Analysts Break Down Immigration Fallout After National Guard Shooting

NTD
11.9K followers
75 Video Views·Dec 1, 2025
Following the tragic shooting of two West Virginia National Guard members patrolling DC by an Afghan asylee, NTD discussed the fallout over immigration and the National Guard Deployment with Mike Leon, NTD News contributor and Host of the 'Can We Please Talk' Podcast, and Simon Hankinson, Senior Research Fellow at the Border Security and Immigration Center from the Heritage Foundation.
📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
Thanks to Daniel for that report. And
joining us to discuss the fallout from
the DC shootings is Mike Leyon. He's an
NTD news contributor and the host of the
Can We Please Talk podcast and Simon
Henson, senior research fellow on border
and security and immigration center with
the Heritage Foundation. Gentlemen,
thank you both for joining us this
morning. We're going to explore both
aspects of the fallout, both immigration
as well as the National Guard
deployments. Let's start with
immigration. Mike, over to you. your
thoughts on that and some of the fallout
that we were just seeing in that last
package.
>> Yeah, good morning to everybody. Um, you
know, obviously my thoughts and prayers
with Sarah's family and and pulling for
Andrew obviously to get through all of
this. Look, this this is one of those
times, Carrie, where I think buzzwords,
phrases, you know, pointing the blame. I
mean both administrations can can take
some of this blame here obviously in
terms of the refugee program that
welcomed in this guy into here and then
obviously the asylum uh case and the
immigration judge that allowed this
person to stay earlier this year. So
there's a lot of fingerpointing to blame
and that normally happens when these
type of things happen and the tragedy is
lost in all of this and how we actually
make sure that not only our troops are
safe, police officers are safe,
everybody gets the proper resources and
vetting. So there's there's a lot to
digest with all of this. In terms of the
immigration aspect of it, you know, I
the one thing I would say, Carrie, that
is kind of counter to what Christine Nom
just said there in the package and I was
speaking with an immigration attorney, a
high-profile one yesterday in New Jersey
that has handled some of these cases
before. You know, the vetting process is
very thorough because granting asylum is
very, very low. In August of 25,
according to track reports, only about
19% of asylum cases were even approved.
Right. So, and I and obviously now I
know there's a temporary hold right now
going on with asylum cases. So, it it's
very tough to get asylum. How he got
into this country with the program with
respect to Afghan refugees that were
helping us fight the Taliban out in
Afghanistan like that that is its own
thing and that was years ago. But in
terms of him being approved asylum
earlier this year, there are other
documents that forensics that need to be
submitted to the judge and all of that
stuff is vetted for lack of a term uh
during the case during the trial. So to
say that this person wasn't vetted and
the Biden administration, yeah, we could
blame the program for having him be on
US soil and whether or not that that
program was merited because of what
those folks did to help us fight the
Taliban and Afghanistan. But now in
terms of him being allowed to stay here,
that happened earlier this year. So I I
I really think the fingerpointing
doesn't help anything. I think the
system needs to be fixed overall and
changed and we need to figure out how to
not get people to radicalize and commit
acts of violence like this.
>> And Simon, your thoughts on asylum and
immigration related to this incident?
And then we'll broaden it up to talk a
little bit more broadly as Mike's
pointing to just the general problem of
radicalization.
Well, on on asylum at large, I think one
point that uh Gnome made is worth
underlining. Under the Biden
administration, there was a policy of
catching and releasing people at the
border. And they parrolled in about one
and a half million people. And both of
those programs rest on the premise that
all of these people coming in are going
to at some point claim asylum. I could
go into why that was illegal and it
definitely was counter to US national
interests, but that's the fact. So,
you've got this backlog of whatever 1.5
million people plus all those that were
caught and released that are presumably
going to claim asylum at some point.
Now, before we release them, we put the
the the tail wagged the dog. We let them
in first and then we put them through
the asylum process where we supposedly
vet them. And always remember, if you
ping against a database that has no
information in it, you're not really
doing a lot of vetting. So, we use that
word very loosely. If you're vetting
someone who comes from Germany, you're
going to be able to have or Japan pretty
accurate data uh shared by those
countries that are members of the visa
waiver program, you're going to have at
least some background. But if you do it
against somebody coming from
Afghanistan, unless they are, you know,
registered with the US government in
some way because they've worked for us
or we encountered them in the field,
you're going to get practically nothing.
And the Taliban is not going to share
whatever they have. So it it is a black
box that we're sort of poking into
hoping that it's going to reveal
someone's entire history, but the truth
is it it won't and it can't. And so
we've got these people in now who have
to go through the system and at the end
of the process if they're denied asylum
they have to be sent home again. And
that's something we haven't been doing
for many years.
>> You bring up uh some interesting points.
Of course many of these people came in
uh during the Biden administration as
Mike points out. This person though
proceeded uh to gain his his access
granted in April during Trump's
administration. I want to pan out a
little bit though. talk about what Pam
Bondi was referring as something that's
going to come up a lot more with the
administration on radicalization with
the violence that we've seen just this
year since Trump's come in office. R uh
these acts of violence from what you
might call radicalized individuals were
both uh people who came from overseas as
well as US nationals if you look at the
Charlie Kirk incident. So Mike, what
what can be done? What should what
should we be talking about as it relates
to countering what clearly is a problem
of radicalization?
>> Yeah. Well, I mean, there's many forms
just in that sentence that you said
there, right? The Charlie Kirk incident
obviously could be political ideology,
which is why I've stressed to not only
to on this program and others, you know,
like let's tone it down. Let's use our
words properly here. Things that you
learn, you know, like in first grade,
second grade, Gary, you know. Um, but
then there's the other part of it,
right, which is uh outside seekers that
come here that do want to commit harm.
Like kind of what Simon said, right? You
got some of these folks that do come
from some of these countries that it is
a black box. And and let's be honest,
it's a black box for a big reason. We've
been involved in conflicts there. Um,
and then we've left there. They've asked
us for help and then they didn't like
the way we've provided the help. And
then all of a sudden now you have folks
that are coming from these countries
that to Simon's point the process is
broken because we were letting them hear
even though they did favors for us and
worked in side with the US government
but we didn't actually properly vet them
to use that word loosely again. So so
there there's two types of
radicalization. I I think the biggest
thing for me Carrie and it's something
again that's why my show is called can
we please talk not some other type of
incendiary language. I think the
rhetoric needs to tone down a little
bit. I I think also we need we need to
choose our words carefully and also we
need to get the process to be a little
bit more rigorous in terms of what it is
that we're doing with immigration
overall from from soup to nuts, right?
In terms of the the hardworking citizens
that do want to be here that we're
sending back right now versus what the
president has said before, which is the
criminals, the the ones that do want to
do harm to our communities, whether it
be through drugs or whether it be
through like this action of this person
right here killing two N National Guards
troops. We we need to figure out the
process to to vet these individuals
properly across the board. Ones coming
in, but then also ones that are
homegrown here. Carrie, we need to be
better with our language across the
board, across the political spectrum.
>> Thank you, Mike. And and we are running
low on time, but Simon, I do want you to
also weigh in on this concept of
radicalization and the broken process of
of asylum seeking.
>> Radicalization is very, very difficult
to fight. I think with uh domestic
terrorists, you know, it it comes down
to families, it comes down to education,
it comes down to ideology. You know,
that's pushing on a string. We we have
to do our best, but you can never
completely stamp out far-left or even
far-right ideology. When it comes to
foreigners, we have a choice. We can
limit at least the risk. We can do much
better social media and other kinds of
vetting, and we can make the prize of US
citizenship a little harder to attain.
You know, we're not deporting anybody
who's a US citizen. I agree with most of
what Mike says, but that was one little
slip. We're only deporting people who
under our laws are not eligible to be
here. And so we have to make sure that
that prize of US citizenship is always
very very hard to get and even to be
able to stay here as an asyl or refugee
or green card holder should be the kind
of pinnacle of our immigration system
and we do not want to give that away
which I think we have been for too long.
>> Well, this tragic incident last
Wednesday has certainly brought this
directly into focus. Appreciate your
comments. Mike Leon, Simon Henson, thank
you.
>> Thank you guys.
