LIVE: Senate Rules Committee Considers Resolution to Withhold Senators’ Pay During Shutdowns

Live News Network
1.4K followers
63 Video Views·Dec 11, 2025
The Senate Rules and Administration Committee holds a meeting on Dec. 11 at 11 a.m. ET to consider S.Res.526, a resolution that would withhold the pay of U.S. senators in the event of a government shutdown.
Today our committee meets to consider Senate Resolution 526, which is based on a simple idea.
Congress can't keep the lights on, the United States Senate shouldn't expect to be paid as usual.
And the federal government grounds to a halt, but elected officials continue to collect
full salaries without interruption. The American people are right to be frustrated.
This resolution, authored by Senator Kennedy, is an attempt to address that disconnect.
It would set up a clear process after the next general election, in the event of a government
shutdown. Senators would see their pay withheld and released only after the government reopens.
Now let me say at the outset, this resolution does not absolve us from doing our job.
Best way to avoid shutdowns is, and has always been, to pass a full year appropriations bill
on time. Shutdowns happen because we fail to uphold our responsibility and accountability
matters. So I appreciate Senator Kennedy offering this resolution. It's straightforward and it
reflects the basic reality that Congress failures have wide-ranging consequences.
With that, I now recognize my colleague, Chairman Bedita.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good to see you and all of our colleagues here,
as folks can continue to trickle in.
This committee has a unique charge of upholding the Senate's traditions and procedures,
with the purpose of helping the Senate as a body function and function on a bipartisan basis. And
in that spirit, I want to thank you, Mr. Chairman, Senator Kennedy, and your staffs
for your willingness to work with us to address some of the significant concerns
that we had with the original version of this resolution.
The version of the resolution before us today, that we're considering today,
does reflect changes that we requested, as well as changes that were requested by the
Secretary of the Senate, in order to reduce the legal, constitutional, and operational
issues with the original resolution. And because of those changes, I will be recommending that we
vote in favor of sending this resolution out of committee and to the full Senate for further
consideration. But before we do that, I do want to briefly raise a couple of points
that I think the full Senate should consider and address before final adoption.
First, I believe that we should treat members of the House and the members of the Senate in the
same way. Under the Senate rules, legislation to do that would be referred to the Homeland Security
and Government Affairs Committee. The current resolution before us is before us only because
it impacts members of the Senate and does not speak to members of the House. But by doing so,
it would place the Senate on unequal footing with the House and potentially adversely complicate
shutdown negotiations in the future. Second, I appreciate the key changes to
take into account the 27th Amendment of the Constitution. And I'll quote,
no law bearing the compensation for the services of the senators and representatives
shall take effect until an election of representatives shall have intervened.
I know it's been partly addressed here, but it's also true that the Constitution also says
that member pay is to be set by law. Yet Senate Resolution 526 is just that. It's a resolution
without the force of law. So as a result, I do think the Senate must have additional
conversations following today's vote to ensure that this effort is done in a way that the Senate
is able to constitutionally and legally implement. Again, I thank the Chairman and Senator Kennedy's
good faith work on this resolution. And so having registered my concerns and the work that remains,
I'm prepared to support moving this resolution to the full Senate. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, Chairman. It's good to see you. I'm glad everybody is here. I call up Bennett
Amendment No. 1. My amendment would prohibit former members of Congress from registering
as lobbyists, not for one year or two years, but for the entirety of their retirement from
public service. This amendment addresses a serious problem in our democracy, the buying
and selling of influence. And this is not a new problem. I first introduced this legislation in
2010. Since then, the amount spent on lobbying and the number of lobbyists has only grown. Last year,
spending on federal lobbying reached a new high, topping $4.5 billion, a 37% increase
from a decade ago. Research shows that in the 1970s and 80s, it was relatively rare for former
members of Congress to become lobbyists. That began to change in the 90s, and that trend has
accelerated ever since. There are now 359 former members who are registered lobbyists.
This is not just an issue of how members spend their time after they leave these halls. It
strikes at the core of our democracy. When Coloradans or Texans or Virginians send their
elected representatives to Washington, they expect them to be focused on their needs and
the needs of their communities. They don't want them to take votes with an eye on their next job
opportunity. I think most members don't do that. I think most members are serious public servants
who put the interests of their constituents first. But even the appearance of this revolving door
erodes Americans' trust in our democracy, our rule of law, and the legislative process.
So this amendment puts forward what I think are some common sense reforms. It bans members
from lobbying. It adds new transparency requirements. That's what Coloradans expect,
and that's what the American people expect. It's what they deserve. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Senator Cruz. I move to table the Bennett Amendment.
The question is on the motion to table Senator Bennett's amendment. All those in favor say aye.
All opposed, nay. The ayes appear to have it. Senator Bennett's amendment is tabled.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the Chair and Ranking Member for convening us today.
I call up my amendment, Ossoff 3. Folks, we have a problem, which is that members of Congress
are playing the stock market while sitting in office, buying and selling shares of publicly
traded stock while making decisions about how to regulate those companies,
while privy to confidential corporate information, while privy to confidential
national security information. It is so corrosive to public trust in this institution.
The American people expect their elected representatives to put the public interest
first, not our private financial interest. Yet time and again, we hear about members of Congress
in both political parties trading stocks like that's their day job rather than representing
the constituents who should be our highest priority. This is not controversial among
the American public. Overwhelming majorities of Democrats,
Independents, Republicans want to ban stock trading by members of Congress.
We've made a lot of progress in the Senate in the last couple years building
a bipartisan coalition to ban it. In fact, legislation that Senator Merkley and I have
worked on with bipartisan colleagues in the Homeland Security Committee passed out of that
committee for the first time with bipartisan support to ban stock trading by members of
Congress. That bill still hasn't been brought to the floor. We all know that there are private
conversations with members going to folks in leadership saying they don't want it to come
to the floor. We need to get this done. We have the opportunity right now in this committee
to send a powerful message to the American people that we take seriously their deep concern and
their justified concern about ethics in the United States Congress. My amendment is very simple.
In a year's time, stock trading by senators is prohibited under Senate rules.
The text of this, the assets that are covered are all drawn from the painstakingly negotiated
bipartisan legislation that's been agreed by the Homeland Security Committee. This will
force us by a date certain to finish the job of advancing that legislation.
This will give the American people confidence that we understand and we accept our job is not
to enrich ourselves. Our job is to advance the flourishing and prosperity and health of our
constituents. I understand that there may be some parliamentary effort to avoid a vote on this.
I know that there are senators who don't want to take a vote on this,
but before we do that, Mr. Chairman, why don't we see this as an opportunity?
What a great day this would be if, instead of continuing to evade this question,
stock trading by senators, this committee, with its reputation for excellence,
came together across the aisle and passed this amendment. Ban stock trading
by United States senators. Do the right thing. I urge a yes vote. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I second the motion of my colleague from
Georgia. If there is a motion to table, is that motion debatable? In other words, can we
give everyone an opportunity to express their views before this issue is tabled?
It's not debatable.
Then I would ask my colleagues, if somebody's thinking about tabling this motion, can you just
wait until everyone who wants to express themselves on this has had a chance to do so? It'd be a
courtesy to extend. I do think that courtesy is important because this issue is important.
We all have a collective interest in Americans seeing that we act with integrity
that is not corrupted by our concern about our pocketbook over the public interest.
There is no way, if you have a huge portfolio concentrated in a particular area or you have
a specific stock that would be affected by legislation, there isn't a voice in your head
recognizing that and perhaps exercising some influence over how you might act.
If you have a huge renewable energy portfolio, then maybe tax credits for renewable energy
passing your mind is a pretty good idea for my investments. If you have a huge inventory of
bank stocks or maybe you have fossil stocks or who knows what,
that should never be a voice that influences us. This straightforward amendment for ourselves
and our spouses is in the interest of this Senate serving the American people.
We are at a time when the public opinion of the work we do in Congress is incredibly low.
Every few months there is an article, I saw one just this last week, about stock trades that
occurred before an important public action was taken and the public goes, there it goes again,
why can't they serve the public? So I would encourage us to take this up. I do recognize
that this is not legislation that will affect the House, but I was thinking back to when I
became Speaker of the House in Oregon and in our rules we adopted gift rules that affected
only the House of Representatives in Oregon. We called it the $10 standard. You could give
an apple pie, a cup of coffee, a t-shirt, a ball cap, but you couldn't take a person on trips,
they couldn't take them to sweetheart tickets for concerts or playoffs or so on and so forth.
It really changed the culture and it led to the Oregon Legislature adopting a very similar law.
So I think it's well worth our doing this here for our Senate. We've been debating this for over
a decade. It's been well over a decade when I first became involved in this and I so appreciate
my colleague from Georgia picking up the torch this year and really helping to drive this forward.
But let's debate this. Let's vote on this. Let's not table this. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Committee that amendments must be related to the matter under consideration which is consistent
with committee rule four. Your amendment is not related to member pay during a government
shutdown. As a result, the amendment falls. Mr. Chairman, I appeal the ruling of the Chair.
Is there a motion to table the appeal? Mr. Chairman, since Senator Ossoff has appealed the
ruling of the Chair, I would move that we table his amendment.
Is the motion to table the amendment or to table the appeal?
Well, an aye vote supports the ruling of the Chair. All those opposed say nay.
Nay. In the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it. Mr. Chairman, I ask for a recorded vote.
Oh, okay. Yeah, I'm sorry. I ask for a roll call vote on the motion to table the appeal.
It appears that a third of the members present demand a roll call vote.
Senator Cruz, Senator Capito, Senator Wicker, Senator Fisher, Senator Hyde-Smith,
Senator Hagerty, Senator Britt, Senator Bozeman, Senator Padilla,
Senator Schumer, not by proxy, Senator Warner, not by proxy, Senator Klobuchar,
Senator Merkley, Senator Ossoff, no, Senator Bennett, no, Senator Welch, Chairman McConnell,
aye. The ayes are nine, the noes are eight. Is there further debate on this motion to
table Senator Ossoff's appeal? The ayes are nine and the nays are eight. The motion to table is
agreed to. Is there further debate or amendment to SRS 526? Hearing none, the question is on
ordering the resolution favorably reported. The reporting forum is present. All those in favor
say aye. Aye. All those opposed nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. SRS 526 is
favorably reported. I ask unanimous consent that in preparing the measure for reporting,
the staff be authorized to make any required technical or conforming changes. Thank you,
everyone. Without objection, the committee stands adjourned.
