Senate to Vote on Dueling Health Care Plans Addressing Obamacare Subsidies

NTD
11.9K followers
133 Video Views·Dec 11, 2025
The Senate is set to vote on Thursday on two competing health care proposals—one backed by Democrats and the other by Republicans—highlighting a deep divide over how to extend support for Americans’ medical costs.
Democrats are pushing for a clean three-year extension of the COVID-era Obamacare tax subsidies, while Republicans want to redirect those same funds into health savings accounts to help families cover out-of-pocket expenses.
Both proposals are likely to fall along party lines, thus failing to reach the 60-vote threshold required to advance legislation in the Senate.
📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
Lawmakers are racing to implement a plan
to prevent a spike in health insurance
costs for Obamacare recipients. The
Senate will hold key votes today while
several senators put forth their own
ideas. Joining us live to discuss is
NTD's Molina Weissup. Good morning,
Molina. What's each party's plan to
address Obamacare subsidies that are
expiring in three weeks?
>> Hi, good morning Steph. So, the Senate
is going to vote on two bills today. one
from the Republican side, one from the
Democrat side. Now, remember the
Democrat's bill is for a clean extension
of COVID era Obamacare tax subsidies for
the next three years. Remember, Seth,
this was a vote that Senate Majority
Leader John Thoon agreed to have as a
way to get those Democrat votes needed
to reopen the government last month. So,
it was part of that agreement there.
Now, Republicans are countering this
proposal with a plan of their own. Their
plan would take the money that's granted
to the subsidies and put them into
health care savings accounts to help
Americans pay for out-ofpocket costs for
healthare. Listen to what both sides are
saying about the proposals.
>> So with just days left on the clock, the
clearest, cleanest, easiest, and best
path left is the bill what Democrats are
proposing a clean extension of current
tax credits. That's it. No poison pills,
no gimmicks, just relief.
>> The proposal we'll put out there will
bring insurance premiums down. It will
be fiscally responsible and it'll get us
away from the practice of giving the
money all to the insurance companies and
put it back in the hands of the
patients.
>> Now, President Trump a while ago floated
the this idea of having the healthc care
savings accounts as a um an alternative
to Obamacare. Um, so that proposal from
Republicans, since it does have Trump's
backing, it could be easier to push um
through Congress with respect to getting
Republicans on board with it. But since
no Democrat support is likely to be on
this bill, it's likely won't make it
through the Senate. Now, because Senate
Majority Leader John Dun scheduled a
both a vote on both the Republican and
the Democrat proposals, that indicates
that there's not bipartisan consensus on
either proposal to get enough to get
enough votes to get either proposal
passed.
>> Now, there's more than just these two
ideas. There are several bills, even
part bipartisan ones that are floating
around the House at the moment. Where do
those efforts stand?
>> Right. So when you look at the House,
there is a similar situation going on
with respect to House leadership. So the
Democrat leaders want to um extend
Obamacare subsidies um for three years,
similar to the Senate's version. But
that plan won't see even a vote in the
House. Here's why. According to Speaker
U House Speaker Mike Johnson, listen,
>> there's a lot of people who are very
concerned about uh Obamacare and the
fact that the subsidies were created by
Democrats for co era limited use and
they want to be extended. Um, we just
can't get Republican votes on that for
lots of reasons, not enough of them. Um,
and so, uh, look, my my colleagues,
>> so Steph, in the House, the Republican
leader is not even bringing up the
Democrats bill for a vote like, uh,
Senate Leader John Thun is doing in the
Senate. Now, House Republican leadership
says they're proposing, um, a plan of
their own, and they're planning to vote
on that proposal next week, but the
details of that plan haven't yet been
rolled out. It's expected to be similar
but slightly different than the Senate
Republicans plan. Um like you mentioned,
there are several bipartisan efforts
underway on the healthcare front. One,
of course, we reported on last week. Um
the group is proposing to extend the
program of Obamacare and make reforms to
address how much government money is
actually going towards the Obamacare
subsidies. Um now there's a new
bipartisan effort underway on a
discharge petition. Now, Steph, that
would force House Speaker Mike Johnson
to hold a vote on those expiring
Obamacare subsidies. That bill would um
extend the enhanced subsidies through
2027, but it also addresses fraud and
tries to rein in some of the practices
of pharmacy benefit managers. Of course,
we know those are the middlemen of the
prescription drug supply chain. Um but
Steph, that petition needs 218 lawmakers
to um sign on it in order to even force
a vote to begin with. And it's unclear
if that vote happens what the support
would look like. But I will say that at
this point there are several Republicans
in the House that are pushing for at
least a 2-year extension of those
Obamacare subsidies just to make more
room and cushion um to make more time
for other reforms to the program. Steph
watching it all very closely. Thank you
so much. NTD congressional correspondent
Molina Weiss Cup.
