led Derbyshire Council It will be hugely concerning to residents
and to their families
While we're making £3.7 billion of extra
funding available to councils to fund
social care and let me say to the
Member for Clapton
relaxing in the lounge
Christmas is a time
forgiveness it's never too
late to apologize
to former
classmates Nick Timothy
Thank you Mr Speaker Labour 's
tax rises mean lower
growth and higher unemployment
and the reason for the tax
rises is government spending The Prime Minister personally promised the country
to limit spending increases
o £9.5 billion a year
so what mandate did he
have in his first two budgets
to increase annual spending 15 times
faster by
£146 billion
Mr Speaker
We had a mandate to change because we inherited major challenges across
the country if only he had
done something to solve
these problems when he was
working in Downing Street he left a complete mess
Neil Duncan-Jones Mr Speaker
over the past few weeks
I have been contacted by
a number of constituents
who work in the health
and care sector because
they are concerned about
the proposed changes
To the rules surrounding indefinite leave to
remain these individuals
came to this country to
do a job we asked them
to do and then we decided
to change the rules half
way through the process
does the Prime Minister
agree that if we are
to be a proud rules-based
nation going back on
our word to people who
are contributing to our
society and building lives here is not only
It's just unfair it's also profoundly un-British
Prime Minister Mr Speaker
we are replacing a failed
settlement system with one
that is fair and recognises
contribution it is right to
apply more stringent controls
And we are currently
consulting on the right approach
I do recognize the huge
contribution of those working
in our NHS and will not change the rules for those
who already have settled
status Sir John Whittingdale
Thank you Mr Speaker Jimmy Lai is
79 and is a British citizen he has
already been in
prison in Hong Kong for
5 years simply for
being a journalis
If he receives a further sentence on the
12th of January he is
likely to die in prison
will the Prime Minister make clear that
his visit to Beijing
can only go ahead if
Jimmy Lai is released The
Prime Minister I thank him
for raising this really
important case And as he knows
we continually raise this
with our counterparts and
will continue to do so and
I condemn the conviction
Obviously we await the
sentence but it's absolutely
clear they've been targeted by the authorities and this is
wrongful and I call it out It is
important that we continue to engage so that we ca
Raise this issue with your
counterparts Sam Corning
In September a National Secular Society report highlighted alarming numbers
of extremist religious
organizations in the UK
from various faith traditions
Expressing hideous views about
women including promoting
female genital mutilation and denying the existence
of marital rape Many of these
are registered as charities
and therefore eligible for various tax exemptions
As well as thousands or even millions of pounds
in public money through gift aid the Prime Minister
as part of the Government'
s mission to halve violence
against women and girls will support my campaign
For a review of charity
law and regulation so
that we can make sure the UK taxpayer
isn 't funding extremism and hate Minister can I
thank him for raising this really importa
Issue The scale of violence
and abuse suffered by women
and girls is a national emergency and the violence
against women and girls strategy will be published
tomorrow setting out concrete
steps in order to deal with it
With this we've already taken
action to protect victims
including placing domestic
abuse specialists in the first
5 999 control rooms and we're launching a new
National Policing Centre to
coordinate police response
And target these crimes
I'll make sure that
Ministers look specifically at the issues
that he's raised Jeremy Corbyn Thank you Mr
Speaker yesterday the Minister of State for
Justice declined a meeting with the
representatives of a
number of hunger strikers in
prison at the present time These are all remand
prisoners they're not convicted of anything
Since then a further prisoner
Kazam has been taken to
hospital as have others Many
people are very concerned
about the regular breaches of prison conditions
and prison rules in respect of these hunger strikes
Strikers Will he make
arrangements for the Ministry
of Justice to meet representatives of hunger
strikers to discuss these breaches of the
conditions they're experiencing
at this pleasant time
The Prime Minister He
will appreciate that there
are rules and procedures in place in relation to
hunger strikers and we're following those rules
and procedures Abdussama
Hamid Thank you Mr Speaker
England is the only country in the world with a
fully privatised and
monopolised water system and
is broken My constituents
in Sheffield Central like
many across the country continue to face problems
Burst water pipes polluted rivers and rising
bills All while the Chief
Executive of Yorkshire
Water has taken 1.3
million in bonus payments
to an offshore company and that's on top
Of her very healthy £660 000 salary
Will the Prime Minister
assure the House that the
forthcoming Water White
Paper will have stronger
accountability and put public interest first
Before bosses bonuses and more
importantly will it consider
bringing the essential public service back into the
House
Prime Minister Yes is the simple answer to that question
and our decisions are already
holding polluters to account
Account Mr Speaker severe
fines banning bonuses
and a record 83 criminal investigations have
been launched We've also secured over £100
billion of investment
to upgrade infrastructure
Deliver better services to constituents Final
question David Mundell
Mr Speaker on Sunday at
Arlington Cemetery I will
have the honour of joining
family and friends of
many of the victims of the
The bombing of Pan Am Flight 103
over Lockerbie on the 21st of
December 1988 The
worst terrorist
atrocity in the
United Kingdom Does
The Prime Minister agrees
with me that after all these
years those family and
friends deserve both truth
and justice and will the
United Kingdom Government
continue to do all it can to bring
about that outcome
Can I thank him for raising
this and nobody could
forget the shocking scenes at Lockerbie and I
know the huge impact it's had on the community
where he grew up and where
people have responded
With such compassion and
strength He has rightly
stood by their search for justice and truth for
all of the intervening
years and I pay tribute to
that All of our thoughts
remain with the families
And friends of all the victims
who deserve the truth and I urge
the Scottish authorities to
consider the points that he raises

