呂特在柏林慕尼黑安全會議上發表演講

新唐人電視台NTDTV
3萬粉絲
867 次觀看·2025年12月11日
美東12月11日上午8:00,柏林,北約秘書長馬克·呂特將在慕尼黑安全會議主辦的「柏林慕尼黑安全會議」活動上發表主題演講。新唐人、大紀元進行網絡直播,中文即時翻譯字幕。
星期四,北約秘書長馬克·呂特將訪問德國柏林。秘書長將與德國總理弗里德里希·默茨先生和外交部長約翰·瓦德普爾先生會面。10:35(歐洲中部時間)北約秘書長與德國總理弗里德里希·默茨先生舉行聯合新聞發布會。
我認為這個活動的時間不可能有改善
這只是美國幾天後公佈的
他們的新的國家安全策略
其中強調了歐洲應該承擔
對自己的防衛責任的主要責任
這對這裡的專家來說並不大驚喜
國家安全策略還描述了歐洲
歐洲被威脅 再次強調了
歐洲被文明滅亡
我認為歐洲必須有一個決定的反應
一種自我承諾
也許甚至是一種自豪
意志和視野
第二
這當然是一個非常關鍵的時刻
正如我們剛才聽到的
您剛纔在您的記者會上
與馬克思主席談論過
這是一個關鍵的時刻
在持續的談判和討論中
關於如何和什麼時候
結束俄羅斯戰爭
第三
我們還在持續和激烈的討論中
討論了俄羅斯針對德國
並不僅是針對德國
而是針對整個聯邦聯邦的社會
不得不說
我們今天有很多時間壓力
我現在就想停下來
俄羅斯在俄羅斯社會受到影響的西方計劃
實際上,當然是俄羅斯
它在世界各地花費了數百萬美元
以反對民主的方式
後來,當俄羅斯政府
試圖正面解決蘇聯的攻擊
實際上,當然是俄羅斯
它正在嘗試刪除
俄羅斯語言和文化身份
在它在俄羅斯的地區
我們能從這裏學到什麼呢?
第一,這種行爲模式
經常被稱爲精神上的預測
第二,當普京告訴俄羅斯媒體
他的國家並不打算對付歐洲國家
但如果歐洲要開始戰爭
他就已經準備好了
我們應該非常擔心
因爲俄羅斯的模式
正在在俄羅斯進行攻擊
我們所說的那些
發送到德國的服務軟件
盜竊飛機
穿過機場和國防部隊
與我們的軍事基礎基礎
進行的互聯網攻擊
這些行爲呼籲
對俄羅斯進行適當的反應
女士們 先生們 同志們
這不是一個選擇的問題
軍事阻擋的厲害邏輯
是我們時代的主要的戰略原則
這是事實
我很高興
在這一天和這一代
是你們 親愛的馬克
我們在兩岸的領導
我非常高興
我們在亞克總統會議上
同意了5%的新國防投資簽證
德國將在2035年
實施國防投資簽證
這一年
正如你們所知
德國進行了相關的步驟
來面對我們的 geopolitical reality
在3月
我們改革了我們的法律
以允許更加合適的軍事資源
上週
共和黨通過了
國防投資簽證法的改革
更重要的是
這一年
德國也變成了
歐洲最大的支持者
在軍事方面
而不是在非軍事方面
在上週的
美國外交部長會議上
與挪威
波蘭和泰國
親愛的馬克
我們宣佈了
資金支出
兩個項目的購買簽證
我們的購買簽證
預先通過的
歐洲要求的簽證
帶來的
我們的總額購買簽證
是700億美元
但是我還想說
更多的盟友
更多的歐洲盟友
需要緊急站起來
我們感謝
美國的努力
在追逐
在歐洲的持久和和平
進一步進步
有着重要的
歐洲和歐洲的
參與
我們在這方面
創造了重要的原則
這包括了
保護
和結束戰爭
這讓歐洲
維持主宰
獨立
和安全
從未來的
俄羅斯攻擊
歐洲展現了
不可思議的優勢
最重要的是
歐洲對於
隨時
和無條件的
制約
但我們還沒有看到
任何
有意義的
俄羅斯準備
來談判
今天俄羅斯的位置
似乎幾乎
減少到
如果我們不免費
我們不能在
11年的戰爭中
討論和談判
這並不是
一個嚴肅的
但這是
一個強烈的提醒
這場戰爭
可能只會結束
當普京感覺
繼續進行戰爭
變得太痛苦
在我看來
這就是我們
作爲歐洲盟友
必須做的一件事
首先
我們必須增加
對俄羅斯的壓力
我們必須讓俄羅斯知道
這些費用
尤其是持續
這場戰爭的
將繼續上漲
俄羅斯在
習近平
提出的
俄羅斯
我們必須
保持
和
我們
We stand on the side of freedom
And as free countries
The differences in political outlook
That will ever cease to exist between us
Should never drive us apart
For they are first and foremost this
An important source of our strength
I thank you
And I look now forward to hearing you
Dear Mark, the Secretary General of NATO
Thank you so much
Dear Johan, dear Detlef, dear Wolfgang
Good afternoon and of course
Good afternoon to all of you
And thank you for the warm welcome
It is always good to be in Berlin
Just over 36 years ago
On a now famous night in November
NATO Secretary General Manfred Wörner
jumped in his car
and drove through the night to Berlin
In the rush he forgot to tell
his staff in Brussels where he was going
Manfred was heading home to Germany
to join the crowds
celebrating the fall of the Berlin Wall
Today a section of the wall
stands at NATO headquarters
It was a barrier to keep people in
and ideas out
And now it is a monument
to the force of freedom
a reminder of the power of unity
and a lesson that we must stay strong
confident and steadfast
Because the dark forces of oppression
are on the march again
I am here today to tell you
where NATO stands
and what we must do
to stop a war before it starts
And to do that
we need to be crystal clear about threat
We are Russia's next target
And we are already in harm's way
When I became NATO Secretary General last year
I warned that what is happening in Ukraine
could happen to Allied countries too
That we have to shift to a wartime mindset
This year we took the big decisions
to make NATO stronger
At the summit in The Hague
Allies agreed to invest
5% of GDP annually in defense
by 2035
We agreed to increase
defense production across the Alliance
And we agreed to continue
our support to Ukraine
But this is not the time
for self-congratulation
I fear that too many
are quietly complacent
Too many don't feel the urgency
And too many believe
that time is on our side
It is not
The time for action is now
Allied defense spending and production
must rise rapidly
Our armed forces must have
what they need to keep us safe
And Ukraine must have
what it needs to defend itself
Now
Our governments, parliaments
and our citizens
have to be in this together
so that we can continue
to protect peace, freedom
and prosperity
Our open societies
our free elections
and a free press
We must all accept
that we must act to defend
our way of life now
Because this year
Russia has become even more brazen
reckless and ruthless
towards NATO
and towards Ukraine
During the Cold War
President Reagan warned about
the aggressive impulses
of an evil empire
Today
President Putin
is in the empire-building
business again
He is throwing everything
he has at Ukraine
killing soldiers and civilians
destroying the havens of humanity
homes, schools and hospitals
So far this year
Russia has launched
over 46,000 drones
and missiles against Ukraine
Russia is likely producing
2,900 attack drones a month
and a similar number of decoys
to distract air defenses
And in 2025
Russia produced
around 2,000 land attack
crucial and ballistic missiles
It is close to peak production
And while Putin
is trying to destroy Ukraine
he is also devastating
his own country
There have been over
1.1 million Russian casualties
since he began his war in 2022
And this year
Russia has lost
on average
1,200 troops a day
Think about it
More than a million casualties so far
and 1,200 a day
killed or wounded
this year alone
Putin is paying for his pride
with the blood of his own people
And if he is prepared
to sacrifice ordinary Russians
in this way
what is he prepared to do to us?
In his distorted view of history
and the world
Putin believes that our freedom
threatens his stranglehold on power
and that he wants to destroy Russia
Putin is doing a good job
of that all by himself
Russia's economy
is now geared to wage war
not to make its people prosperous
Russia is spending
nearly 40 percent of its budget
on aggression
and around 70 percent
of all machine tools in Russia
are used in military production
Taxes are going up
Inflation has skyrocketed
and petrol is rationed
Putin's next presidential campaign
slogan should be
Make Russia Weak Again
Not that he is troubled
by free and fair elections, of course
And how is Putin able
to continue his war
against Ukraine?
The answer is China
China is Russia's lifeline
China wants to prevent its ally
from losing in Ukraine
Without China's support
Russia could not continue
to wage this war
For example
about 80 percent
of critical electronic components
in Russian drones
and other systems
are made in China
So when civilians die in Kiev
or Kharkiv
Chinese technology
is often inside the weapons
that kill them
And let's not forget
that Russia also relies
on North Korea and Iran
in its fight against freedom
with ammunition
and military equipment
So far
Putin has only played
the peacemaker when it suits him
to buy time to continue his war
President Trump
wants to end the bloodshed now
And he is the only one
who can get Putin
to the negotiating table
So let's put Putin to the test
Let's see if he really wants peace
Or if he prefers
the slaughter to continue
It is essential
that all of us
keep up the pressure on Russia
and support the genuine efforts
to bring this war to an end
NATO's support means
Ukraine can defend itself
today
be in a strong position
to secure a just and lasting peace
and be able to deter
any Russian aggression in the future
Billions of dollars worth
of critical military hardware
is flowing into Ukraine
sourced from the United States
paid for by allies and partners
This is firepower
only America can provide
We are doing this
through a NATO initiative
indeed we call PERL
Since it was launched this summer
PERL has supplied around 75%
of all missiles
for Ukraine's Patriot batteries
and 90% of the ammunition used
in its other air defense systems
And I want to thank Germany
and all our allies
for their support
PERL is keeping Ukraine in the fight
and protecting its population
And I count indeed on more allies
to contribute to PERL
and to step up support to Ukraine
in many other ways
because we must strengthen Ukraine
so they can stop Putin in his tracks
Just imagine if Putin got his way
Ukraine under the boot of Russian occupation
his forces pressing
against a longer border with NATO
and a significantly increased
risk of an armed attack against us
It would require a truly gargantuan shift
in our deterrence and defense
NATO would have to substantially increase
its military presence
along the eastern flank
And allies would have to go
much further and faster
on defense spending and production
In such a scenario
we would long for the days
when 3.5% of GDP
on core defense was enough
The number would grow massively
And with that imminent threat
we would have to act fast
There would be emergency budgets
cuts to public spending
economic disruption
and further financial pressure
In that scenario
painful trade-offs would be unavoidable
but absolutely necessary
to protect our people
So let's not forget
Ukraine's security is our security
NATO's own defenses can hold for now
But with its economy dedicated to war
Russia could be ready to use
military force against NATO
within five years
Russia is already escalating
its covert campaign against our societies
Russia's list of targets for sabotage
is not limited to critical infrastructure
the defense industry and military facilities
There have been attacks on
commercial warehouses and shopping centers
and explosives hidden in parcels
And Poland is now investigating
sabotage against its railway network
This year we have seen
reckless airspace violations by Russia
Whether it is drones over Poland and Romania
or fighter jets over Estonia
Such incidents put lives in danger
and raise the risk of escalation
And while we often think of the risk
primarily in terms of our eastern flank
Russia's reach is not limited to land
The Arctic and the Atlantic are additional avenues
A reminder yet again
of why this alliance has been so crucial
for so many years on both sides of the Atlantic
So we are working together
to ensure the safety and security of all allies
on land, at sea, and in the air
We have increased our vigilance
and strengthened our deterrence and defense
along the eastern flank with eastern sentry
And we continue to protect
our critical infrastructure at sea
with Baltic sentry
NATO's response to Russia's provocations
has been calm, decisive, and proportionate
But we need to be prepared
for further escalation and confrontation
Our enduring commitment to NATO's Article 5
that an attack on one is an attack on all
sends a powerful message
Any aggressor must know
that we can and will hit back hard
And that is why we made
the crucial decisions in The Hague
on defense spending, on production
and support for Ukraine
And yes, we are seeing important progress
Look at ammunition production
We have seen a six-fold increase
in European production
of 155-millimeter artillery shells
compared with two years ago
I visited a new factory in Germany
in Unterlüs, this year
which plans to produce
350,000 artillery shells a year
Germany is fundamentally shifting
its approach to defense and industry
to increase defense production
And the investments Germany is making
in its armed forces are extraordinary
Around 152 billion planned for defense by 2029
3.5% of its GDP by 2029
Germany is a leading power in Europe
and a driving force in NATO
German leadership is essential
for our collective defense
Its commitment to doing its fair share
for our security is an example
to all allies
We need to be ready
because at the end
of this first quarter of the 21st century
conflicts are no longer fought at arm's length
Conflict is at our door
Russia has brought war back to Europe
and we must be prepared for the scale of war
our grandparents and great-grandparents endured
Imagine it
a conflict reaching every home, every workplace
Destruction, mass mobilization, millions displaced
Widespread suffering and extreme losses
It is a terrible thought
But if we deliver on our commitments
this is a tragedy we can prevent
NATO is here to protect one billion people
on both sides of the Atlantic
Our mission is to protect you
your families, your friends and your future
We cannot let down our guard
and we won't
I count on our governments
to keep up with their commitments
and go further and faster
because we cannot falter or fail
Listen to the sirens across Ukraine
Look at the bodies pulled from the rubble
Think of the Ukrainians
who might go to sleep tonight
and not wake up tomorrow
And what a standing
between what's happening to them
and what could happen to us
Only NATO
I have a duty
as Secretary General
to tell you what lies ahead
if we don't act faster
invest in defense
and continue our support for Ukraine
I know this is a hard message
as we head towards the festive season
when our thoughts turn to hope, light and peace
But we can take courage and strength
knowing that we stand together in NATO
with determination
and the knowledge
that we are on the right side of history
We have a plan
We know what to do
So let us deliver
We must
Thank you
Thank you so much, Secretary General
Great speech, if I may say
We don't have a lot of time
We have approximately
Because Secretary General
has an important follow-on meeting
We have approximately 20 minutes
So if you have a good question to ask
let me know
But let me use my privilege
of sitting up here
by asking the first question
for both of you
Everybody knows
as has been said publicly
that we have entered
what appears to be a critical moment
in the negotiations
about how to end
and when to end
the Ukraine war
I'd really like to have your view
and your view also
Foreign Minister
How close are we?
Do you really believe
that there is
You've expressed some skepticism
in your remarks
that there is a willingness
by the Russian side
to sign a quote-unquote deal
How close are we?
Some people have told me
that it might be possible
to get something done before Christmas
Well, how wonderful would that be?
Is that an illusion?
Please
It's difficult to say
That's the honest answer
And I can only say that
President Trump, the Americans
are working tirelessly
to get this done
And I really want to
commend them for that
And Germany and France
and United Kingdom, Poland, Italy
and the other European allies
in Canada are helping
and there the Netherlands
to support wherever they can
the peace effort
And of course
there are various elements
One is how do you reconstruct Ukraine?
There was some news yesterday
that progress is being made there
We know that it will be crucial
after a long-term ceasefire
slash a peace deal
that the Russians will never ever try
again to attack Ukraine
So there have to be
security guarantees in place
of such a quality and level
that Putin knows if he tries again
the reaction will be devastating
And we all know
there will be a delicate
difficult discussion about territory
which in the end
only the Ukrainians can decide about
Do I think that
when it comes to Ukraine
the U.S. and Europe
to get to one page?
Yes, I'm positive
I think we can
Am I sure that the Russians will accept?
I don't know
This is the test
which I also said in my speech
We have to test Putin now
whether he is serious
And the guy is willing
last month to suffer
25,000 of his own people
25,000 people dead
not seriously wounded
No, killed, dead
25,000
1.5 billion
1.1 million
dead or seriously wounded
over the last four years
So let's see
whether he is getting to a point
where he thinks that this is
unsufferable for him and his people
and that he wants to make a deal
But that's of course
the big test coming up
I would only add two points
The first one is
we will only get Putin
to that very point
if it is absolutely clear
that we as Europeans
and of course the United States
as well are with the Ukraine
will support Ukraine
that we will be able
especially in the European Council
in the next week
to make it possible
to make use
of the Russian sovereign assets
That's what the German government
is working for
This is a proposal
of Chancellor Matz
And we are slightly optimistic
to get it through
This is absolutely our target
And Putin has to know
whatever happens
he may be ready for
an agreement or not
We will be supporting Ukraine
defending the sovereignty of Ukraine
and be with the people there
Secondly
Of course everybody would expect
Ambassador to have an agreement
before Christmas
That would be really great
The best Christmas gift
for everybody
especially for the suffering people
in Ukraine
But it has to be a sustainable solution
So if you look back
into German history
it's always not so easy to compare
the very historical situation
But we know from the situation
after the Second World War
how it was ended
with of course the military
saying OK
the weak politicians agreed
to a peace treaty
which was not necessary
at that very point
And that was always a burden
for the Weimar Republic
here in Germany
So we have to have that in mind
And that was also a point
I made in Beijing
with my colleague Wang Yi
in these days
because he also asked me
why not making an agreement
why not handing over Donetsk
to Russia
We as Europeans
know what it means
to have a peace deal
which is acceptable and bearable
for the people in Ukraine
and which in a way also is part
of the guarantees
we all need
for the future
not to be faced
with a new Russian aggression
in the future
All right, thank you very much
Since we are here
three men on the stage
I'll go to a lady first
There is a lady
who is raising her arm
Let's go to that lady first
Anna Wielaszczuk
International Editor
at Tagesspiegel
Secretary General
Both you and Minister Wadephul
have stressed the value of unity
that cohesion
both within the EU and NATO
is our strength
However, we've seen
the 28-point plan
that tried to formulate commitments
to third parties and NATO
about NATO's future
We've seen communication
coming out of Washington
saying that NATO's capabilities
in Europe
should be served
within a very steep timeline
How do you convince someone
who does not see value
in unity and cooperation
of just that aim
and maybe as a plan B
Do you see a future for NATO
where the U.S. is explicitly
or implicitly withdrawn
a European or other coalition
of the willing within NATO
To your second question, no
I don't see that
I think it is crucial
that we keep the transatlantic bond
as strong as it is today
and it is very strong
When you look at
the national security strategy
the U.S. brought out
I know there was a lot of talk
of course in European capitals
But look at what is actually saying
Complete commitment
to European security
Complete commitment to NATO
and a complete commitment
to the fact that we can only defend
the Euro-Atlantic area
if we stick together
And yes, there is a lot
you can discuss about
but this is at the core there
When you take President Trump
when he was in his first term
and now in his second term
he has been extremely clear
that he is totally committed to NATO
having one big irritant
the fact that Germany, the Netherlands
and many other countries
were not even getting to the old 2%
let alone spending
what he is spending, 3.5%
And now in The Hague
we have dealt with this
We decided to move to the 3.5%
equalize with the U.S.
I think it is his biggest
foreign policy success
when it comes to the Euro-Atlantic area
And not only because
we want to equalize with the U.S.
but because we need to spend
this money to keep ourselves safe
from the Russians
And also taking a careful look
at the Chinese military build-up
taking place today
And Europe is now stepping up
Germany is leading
that whole phase of stepping up
with the defense spending here
Germany's presence in Baltic century
Eastern century
The coalition of the willing
where Germany and the U.K.
and France and others
are working together
to agree on what is necessary
to keep Ukraine safe
post a peace deal
And of course
Pearl
So the money needed
to buy from America
to give essential weapons
to Ukraine
Again, Germany taking the lead
So Europe is stepping up
Germany taking the lead there
But many others also
absolutely stepping up
including the Netherlands
the Scandics
Scandinavians
the Baltics
And of course Poland
And many others
So we are in a much better place
So I am absolutely convinced
This alliance is there to stay
And it is crucial
Also in the U.S. interest
Because you cannot
defend the U.S.
without a Arctic
which is defended
And for the Arctic
you need NATO
You cannot defend the U.S.
without a safe Atlantic
You need NATO
to keep the Atlantic safe
Look at the nuclear submarines
the Russians have
who might want to sail
towards the U.S. coast
And you cannot keep the U.S. safe
without a safe Europe
And Americans know this
All the senior policy makers
from the White House down
to the State Department
to the Pentagon
They all know this
And they all agree with this
If you ask a question
please identify yourself
And please make sure we know
whether you address the question
to both speakers
or only to one of them
Let's go to Matthias Gebauer first
And then we'll go to this side of the...
Hi, it's Matthias Gebauer
German magazine Der Spiegel
Mr. Rutte, I have one question
You very much underlined
the ongoing and permanent threat
Russia poses to Europe
But you also mentioned
right now that Russia
is also a threat to the U.S.
On the other hand
in the just very recent
national security strategy
the White House put out
Russia is not really
not even named as a threat
It's quite the opposite
It's named as we want like
stabilize the relations
towards Russia
which is a stark contrast
also to the communique
of the Hague summit
where Russia is mentioned
as the main threat to NATO
How, as NATO Secretary General
How do you want to align
these two views
And did you already talk
to President Trump
about the contents
of the national security strategy
and this very opposing
lines towards Russia
Well, again, let me tell you
what I'm...
In all my discussions
with the United States
when it comes to NATO
when it comes to defense
of the U.S. itself
and the collective defense
of the Euro-Atlantic
And I don't want to repeat
the previous question
because we do not have so much time
But let me refer to my reaction
to the previous question
I think there's the evidence
that the U.S. is not a NATO only
because they didn't want to
repeat the mistake
after the Second World War
at least after the First World War
of not being involved
They are a NATO
because it is providing them
with the direct security
they need for their future
And it has to do, of course, with Europe
And that's clear in the NSS
in this national security strategy
that they're completely committed
to the European security
NATO security
and working together
But it also has to do, as I said
with the Arctic and the Atlantic
These are three key elements of NATO
which are there
not only to keep Europe safe
but to keep the whole
of the Euro-Atlantic safe
And when it comes to the Inner Pacific
they also, of course, have to
spend time there
That's clear
And NATO is not directly involved
We have a close cooperation
with many countries there
in this Inner Pacific IV Corporation
But it was the American president
explicitly asking me
when I first visited him
in the White House in March this year
after he got back into office
after the inauguration
to make sure that we
relationship with the IP4 close
because he and all the senior
policy makers know that
these two theaters
the Inner Pacific and the Euro-Atlantic
are closely connected
May I add
I would ask all of us
not to put things in doubt
which nobody puts in doubt in Washington
but only which is put in doubt
perhaps
and which is challenged
in Moscow and in Beijing
And this is the strength
and the cohesion of our alliance
And as the 28-point plan was mentioned
it is no longer existing
We had some influence on it
When it was made public
published
When it was published
it was
We were able to talk to the Americans
I was able to talk to Steve Whitkoff
and to discuss the points
We were able to discuss it
with Marco Rubio
And we have a new plan
which is a 20-point plan
which has really changed
Do we have to be engaged
with the United States
more than before?
Yes
Is it possible
to find a common ground?
Yes
And that was
that was the very success
of the Hague Summit
in this springtime
So when we went forward
when we were clear
that we are engaged
that we not only spend 2%
but we are ready to spend 5% or more
United States were there
And of course
there was a common ground
And we found that
common declaration
And you see no doubts
also in this specific new paper
from Washington
which really put in doubt
the nuclear umbrella
and the willingness
to defend Europe
together with European allies
And please do not
do us not allow
to raise questions
which were in really
in the end of the day
not raised in Washington
All right
We'll go to this side of there
Where were the questions here?
Gentleman over there
Jan Dombyski
Polish Ambassador to Berlin
One question to Secretary General
In all this discussion
about security guarantees for Ukraine
I've nothing found about
reduction of Russian military presence
on our borders
Is it a part of a discussion
because this would be
the best security guarantee
for Ukraine
the militarization of Crimea
or of occupied territories at least
to reduce the Russian presence
on against Ukraine
and against us
Ambassador I understand the question
Of course I am
aware of
fair stages of all the discussions
I cannot go into all the details
But what I was talking about
was primarily focusing
primarily focusing on
making sure that
whatever the military power of the Russians
and at this moment
that's considerable
given their extreme investments
now in defense
total defense budget
200 billion dollars
and with their purchasing power
that's about the same
as the whole of European NATO
is spending on defense
in terms of purchasing power
So it's really a lot of money
And they don't have
all the bureaucracy we have
So they can take the decisions
quickly, easily move to this
wartime economy
as they have done
And that's why they are posing
a threat immediately
And what we need to do
with these security guarantees
first of all is to make sure
that they will never try again
By knowing that
our reaction will be
as I said devastating
That's now the prime focus
We have time for
maybe two more questions
There is the lady
Yes, in the fourth row there
Sorry
My name is Anahud Herkes
I'm the chair of the
Koenig Center organization
My question is addressed
to both gentlemen
In your brilliant speech
Secretary General
You referenced
the fall down of the Berlin Wall
And I remember
when I was a young diplomat
We drew extraordinary insights
from the fragility
both of the Eastern European
And I apologize
about this to our European friends
And Russia
And the Soviet Union in particular
Question
To what degree
in your strategic foresight and insights
does intelligence knowledge
And I'm aware
you cannot share everything here
play a role about the actual fragility
potential fragility
of the current Kremlin regime
And how does that way
If it does, Prime Minister
How does that way
in your defense strategy
Thank you
Yes, of course
You already gave
a part of the answer yourself
That it's a bit difficult
to get too much into that
But let me just more generally react
That I was 14 years
Prime Minister of the Netherlands
And I had a lot of dealings
With Putin before he invaded Crimea
And then after Crimea
Because of MH17
The downing of the Malaysian airplane
Where 298 people died
And I had a lot of calls
With Putin then
And met him later in G20 meetings
On that subject
And I've stopped long time ago
To guess what's up in his head
And what I...
I look at the facts
And the fact that you have a dictator
Willing to sacrifice
1.1 million of your own people
Take Pokrovsk
We are all now intimately aware
Of the geography of Ukraine
We all know what Pokrovsk is
In Donbass, in Donetsk
And that small city of 60,000 people
They started to onslaught on that city
In the summer of 2024
It is now the end of 2025
They still have not captured it
And in the meantime
On this front line
They are losing
Last month 25,000 people getting killed
If you have a dictator willing to do this
Because you have this crazy idea
Of some historical whatever he has
Then you have to be very careful
And we have to stand ready
And that's why it is crucial
That the biggest economy in Europe
And that is Germany
With its enormous power
Has decided
In already under Schultz
With its president
And then with Chancellor
When this government was formed in March
Even before the government was formed
Under the leadership of now Chancellor Merz
To make this extraordinary investment
In this defense
It is crucial
Please I know also in Germany
Some people are questioning
Do we really need to do this?
Yes
If you love the German language
And you do not want to speak Russian
It is crucial
It is a sine qua non
Because otherwise
This guy will not stop with Ukraine
That's I think
What we have to be very watchful
I could only add
There are some more good reasons
But only to speak German
We love to speak German
But yes I know that
But let me please
Only perhaps one consideration
We do see
That our sanctions are in place
And that they have effects
On the Russian economy
And of course it works
Nobody knows exactly
And could define
What it means for the decision making process
Of Mr. Putin and his comrades
OK
But it works on the ground
And I would only encourage all of us
To go consequently
Alongside with this way forward
Because sanctions are the only
Besides the military support for Ukraine
Are really preferring Russia
And in the end of the day
Of course it will play a role
In its last decision
We have time for one last question
Yana over there
Yana from European Council on Foreign Relations
Just one quick question
Coming back to the
US national security strategy
There is a passage in there saying
That the US wants to rebalance
Strategic stability in Europe
Coming back also to the nuclear aspect
How do you interpret this
What does that mean
What is the US thinking behind
Rebalancing strategic stability
With the Russians in Europe
Well what we have seen over time
Of course is that
Basically let Russia
To decide for a moment
But when we look at the Russian
At the American front policy
And its approach to NATO
First of all
There was this big irritant
Of the European and Canadian allies
Not spending the same
As the Americans were spending
That is now dealt with
And again Germany even six years
Before the 2035 deadline
Getting to this 3.5% crucial
Then the Americans
Have always been clear also
That they expect Europe to do more
To do more of the heavy lifting
And why is that
Because the US also has to concentrate
On the Indo-Pacific
And other parts of the world
And knowing that these theaters
Are more and more getting interconnected
So that's what you will see
Over the coming years
A shift
Not dramatic
But to some extent
In Europe we will have to take care
More of our own defense
This whole rumor about 2027
Is not right
The US has also confirmed that
So that's off this Reuters report
On Friday was not right
But more generally
Yes it is clear that Europe
Will have to step up
And that's exactly what we are doing
And is there room of enhancement
Of course there is
I would only add one point
We should not only concentrate
On the so-called end question
Because we have some restrictions
Also legally binding for Germany
But we have some other qualities
Like deep precision strike capabilities
And that's where we are concentrating on
And that has similar effects
And can have similar effects
Thank you
Thank you very much
I know I have to apologize
To all those who wanted to come in
But we've really run out of time
I apologize
The one thing I know
Is that these two gentlemen
Will meet again
At a certain event in Munich
In mid-February
And some of you will also be there
I'm sure many of the journalists
Media people will be there
So let's meet again in February
Hopefully with good news
Better news then
Than the news we've had
In recent days and weeks
Thank you all for participating
Let's give our two speakers
A round of applause please
And I think our Bavarian hosts
Are kind enough to invite us to a glass
Or something to eat downstairs
Thank you very much
