Judge Song Kim serves on the Changwon District Court in South Korea. While serving as a judge, she was seconded by the Korean judiciary to the International Criminal Court (ICC) to work as a Visiting Professional, contributing to research and practice in international criminal justice and human rights accountability. Judge Kim is an active member of both the International Criminal Law Society and the International Human Rights Law Research Association under the Supreme Court of Korea. She is a contributing co-author of the recently published ICC Case Study by the Judicial Development Foundation and has delivered expert presentations at major global forums addressing forced organ harvesting and transplant ethics, including “Global Magnitsky Sanctions as Measures to Combat and Prevent Forced Organ Harvesting” at the 2021 World Summit on Combating and Preventing Forced Organ Harvesting and “Organ Transplant Act in Korea – Overview, Cases and Suggestion for Amendment in Compliance with the Declaration of Istanbul (2018)” at the 2019 Asia Symposium on Combating Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism at the University of Tokyo.
Distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, it is an honor to speak at this seminar marking
the anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Nearly 20 years have passed
since I first encountered the shocking reports of forced organ harvesting in China.
What remains most painful is that this grave crime has still not ended.
Today, I'll briefly share Korea's experience and the evidence related to this issue.
But my main focus is on what must come next, how the international community must now move
from awareness to coordinated international and transnational action to prevent and combat
forced organ harvesting. Forced organ harvesting from prisoners of conscience,
most notably Falun Gong practitioners, is a crime of extreme brutality.
But Korea is not merely an outside observer of this tragedy. Through transplant tourism,
Korea has been directly and systematically entangled in this crime.
A 2016 U.S. medical study identified South Korea as the second largest source country
for overseas organ transplants, with China as the main destination.
Several Korean media investigations also revealed that large numbers of Korean patients
were traveling to China for organ transplants with extremely short waiting times.
My own legal analysis further confirmed the extreme abnormality of China's transplant tourism.
Among about 70 Korean organ trafficking criminal cases, most cases involved brokerage to China,
with some brokers committing dozens of illegal transactions. The so-called donors were
unidentified Chinese individuals or prisoners, and the waiting period was often just three weeks,
dramatically impossible in any ethical system. Confronted with these realities,
Korean civil society, particularly organizations such as KAEOT, has worked for more than a decade
with partners, including DAFO, to raise public awareness and push for legal reform.
These efforts led to an important amendment in 2020. Korean law now requires patients who
receive transplants abroad to report their transplant to the Ministry of Health. This
was designed to end the legal invisibility of transplant tourism. However, not a single
case has been reported to date. This reveals a difficult but critical truth. National legislation
alone is not enough when the crime itself is transnational and systematically hidden.
Public awareness has risen not only in Korea but across the world. Parliaments throughout
North America and Europe have passed resolutions condemning forced organ harvesting. Most recently,
the Falun Gong Protection Act was passed by the U.S. House of Representatives. These developments
are meaningful. But we must now move beyond fragmented domestic action toward coordinated
international responsibility. This November, 15 countries issued joint statements condemning
China's human rights violations. The next step must be to elevate this issue to the institutional
level of the United Nations, particularly the Human Rights Council and the General Assembly.
International law is clear. States do not merely have the right to act, they have the duty to act.
Under international law, all states are legally obligated to cooperate to bring to an end
serious crimes such as genocide and crimes against humanity. This duty is now recognized
as part of customary international law. This means that when such crimes occur,
other states must not recognize the situation as lawful, must not assist in maintaining it,
and must actively cooperate, primarily through collective actions such as UN resolutions.
We can see this clearly in state practice today. The international response to Russia's war crimes
in Ukraine shows that this duty to cooperate is real and actionable. The UN General Assembly
condemned the aggression, and the Human Rights Council adopted two resolutions to condemn the
crimes and launch investigations. Another critical international mechanism is the UNTOC,
the United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime, and its Protocol
to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking in Persons, also known as the Palermo Protocol.
First organ harvesting in China represents the most extreme form of human trafficking for the
purpose of organ removal. Yet remarkably, this issue has never been systematically addressed
within UNTOC's action plans or conference resolutions.
Encouragingly, in 2024, the U.S. State Department's Trafficking in Persons Report
explicitly identified China's forced organ harvesting as a prime example of organ removal
trafficking. The same year, KAEOT, the Korean NGO, participated as a panelist in UNTOC's
constructive dialogue addressing the forced organ harvesting issue directly within the treaty
framework. Together, this development shows why the UNTOC approach is so important. It is practical,
action-oriented, and less political, focusing on real investigations and law enforcement
cooperation. When combined with the moral force of the human rights and genocide framework,
it creates a far stronger path for international action.
China is a party to the Genocide Convention and is bound by the strongest rules of international
law. But, in reality, there is still no effective international court process to hold the Chinese
government legally accountable, mainly because the major international courts, such as the ICJ
and the ICC, do not have clear jurisdiction over the situation. But, this does not absorb
the rest of the world. When crimes shock the conscience of humanity, international law requires
collective responsibility. States must use every lawful tool available, especially collective
action through UN resolutions, along with legislation, sanctions, universal jurisdiction,
diplomatic pressure, and treaty mechanisms. If the world turns away now, we are not only
abandoning the victims, we are allowing a failure of the international legal order itself. Because
every state has a legal duty to cooperate and to take all lawful measures to bring the atrocity to
an end. To remain silent is not just a moral failure, it is a failure to uphold international
law. Thank you for listening.