American trying British Pub Food (Nicholson's Pub)

English Cuisine
7 followers
Today we're here in the heart of Cincinnati and we're right in front of Nicholson's Pub.
This place is supposedly supposed to bring a taste of the UK to the Midwest. Serving up scotch eggs,
pouring pints, and promising an authentic British experience. Will this place stand up to the true
test of being authentic or is it just another American take? I will say they're starting off
very nicely but my folks in England are not going to be very happy because we have a Scottish flag
we have a Welsh flag and then we have a Union Jack. Savannah what are we missing?
We're missing the English flag. I'm sorry I think this is a Scottish place though
do with that as you will but let's go try out their food.
We have the scotch egg in front of us here. I want to point out the egg yolk is runnier than we've
had in the past in the U.S. A nice beautiful sausage encasing. Now I paid $11 for one scotch
egg but they've got some mustard here on the side so let's go ahead and jump into it here
and try her out. Give a dip of some mustard.
That's very yummy. That is the closest to one that I've had in the UK here in the U.S. I'm not sure
what this green ---- is here. It's foreign on a scotch egg plate but scotch egg is good. I'm gonna
give that a 9.1 out of 10. Something I'm very excited about. Bangers and mash and they have a
onion gravy on there. Mashed potatoes. I'm gonna get a complaint from my British folks about
potato skins being mixed in there but let's give them props where props are due. That is a proper
sausage. This is not that hunky-dory Mickey Mouse they give me at the other places where
it's American breakfast sausage wrapped up in something else. This looks like a real British
sausage. So the only one way to find out it's good. It's different spicing than American sausage
for sure. Let's try a little gravy and potatoes. That's good. Very good onion gravy and the
potatoes do have good flavor with them. That has been the most authentic bangers and mash I've had
on this side of the pond. For flavor profile and rating I'm gonna give it an 8.7 but this is the
shepherd's pie here. A giant salad here on the side but I'm more interested in what this is.
Now on the menu it reads that they have lamb and a beef mince mixture in their shepherd's pie.
Oh man we found lamb. We found lamb ladies and gentlemen at a restaurant naming it shepherd's pie
and actually putting lamb inside. That is incredible. They have parmesan on top which I have never seen
that like that but I put cheese on top of my cottage pie that I made so to each their own.
It's hearty. The stew is lacking a little bit in flavor but I'm so giddy that they actually have
lamb in this. I'm gonna give that an 8.2. The mash is the same as the bangers and mash made the same way.
It has a creamy inside a little bit of texture on the outside. Not bad. The most authentic shepherd's
pie I've had in the U.S. so far because they actually use lamb. Now the final thing that we
got here because we're testing this everywhere we go. I just got shot in the face with a shot of lemon.
Is it filming? Is this thing on? Are you filming? Yeah. Oh all right guys to wrap this meal up we have
fish and chips. Now I will say it doesn't look like any UK fish I've ever had. I'm not excited
for the breading. This is looking like panko crumbs which again there's nothing wrong with it
but this is the only thing that's really been off the mark. Super off yeah. In terms of authenticity
it's not the best tasting meal I've ever had for UK food standards. Those are also smaller pieces
of fish. This is this is probably one. Over there they say that's a fish finger. Yeah this this should
be one piece. Yeah. Right here and you should get a little bit more. We're used to that from a chippy
but hey beggars can't be choosers here in Squincinati. But we're gonna take our malt vinegar
here give her a little ooh yeah. A little razzle dazzle. A little ooh yeah on those chips. Now I will say
they call them fries on the menu but we're getting closer to a chip. Closer. Closer. It's a lot
thicker. Closer. We're getting closer to a chip. There we go. But we got that on there. Don't put
oh don't put it on both pieces. Just a wee bit. No. Just just a wee bit. I don't like that. Here we go.
It sounded like it had a crunch.
Oh no. I want to say it's had it. Do you not like it? It's okay. You don't look like you're. The
breading. Yeah. Kind of turned me off. Right we kind of got back to the bedroom. Things got a
little heavy. Started pulling stuff out of the drawers. Just wasn't what I thought it was going
to be. Okay. It's got a nice crunch to it but it's panko crumbs. The more I eat it the worse it gets.
I'm gonna give this like a 5.3. It's just not great. The tartar sauce is nice. The chips are
okay even though they're still kind of fries. But the panko crumbs and the fish is just very dense.
It seems like it's been frozen a while. I'm not a fan. If you serve this to someone in the UK
there'd probably be a fight. All right everybody we're gonna try the shepherd's pie first. I
don't think I've had lamb since we've been in the UK actually. What about you Juanny? Nope.
I don't like the parmesan on there. Yeah parmesan is not the right cheese.
No. I do like having the you know the lamb flavor and it not being just beef.
But I agree with you that this feels like lacking flavor. It's just kind of salty.
I'm gonna give it a 7 out of 10. It's okay. Not my favorite. But it is authentic. But it is
minus the parmesan. Somewhat kind of authentic. Listen we got lamb in there. That's a big plus.
I don't like these. I will not be trying that because I don't want to try it when I know I
don't like that. That feels unfair to me. All right now we have the bangers and mash. I am
not sure why this table is so high up. I feel like I'm having to like raise my arms to eat but
this looks great.
What kind of sausage is that? I don't know. It's definitely not American though.
Is it like pork though? Oh yeah pork sausage. Yeah pretty good. Pretty good. And again
the mash has potato skins in it which I'm not a fan of but I feel like it's just it's a little
lazy I call it because you can just peel those extra bits off make it nice and creamy. Some
people like the texture in there. I personally just want it to be all creamy. This does have
a pretty good flavor though. Some people don't season their mashed potatoes and it's bland but
this is pretty good. I'm gonna give all of this
an eight. Solid eight. All right moving on to the fish and chips. Will you slide it over?
All right the final thing for you to try is fish and chips. Fish and chips and I will not be using
a knife and fork. You can get mad at me if you want to. Okay. I don't like the breading.
Why is the fish so like dense? Yes. Probably because it was frozen for a while.
No. No more of that. No no no. These are better. I just why go to all the effort
of clearly like they've done their research of making everything else
pretty similar to what you get in the UK and then you bread your fish in panko crumbs.
Like you were doing so good. What what is this? What did I know? That's gonna give like a five.
Wow. Savannah's going after him. It's not gross. Like if I was getting this and it was like not
supposed to be like from the UK. Okay it's decent. Still not my favorite fish and chips but
I don't think you could find one piece of fish in the UK that looks like this.
