Landscape Photography Daily Critique #1.mp4

The Landscape Lens
1 follower
1 Video View·Dec 2, 2025
This is the first video of a Landscape Photography Daily Critique that I will run throughout December sponsored by Kase filters. The aim is to provide photographers with feedback on their images and also create short (ish) videos for other photographers to learn from.
These images were submitted by Rob Henderson. Thank you Rob!
If you would like to take part then there are a few slots for the end of the month. Please send 3-5 images with both your edited images and original RAWs via WeTransfer to alex(At)alexnail.com. You should include a short text file with your name (unless you want to be anonymous) and anything you are struggling with.
This series was kindly sponsored by Kase Filters.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Hello everybody and welcome to a brand new series of daily critiques where each day
throughout December I will be discussing two or three images from the same photographer
discussing some of their strengths as well as some of the things that I would have done
differently and all of this is highly subjective so you may disagree but hopefully this will be
a useful learning aid no matter what level of photography you are at or at least give a
different perspective that you might be able to apply to your own images and we do have different
levels of photography represented in the images that have been submitted so far so hopefully
there'll be something here for everyone and if you would like to take part there's still about
10 slots left so there are details below this video telling you how to submit your images
but I'm hoping to keep these videos short so I don't want to give too long a preamble here we're
going to try to keep them below 15 minutes if we can and we're going to start with two images by
Rob Henderson who is a young photographer I think he's about 21 who I've hiked with a couple of
times before he's a very talented guy so we're starting this at a fairly high level but two
beautiful images to start off with and without saying any more let's get started. Okay so we've
got two images from Rob here that we're going to discuss starting with this photograph from
Torridon a beautiful central balanced composition for me the focal point is the relationship between
this lochen nestled in the mountain Benjerrig here and this peak which is one of the Munros on
Liege so there's a lovely symmetry to those two subjects that is echoed in the wider backdrop with
this rainbow somewhat mirroring the downslope of the mountain itself so it has this lovely
central enclosed feeling that I think balances absolutely beautifully and I can imagine that
with this rainbow appearing that Rob might have been a little bit hurried in trying to frame a
composition here and he's done an absolutely fantastic job with the background but maybe
the foreground doesn't quite work as well as it might in an ideal world which of course is a silly
thing to discuss because you're never going to quite get an ideal foreground but what this
foreground does do is add a real sense of depth and place and we're going to see that in the next
image actually but I do think that including foregrounds can really add an extra dimension
to your images as well as making them feel more personal it's just that in this case the backdrop
has such lovely qualities that I feel like the foreground competes with it a little bit too much
particularly with these very horizontal lines in the rocks in the foreground here in this sandstone
and also in the contrast that comes from having the foreground sunlit like this and that's even
more of a problem with this white lichen which you have to say is a real issue when photographing
these mountains I've had a few battles with this white stuff in the past particularly when it's
sunlit so we are going to have a little bit of an edit to see if we can help that to be less of a
problem in the image but broadly speaking I think if I were to try to approach this composition
myself and I had the luxury of time I perhaps would have had less foreground and more background
if I couldn't find anything better than what Rob has found here another very minor point is that
the sky is maybe slightly unbalanced by the fact that there's a lot of contrast in this
right hand side and particularly with this highlight in the cloud so that's another area
that draws my eye a little bit and that's what we're going to tackle in the edit so here is
Rob's original file and you can see these water drops on the right I think he was right to crop
in anyway so he may not have bothered to clean his lens when he took this photo because he probably
knew he was going to crop to 4x5 which I certainly think was the right choice and I have had a quick
go at editing this myself and I don't want this series to become how to edit a photo so I'm not
going to be discussing a lot of the edits that I do at all because I want the thought processes
to come through so we're going to try to tackle some of these local issues that I mentioned
rather than talk about general editing practice in this case so we're going to start by just
darkening down the sky a little bit more with a soft gradient just to bring it a little bit closer
to Rob's very accomplished edit and you can see we still have this problem with the cloud on the
right and actually I want to add a bit of contrast to the sky to bring in the drama of these kind of
sunshine and shower skyscapes which are very dramatic and then we just need to hold back that
highlight locally so we can just select a large brush here and paint over that little highlight
and just knock it back ever so slightly just so that it doesn't draw the eye so no major change
there but just tweaking that sky to be more to my liking and incidentally as I look at this I think
the contrast that Rob has applied to the mid-ground is a little bit better so I probably go in and
mask that top portion of the image to add a bit more contrast but in this case what I really want
to show you is just how to improve the state of this lichen in the foreground here and we're going
to do that by reducing contrast and darkening exposure and when I'm making local adjustments
I tend to like to paint them very loosely rather than using really targeted selections which tend
to create artifacts particularly if you're producing large prints so I'm choosing a soft
edged brush here and I'm just going to loosely paint over the areas that have these very bright
highlights but especially this lichen on the rock and what we're going to try to do is make an edit
that darkens the lichen but not the rock or at least not in a way that is obvious and I'm going
to do that by reducing the contrast which you can see actually brightens the rock surrounding
the lichen hopefully you can see that and that's actually going to allow us to darken the lichen
a bit more without changing the tone of the rock and that just knocks back the brightness of that
area and you can even go a bit further because we're only going to notice the darkening of the
rock if it's fairly significant and I think you can go this far without it being a problem and
that really helps to knock the area back if you want to soften it a little bit and reduce the
amount of contrast then clarity can be a really nice tool again just to take away some of that
high contrast detail so that's the before there and sorry that's the before and that's the after
so you can see that really helps to reduce those distractions and that's a great technique if you
photograph these mountains yourself it's one that I do use just to to prevent these areas from
becoming big problems in an image so on to the second photo I should say excellent image this
Rob I wish I'd taken it myself not least because it's on Ben Jerrig which is an incredibly hard
mountain to get up so congratulations on a fantastic photo here and even more so on this second image
from the Mammaws in Western Scotland I love this foreground it's complicated it's a little bit
messy it's a little bit jarring against that background but for me all the more interesting
because of those qualities it really does show the the nature of the ground that you're stood on
and it's a beautiful composition albeit with compromises such as these rather large areas of
particularly this one at the base of the frame in shadow it's a shame that that's not a bit more
dynamic but you can't have everything and I can understand including it to bring this rock into
frame and this lovely pyramidal shape which of course echoes the shape of the mountain in the
middle of the frame and again this relationship between the mountain and the lock and so there's
actually some real similarities between these two images despite their disparate locations
I imagine this is taken at sunrise from the lighting direction but also from the cloud
inversion which do tend to be more common at sunrise at least in the UK I don't know if that's
true in other areas of the world and of course the the backdrop as a whole is absolutely spectacular
and and perfectly lit so really really gorgeous image but it's the composition that really shines
through here it does feel very personal and it feels original I've seen a lot of photos
from this area because of course this is a lovely combination of subjects in the backdrop but I
think this is a particularly interesting foreground choice but I do have a couple of
things that I'd like to change one was from looking at the original file the other is
actually just looking at this edit and in this top right hand corner it's just a little bit hot
too hot to handle it draws my eye the the color saturation and and the clipping so if we go to
Rob's edit which was included with the the raw file effectively we can see he's got a lot of
masks here and maybe more than he would need I have to say so maybe you could edit slightly in
a more simple way but the the problem here has actually come from setting a white point in the
channel here and that's caused some pretty hard clipping of the sky and just makes it a little bit
too too fiery and it does draw my attention a little bit and I suspect that's affecting this
sunlit area of the foreground on the left as well so I have just had a quick go at editing this from
scratch and this is before I've done any local adjustments which is why I think Rob might have
done more than he needed to in this case with all of those changes though certainly that some of them
will do some very subtle things which can actually together really enhance an image I'm sure but I do
just want to tackle this sky so we're going to just put a selection over the sky so we select
our masks here and select the sky and I'm just going to slightly darken down the sky as a whole
and then you can start to see some of the blue color of the sky and also some of that detail
coming back in those highlights so that gets me part of the way there and then I'm going to drag
a linear gradient over the whole top right hand corner which you can hopefully see is a lot brighter
than the rest of the image just to hold that entire area back and now we can start to see
these highlights being rendered in a really nice spot and as a final correction I'm actually just
going to reduce the contrast again in this area so we're going to drag the contrast down
and just add a little bit of negative clarity just to soften the contrast in those highlights just to
make it a little bit quieter a little bit more gentle and we can just slightly knock back the
exposure as well and get away with not having masked that better although if you do want to
you can subtract another mask away from this mask so I'm subtracting a linear gradient here
just to soften that edge on the left not that I could really see it but that's how you would do it
and we can hold back some of these highlights as well and reduce the contrast and I think Rob's
done that generally very effectively he just made a slight error I think in setting that white point
and actually let's just hold back that corner that tiny bit more up there so I think that's
more or less where I would go with this maybe I'd take a bit of saturation out of the sky as well
but not the blues Rob did take a bit of blue out of this which I think is quite nice this
contrast between blue and orange but one last point Rob did I think distort this image and crop
this image slightly so if we just go between the two here so this is the original DNG with his edits
and you can see that we introduced this extra layer this extra pyramid in the foreground which
I personally think is a really nice feature of the photo that I wouldn't want to remove myself so
two minor points there but another wonderful image and a great way to start off this series
so thank you very much Rob and if you would like to take part yourself please do look at that
description below and finally thank you very much once more to Kay's Filters
for sponsoring this series and I'll see you in the next one.
