The IRRESISTIBLE Sauce That Earned 6 Marriage Proposals

Healthy food
928 followers
Imagine making a sauce so good,
women were compelled to propose to you.
That's the apparent story behind my favorite
all-time fish dish in New York City
and the latest inductee into Stevie's Food Hall of Fame.
This is Iron Chef Mark Forgione's
halibut and croutes in sauce proposal.
Now, restaurant Mark Forgione is probably
the restaurant in New York City I've been to the most times.
And they have some of my favorite dishes.
But we've actually spoken recently
and eventually we're going to shoot at his place
and he's gonna show me all three of these recipes.
But this is my recreation today.
And eventually we'll see how close I get.
So I've got hazelnuts here, just a couple handfuls.
What I'm gonna do is pop this into my toaster oven,
toast them on 350, just until they start to get fragrant,
nice and toasty and brown.
Now, before we get into the sauce proposal,
here we have a nice filet of halibut.
I asked my fishmonger to take off the skin.
When I got home after shopping this morning,
I just took it out the bag,
seasoned it on both sides of the fish,
threw it in the refrigerator uncovered to dry it out
and allow that fish to get seasoned and absorb that salt.
Now, halibut and croute, what does that mean?
It's halibut encrusted, right?
So the incredible thing that they do
is they take a piece of white bread
and get it nice and fresh baked
or you can get one of these pieces.
Now what we're gonna do is take this piece of bread,
flatten it out with a rolling pin
into a flat thing like that.
You know, bread like this with the grilled cheese
make like an amazing smashed grilled cheese.
Anyway, this now should be bigger than the piece of filet.
Set that off to the side, we need an egg.
Now I just need the whites.
I'm just gonna rock it back and forth
till we just get the egg white.
We just wanna whip it,
just till it's a little foamy and easy to spread.
See now, our hazelnuts are toasted.
Just gonna rock them.
You're gonna get a lot of that easy to get off skin.
Any pieces, others you could just go
and just peel that skin off.
God damn, let them cool.
Then we just set those off to the side
and let them chill.
And we're just gonna brush that egg white
on top of the halibut filet.
Just the top half.
Then we're gonna take the halibut filet,
we're gonna flip it so the bread makes contact with the egg
right in the middle of the flattened bread.
Then what we can do, take a knife and trim off the crust.
And then split it into two.
Flip them over.
And so the halibut and croute is prepped.
Now we're gonna place this in the fridge
and allow that egg to act as like a glue
and seal to that fish.
Then we can prep everything else.
Hazelnuts are cooled.
Just gonna get a Ziploc bag.
Get the hazelnuts in.
You don't need to seal it.
We're just gonna take a pan and just sort of crack them.
These are gonna add some nice texture.
Hazelnuts are prepped.
We can set them off to the side.
Now one of the elements to go with this dish
is a cauliflower puree.
It's a dead simple recipe.
It's easy to make.
It's like a beautiful switch up
from something like a mashed potato.
And it's really just cauliflower,
heavy cream, and some salt.
To a pot, just gonna add a pint of cream to start
and we'll see if we need a little bit more.
So now we're gonna use this cauliflower a couple ways.
The first one is in this cauliflower puree.
The next way is we're going to be adding
some cauliflower roasted onto the dish.
So we're gonna prep the cauliflower
a couple of different ways.
First I'm just gonna go in
and start to release some florets.
The outer ones are the bigger florets.
Those are gonna be the ones I'm gonna use for the puree.
You wanna cut them in half, you could do that.
You could leave them whole.
Just keep them equal size.
Add them to the cream.
Just a little more cream to cover.
Some salt.
We're gonna place this on the stove.
Bring it up to a boil and then drop it down to a simmer.
Do not put a lid on it and do not cook it too hard
otherwise it's gonna boil over
and cause a mess in your stove.
Let's see if I manage to do that this time as well.
Now the other way, I wanna access the smallest florets.
The ones that are towards the center
or the heart of the cauliflower.
I want these little bites.
That's sort of how they serve it in the restaurant.
Right, like little bits like that.
Nicely caramelized.
You can also give a bigger one
a little cut in half like that.
Mark also serves this with romesco,
treated in a similar fashion.
But that's hard to find here
so we're just gonna use some good old broccoli.
I'm just gonna sort of approach it the same way.
Now for an elegant dish like this,
this should be enough for maybe two people.
By the way, this is kind of like
an incredible date night dish.
You wanna keep it light.
It's a great amount of vegetables for two servings.
You know, when we do these Hall of Fame dishes,
these recreations, sometimes it's fun to like
act like a chef at home, plate it really beautifully
or even just practice plating it
in a different way than you're normally used to.
So that's part of the idea here.
So we're gonna set that off to the side.
That's prepped.
Milk's starting to boil.
I'm just gonna drop it down to low.
We're just gonna cook them until they're super tender.
Now, what is sauce proposal?
One of those things where I tasted the dish
with a fork and I just kept dipping the fork in.
What is that?
It's just the most incredible thing
I had tasted at the time.
What it essentially is, is a butter emulsion.
So a butter sauce.
So we're going to use a lot of butter.
It's a restaurant dish, shouldn't be surprising.
You're not gonna make this all the time.
Although you could.
And the emulsion is going to be flavored
by soy sauce and lime juice.
Salty, umami, acidic, bright, buttery, fat,
all of these things combined with the roasted broccoli,
the cauliflower puree, the crunch of the accrued fish,
out of control.
And with the butter, we need two things.
Eight ounces, which is two sticks of butter
that we're going to keep cold and emulsify into the butter.
And then one stick we're gonna turn into brown butter
and add that after we add this.
So we're going to keep this in the fridge.
And then we're going to turn this into brown butter.
Then we need a half cup of soy sauce
and a half cup of lime juice.
Should be about three limes if they're juicy enough.
Looks like it's going to be four limes for me today.
But I've got extras.
At the end, I may use one to just brighten up
the sauce before serving.
But that's it.
Butter, lime, soy sauce.
First step is to brown the butter.
Now we're going to make our brown butter.
And of course, as I do this, what do you know?
We boil over the cauliflower.
I told you that's going to happen.
Had the heat on a little too high.
Anyway, to a saute pan,
we're going to add in a stick of butter.
And we want to make brown butter.
So we're going to keep it on medium low heat
and slowly melt the butter and cook it
until the butter starts to turn a little bit of golden.
There's a foam that sort of settles on the top
and the milk fats and the solids separate.
And the milk fats at the bottom of the pan begin to brown.
A nutty aroma starts to perfume off of the butter.
And that's when you're done.
So now we've got our brown butter.
We're going to get that into a bowl.
Put all those milk fats in there.
We're going to get that onto some ice.
Then we're going to start to whisk it.
If you don't whisk it, as it cools,
it's just going to separate.
With this ice, whisking it,
it's going to cool it down fast, stop the cooking,
and then allow it to form back into like a workable solid
that then we can mount into the sauce at the end
for that added brown butter flavor.
It should be like caramel nutty aroma.
Absolutely delicious.
Once it cools down, switch from a whisk back to a spatula.
Drag it along those walls.
It's going to start to firm up any second now.
Now you can see it's firmed up.
The milk solids are not suspended in that butter.
This can go into the fridge to further set.
So now what I'm going to do is I'm going to fish out
the cauliflower, get that into a blender.
And with it comes some of that cream that we cooked it in.
And we kind of need a little bit of that
to create the right consistency.
Now, I don't want to add too much.
So I'm going to start blending it like that
and see if I need more.
It's really hard to adjust it when it's too thin.
I think that's going to be good.
It's nice and thick,
but it's really kind of light and smooth and creamy.
See that?
It's like an ethereal texture.
So I'm going to pour it back into the pot.
You can get an idea of the consistency.
It's like thick, it's flowy.
I need more liquid in there
and it would have been a little too thin.
Almost like really light palm puree.
Keep that warm on the back of the stove.
Now, before we get to cooking the fish, making the sauce,
got some fresh parsley here.
I'm just going to bunch up the parsley,
just like you would chiffonade basil,
just sort of roll it up and then slice it thin.
And set that off to the side.
We're going to need some capers,
maybe about a tablespoon should work.
So we've got our butters, our brown butter,
our unsalted butter, our lime, our soy,
our veggie capers, parsley, hazelnuts,
and our cauliflower puree, and our fish.
The bread and the fish have now become one.
First, the sauce proposal.
So to make this sauce,
we're first going to get that soy sauce up to a boil.
And I'm just going to let it simmer
for about two to three minutes.
Allow just a tiny bit of evaporation
and concentration to occur.
Then we're going to take the lime juice
and we're going to add that into the pot.
Again, we're going to bring that up to a simmer,
get it hot, and then we're going to turn the heat
to very low.
I'm going to go ahead and start whisking
in the cold, unsalted butter.
Now the technique to this is going to be adding
one knob of butter, about a tablespoon.
Whisk it until it's fully melted
and incorporated into the sauce.
And once that butter is melted,
then and only then do you begin to add another one.
And then we're going to start doing the same thing,
a tablespoon at a time with the brown butter.
Starting slow in the beginning
is going to help you achieve a proper emulsion.
The same way drizzling olive oil slowly into a dressing
gets it emulsified the same way.
What we're just going to do is slide that off to the side,
set that on low, and let that whole mixture
just reduce slightly before we're ready to serve it.
Next up for this particular fish dish,
I like to use a small nonstick pan to cook the fish.
So what we're going to do is spray a little bit of oil
in there and just bring it up to a very modest temperature.
I don't want the surface of the pan
to be any hotter than like 300, 325 degrees.
Once it's hot, we can go ahead
and add in our fish bread side down.
We're going to put a weight on top of it.
And the goal here is to slowly cook the fish
and to slowly brown and crisp up that bread.
We want simmering happening around the edges
to make sure it's hot enough to brown,
but we don't want it too hot.
And every now and then we're just going to pick it up
and see how we're doing.
You can control the level of golden brown
you're going to get on that piece of bread,
but you're also watching the fish cook from the bottom up.
Once we've let that cook about 80 to 90%
on the bread side on that low heat,
and it's nicely crisp and golden brown all over,
then we can give it a flip and kiss the other side.
I really want to just get heat flowing from the bottom up.
After a minute or two, I'm going to temp it.
If it's around 110,
I know it's going to carry over cook to around 135,
and that's going to be a perfect temperature for fish.
Get it out of the pan and let it rest
while we finish the rest of this dish.
Now I'm going to get my stainless steel saute pan,
medium high heat.
And again, we're going to coat the bottom of the pan
with some oil.
We want a little bit more oil for this
because we're trying to achieve
a really caramelized vegetable.
Once it's hot, we're going to go in
with the tiny broccoli cauliflower florets we cut.
Hit them with some salt and do not touch them.
We really want to allow one side
to develop a really nice brown, caramelized,
sweet, nutty aroma and flavor.
Once you see one side is nicely browned
after a few minutes, give it a toss
and then try and achieve that
with another side of the vegetable.
They are small, but when you're cooking them like this,
they're not going to get mushy too fast.
So you can go a little bit heavier on the heat.
That caramelization is a vital feature to this dish.
After that cooks for about five, six minutes,
then we can go ahead in and add the hazelnuts
and allow those to get hot, toasty a bit,
bring out some of their flavor, wake them up.
After the nuts toast for a couple minutes,
we can go in with the capers.
Get those mixed in and then the final step
is to add the sauce, but you want to make sure
the pan's not too hot before you add in the sauce.
I don't really want to cook it any more than it is
and risk breaking it.
But I did add the sauce when it's a bit too hot.
Just stir that into the vegetables.
That steam will sort of finish it through
and then we're ready to plate.
Oh yeah, one last thing.
Right before you serve it,
throw in that sliced parsley we cut earlier.
I forgot to show that on screen.
Now for plating, we're going for this yin and yang look.
So we're going to take a big dollop of the cauliflower,
drop it on one side of a shallow bowl.
Then with the back of a spoon,
press into the cauliflower and turn the bowl
while dragging it around the bowl
to create this iconic pattern to the plating.
Next up, we take our sauce proposal and our vegetables
and we just start to display them in that little crevice
we've created with the cauliflower.
A bed for the fish to sit on,
where the sauce and the vegetables are sort of nestled
and contained by the cauliflower.
Pour in all of that magical sauce,
the whole reason I'm obsessed with this dish.
Then we just place our halibut and crout right in the middle.
And yes, this is a different piece of fish.
I lost some footage, but you get the idea.
Now this may not be exactly how Mark does it,
but I assure you, it tastes pretty damn similar
and good enough for me at home.
I love the hazelnuts in it.
The yin and the yang of both the plating
and the sauce and the cauliflower
just blend together so well.
And I mean, look at this perfect fish,
crisp bread, moist fish.
And man, that sauce just hits that rich, fatty,
umami, acidic note, just bounces around your tongue.
This is going in the Hall of Fame.
And if you want to make this,
the recipe is going to be down in the description.
And soon we'll head on over to Mark
to see how we actually measure it up.
Also, if you haven't yet,
check out my link in the description
for my Patreon cooking school.
Totally different concept to what we got going on over here.
If you're curious, the link's going to be down below.
Anyway, that's all that I have today.
I'll see you next time.
Until then, take care of yourself.
Go feed yourself.
