The Officious Bystander Test - Contract Law.

History of Law
11 followers
10 Video Views·Dec 12, 2025
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Welcome back everybody to our study in the law of contracts. In this lesson what I want to do is
talk a little bit about the officious bystander test, which is a test which relates to the
implication of terms, i.e. implying terms into contractual arrangements. And this is only going
to be a short lesson given the fact that this is not a particularly complicated or convoluted
test. And we'll just recap some of the things that we've been talking about in the previous lessons
and we'll talk about essentially the roadmap for the next few lessons as well at some point in
this lesson too. So the previous lesson introduced the subject of implied terms. We noted about the
ways in which a term may be implied by a court. We had noted that when we talk about implying terms
there are three main ways which terms can be implied into a contract when it comes to the
sort of practical implication of the term. Firstly being implied by courts, secondly being implied
through custom, and then thirdly being implied through the imposition of the Consumer Rights Act
from 2015. And then when talking about the first of these prongs in relation to the implying of
terms, implying terms by court can either be done through fact, implication by fact, or implication
through law. So one of the things that we noted is that implied terms in fact can be established
if they would be efficacious for business purposes. We talked about the case of the Moorcock
in which you have the where you have the defendants being the owners of a jetty, you being the
claimants being the owners of a ship that was unloading at the jetty, and it was argued that
there was an implied term that the defendants take reasonable care in ensuring that there would not
be damage done to the ship itself. And it was seen that this would be efficacious for
business purposes rather than just be desirable. It's struck at the heart of the contract itself.
This lesson is going to talk about the second process by which a term may be implied in fact,
this being the officious bystander test. So generally speaking when we think about terms
implied by courts in fact, there are two routes in which you can go down. You have the efficacious
business test and then you have the officious bystander test. What the officious bystander
test tells us is that we can imply terms which are considered to be so obviously part of the
contract that it goes without saying. So it doesn't necessarily relate to the conduct of
the potential efficacy of the business practice or the necessity of the business practice in order
for a term to be implied into a contract. But it's really something that is just so obvious,
it's so obvious that this term has to be part of the contract itself that the idea of it not
being the part of the contract doesn't make any sense whatsoever. And therefore we can imply in
fact the existence of this term through courts. It goes without saying that this term is required
for a contract. It is called the officious bystander test because it comes from the case of
Sherlaw and Southern Foundries Limited from 1939. Specifically this quote. They say quote
I'm a facey that which in any contract if left to be implied is something so obvious that it goes
without saying so that if while the parties were making their bargain a bargain an officious
bystander were to suggest some express provision for it in their agreement they would testily
suppress him with the common oh of course. So essentially what this test requires us to do
is to imagine let's say that we are at a cafe and that I am a random bystander that's listening
in on the negotiations of a contract between two people and I go up to them and say oh by the way
this term should be in that contract and that they respond with oh of course it should be of course
it should be. That is essentially the officious bystander test such that any bystander that would
any reasonable bystander that would just be able to happen upon your conversation
with another person negotiating a contract would know immediately upon knowing the express terms
in the contract they would know immediately which other terms should be part of the contract
and when those terms are cited by this officious bystander the people negotiating the contract
would have said oh of course what a silly idea to not have this in the contract. So that's what
officious bystander test means that's where the phrase comes from and that's where the word comes
from. Essentially what you do is you associate yourself with a negotiating partner at a table
in a restaurant you are you are assuming that you are negotiating a contract and the negotiations
are overheard by an officious bystander and if bystander were if the said bystander were to ask
if the contract was going to have x term in it and you both respond in the affirmative
then this term will be implied in fact by the courts that's essentially what the officious
bystander test tells us and what it said what it means therefore is that these are terms that are
so obvious that they have to be a part of the contract that they are almost de facto and
prima facie in the contract and just through the nature of the contract itself through the nature
of the contract and the facts of the terms of the contract that are expressly cited and so as a
result of that that's why we determine that this is a way in which the courts can imply a contract
in a employer term in fact if you look at the facts of a contract you look at what the contract
says and you go well this term has to be in it because if it doesn't then it doesn't make sense
then this is an implied term through the officious bystander test.
