Ranking Member Mary Gay Scanlon delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Dec 4, 2025
Hearing: Balancing the Federal Budget: Examining Proposals for a Balanced Budget Amendment
Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to
our witnesses for testifying today. It's
an interesting topic and one that has
certainly at least superficial appeal,
but the devil, as always, is in the
details. The decisions that Congress
makes about the economy, about taxes,
spending, and budgets are or should be
decisions about our values, who we're
fighting for, what kind of country we
are or want to be, and the future we're
trying to create for our children. Which
brings us to the topic of today's
hearing, a balanced budget
constitutional amendment, which at least
in the proposals we've seen so far,
seems to be a misguided proposal about
how to address the often competing
values and interests that have to be
taken into account when crafting our
national budget. We all share the goal
of developing smart, efficient fiscal
policies and budgets. But for decades,
Republican presidents and members of
Congress have talked a big game about
fiscal responsibility while enacting
policies that have exploded the federal
deficit and the national debt. It wasn't
that long ago, not generations as the
chair suggested, but only about 25 years
when under the Clinton administration,
the US had a balanced budget for
multiple years, fueled in part by a
combination of tax increases, spending
cuts, and reduced military spending. But
since then, in the early 2000s, and
again during the first Trump
administration, Republicans have handed
the ultra-wealthy huge tax breaks,
eroding the federal government's revenue
base and threatening our ability to fund
essential programs that Americans rely
upon. Time and again, these policies
have failed to produce the broader
benefits for all Americans that the
advocates of trickle down economics have
promised. and instead these Republican
policies have exploded the deficit,
adding 10 trillion to the national debt.
Despite this, this summer, Republicans
once again doubled down, permanently
extending the Trump tax giveaways from
his first administration, extending
those giveaways to the wealthy in their
one big ugly bill, further expanding the
deficit, and ballooning the national
debt, as was just noted. Now, after
voting for that policy, our Republican
colleagues are making a show of caring
about fiscal responsibility. But don't
be fooled. Today's hearing is part of a
decadesl long orchestrated political
effort to help corporations and the
wealthiest people avoid paying their
fair share. It's based on a theory that
tries to convince people that reckless
tax giveaways to the ultra wealthy
somehow stimulate investment and
economic growth for everyone for the
greater good. But that's a lie that's
been debunked again and again and again
for more than 50 years now and one
that's led to skyigh income inequality
and the enshrinement of a corporate
oligarchy in our society. These tax
policies, these giveaways have fueled
the greatest re rise in income
inequality that our country has known at
least since uh the robber baron days,
resulting in a continuing transfer of
wealth from working and middle class
Americans to the wealthiest among us.
And we need look no further than the
fact that the top 1% in our country pay
a lower tax rate than all other
Americans. This pathological dedication
to trickle down economics is outrageous.
It betrays the values this country
should stand for and which our budget
should reflect. If we want to shrink the
deficit and lower the nation's debt, we
should be talking about a tax policy
that gives relief to working families
and makes the rich and corporations pay
their fair share rather than allowing
them to reap even more profits by
imposing the costs of their business on
the American people. Whether by paying
substandard wages that force workers to
rely on food stamps or subsidized health
care to survive or that force Americans
to pick up the costs of industrial
waste, dangerous products, or unsafe
working conditions. A tax policy that
makes sure that everyone pays their fair
share isn't a radical idea and should be
the starting point of any serious
discussion about bringing the two sides
of the budget equation. taxes and
revenue on the one hand, spending,
including military spending, on the
other, but it takes a different kind of
politics than what we're hearing today.
One that believes that the purpose of
government is to serve all Americans,
not just the wealthy and well-connected.
And the programs that our Republican
colleagues have been only too ready to
slash in their big ugly bill and with
the political scam of a balanced budget
amendment they're that they're pushing
here. the these programs are critical to
the health and well-being of the
American people. The majority of our
yearly spending is mandatory. That is
funds not subject to congressional
appropriation and which must be paid,
including Medicare, Medicaid, Social
Security, veterans benefits, retirement
programs for military service members
and uh retired federal employees. These
are vital programs that help our
government keep its promises to the
American people. Less than half our
budget goes to discretionary spending,
which is spending that Congress
appropriates every year, and half of
that money goes to defense spending. We
can make sure our national debts on a
sustainable path by investing wisely in
the American people and taxing fairly.
We can work to build an economy that
grows from the middle out, not the top
down. We can provide affordable
healthcare and child care, affordable
housing, and make sure that every child
gets a worldclass public education. But
that's not the focus of today's hearing.
Instead, the solution to the deficit
problem they helped create is to propose
constitutional amendments that force
Congress to balance the budget on the
backs of working and middle class
families, forcing cuts to essential
benefits like Medicare and Social
Security. House Republicans have
introduced at least six different
proposed balanced budget amendments.
Though they don't all share the same
features, they have the same common goal
to continue to put their thumb on the
scale to favor big business and
billionaires over working and middle
class people, seniors, and our most
vulnerable Americans. A balanced budget
amendment would shackle Congress and
limit our flexibility to respond to
changing economic conditions or crises
with appropriate fiscal and budgetary
policies. As the chair mentioned, many
of these proposals would require a
supermajority in Congress to raise
revenue or raise the debt limit, but not
to cut spending. The framers of our
Constitution rejected the principle of
requiring a supermajority for basic
government functions because they
believed it would shift power away from
the American people's popular will to a
determined minority. balanced budget
proposals requiring a supermajority
would allow an extremist minority to
hold our nation's economy and financial
stability hostage. And you only need to
look at the chaos of the current
Republican majority in the House to see
what might be in store under such a
proposed amendment. We've seen political
brinksmanship over the debt ceiling and
government funding. We've seen speakers
dethroned and federal budgets that slash
health care and food assistance for
Americans while giving more handouts to
billionaires and big business. A
balanced budget amendment would only
make things worse and this dysfunction
would then be baked into our
constitution and democracy. I don't
think that's what the American people
want or need. The bottom line is we
don't need to amend the constitution to
balance the f federal budget. Our
colleagues need to get their heads out
of the sand and be willing to look at
the revenue side of the equation. During
the 90s, under a Democratic president,
and a Republican controlled Congress,
the federal government ran budget
surpluses without a balanced budget
amendment. Our Republican colleagues
control the House, the Senate, and the
White House. If they wanted to do this,
they could. But instead, they've chosen
to make their number one legislative
priority this year a trillion dollar
handout to their billionaire buddies.
Our budget is not just numbers on a
spreadsheet. It's the choices we make to
invest in our neighbors, our
communities, to provide opportunities
for young people, to take care of the
elderly and the most vulnerable, and to
invest in American prosperity. If we
really want a prosperous economy where
everyone can get ahead, we need to
abandon the misguided orthodoxy of
trickle down economics. Instead, we need
to focus on policies that support
children, family, communities, and our
wider economy. We don't need a balanced
budget. We just need Congress to do the
job the American people sent us to do.
Thank you, Mr. chairman and I yield
back.
