Daniel Lacalle, Ph.D, Chief Economist at Tressis Hedge Fund, offers his analysis to NTD on tariff income. He says reducing, or even eliminating, income taxes for lower tax brackets is within the realm of possibility. It might not be possible for all income levels, but the move would help stimulate the economy. -- 📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
President Trump said the United States
could eliminate income taxes over the
next couple of years due to tariff
revenue. Joining us to discuss is Daniel
Lay, chief economist at Tresis,
international financial analyst and
author of the book Freedom or Equality.
So Daniel, good to see you. Um, what is
your view on the likelihood and
feasibility as well of tariff revenue
completely replacing income taxes?
>> Hi Don. Well, obviously completely
replacing income taxes very difficult.
Income tax receipts uh go up to $2.4
trillion. Uh the latest figures that we
have from tariffs account for uh
revenues of about 24 billion a month. So
that would be uh a little bit more than
300 billion in a year if everything
remains the same. I think that what
President Trump is trying to convey is
the following is that there could be a
substantial reduction of income taxes
particularly for the lower end of the
income tax bracket. Uh that could even
end up eliminating the income tax for
the lower range. But eliminating
entirely the income tax seems very very
difficult. uh certainly from a revenue
standpoint there is another way of doing
it obviously which is by reducing
dramatically government spending but we
also must acknowledge that it's quite
unlikely that any administration is able
to reduce government spending by the
equivalent of two 2.4 4 trillion because
it would include a very very significant
part or actually almost more than half
of uh mandatory spending. Therefore, I
think that what President Trump is
actually looking at is probably
eliminating the lower end of the income
tax bracket entirely and that actually
could be feasible.
>> Okay. So Daniel whether we're talking
about eliminating it completely or
partially I mean in principle the plan
could stimulate economic growth right by
reducing the tax burden on workers
in any shape or form uh any measure that
we have discussed actually a couple of
times like for example uh reducing tax
even providing a check from the
extraordinary revenues coming from
tariffs etc. any of those measures are
going to be positive for consumption for
economic growth and for uh and for the
improvement of the manufacturing and the
services sector within the United States
through domestic demand. Any of those
measures will be positive. But we also
have to acknowledge that the first thing
that the United States needs to do is to
rein in the enormous fiscal burden that
has been inherited from the Biden
administration with a deficit that
stands close to the two trillion figure.
The the first and foremost policy needs
to be eliminating or certainly bringing
that deficit to the lowest level
possible.
Okay, Daniel, could you just address
some concerns out there on this plan?
Um, for example, hypothetically
speaking, if the US were to impose uh
$2.4 trillion of tariffs uh a year, what
would be the impact on trade and the
economy?
>> Well, certainly 2.4 4 trillion in
tariffs is a phenomenal figure and uh it
looks almost impossible to achieve if
you look at it from the figures of
imports into the United States. But
let's assume that it would happen. Let's
assume $2.4 trillion of tariffs from
abroad. It would definitely reduce
international trade with the with the
United States. Absolutely. because let's
let's assume that that the entirety of
those tariffs are absorbed by the
producers abroad. Even if that were the
case, it's going to make it very very
difficult for those producers to uh go
to the US market in the shape and form
that we see it today. So, uh in essence,
it would it would certainly have a very
very dramatic impact on international
trade. uh it would certainly also create
the desire from other governments of
imposing very aggressive tariffs against
the United States uh if it's as
successful as to uh reach the levels of
revenues that make it possible to
eliminate such uh an incredibly
receipt heavy uh tax as the income tax.
No. So I don't know it's it's very very
very challenging to think that something
of this magnitude can happen. I think
that the the opportunities are are that
are more feasible are in a reduction in
taxes for the for the US citizens maybe
even uh the possibility of a check if
the revenues are exceptional. And
certainly now that the waters of trade
agreements have settled and we know that
next year there's going to be a
significant level of growth in
international trade and there will be
very very low implications of these
tariffs on inflation. Then at least what
we know right now is that there could be
revenue positive and growth positive
measures uh that may not entirely
eliminate the uh income tax but would
certainly improve the domestic economy.
Uh a 2.4 trillion of t of of tariff
revenues seems to be in any in any shape
and form almost impossible.
Okay, let let's say we get a partial
reduction in income taxes through
tariffs. The question still remains
though, are tariffs a sustainable
revenue source for a country?
>> Well, if it continues to be a growth
economy that uh the rest of the world
wants to sell to, absolutely they are.
In fact, if you look at China, if you
look at Brazil, if you look at the
European Union, we talk a lot about
tariffs in the United States, but we
don't talk about the tariffs and
non-tariff barriers that these economies
continue to implement. And it seems that
nobody is creating a big fuss about it
all. So uh are they uh a measure that is
leveling the playing field in trade and
that at the same time is strengthening
international trade and improving the
situation for United States companies
with non-inflationary effects? Yes. Are
they a magic wand that can generate
perpetual revenues forever and
increasing those revenues? Not
necessarily. So I think that we need to
be balanced. I think that the measures
that have been implemented this years
have proven to be positive for the
economy. The economy is growing at a 4%
annualized rate according to the Atlanta
uh Federal Reserve. They have not
created inflationary pressures. The
latest estimates from Bloomberg
economics show that inflation in the
next month is going to be at the same
level as it was in August and lower than
in September and October last year. And
at the same time we are seeing that it's
gen generating significant revenues and
that the deficit is being reduced then
there are a lot of positive elements.
What we need to see is the effect in
2026 and 2027. If as I expect the
deficit of the United States is going to
drop down significantly in terms of GDP
and also in terms of in absolute terms
and at the same time we're going to get
a stronger economic growth, more
manufacturing and a better service
economy. All those elements then are
likely to generate a a positive outcome
and I think that that is undeniable
right now.
>> Yeah, I mean those are all positive
outcomes. Um Daniel, maybe you can just
address one more concern here. Uh and
that is do you think announcing tariffs
will fund US government operations? Um
sort of leave a bad taste in other
count's mouths because uh I believe you
said before other countries pay for
these tariffs. So would tariff targeted
nations think um the US is basically
exporting its tax burden onto them?
Uh it's a great question but ultimately
if you think about it that's what all
governments do don't they? Uh when they
are imposing CO2 taxes on US companies
when they're imposing uh the different
regulatory taxation and tariff and
non-tariff barriers on US companies.
they are doing it and saying to their
citizens in their countries that they're
doing it to fund uh policies and
programs in that country. No. So uh yes
absolutely uh taxation and uh and trade
uh measures are all uh taken to uh to to
to try to improve the situation or to
try to pay for programs in the country.
But that is not only in the United
States is also in other countries. What
you're absolutely right is that there is
a completely biased narrative all over
the world in which it seems that the
only country in the world that puts
tariffs is the United States which is
false and it seems that the only country
in the world that wants to pay for uh an
improvement in the conditions for their
own citizens is the United States. when
China, when the European Union, when
India themselves are actually doing
exactly that, using the trade tariff and
taxation barriers to fund programs or uh
supporting local industries.
>> Very good points there, Daniel. Thank
you for speaking with us today.
>> Thank you very much, Don. Have a good
day.