Sculpture in the ancient Greek world, part 1

Eternal Sculpt
13 followers
31 Video Views·Dec 12, 2025
Joshua Hall, Matthew Lloyd, and Josho Brouwers sit down to talk about sculptures in the ancient Greek world. In this first part, we deal with sculpture from the pre-Classical periods. Unlike our previous podcast videos, this one includes pictures of the stuff we talk about. Enjoy!
Comments are disabled for this video.
Hello and welcome to another Ancient World Magazine podcast.
Today we'll be talking about sculpture in the Greek world.
My name is Matthew Lloyd.
I'm Joshua Hall.
And I'm Yoshua Brows.
I don't know if this is the best thing to sort of say first up,
but some of the reading I was doing for this episode,
I noticed that people were including the Mykonos relief amphora
showing the sack of Troy, the Trojan horse, in sculpture sections
rather than with pottery and vase painting,
which is where I would instinctively think of putting it.
I bring that up to sort of say,
how do we unify what we think of as sculpture?
Because when you raise the topic,
the first thing you probably think of are the freestanding statues
beginning in the archaic period with the Koroi and Korlai
and going on into the classical period and so on.
But then alongside that, you'll think of architectural sculpture,
which varies between low relief friezes to very high relief metopes
and pedimental sculptures that are just sculptures
pretty much in the round, arranged in the triangular roof sections
at the front of temples.
And then going back a bit further in the earlier stages,
we'd even talk about terracotta figurines and all kinds of 3D models.
So what we mean by sculpture is quite broad.
It's generally a lot more than simply carved marble
or cast bronze that a lot of people think of as being Greek sculpture.
And actually, it's funny that you mentioned terracotta by saying going back,
because actually in the Western Greek world, in Magna Graecia,
terracotta is one of the main forms of sculpture
all the way through the Greek period.
We don't see marble working all that often.
And things like terracotta and limestone are much more common materials in the West.
And some of this, something we will probably get more into later,
is to do with available resources.
So in mainland Greece and the Aegean Islands,
there are many marble deposits.
There's a lot of good marble that is used for architecture and sculpture,
whereas elsewhere, and in order to get at that marble,
you've got to have the technology that helps you dig it out the ground.
The same with bronze.
You need access to tin and copper to have much bronze sculpture.
So the kinds of sculpture you get in different places at different times
depend very much on what's locally available,
what kind of connections you have to get things that aren't locally available,
and the techniques known to you at the time.
So I was thinking, this might not even be a question for most people,
but I was thinking about how in Iron Age sculpture,
which is mostly either ceramic or in the 8th century bronze,
there's no, at least I don't know of any iron sculpture.
And of course, that's at least in part because there's no casting of iron.
They can't get the temperatures high enough to melt iron and cast it.
They are forging iron.
Therefore, you wouldn't really be able to create a human figure
or a representative figure out of iron.
So this is one of the advantages bronze has as an artistic medium.
When you say sculpture, I think most people, like what you said,
probably think about large statues,
but you should also include the small figurines,
also simple things like the lead figurines
that are very common throughout the ancient world
that you also find in large quantities at the Temple of Artemis Orthea,
I think it's part of that sort of stuff.
I'm not sure if I would include the Mykonos glass though.
Well, you think you wouldn't include the Mykonos vase,
but then is it more like the Metopes on slightly later buildings?
And perhaps at this point, we should explain what a Metope is,
which is on the Doric style of architecture around the architrave.
It is divided into sort of roughly square sections
and some of these have three lines across them
and we call them triglyphs or they are called triglyphs,
I guess that is an ancient word.
And then between them, there is a space that was often used for relief sculpture
and you find similar things on early bronze tripods
where there is a square section and you can have a small scene
normally involving no more than two or three figures
that tells you part of a story
or is some kind of scene from life.
And they are more often in low relief,
that is the carving into the stone doesn't go too deep.
That's not universally the case,
but it's certainly the case throughout a lot of Greek history.
And yeah, so when I'm suggesting that this is more like
the Mykonos relief amphora,
which is sort of a clay model with the scenes,
the scenes are brought out in clay rather than being brought out in paint.
So it arguably fits better with architectural sculpture
than with say vase painting,
whereas vase painting would fit better alongside wall painting,
which is a kind of architectural decoration,
but because it is painted on its techniques,
its styles,
its themes are closer to the vase painting than the stone carving.
Yeah, I guess so.
You could reduce it even to the word sculpture
and say anything that's sculpted as such.
So either shaped by hand
or when you remove or cut stuff away in order to reveal an image,
you could count it as sculpture, I suppose.
Shall we go back to the beginning then,
which I was thinking early Iron Age,
but of course looked at Joshua's notes
and he's going back into the Bronze Age.
Well, you could go back to the Stone Age if you want to
with all the early figurines,
but yeah, I think the Bronze Age is probably a good point to start
because, you know, when a lot of people think about sculptures,
they think about the large sculptures,
so we don't really have much for the Bronze Age.
There are some exceptions.
I mean, for the third millennium BC,
we have, of course, most famously the Cycladic idols, as they're called,
the figurines that are made from marble for the most part,
and some of them got to be quite large.
I don't know if anybody's ever been to the Cycladic Museum in Athens,
but there are examples that are more than a metre tall, basically.
So that's sort of a semi-monumental sculpture, if you want to call that.
And then when you get to the, aside from the stone figurines,
you also have, of course, pottery figurines.
And as you go into the second millennium,
you get, or at least the second millennium BC,
I'm not quite sure about the third millennium,
but you get bronze figurines as well.
You have the terracotta figurines and the Fi and Sai figures, of course,
which are possibly worshippers or supposed to be deities
or whatever they're supposed to be.
And with larger sculpture, that's mostly lacking for the Bronze Age,
the exception of a large plaster face from Mycenae,
which either belongs to a sphinx or to a goddess of some sort.
It's a female face painted white with red circles,
maybe sun symbols on the cheeks.
And of course, most famously, the Lion Gate relief at Mycenae
is one of the few truly remains of monumental sculpture,
in this case, relief with two lions or lionesses
flanking a Bronze Age column.
And there's some other architectural decorative stuff
like the facade of the Treasury of Atreus.
What about on Crete in the Minoan period?
Would you consider something like the sacred horns
to be monumental sculpture?
Yeah, you could make a point.
The horns of consecration, that they're a form of sculpture.
Let's pretend I used the right terminology there.
Yeah, no, but the sacred horns, it's the same.
I thought you were saying that.
There are other architectural elements,
but I'm not sure if you could also...
They must have had, or they're usually assumed
to have had a religious significance as well.
But they're also known from art, of course.
There are reliefs.
If we're talking about reliefs also in vessels,
we have, of course, stuff like the Cetriton from Mycenae
and a few other vessels, the Vavio cups,
that sort of stuff.
You can regard it also as sculpture.
So you have it in the small scale,
the Harvester vase from Triada
and the Chieftain Cup that we've written about also
for Ancient World Magazine.
That's all in relief, basically, but it's all small.
I'd say the difference between what we see
in the historical period
and what we see in the pre-historical period
is that these wooden statues relate
to something we find in other media.
We find it in marble and sometimes even in bronze,
but we don't really have that idea in the Bronze Age.
We don't find large-scale bronze sculpture
or large-scale ceramic or marble sculpture.
So we can hypothesize
that there were large-scale wooden statues,
but it's really just, it's possible,
but I don't know what cause we'd have
for assuming something like that.
No, the only thing we have is the small scale,
including like the Serpent Goddess figurines.
What are those made of?
They're faience, so yeah,
so the same type of paste that they also use.
So, but that's about it.
And also, you know, like what you said,
also in other media, we don't have any,
we have the wall paintings and stuff
where sometimes there are figures,
especially female figures surrounded by griffins
are usually interpreted as either priestesses
or more likely female deities of some sort,
but there's nothing in the wall paintings
or in other media that suggests the existence
of some form of cult statue.
I'm thinking the sarcophagus from Ayat Riada
has people bringing objects to some sort of shrine
where one of the standing figures
has sometimes been interpreted as some sort of statue.
Yosho, did you mention the Agia Irini statues from Chios?
No, I did not.
The sort of meter and a half high ceramic statues,
they date to 15th century.
Okay, they are large scale terracotta statues.
At large scale is, for the time,
we're talking about a meter,
meter and a half tall statues of women.
They may be among the largest Bronze Age sculptures we know.
And here's me interjecting for a moment
while editing this episode.
In the meantime, I've written an article
about the terracotta statues from Agia Irini.
It's available on the website.
You might want to have a look there
if you want to find out more.
So going into the post-palatial period,
we keep a lot of the smallest scale of sculptured objects.
There are many figurines, human and animal,
known from 12th century contexts and later,
but anything, we're talking even smaller scale
than previously.
We have nothing sort of resembling,
nothing more than half a meter or so in size.
And some of this may be preservational,
but really the lack of figurative imagery
in throughout the arts is sort of indicative
of a less emphasis on this visual element of culture.
There are exceptions to this rule, of course,
perhaps most notably the terracotta centaur
which is partially wheel made model of a centaur
with a fully human front and a horse behind
that was found intentionally broken into two pieces.
Its head was found in a separate grave to its body
and it's great, but it is sort of standing
not quite alone, but alone as a mythological subject
in this period.
And other wheel thrown terracotta sculptures
are known of animals.
There are wheel made bovine sculptures
found in graves from the time,
but yeah, we're dealing with a smaller scale
and fewer finds certainly for several centuries
until between the 12th and ninth century really
before we start getting this huge influx of finds
from Olympia with the increase in dedications
at that site where we find bronze sculptures
coming back into play.
Again, we're talking quite small scale,
but representing humans, animals, bulls, sheep,
lots of horses.
Horses are very well represented
from the eighth century late geometric sculptural repertoire,
but also ceramic models of chariots
and warriors, both ceramic and bronze
and male and female figures.
There are terracotta male and female figures
that are naked and are distinguished by their genitals.
And this I think is a subject we will come back to
when discussing sculpture throughout time.
Use of nudity and gender sculptures,
but we're still kind of dealing with a period
of smaller scale models.
Many of the bronze models are attachments for tripods,
but this is the time period when we're getting
a much greater visual repertoire
coming back into the archeological.
The warrior figurines just to sort of latch onto that one
because they, you've got these bronze figurines
that have, often they have belts,
often they have some type of headgear
and they usually have an arm raise,
which is supposed to hold a spear or something.
And it's also, the argument has also been made
that they, instead of representing warriors,
they might also represent deities instead
because Zeus in later art is also depicted,
you know, hurling the thunderbolt
and that sort of stuff.
So back when I was doing my PhD thesis,
I read a book about the warrior figurines
from Olympia and a few other sanctuary sites.
And the argument was made that for the most part,
these were not supposed to be warriors,
but more deities, anything possible to determine, I think.
Getting a bit later into the seventh century,
one of the first sculptures we have
that has an inscription on it
comes from Thebes in Boeotia, central Greece.
And it's a dedication by someone called Manteclos to Apollo.
And there is some debate here
whether the figure itself represents Apollo
because its hand is in a position
that could be holding a bow.
One of its arms is missing.
So here again, we have that discussion.
Is this dedicated to Apollo and represents Apollo
or is it a human figure?
Is it representing the dedicant,
the person donating the figure?
And this is one of those things
where we don't have a firm answer.
We can speculate based on our evidence.
And let's for a moment bring back
the Lefkandi centaur into this discussion
because while the Lefkandi centaur is somewhat unique,
it has certain features to it
that indicate characterization.
So on the hand that survives,
which is the right hand,
there are six fingers,
both painted and inscribed into there.
You can tell it has six fingers on its hand.
And in the front left leg,
there is a gash that looks like
it's supposed to represent a wound.
So based on the analogy of later myths,
it's been speculated that this is Chiron.
The centaur who trained Achilles among others.
He trained basically everyone.
Achilles, Heracles, Jason, yeah.
There are questions here about
whether that myth can go back that far,
whether or not we can firmly identify it as that figure.
But what matters there is that there are things,
features on this model that indicate
it is a specific character
that it relates to a certain story.
With these later bronze figurines
that we're talking about,
the question is how far do these features
look like they are distinct,
look like they could characterize a specific person?
Because Yoshua mentioned the upraised arm
representing Zeus,
which we do find in later iconography.
But in much more iconography,
much closer in date to these,
we find figures that appear to be human
holding spears up in that same pose.
Yeah, it's what you also see in the vase painting.
Of course, it's more or less contemporary
with this complete geometry,
but you have all these guys
holding spears above their heads.
When we question whether or not a figure
is a specific figure,
that's really where the information comes in.
One of the earliest scenes on a tripod leg
is a picture of two of these figures in helmets,
I think they're otherwise naked,
fighting over a tripod.
And a century or so later,
maybe 150 years later,
the scene we know is Heracles and Apollo
fighting over the tripod at Delphi.
So the question is,
is this scene 150 years earlier?
And the answer I would suggest is no,
it's two people competing over a tripod
because there's nothing to characterize
either of them as Heracles or Apollo.
Yeah, this is a big problem with interpreting
ancient Greek art in any case
because a lot of it is back-read
based on sources that are much later
than the material that we're actually talking about.
I mean, we also talk about the Bronze Age
and there's still an attempt on the part
of lots of people
that try to interpret this evidence
of reading Homer back into the Mycenaean Age,
for example,
or of applying Greek myths
known from Pindar or even later Pausanias
or Pseudo-Apollodorus
and applying all that to interpret the evidence
from the geometric figurines or vase paintings,
that sort of stuff.
Snotgrass warned about this, of course,
in his book, Homer and the Artist,
which was published in 1998, I think.
Well, he basically looks
at the earliest vase paintings,
which are usually claimed to depict scenes
of inspired by Homer
and then shows that, nope,
they're not inspired at all by any version,
any kind of episodes known
from the Iliad or the Odyssey.
They're all different scenes,
different traditions, basically,
and there's no reason to assume
that like what you said
with the two guys fighting over a tripod,
150 years before the first attested scenes
where it's Heracles fighting Apollo
that these scenes are the same.
We're chronologically just about at the point
where we can start to talk
about freestanding stone sculpture.
So what happens in the 7th century?
What do we then get
that leads us to freestanding stone sculpture?
We've had this period in the early Iron Age
where the intensity of connection
across the Mediterranean has declined
and this 8th century period
where having already sort of started
to get more intense
over the preceding centuries,
it's really kind of kicking off.
And in the 7th century,
we start to get these stone sculptures
that are freestanding
and in limestone usually
and looking a lot like Egyptian statues.
So we find that what must have happened here
is this intensity of connection
is bringing Greece and Egypt back together
and Greek sculptors,
people from the Greek,
well, probably the Greek islands,
perhaps Attica,
are finding their way to Egypt
or people from Egypt
are finding their way to Greece.
We don't really know that.
It's easier to talk about transmission of ideas
than of people.
But the concept of sculpting
a life-size or near life-size human figure
out of stone
becomes one that the Greeks really pick up on
and run with it for many, many more centuries.
But that idea sort of picked up from Egypt,
but from the very beginning,
what Greek sculptors are doing with it
looks very distinct from Egyptian sculptures.
You really are finding that this is a technique,
a technology or a skill
that is being completely reinterpreted
in a new context
where they have different cultural needs for sculptures.
In art historical terms,
they refer to the 7th century
as the orientalizing phase
and it sort of starts,
Crete starts sort of slightly earlier
than the rest of the Aegean.
So Crete may have had a forerunner role
if you look at mid-7th century BC
Cretan figurines and statues
like the Lady of Auxerre
which dates to about 640 BC
which probably Cretan is now in the Louvre.
You look at a terracotta figurine from Crete
that dates to about 650-625 BC
which also has these Egyptianizing features.
There might also be some Assyrian influences there
in the way that the hair is treated,
the shape of the hair is sort of like the Egyptian wigs
but the way that the hair is textured
reminds one of Assyrian reliefs
for the most part.
And the terracotta statue,
they refer to them,
to these Cretan examples,
as Daedalic statues
because of the style.
Of course the reference to Daedalus,
the famous inventor who built the labyrinth at Kronos,
supposedly.
And the interesting bit about the terracotta statue
from about 650-625 BC
from which is now at the Heraklion Museum in Crete
is that she also has bare breasts
which some say might go back to the Bronze Age,
a common way of depicting women in art.
And all of these statues,
the way that they're executed,
the way that they're made,
the dimensions, the proportions,
especially also with the Lady of Auxerre
that really reminds one of Egyptian statues
and Egyptian ways of depicting people.
The Lady of Auxerre also has a hand on her heart
which again really reminds one of similar scenes
from Egyptian art.
And when you move to the mainland,
you get these Daedalic hairstyles there also.
For example, a bronze figurine from Delphi
from about 625 BC.
We're going to put pictures on the website by the way.
If you're listening to this
then you might also want to check out the website
so you can see what we're talking about.
So you get these orientalizing statues and figurines
until finally you also get these large,
towards the end of the 7th century,
these large freestanding sculptures.
These naked youths, for the most part,
that are striding forwards with their arms tightly
along the side of their bodies.
One leg forward, one leg behind.
And that's something you also see in Egyptian art.
In Egyptian statues, the exact same pose
and the proportions are similar
and the way that the anatomy is executed,
especially in these early Koroy, is very similar.
So those are all statues of naked youths.
And on the other side,
you also have similar stone statues of women
the so-called Kory, singular Kore,
from the Greek word for girl, basically.
And these are always clothed.
They always wear dresses.
And the way that these are executed
has been compared not only to Egyptian art
but also to images of women from the Near East,
from Anatolia, from Mesopotamia,
the Levant, that sort of region.
So yeah, there's loads of interaction here
between the Aegean and other areas
along the ESMF training seaboard.
Like Matt says, whether that's an exchange of ideas
or also an exchange of people,
that's something that's very difficult to determine.
It's worth remembering that this was a period
that we actually have evidence of Greeks
being very mobile in the Eastern Mediterranean.
I mean, the 7th century
is when we know Ionian Greeks
were serving the pharaoh Psamtik as mercenaries.
For instance, there's even that dedication
from somewhere in Anatolia
of an Egyptian statue brought back
by one of the Greek mercenaries.
So there definitely was a lot of opportunity
for ideas to move along different...
But maybe something important to stress also
is that these from Egypt
and possibly other regions from the Near East
were influencing to be mostly Egyptian,
is that the Greeks at around the same time
also start borrowing stone building techniques,
possibly from Egypt.
If you look at the earliest Greek temples,
they're usually assumed to have been inspired
by Egyptian temples as well.
Even though the idea, you know,
the basic structure,
columns with architraves on top of them
to cover distances basically,
then you already find that in the Bronze Age,
just not in stone.
What we need to think about here is
while many of these ideas
are influenced from the Near East and Egypt,
they are very much used in a new context.
So this is, it is a Greek decision
to display these youths,
these young men naked.
That is not something they get from Egypt.
That is something that the Greeks are doing.
And the same as Joshua was just saying
with the architecture,
they're learning the stone building techniques,
but they are applying them to building plans
that they were already using,
but that this also allows them to change those plans
and do different things with those plans
in terms of the peristyle architecture,
in terms of the shape of the buildings.
We discussed this a bit in our last podcast on sanctuaries,
how the shape of the temples is long
because of the building techniques in wood.
And then you can get it a bit more squat
when you start using stone,
but it's still kind of influenced
from that earlier plan that they were using.
And again, we can come back to this idea
that these young men are being depicted naked.
The women are not, typically.
And again, you go back to the Bronze Age,
many of the sculptures of women we discussed
were naked or partially naked.
There are a couple of examples from Crete
in the 7th century.
There are a few figurines in the 8th century,
but by the time we get to the late 7th, 6th centuries,
men are being depicted,
or young men, youths are being depicted naked,
women clothed.
And that is a deliberate decision
on the parts of the sculptors
and the people employing the sculptors.
Perhaps we should talk a bit about the context
of these early sculptures.
For the most part, at least the male youth
tend to be grave markers.
So these were statues that were erected
at a grave site, a burial site,
usually with cremated remains.
They sometimes had an inscription on the base,
especially the later examples from the 6th century
sometimes have an inscription where they say
to whom they're dedicated.
So these are the ideas that the deceased
were also young men that were struck down
in their prime of life, basically.
And they had these large statues made in their honor,
presumably also intended to represent them.
They sort of marked their position in the cemetery.
So you have to imagine walking along a cemetery
towards a city that you would have
like these funerary monuments next to the road.
I actually happen to have one of those inscriptions
from the later 6th century in front of me right now
because I was quickly rereading
Geoffrey Hurwitz's art and culture of early Greece.
Stop and grieve beside the tomb of Croesus,
dead, whom once in battle's front ranks
raging Ares destroyed.
It's a very moving, I mean, description.
It's a very good way of heroizing someone
without using iconography to it.
I mean, as Hurwitz points out,
it echoes some of the things we hear in Tertius
and other archaic poets,
the way of talking about the glory of war
and the corroid.
That style doesn't leave a lot for personalization
to highlight or worship a certain aspect of the deceased.
So the inscriptions really do complement
the statuary, I would say.
A question we have to ask here
about that question of individuality
is that we talk about this style
not allowing individual expression in the sculpture,
but as I emphasized earlier,
this style is a choice on the part of the Greeks at the time.
They are thinking,
we want to depict these young men naked,
and they could have various different ways
of individualizing them.
If you look at the corroid,
you can see they have different clothing,
quite a bit more variety between how they're dressed
and how they look,
which you don't get so much with the youths, the corroid.
So there may well be an element here
of not wanting too much emphasis on individualism.
Nevertheless, though, we are talking about people
who are able to afford
these exceptional large stone sculptures.
We don't think this is something
that's available to everyone.
It is very much an elite group.
Yeah, well, also the inscription
that Josh read out about Croesus,
that's very aristocratic, of course,
if you think about Homer
and how he talks about being struck down
in the front ranks by Ares,
really recalls a kind of epic language.
So that also suggests
that it's very much an aristocratic ideal.
And it's quite telling, I think,
that Croesus, who is struck down by Ares,
so he dies in battle,
gets a kouros that is completely naked
without any military paraphernalia,
at least as far as we've found.
I mean, maybe they did add a shield to the grave
and stuck a spear in the ground.
We don't know exactly.
The statue itself doesn't look at all like a warrior.
Well, to emphasize the aristocratic nature
of that particular burial as well,
the name Croesus obviously comes from the Lydian king.
And I can't but be struck by that
as similar to the outlandish naming conventions
of the British aristocracy in previous centuries,
where, yes, the Englishmen giggling,
they're laughing in the background,
thankfully, assured me that that was a good joke.
But the just outlandish names
associated with classical mythology
and ancient figures.
We know from the textual sources
that if you had a guest friend,
so you had a formal relationship
with someone abroad, a foreigner,
who would also provide you with a place to stay
if you came to visit there
and you would exchange gifts
and all that sort of stuff,
that it was customary
if you had a guest friend who was a foreigner,
you would name your son after him.
So it could very well be
that Croesus' father was friends
with Croesus the king of Lydia
or had ever been there, for example,
and that he wanted to show to people
that he had this relationship
by naming his child Croesus as well.
I mean, that still is a way of showing off
how connected you were.
Yeah, of course.
But I mean, if you put this up in a cemetery,
this larger-than-life statue, basically,
that's already quite a statement, of course,
compared to all the people
that are completely archaeologically invisible.
So going back to the context and the inscriptions,
we do find more Cori as grave markers
than we find as dedications.
And the flip of that is
we find more Cori as dedications than grave markers.
But a very significant Cori
that we know of as a grave marker
is the Cori that marked the grave of Thrasycleia.
And I was just trying to find the inscription somewhere,
but I don't have it,
or I can't find it anywhere.
But her inscription doesn't tell people
to stop and mourn for her.
It just is very sad that she died
before she could be married.
I have the inscription in front of me.
Tomb of Thrasycleia.
Maiden shall I be called forever,
given this name, not marriage by the gods.
Aristion of Peros made me.
So we find here a stark contrast
between this man who was struck down in battle
and was killed by Ares,
and this woman who we have no idea how she died,
but she wasn't married,
and that's what mattered about her
according to the contemporary Greeks.
And a theory of the choice of the grave markers here
is that Thrasycleia, who died unmarried,
gets a freestanding sculpture.
Croesus, who died in battle,
potentially also unmarried,
but young at least we assume
from the description of him,
gets a freestanding sculpture.
We also have relief sculptures from Attica
that marked graves of older men with beards.
So these Coroi don't have beards.
That's one of the ways we can identify them as youths.
But the relief sculptures often do have beards
and they do have these markers
that indicate that they are older men.
Some of them wear armor.
Some of them are engaging in sports.
There are boxers and other figures like that.
And this is like a distinction
potentially based on age in these grave markers.
What is perhaps surprising,
especially if you're familiar
with the classical relief grave markers,
is that we have very few from the 6th century
representing older women, mothers especially.
We find contemporary black figure plaques
that depict the deceased as a woman,
often an older woman.
But we find very few older women on stone grave markers.
So while there is undoubtedly a class element to this,
a people who can afford large stone sculptures element,
there also seems to be an age factor here
that young women who died and married
were valuable objects that needed a sculpture
to mark their grave.
And young men who died in battle
were heroized perhaps by having these ideal youths
on their gravestones,
whereas the older men did get relief sculptures
and could be depicted as warriors.
But older women, mothers especially,
don't seem to have got any sort of monumental marker
in the 6th century in Athens.
About young men dying in battle,
that's of course the so-called beautiful death,
which we already find in Homer.
And is a recurrent theme in archaic poetry and beyond.
For example, there's one point in book 22
where Priam says,
and I'm using the translation by Latimore,
for a young man, all is decorous
when he is cut down in battle
and torn with a sharp bronze and lies there dead.
And though dead, still all that shows about him is beautiful.
But when an old man is dead and down
and the dogs mutilate the gray head and the gray beard
and the parts that are secret,
this for all sad mortality is the sight most pitiful.
So, you know, a young man getting struck down in battle,
that's beautiful.
Because, you know, his youth and his strength
are preserved for all eternity.
He never becomes old.
But if an old man dies, then it's pitiful.
And we find the same thing in Tertullius.
Exactly.
A century later.
Exactly the same thing.
Are you going to let the old men be the ones that die?
Jean-Pierre Vernon, in one of his books,
writes when the hero gives up a long life
in favour of an early death,
whatever he loses in honours paid to his living person,
he more than regains a hundredfold
with the glory that will suffuse his memory
for all time to come.
This also reminds one of the bargain
that Achilles struck, of course, with his mother.
His mother told him not to go to war,
that he could stay at home and live a long life
and have many children and die happy.
Or he could go to Troy
and be struck down in his youth, basically,
but be immortalized for all eternity
instead of forgotten.
And that's sort of this ethos
that's common throughout the archaic and classical periods,
and beyond, also, like during Hellenistic age goes on.
So yeah, these Kuroi are the physical embodiment of that ethos.
It's worth pointing out that that ethos
wasn't necessarily universal.
I mean, famously, we have Archilochus in a poem
celebrating that he threw his shield away
to save his skin,
and that he'll just go buy another one just as good,
and it's better to be alive than die.
Yeah, but that proves that the ethos is widespread,
because otherwise he wouldn't be able to parody it.
I mean, of course, there are the practicalities of war on the one side.
You know, you can say,
well, you know, I could die now, age 35,
and be preserved for the rest of eternity,
or I can run away and live to fight another day.
You know, it runs up against practicalities.
Who says that Croesus died fighting honorably?
He might have been running away, for all we know.
We only have the inscription to say
that he was struck down by mighty Ares.
We have no idea what really happened.
But the fact that Archilochus parodies this
basically shows how strong this ethos is
in this particular period.
This is the ideal.
That doesn't mean that it always happened,
but it's the ideal that they were working from,
and it's the thing that they celebrate,
and the thing that they would pump up
if, you know, given a choice.
They're not going to put a statue of Croesus,
you know, on his knees begging for forgiveness,
and then the inscription says,
you know, Croesus died like a dog.
It's not going to happen.
I like the idea of the Caridas Kouros statue.
That'd be a fun one.
Well, there is, if we move a bit further forward in history,
there's a very good example of the use of public monuments
to lie in this kind of way
in the tyrannocide sculpture from the Agora of Athens.
So, at the end of the 6th century,
the tyrannocides, Harmonius and Aristegiton,
were commemorated in sculpture by Antenor.
This sculpture was removed by the Persian king Xerxes in 480,
but after the Persian wars were over,
Critias and Nesiotes replaced them in 477-6,
according to the Parian model.
And then the original sculpture was returned to Athens
150 years later or something,
after Alexander's successors took them.
Anyway, this is one of the earliest examples of sculptures
certainly based on real people that are trying to tell a story,
freestanding sculpture that is trying to tell a historical story.
The original bronze statues by Antenor
were set up in the late 6th century
or possibly early 5th.
The idea there is that because these two were tyrant slayers,
they killed Hipparchus, the brother of the tyrant Hippias,
who were the sons of Peisistratus,
that they should be commemorated as heroes.
And they're commemorated as such in song
that celebrates their attempts to liberate Athens.
But according to Thucydides, this is not the story.
The actual story is that Harmonius,
who was a beautiful young man,
and in the copies of the statue that survive,
because we only know this sculpture through Roman copies,
he is depicted bare-chinned without a beard,
that Hipparchus was in love with him
and made gestures of affection towards him.
But Aristeguiton was his actual lover
who tried to kill Hipparchus in vengeance for that.
He painted as more of a love story gone awry.
I wouldn't necessarily say that we believe Thucydides
over the popular memory,
but what we do learn here is that there is an attempt
to control the popular memory
through the erection of a statue.
And that statue is very interesting
in terms of style for a number of reasons.
There's a lot more action going on in this sculpture
than we have ever seen in Greek stone sculpture before.
This is probably because it was not a stone sculpture.
It was a bronze sculpture.
So this allows greater freedom to depict movement.
The weight of the bronze is far less
than the weight of the marble.
Therefore, it's a lot easier
for the statue to support itself.
But this is also a sculptural group.
So we're not dealing with a single statue marking a grave
or as a dedication by an individual.
We're dealing with two statues intended to work together.
And both the figures have different poses.
Aristogitan, the older one,
sort of has his arm stretched out holding a sword,
whereas Harmonius, the younger one,
has his arm up to strike.
And it's suggested that this kind of indicates
that Harmonius is young and impetuous and going for it
while Aristogitan is reserved and defending himself.
So again, we've sort of got these age factors
coming into play.
We have like, this is how the young man is depicted.
This is how the older man is depicted,
as well as telling a story about what these two men did
and trying to control that story
as part of a narrative of anti-tyranny
in the sense of Greek tyrants
and reinventing them as pro-democracy heroes.
And again, in lyric poetry,
we find drinking songs about how Harmonius
and Aristogitan tried to liberate Athens.
Yeah, as far as the way that the sculpture is done
and its emphasis on movement,
it makes it seem like it very much belongs
to the first part of the 5th century BC
rather than the later 6th,
because it's very much what's referred to as severe style,
occurring between about 500 and 460, let's say, BC.
And severe style sort of flows from archaic,
but there is more of a softer rendering of the anatomy
than ever before.
The expressions in the faces are usually rather vacant.
You see that very clearly also with these statues.
They don't really have any expressive face.
You can't really read their faces
to see what's going on with them, internally at least.
So the emphasis instead is put very much
on the motion that they're making,
the action that they're taking.
And that's very typical for the severe style,
that all of this sort of action element.
And that's new compared to most archaic sculpture.
There are some differences, of course,
if you look at sculptural reliefs
where they have gorkhans running, for example.
That's clearly very typical.
They have these sort of half-kneeling poses
where they have one leg bent forwards
and one leg bent backwards
to indicate that the gorkhans are running, etc., etc.
But in freestanding sculpture,
this kind of work, like with the tyrannocytes,
it's very typical for, let's say,
earlier part of the 5th century BC
when you have the severe style.
And we might say that this sculpture
has more in common with the,
especially, pedimental sculptures
found in architectural relief,
both in terms of the fact
that it is a group telling a story,
which we find a lot more
on architectural monuments of the 6th century,
and in terms of the fact that this is public art
in the sense that it is serving
not individuals but the polis.
So even though we're questioned
how far these koroi represent individuals
and what is trying to be said
with the standardized depictions of figures,
they are still, as far as we can tell,
commissioned by individuals,
which is also the case in terms of the public art.
So the Agmionidae paid for a temple at Delphi
in the late 6th century.
So we have, I don't want to say aristocratic
because Hans families will yell at me,
but these significant wealthy families
paying for monuments and sculptures
that are supposed to be for the public
rather than their family.
So yeah, that's the distinction.
They're telling a story for everyone, in a way,
and they are still there to promote themselves.
This isn't the Agmionidae.
Aren't doing this out of the goodness of their hearts
so much as they're doing it to promote
the Agmionidae against the Peisistratids.
Although, obviously, this is erasing
the actual religious motives they may have had.
They may well have strongly believed
that by doing this,
paying for the pediment of the Temple of Apollo at Delphi,
they were getting the god on their side,
that they were doing it for Apollo,
but that that would also benefit them.
That's a reciprocal relationship with the god
as much as an entirely secular, self-motivated act.
We don't know who paid for the tyrannocide statues,
I don't think.
Certainly, it's not connected to a family in that way.
Maybe connected to Polis.
Could be.
And the original statues,
I think were supposed to be in the Agora.
So yeah, there were, I mean,
there were more statues in the Agora, of course,
and more monuments in the Agora
that were all paid for at least,
you know, by the state,
such as you would define it for Athens.
So yeah, I would assume also because,
like what you said,
the political significance of these statues,
sort of a celebration of the end of tyranny,
and by extension, of course,
a celebration of the emergence of democracy
in Athens a little later,
towards the end of the 6th century.
It makes sense to put these statues
in the civic center of Athens
and have them paid for by the communal funds,
even though most of the people
that would put money in those funds
would have been, of course,
the foremost families of Athens itself.
I mean, democracy didn't change that much
as far as the policies are concerned in Athens.
I mean, the rich and the well-born
were usually still the dominant factor in Athens,
but at least, you know,
it looked like it was, you know,
against tyranny, against monarchy, basically,
in this particular sense,
and more towards a wider form of government.
Another contemporary development
is having had all these kouroi out and around.
Many of these grave markers
were used to build the Themistoclean Wall
in the Persian Wars,
so this isn't immediately on democracy,
on the invention of democracy, as it were,
the Cleisthenic reforms,
but within the generation,
it's fine to take down these aristocratic monuments
to build your walls,
but even before this,
we start getting these markers
throughout Athens of Hermes,
of representations of the god Hermes
on stone pillars with male genitals partway down,
and it has been argued by Josephine Quinn sometime
that this is kind of a direct threat to the kouroi,
like you have these heroic nude statues,
and they are being joined by this kind of mockery
in the form of the Hermes with their genitals out.
Now, the Hermes are supposed to represent the god Hermes.
They're usually interpreted as boundary markers,
but I'm not sure what Quinn would say.
Well, it's still a sense that they are boundary markers,
but it's this idea that in marking those boundaries,
you're setting these things up throughout the countryside,
whereas you've said in the past,
the roads have been lined by these cemeteries
for very wealthy individuals.
It's been a while since I read the argument,
but the idea there is that this is your countryside
that was once marked by these grave markers
is now marked by these Hermes.
It's an interesting approach to sculpture.
When they stop using these large statues as grave markers,
I think they'll fix it.
It's late 6th.
Yeah.
Certainly in terms of how we date them,
because in a lot of what I was reading,
they attribute it, in Athens at least,
to the Pliasthenic reforms,
where expensive grave markers are said to have been outlawed.
You can't spend too much on your grave marker.
Or too much on your funerary rites as well, if memory serves.
I think there were strict rules
as to how lavish your funerals could be,
which sort of suggests that they tended to be quite lavish.
But of course, this only applies to Athens.
I think every sculpture I know of from elsewhere
is a dedication.
So in Thebes, there are a number of,
or in the Thebes Museum, I should say,
there are a number of coroi that come from a sanctuary of Apollo.
And this is one of the reasons why we didn't go into this,
because I don't think anyone takes it seriously anymore.
This old idea that the coroi represent Apollo,
which, yeah, I don't really have anything to say about that,
but I haven't really already said about the lack of attributes
to indicate individual personality or individual character.
I mean, especially in the case of Croesus,
it's very clear that that's not Apollo.
It's very unlikely to be Apollo
and more a representation of the youth
who was struck down in battle,
the celebration of his youthful beauty.
Yes, and of course, that inscription was discovered
a lot more recently than people thought these might be Apollo.
I mean, it's one of the reasons why no one considers that anymore.
It's the same for all male statues, basically,
where the depiction is a young man.
Obviously, the Apollo of Dreyros, for example,
which I don't know if we've mentioned already,
but it's one of the earliest larger,
large-ish bronze statues made of a bronze sheet
hammered around a presumably wooden core,
which is how bronze statues were initially,
larger bronze statues were initially made.
The smaller ones were poured, made in moulds,
and the larger ones were originally sheet bronze
hammered around a wooden core,
and then later you get the lost wax method for large statues.
But this Dreyros figure as well,
it's referred to as the Apollo of Dreyros
because it's a handsome young man.
And we have no idea whether these are actually
supposed to be gods or not.
Talking about that made me think about
the large stone sculptures we have from the 7th century,
the Naxian Koros on Delos
and the unfinished Koros on Naxos
that is 10 metres long.
It's huge.
Colossal.
It's still in the quarry.
And it appears that in trying to excavate
this large bit of marble,
the masons cracked the stone
or discovered that there was a crack in the marble
so it was unusable.
But the amount of detail already in the statue
before they'd got that far is quite interesting
to see how much was done
while getting the marble out of the ground.
And these much, much bigger figures
almost certainly would have been cult statues, I think,
because they're far larger than life
and thus probably gods in that sense.
And we know, of course,
from the 5th century BC
you get these gigantic cult statues
like the statue of Zeus at Olympia
which was made by Phidias in around 435 BC
so we're moving a little further in time now
which was more than 12 metres tall, supposedly.
And he made a similar huge statue to Athena
in the Parthenon
which were not made of marble
but they were made...
They were chryselephantine.
I think we talked about them also in previous podcasts.
So they were a combination of ivory and gold
on probably a bronze skeleton of some sort,
a bronze wood skeleton.
So you get these huge statues
about the middle of the 5th century BC at least.
But it's interesting that there's no similar example
from a huge stone statue from elsewhere in Greece
outside of this quarry find.
You'd think one of the reasons why we don't find...
Well, one of the reasons why those cult statues
from Athens and Olympia are no longer extant
is because the gold was valuable.
You could take the gold and use it for something else.
And this is why we don't find a lot of bronze statues
because the bronze could be recycled.
So you would expect to find some evidence
of colossal stone statues if they were that common.
So we can pretty much say they were uncommon.
And the example on Naxos gives us an idea why
because you could get so far into carving it out
and then discover that the stone wasn't going to support itself.
The stone has a huge crack in it or whatever it was.
They realized about that stone
that they weren't going to be able to use it.
So Naxians managed one huge marble statue
and then decided to use their marble for more statues
rather than fewer statues but bigger.
And this is a good point to end part one of our podcast
on sculpture in the ancient Greek world.
Part two, which will focus on the classical and Hellenistic periods
will be uploaded in a few days.
In the meantime, if you enjoy this podcast
please consider supporting us via Patreon.
Go to patreon.com slash ancientworldmag
Warm thanks to all of our patrons
and in particular to Rachel K. Bicknell
who's been with us for a while.
Be sure also to visit our website at ancientworldmagazine.com
Pictures to accompany this podcast will be uploaded to our website
so if you want to see what we're talking about in particular
you should go there and check out the gallery
that's attached to the page
dedicated to this particular episode of the podcast.
Thank you for listening and until next time, bye-bye.
