PART THREE OF THREE James McNeill Whistler, John Singer Sargent, and William Bouguereau
This exciting 3-part series looks at seven of the world’s best oil painters from history and examines how each laid down their paint layers to create their masterpieces. Part three covers three amazing artists who were all contemporaries of one another but whose styles varied significantly. American artist, James McNeill Whistler, was one of the most influential of the avant-garde painters in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. John Singer Sargent painted stylistic portraits of some of the biggest names of his time, and William Bouguereau was one of the most renown artists in Western Europe during his lifetime. UDemy https://www.udemy.com/user/jill-poyerd/
0:00 Introduction 0:38 James McNeill Whistler 10:27 John Singer Sargent 21:06 William Adolphe Bourguereau 31:54 Conclusion
It's been said that in preparing for a painting,
J.M.W. Turner once instructed sailors to tie him to the mast of a ship for four hours during a
severe storm in order to get a proper feel for the event. He enveloped himself in the situation
so he could get a full perspective on the scene. In a similar way, James McNeill Whistler was known
to set out by boat onto the River Thames at twilight in order to capture the feel of the
evening along the coastline. Sometimes he remained there all night. James McNeill Whistler was an
American artist. Born to a military man and civil engineer, he initially followed his father's path
to West Point, only to be dismissed three years later due to his demerits and for failing chemistry.
One thing he didn't fail at was drawing. After working a few minor jobs, Whistler decided to
pursue art, so he moved to Paris, the hub of artistic development. It was there that he was
exposed to the many avant-garde art movements, observing the works of the realists, the pre-
leading to paintings that were rather thickly and directly painted.
But eventually, he began diluting his paints and working with thinner layers.
As he worked with the thinner layers of paint, he noticed he had greater success,
so he made that his primary method of application.
After working in Paris for several years, Whistler decided to move to London where he
felt he could stand out a little more and possibly advance more quickly. Initially,
he was successful there as well, but in 1862, his painting Symphony in White No. 1
was rejected by the Royal Academy. He felt dejected. At the same time, he was feeling
frustrated with the limits that realism placed on his expression, and he had a desire to be
original. So, he set out to revamp his painting style. To do this, he studied his large collection
of Japanese prints, as well as Greek sculptures, the Pre-Raphaelites, and Rococo paintings.
The result of his study and experimentation was the painting style we see in his Nocturne series
through the 1870s. This breakthrough is considered by many experts to be a version of
post-Impressionism, at a time when most of his contemporaries were still exploring realism
or Impressionism. Also around this time, Whistler became enamored with the calm
night scenes along the River Thames. He preferred the peaceful atmosphere in the evening
over the hectic lifestyle during the day, so he began to paint what he called his Nocturne series,
loose tonal paintings that focused heavily on color, form, and line.
This series of paintings, as well as many of his other works, were named after musical terms,
feeling that painting had a lot more in common with tonal harmonies found in music.
The word Nocturne means night scene, and is the application style we're going to explore here.
Now, as mentioned, Whistler would sometimes spend the whole evening on the river, sketching
and absorbing the scene. He would then return to his studio and paint the piece based on his
drawings and from memory. Like Turner, his paintings started with very thin washes of color,
using what he called his sauce, a blend of mastic varnish, large amounts of turpentine,
and linseed oil. Unlike Turner, Whistler didn't wait for layers to dry. He would apply very thin,
translucent paint to still wet layers, wet in wet. There were no large sections of thick or
impasto paint like we saw with Turner. Small impasto effects were saved for the small features
and highlights. Whistler painted on both panel and canvas, and his Nocturnes began with a medium
or dark gray-toned ground in order to subdue his colors. He liked his paintings to be low-key,
meaning mostly middle to dark values. So, a medium to dark-toned ground would automatically
provide his paintings with the calm, mysterious feeling that he was after. To tone his ground,
Whistler either tinted it with pigment or applied a dark gray wash to the gesso and let it dry,
an imprimatura. After that, it's debated whether or not he sketched a brief underdrawing for his
Nocturnes. He definitely did it for his earlier portrait work, but whether or not he did, instead
of moving on to a monochromatic underpainting of some kind, he proceeded right into the formal
painting of the scene, the upper layers. He would first establish his darks by either brushing
on a mix of umber and black, or by leaving parts of the imprimatura exposed. Next, he applied a coat
of his sauce, applied with a large brush, scumbling over shadows, scraping, rubbing, and dragging the
paint. All went in wet, until he was satisfied with the appearance. Sometimes his oil paint was
so thin, he had to lay the canvas flat while it dried, so it wouldn't drip. And if you look closely
at this portrait, painted around the time of his Nocturnes, you can see where the paint actually
did drip down the canvas. Whistler liked to mix all of his paints on his palette before painting,
and these color mixes tended to be rather complex, almost all with some degree of black.
He liked his paints opaque, and those that were transparent were usually mixed together
with his opaques in order to lessen their transparency. Because he usually painted a la prima,
meaning in one sitting, he had a large collection of brushes, and was known to trim the bristles
of the brush if he needed a different shape. As mentioned, he often finished his paintings
with a few minor touches the following day, once the surface had dried enough,
and he always varnished. His finished work and new perspective became a central part of what
became known as the aesthetic movement, where artists painted for art's sake, not to represent
the visual world in its proper form. In the spirit of artistic expression, he would sometimes
decorate the frame to work with the painting, and he began signing his name with his initials,
arranging them to depict a butterfly. But this new way of thinking sometimes conflicted with
Victorian ideals. In fact, in 1877, a significant clash of these ideals took place. One that
captured the public's attention and became one of the most famous court cases in art history.
It began when John Ruskin, a renowned art critic of that time, was touring a new exhibition at the
Grosvenor Gallery in London. When he came upon Whistler's Nocturne painting, titled Nocturne in
Black and Gold, The Falling Rocket, Ruskin was taken back by the piece, and not in a good way.
He commented in his public newsletter that he felt the piece was equivalent to flinging a pot
of paint in the public's face. Incensed and heavily in debt, Whistler sued Ruskin for libel,
and won. Unfortunately, Whistler was only awarded one farthing for damages, equivalent to one
quarter of an American penny. Between his debts, legal fees, and loss of public interest due to
the bad publicity, Whistler soon after went bankrupt. But in 1879, he obtained a commission
to produce etchings in Venice, Italy, where he worked for over a year producing not only the
required etchings, but also over 90 pastel paintings or sketches. His work in pastels
would help reinvigorate the public's perspective on the medium in the latter part of the 19th
century. Slowly, his life and career were rebuilt. He continued to paint Nocturne-inspired landscapes
as well as portraits, often of children, in his thin application style until his death in 1903.
One of the reasons Whistler's artwork looks so technically fresh is that he was careful not to
overwork his paintings, even his portraits. He was willing to scrape off an entire day's work
if he felt it was beginning to look overworked, and then start from scratch at the next sitting.
Another artist known to do this was John Singer Sargent. In the early 1880s, James McNeill Whistler
cleaned out his studio at 31 Tite Street in the Chelsea neighborhood of London and relocated down
the street. Chelsea was a popular section of the city where painters, poets, and musicians lived
and worked. Oscar Wilde, for example, lived across the street. So perhaps it was no surprise when John
Singer Sargent himself moved into Whistler's prior flat and opened his London studio, a studio that
would host some of the most influential figures of that time. John Singer Sargent was the quintessential
international artist. I like how the Metropolitan Museum of Art describes him. Sargent was born of
American parents in Italy, learned to paint like a Spaniard in France, and lived in England for most
of his life. He was one of the most talented artists of the 19th and 20th centuries, and although
his heritage goes back to colonial America, as mentioned, he would make his career in Europe.
Sargent was born in Florence, Italy in 1856 while his parents were both on travel. They both
encouraged his pursuit of art, and seeing that he was a child prodigy saw to it that he had art
instruction as they traveled. But his real education began at the age of 18 when he studied
for five years under Carlos Duran, a young avant-garde painting instructor in Paris.
Duran encouraged his students to jump right into a painting, to utilize the thick quality of the
paint, to maintain freshness in their work, and to study the works of more painterly masters
such as Hals, Rembrandt, Van Dyck, and Velázquez. In fact, Duran's instruction was significantly
influenced by the works and processes used by Velázquez. Sargent too would adopt many of
these strategies and use them throughout his career. When asked about his painting methods,
Sargent was notorious for being vague in his explanations, feeling that it was simply a matter
natural process based on instinct and training. He never gave interviews and destroyed much of
his personal correspondence. But thanks to students who recorded some of his class instruction,
as well as today's technology, we can piece together his general working process in oil,
which he himself summarized in this single quote,
If you begin with the middle tone and work up from it towards the darks so that you deal last
with your lightest lights and darkest darks, you avoid false accents. Sargent usually painted on
canvas, and when preparing his surface, he often extended the canvas beyond his painting area
in order to enable him to make modifications during the painting process, and to reposition
the figure's position within the composition after the painting is finished, if desired.
He would then apply a medium or light gray toned priming layer with ivory black and lead white,
feeling that it contrasted nicely with the warm tones in his paintings.
Once the surface was prepared, he would sometimes sketch loose lines with charcoal,
and then wipe the surface with a rag to both soften the lines and to give the surface an
additional gray tone. Now when he was preparing his paints for a painting session, he would load
up his palette with plenty of paint. He was not sparing. A student describing it as enough paint
for three paintings. The first layer of paint was usually brushed on with broad strokes using a
large stiff bristle brush. His objective was to establish the primary shapes, using mid-tones
first. This, he felt, would help him better judge the remaining values. He applied the paint directly,
overlapping the edges, and blending on all sides, creating a kind of tonal underpainting.
Sargent felt that this layer, the painting's understructure, had to be right. If the mid-tones
and the initial shapes were not right, it was best to start again, especially when establishing the
shape of a head for a portrait. In the case of his painting Mrs. Hugh Hammersley, he repainted the
head's understructure at least 16 times. Once the mid-tones were established, Sargent would add his
defining layers of paint. He would paint on his shadows, the darks, followed by his lights,
and darkest darks, all wet-in-wet when possible. He often thinned his darks with oil and turpentine,
but much of his paint, generally speaking, was straight from the tube, using the fewest
strokes possible and establishing the exact color and value in the piece. He thought through every
stroke. Finally, he applied his finishing touches. His student, Julie Heinemann, explains his process.
Till almost the end, there had been no features, no accents, simply a solid shape growing out of
and into the background with which it was won. When at last he did put them, each accent was
studied with an intensity that kept his brush poised in mid-air, till eye and hand had studied
to one purpose, and then, bling! The stroke resounded almost like a note of music. In addition to his
confident bravura brushwork, he was very conscious of where to blur the edges and where to establish
hard lines in order to draw the viewer's eye. And when painting a figure, in order to avoid
visual bias, meaning misjudgments due to an individual's unique vision, he would sometimes
hold a plumb line in his left hand in order to help him better judge angles. Sargent was a tall man,
over six feet in height, and very sturdy. He was publicly shy, but intimately social, with a love
for food, cigars, and beauty. He was known for talking while he painted, and was said to be in
almost constant motion, including backing up nearly twelve paces periodically to evaluate his work.
When ready, he would lunge forward and place the stroke, always deliberate. Like Whistler, if he
pleased with how things were going, he would wipe everything off and start again. Changes were
sometimes made very late in the painting process as well, if he became dissatisfied with how things
were progressing. He's said to have destroyed a painting after working on it for twelve sittings,
but he brought the new version to completion in six. And corrections didn't always end when the
was officially completed. In fact, like Turner, he was known to make corrections even when a
painting was sitting in its frame. An example of this concerns one of his best known paintings,
and an incident that nearly ruined his career. In 1883, Sargent painted a portrait of a society
woman with her right dress strap falling off her shoulder. When the painting exhibited at
the 1884 Paris Salon, it triggered public outrage, being seen as obscene and ruining the sitter's
reputation. One critic even writing that, quote, this portrait is simply offensive in its insolent
ugliness and defiance of every rule of art. The woman, the sitter, was so embarrassed by the
shock and negative response that she asked for the painting to be removed.
Instead, Sargent repainted the strap, as we see it today, after the exhibit, and kept the painting
for himself. The incident caused a severe drop in clientele, to the point where, in 1886,
he decided to move to London. England would remain his home for the rest of his life.
Slowly, he was able to rebuild his career. But it wasn't the British that helped restart his career.
It was the Americans. On a visit to his home country to fulfill a commission in 1887,
his reputation began to grow. And by the time he returned to the States in 1890, he had received
a large number of high-end commissions, completing 40 portraits within nine months.
This led to the commission for the portrait of Mrs. Hammersley. She was an influential woman
of society, and helped restore his reputation both in London and in Paris. The public was finally
able to get past the scandal. The backing of the Americans, and the commissions he received at a
time when he was vulnerable, could explain why he rejected the honor of knighthood from British
royalty. He wasn't willing to renounce his American citizenship. In 1907, the same year
he turned down the knighthood, he drifted away from painting portraits. Apparently, he had burned
out, and is even quoted as saying, no more portraits. I abhor and abjure them. Ask me to
paint your gates, your fences, your barns, which I should gladly do, but not the human face.
Instead, he turned to the immediacy and the transparency of watercolor painting,
in addition to oil, traveling and painting a variety of genre. Italy, and Venice in particular,
always held a special interest for him. Early in his career, you can see his interest in people,
painting Venetian alleyways and interiors. After giving up portraiture, he focused more on
scenic landscapes and architecture. Interestingly, he was also an accomplished pianist.
John Singer Sargent died in his sleep in 1925. He and Whistler rejected the academic method
of painting, in favor of styles that allowed them greater freedom of expression. But it's
important to note that Sargent felt that any painting method could bring the painter to a
beautiful completion. In other words, there are many roads to roam. A perfect example of that can
be seen in the work of William Adolph Bouguereau, a contemporary of Sargent and Whistler's, who chose
the academic method of painting to achieve equally magnificent results. William Bouguereau is often
considered the quintessential academic painter, and was one of the most successful artists of
his time, producing stunningly realistic paintings, and building a reputation for his unique neoclassical
style that appealed to a vast number of patrons, including Emperor Napoleon III of France.
Around the time of the French Revolution in the early 1800s, there was a renewed interest in
and curiosity about the methods of the earliest masters. Members of art academies wanted to return
to the smooth enamel-like painting surface of old, and this led to what is sometimes referred to
as the academic method of applying oil paint. French academies eventually developed a process
that mimicked the highly finished results produced by Van Eyck and others. In fact, they promoted
this method as having discovered the old masters' secrets. One thing that made Bouguereau stand out
is that while many leading artists of his time were leaning towards a looser form of realism,
capturing everyday life of the common man, he was portraying the ideal, the beauty of the human form
in its perfection. And to me, he stands out from fellow neoclassical painters in that his figures
feel alive, gentle. It's been described as flowing and graceful, sculptural.
His style was in utter contrast to an up-and-coming movement of that time,
Impressionism. He could never quite grasp it, and is quoted as saying,
As for the Impressionists, the Pointillists, etc., I cannot discuss them. I do not see the way they
see or claim to see. William Bouguereau was born in 1825 to a wine and olive merchant in the town
of La Rochelle along the southwestern coast of France. In his youth, he was sent to live with
an uncle, a Catholic priest, in order to obtain an education. It was here that he began his initial
training in art. At 17, he was called home and expected to take over the family business,
but his heart was in painting. Eventually, his uncle helped him earn extra money through local
portrait commissions, which enabled him, at age 20, to move to Paris, where he would study painting
formally under the respected neoclassical artist Francois Picot. While in Paris, he won a much
sought-after French scholarship, enabling him to study the techniques of the masters in Rome for
three years, to include one of his favorites, Raphael. Upon his return to France, his career
would take off and not let up throughout the rest of his life. Bouguereau is described as a kind man,
of good constitution, and with a happy demeanor. He was a family man, with a wife and five children,
until tragedy struck. In 1875, his 16-year-old son died, his grief inspiring two religious-themed
paintings. Then, in 1877, he lost his wife and the child she gave birth to. Grief-stricken, he poured
himself into his work, and in time, he fell in love with one of his students, American artist Elizabeth
Jane Gardner, who was nearly an equal in artistic talent and expression. She would eventually become
his second wife. William Bouguereau's typical painting process began on canvas, his preferred
surface. He would cover the fabric with a layer of glue sizing, after which he would apply two to
three layers of warm, gray-toned ground, allowing much of the texture of the canvas to remain, so
that the paint would have more grip. After the ground, it's said that he applied a layer of
varnish in order to seal the gesso and create a less absorbent painting surface. In creating the
painting image itself, Bouguereau engaged in an intense level of preparation. It's reminiscent of
the process used by Jan van Eyck, and that's appropriate, as the academic method drew on the
methods used by artists of van Eyck's era. Bouguereau developed each painting composition through a
multitude of sketches. He's said to have sketched constantly. Initially, he worked through his ideas
through thumbnail or loose sketches. Then, once the composition was solidified, he produced small
oil sketches or color sketches to work out the color scheme. When satisfied, he would then create
a formal, life-size drawing using vine charcoal on heavyweight toned paper. This would be his primary
design, and it was carefully executed. The drawing, called a cartoon, was then transferred onto the
canvas using some sort of pressure method, perhaps a form of transfer paper or stylus indentation.
Once the lines were traced onto the canvas, Bouguereau inked over the lines and then sealed
everything with a layer of varnish. Again, much like van Eyck. His advice to students?
Remember that everything must be thought out beforehand. Everything, down to the last details.
Once the cartoon was sealed, Bouguereau is believed to have applied a thin semi-opaque
neutral scumble to loosely establish his forms. Once that dried, he would proceed into the formal
painting layers, where he's said to have built up his forms through the modeling of thicker wet paint.
A base tone applied with broad strokes and a lighter tone modeled into it.
Modeling refers to the use of color and value change to create form. Unlike van Eyck's method,
using transparency to allow some of the base layer to show through, Bouguereau's initial
layers were opaque and were meant to completely cover the underpainting and drawing. Once those
layers were complete, a student reports that he would stop to smooth the paint with his palette
knife, going over the entire painting and removing paint as needed. He also used a knife to scumble
parts of the landscape in his backgrounds, in addition to direct painting. Bouguereau worked
quickly and with ease, likely due to his level of preparation. An observer commenting that the
speed at which he painted was beyond anything he'd ever seen. He used a small palette, usually sat on
a stool to paint, and had a multitude of brushes close at hand. He selected from a large number of
paint colors as well, and worked mostly with tube paint, grinding fresh paint only on occasion.
The next layer involved glazing and direct painting. He typically glazed the darker areas
of his painting, the backgrounds and the fabrics, but there also appeared to be areas of glaze in
his skin tones for additional color change and form development. To thin his paint, Bouguereau
was known to use various amounts of turpentine, nut oil, and varnish, according to the color being
used. He's said to have mixed some combination of medium and varnish into all of his paints,
in order to increase brilliance and transparency, and to help it dry faster. Unfortunately,
the addition of varnish would end up decreasing the durability of the paint layer,
and increase the likelihood of future cracking. His lightest lights are painted using opaque whites.
In fact, his lights seem to increase in opacity as they lighten in value. Apparently,
according to one of his students, Bouguereau could complete a life-size figure painting in
eight days or less. He worked on three to four paintings at a time, in order to fill his long
eight to ten hour work days. In the end, he finished over 700 paintings, a huge accomplishment
when you see his level of detail and perfection. He was known to be a perfectionist.
His accomplishment, in his words, is due to hard work. Quote,
I produce a lot because I work all day long, without any breaks. It is the only way, in fact,
of achieving good work. William Bouguereau was extremely successful in his lifetime.
Being in high demand for commissions, winning almost every award and accolade available,
and holding several important leadership positions in French art societies.
His popularity spanned Europe and even into America. But his reputation dropped off after
his death in 1905 due to the popularity of the avant-garde art styles. As remarkable as his
talent was, he wouldn't regain full recognition again until late in the 20th century. Unknown to
many, Bouguereau not only painted idealized scenes of children and peasants, he also volunteered
throughout his life to help the needy. Something else that makes him stand out was his openness to
teach women. One of his teaching positions was at the Académie Julienne in Paris, where for decades
he enjoyed mentoring up-and-coming female painters, including Cecilia Beaux, something society was
still adjusting to at the time. No artist is without their critics, and Bouguereau was no
exception, especially from those who favored the avant-garde. But unlike Whistler and Sargent,
he never really let it get to him. He just continued to paint in pursuit of beauty.
Throughout this series, we've looked at some of the most famous and most talented artists in
history, examining each of them from the perspective of how they built up their paint layers,
and tracing the progression through history. Knowing a little bit more about how they built
their paintings takes some of the mystery out of what they did, and at the same time gives us a
deeper appreciation for the methods they applied to achieve their specific look.