Top 5 WORST first cars under $5000

Ex Used Car
15 followers
8 Video Views·Dec 7, 2025
Your first car is so important, and look, we completely understand, a budget of $5,000
doesn't exactly open up a world of opportunity when it comes to car buying.
But look, there are some cars out there that you guys need to avoid at all costs.
So, here's our Redriven Top 5 Worst First Cars Under $5,000.
Yes, it oozes European cool, yes it looks very funky and stylish, and it's French, but in
fifth place, and needs to be avoided, it's the Citroen C4.
Even when new, the first generation 2004 to 2010 C4 was subject to a host of factory recalls.
And now that they're well past their prime, all sorts of issues are popping up.
Everything from faulty electronics to dodgy suspension components and gearboxes are a
major concern.
And then add the issue that the cost of these replacement parts are expensive, and in many
cases, these parts can be a nightmare to source, just add up to the C4 being a car
that you need to ignore.
Oh, these things are just, these are horrible.
In fourth place, it's the Holden or Chevrolet Cruze.
Even when brand new, the Cruze scored the unenviable rank of the lowest reliability
among compact sedans.
And now that they're carpet bombed through the used car market, things are just getting
worse.
Failing transmissions, rubbish engines, electronic issues, brake and suspension concerns, the
list just goes on and on.
Look, these things are just bloody rubbish.
For five grand, there are so many better alternatives.
Go and watch our top five first cars under $5,000 to find out what you should be buying
instead.
The French are phenomenal at making art and food and cheese and wine and photography and
architecture and they improved kissing beyond our wildest dreams, but the Peugeot 307, what
the hell were they thinking?
How a company that gave us such motoring icons like the 205 GTI, 106 and 306 Rally can turn
around and deliver such a pile of crap like the 307 is completely beyond us.
Look out for everything from very expensive failing head gaskets to very annoying faulty
indicator stalks.
And look, while you're at it, check out the faulty suspension components, failing ignition
systems, dodgy interior trim, fuel leaks and failing electronics.
Actually, no, don't check those things out.
Just keep away from these things in the first place.
Well this is bound to upset a few people.
In second place, it's the Volkswagen Golf, the Mark 5 Volkswagen Golf and specifically
anything with a 1.4 litre engine or a DSG gearbox.
We get it.
You want a stylish, well-engineered, safe, practical and efficient car and being German,
surely a Volkswagen Golf delivers those requirements in spades.
Plus, you'll get to cruise around in a car with a posh European badge on it.
Well, the problem is, excluding the GTI and R models, if you're buying a Mark 5 Golf at
this price point, chances are you're probably just buying someone else's problems.
Back in a 2014 customer satisfaction survey, the Mark 5 Golf came 145th overall and held
the unenviable position of being the lowest-ranked family hatchback.
That was back in 2014 and like, the Golf isn't a fine wine, it's not improving with age.
But what goes wrong with them?
Where do we start?
Water pumps, oil leaks, persistent major electronic issues, suspension problems, interior faults
and look, honestly, the list just goes on and on.
Look, there are the occasional unicorn Mark 5 Golfs out there that owners love them and
nothing really ever goes wrong, but with the potential problems at hand and what they're
going to cost to fix, we just don't think it's worth the risk.
Before we get to number one, please do us a favour and throw us a like, why not subscribe
to this channel, make sure you hit the bell icon to turn on notifications and why not
follow us on all of our social media.
Right, which car takes out first place?
It is the genuinely horrible Holden Opel Vauxhall Astra.
And which exact Astra?
Well, all of them.
Why?
Well, the Astra is an absolute maintenance nightmare and what goes wrong with them?
Well, everything.
Engines misfire, transmissions fail, fluids leak, alternators fail, coil packs and timing
belts have issues, clutches have issues, steering locks jam, the car's ECUs just freak out,
they are riddled with electronic gremlins, air conditioning fails, even the mirrors fall
apart because the glue they use just isn't handling Australian weather, plus the parts
are far too expensive for what the car is even worth and they're a nightmare to work
on.
Look, mechanics call these things disastrous and we know of used car dealers that won't
even take them as trade-ins because they're just that dodgy.
So now you know all the cars to avoid, best check out the cars that we do recommend, so
click on the link for the top five best first cars under $5,000 that we do recommend.
And what did you think of the list?
Do you still want to actually buy any of these things?
Why would you do that?
Let us know in the comments section below.
See you next time.
