What were real MEDIEVAL PIRATES like?

Medieval Legends
5 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 1, 2025
The truth behind real medieval pirates. Who they were (and why so many were ordinary people). How they fought, what weapons they used, and what their ships were actually like. How kings, merchants, and nobles quietly encouraged piracy. Famous medieval pirate raids and the chaos they caused
The word piracy these days conjures up the golden age of piracy, tricorn hats and dreadlocks
with beads in them and people bouncing around drinking rum from island to island, cutlasses,
cannon, great big ships. However that is the 17th century and piracy has been around,
is still with us today, but has been around since antiquity. The Romans suffered under pirates,
the Greeks did as well, even the bronze age collapse was potentially caused by pirates,
known as the sea peoples. Did medieval people suffer from piracy? Yes they did, let's go into
a few more details about it. Before medieval England, the south coast, the east coast and
the west coast were infested with pirates, particularly the north sea of course with
the vikings, the viking raids, basically the vikings were pirates. But the south coast,
all sorts of piracy went on along there and of course the Irish sea was rife with pirates,
so the whole island is surrounded by medieval pirates of one sort or another.
One of the more colourful medieval pirates was called Eustace, Eustace the monk, because he
entered a monastery when he was younger, fell out with various people and started a life of
piracy in the channel. He was based around the south coast around 1170, died in 1217
and he raided shipping of all sorts, he raided English shipping and French shipping,
but he's particularly colourful because we know an awful lot about him, because there were
adventure stories told about him. In the similar and less well-known way to Robin Hood for example,
his life became surrounded with ballads and tales of all sorts of weird things and daring do.
He's variously accused of being able to employ sorcery in in terms of piracy. Whether that's
true or not I'll leave that to your own imagination, but the medieval audience
lapsed that up. But he was a real figure and he was employed by several kings
and he had a pirate fleet. Born near Boulogne to a minor noble family in northern France, he was
entered into a monastery at a fairly young age and it appears from there the stories of his
employing sorcery starts to develop. A record called the L'Histoire du Duc de Normandie,
simply describes Eustace as Eustace the monk, a very wicked man, which I think is quite descriptive.
So they obviously thought he was quite bad, but he went from leaving the monastery for whatever
reason. We're not actually told, the reports vary, the opinions vary. He obviously fell
out with somebody or maybe he had a big fight or maybe he refused to do monkish type of things
and he went on the run. He then appears to have fallen out with a local noble
and raised a gang of people and burned some of his mills to the ground. Now,
mills were a very important source of tax for the local nobles, so it appears that that was
fairly strong comment on the state of political affairs there. It may be that he was disowned or
there were all sorts of minor noble squabbles going on at the time, but he managed to raise
a gang and burn mills down and then went on the run and was declared outlaw and fled to sea.
At sea he becomes what's called a routier, a traveller of the roads. It's very similar in
some ways to the concept of a Japanese ronin, a masterless samurai, although he was a piratical
bad person. But he seems to have wandered the roads and then finally ended up at sea. I assume
he had a band with him though, because one man can't really do that much mischief if people
don't want him to. So perhaps he'd already gathered a band of ne'er-do-wells with him at
this stage and they decided to embark on a life of piracy. I wonder where they got their first
boat from? I wonder if they actually stole their first boat? The records don't say anything like
that, they just say he became a pirate, which leaves all sorts of questions about the origin
story left open for us to interpret. But at some stage he got himself a ship and started his life
of piracy. Around 1204-1205 he seems to have really begun his career of piracy quite strongly.
He formed a sort of pirate base in the Channel Islands, particularly Sark and Guernsey,
using the geography of those islands as a sort of means of hiding. They've got lots of inlets
and places to hide. And they're not remote exactly, because they're quite accessible from
the Channel, but at the same time they're not easily accessible. You need boats to attack them.
So if you want to have a pirate base, having an island base obviously makes a ton of sense.
He set about raiding coastal shipping, both the English and the French, and occasionally raiding
towns as well. Because let's not forget, pirates don't just attack other people's ships, that's a
main part of what they do, but they also raid coastal villages and coastal towns if they can,
and take riches there. Very similar in some ways to what the Vikings did back in the early
medieval period. This is an unusual situation, because we don't normally do sponsorships, but
the guys behind Mount & Blade 2, Bannerlord, have kindly sponsored this segment of the video. Now,
I wouldn't normally do sponsorships at all, just because they don't really fit in with the video,
but this one does, because as some of you know, I am actually a gamer myself. I play games and I
make games. I'm actually the CEO of a company called Rebellion that makes games like Sniper
Elite, and that may come as a shock to some of you, but this game in particular, I actually played
the first one. I played Mount & Blade back in the day, and it's fascinating because for me,
it's about horses and blades from horseback, and weapons from horseback, so it was an interesting
exercise for me to try and transfer my actual knowledge of fighting and combat from horseback
to a computer game, and I think they did it very successfully. So Mount & Blade 2, Bannerlord,
has got a new DLC. This one is all about sea stallions, the longships, basically, the oceans,
ocean-going combat. Now, that was a thing in the medieval period, although it was much less
organized than later periods, but ocean-going voyages with the Vikings, the Romans had them,
obviously the Norman invasion came over the land, and they weren't completely confident in
the people that were fighting naval actions. It wasn't really completely understood how to do it
properly. You had a very different historical approach. You didn't have cannon, for example.
You did have ranged weapons, but they weren't that effective. It was when gunpowders and cannon
came in that you could have ranks of cannon and you could shoot broadsides at people,
but in the medieval period, very much, it was important. Commerce was important. Anyway,
what this allows you to do, this DLC called Warsails, allows you to explore the oceans,
really. It allows you to look into a faction called the Nords, which I assume are based very
heavily on the Northmen, the Danes. On these islands of England, we talk about the Vikings,
we talk about Danes, Danaxes. These were all synonyms for a group of people that lived in
the cold north of Europe and were great explorers. They were explorers, they were settlers, they were
traders, they were also pirates as well, and raiding coastal landscapes was very important.
In fact, they often went up rivers. They raided Paris, for example. So that's quite a long way
inland, but very close to a river. They were the scourge of the seas, actually. So in this DLC,
it's going to be very interesting to see whether you become a scourge of the sea. And controlling
a ship isn't that different to controlling a horse. I mean, a ship doesn't have its own mind,
but it's influenced by the tides and the waves and the weather and the wind, obviously. And how you
trim the sails and how you control the angle of attack and the direction has got a lot of parallels
with horsemanship on land. So it's hardly surprising that when the Vikings settled
and decided to look into combat on land, they became very good at that as well. And
Vikings were the earlier Normans. Basically, the Normans were Northmen, hence the name.
They settled in parts of northern France and became the Norman dynasty. And that's really
what they are. They are Frenchified Vikings. So Mount and Blade 2, Bannerlord, this Warsails DLC
is out now, I think, by the time you listen to this bit. I may see you on the seas. You never
know. I'll be out there playing the game and enjoying it. It's a lot of depth in it. And
obviously, there's just no time to go into the depth here in this video. But thank you very much
for the sponsorship from the team and good luck with the next DLC, because hopefully you've got
plans for what you're doing next, too. The more lurid tales about him describe how he can use
sorcery to disguise himself and then trick his way into places and confuse people. I think it's
probably likely he did use deception as well, because if you think about it, he was trained as
a monk. So he had all the airs and the graces. He spoke the Latin. He probably had the clothes.
So he could become a monk, if you like, and people wouldn't necessarily recognize him. I
wonder if he had a tonsure as a pirate. But it was no use as a monk. But people would defer to
the clergy back in those days. So if a monk entered your town and wanted to speak to the local bishop
or dignitary, I think it's unlikely anybody would suspect them particularly. So maybe these tales
grew up as a way of explaining how he managed to use his background to great effect, to find out
about places, get in, sort out which gates are well protected, which places are, where the money is,
and then plan his raid, leave and then plan his raid. So I think that's kind of interesting,
how the stories may disguise a reality. At around this time, King John of England is fighting a
war against the French. He's lost Dormondy. Everything is going quite bad. This is the
King John that's famous in the Robin Hood stories. You can see how Robin Hood and Eustace the Monk
not connected exactly, but they kind of are part of the same corpus of
very early action adventure stories, if you like. Anyway, it appears that King John
hired him or employed him somehow. Now, the records say he entered the service of King John.
And I think that disguises the reality of it, that Eustace was a man for hire. He was a mercenary.
He was a pirate. And presumably King John said, look, we'll pay you money. That'll be easy money.
You promise not to raid English shipping and promise not to raid English ports.
But we want you to attack the French, even though you're French. Money. So some kind of deal was
done. And Eustace sets about attacking only the French and neutral ships as well. He gets into
not exactly trouble for neutral ships, but neutral ships were attacked by accident on purpose,
I suppose. But mostly he attacks the French shipping. And this is quite useful because
it gets in the way of the French logistics chain because a lot of heavy goods were transported
coastally as well. So if you're raiding the coastal transport system, you're actually getting
in the way of the logistics of the French army. So he was very effective at that. The official term
privateer or somebody who has a letter of marque appeared under Edward in around 1293.
So it's a bit later, this sort of official term of privateer, which is in effect a licensed pirate
or a pirate that is licensed by one side has to give a share of the booty to the crown and in
return they get permission to be a pirate. I suppose that's what it comes down to. So Eustace
didn't have specifically what's called a letter of marque, but he did have an agreement with the
crown that specifically said you can keep half the booty that you find and the crown will keep
the other half. How accurately that sharing of the loot was, is a pirate going to give you a fair
share of the loot? Maybe they did. I think it's unlikely. So there was some money went to the
crown and a lot of it was kept by Eustace to run and expand his fleet of pirate ships.
We have a record of King John granting Thomas of Galway's fleet permission, similar to that of
Eustace. We don't actually have Eustace, the data from Eustace, the records from Eustace is a
letter of marque or equivalent, but Thomas of Galway has one and it literally says
you are hereby a pirate and I want half. You share your ill-gotten gains, whatever you capture
in piracy, I want half and you can have half. More technically it actually says that you may take
half of the value that you capture from our enemies. The sources about Eustace speak of
him having up to 30 ships in his fleet, which is surprisingly significant when you have to
remember there is no such thing as the Royal Navy, there is no real official navy protecting the coast
at this stage. There were loose arrangements with people and the crown often had between five and
ten ships. It appears that Eustace had up to 30. Now they are going to be a huge variety of different
shapes and sizes, but it does appear that he had a flagship because the flagship comes in
in his final days in particular. But he definitely had a flagship and he had a fleet of up to 30.
As you might expect there's a twist in the tale. So Eustace appears to fall out with King John,
we don't know why, maybe he wasn't paid. The crown often doesn't have enough money to pay
its debts so maybe the king thought he'd get away with it and Eustace went no, I'm going to go to the
other side. So King Louis, the names of French kings are very easy to remember. They're all
called Louis, they all have numbers. This is Louis VIII. You just have to remember which number does
which thing in history. If in doubt who is the king of France, Louis is a 50-50 guess for the
history of France. I suppose they're easier to remember than the Ethel kings or the egg kings
of early medieval Britain. Louis VIII pays him money to swap sides and that's exactly what he
does. So he then starts raiding English towns and English shipping and English infrastructure
in return for being paid presumably more or maybe just the same amount by the French. Now
obviously the issue there is that he was an insider when it comes to the way the English fought and
the English structures and the English ports so he knew all sorts of things about them. So he has a
perfect opportunity to flip sides and then have a huge advantage in raiding the English now instead
for Louis. In 1216 Prince Louis invades England, lands his forces on the south coast with the help
of Eustace's navy. Eustace's navy, in effect his fleet, forms the logistical backbone of the
invasion of England around 1216. On the 24th of August 1217 his reign comes to an end. His fleet,
the logistics arm of the French attack, is attacked by Hubert de Bourgh from upwind using
some innovative tactics at the time. It's pretty nasty actually what he did. Hugh attacked the
flagship and he used lime, powdered lime. He attacked from upwind and he emptied these sacks
of lime, barrels of lime into the air, flung them high and the lime drifted across the enemy decks
and lime, if anybody knows it, is very caustic. It gets in your eyes, it then reacts with the
moisture in your eyes and your skin and your mouth and your lungs and actually starts to heat up and
burn. I mean lime becomes slaked lime which then is mixed with water and it's used in mortar so
it's a part of the carbon cycle. So you burn the carbon dioxide, you get limestone, you heat it up,
that drives off the water. You can then use that to create mortar. You add mortar, it changes its
structure, becomes kind of gummy and can be used in mortar and then over time the carbon dioxide
is involved and it becomes calcium carbonate again and sets back into limestone so it's a cycle.
But if you chuck that powdered lime, that basic ingredient, into the air it's bad. Bad for your
eyes. They raided the flagship of Eustace and found him hiding in the lowest part of the ship,
hiding away. He offered a vast sum of money for his life but they weren't going to accept that.
I mean he turned coat twice. I suppose you could argue why don't you get him to turn coat a third
time. But anyway they beheaded him on the rails of his own flagship there and then on the spot.
That was the punishment for the sort of piracy and his fleet was destroyed, lost its leadership
and the invasion of France collapsed as a result of having no logistics chain.
So that's the story of Eustace, one particular pirate adventurer that we know about. We know
about that because there are lots of stories written about him. How much is true, how much is
false, I'll leave that to your imagination. But it seems very likely that he did a lot of the things,
apart from the sorcery perhaps, that he's written about. But who were the ordinary pirates? Who
were the everyday pirates? Well it appears that it gets complicated. People weren't pirates full
time. It appears that piracy was a thing that otherwise legitimate merchants and travellers
occasionally did when the opportunity arose. I guess the high seas are very flexible when it
comes to lawful or lawlessness. So if you are in a big ship and you've got soldiers, you come across
a smaller ship. It is relatively straightforward. Nobody's going to come to their help. Relatively
straightforward to attack, take their goods, potentially kill everybody on board, throw them
into the ocean, potentially even sink that ship once you've emptied it. And nobody will know, apart
from the crew of the attacking ship of course, nobody will necessarily know what's happened to
that ship. Because ships founder all the time in the weather. They crash into rocks, they sink for
all sorts of different reasons, they just break open. The white ship for example was very high in
the water and founded in bad weather. So ships going missing for legitimate reasons were very
common and therefore it meant piracy was almost a crime where you could just pretend the ship
founded. And I guess, I don't know whether the wool or the goods were marked with a merchant's
mark, perhaps they were, so you'd have to you'd have to sell those in a dodgy place. But if you're
going to offer stolen goods for less money, yeah I'm sure there are some merchants that would take
them on. It seems that much of the English piracy was centred around the so-called sink ports, the
five ports as in French, sank, the five mispronounced in typical English way,
where the majority of the maritime shipping passed through. These were Hastings, Romney, Hythe,
Dover and Sandwich. Some of them are still ports today, Dover's a hugely important port today.
Others are actually now landlocked completely and you have to go upriver to get to them. But in the
The land has shifted and changed. They were coastal ports themselves. There are a couple of
others that are sort of added to the sink ports later on, but obviously there needed to be five
for them to be sink ports. Those other two are Rye and Winchelsea and all of the sink ports,
the original five and the two other ones, owed the crown what's called naval service.
So they had an obligation to, for their rights and as part of their taxable status, they needed
to provide a certain number of ships for a certain number of days a year. Between them they had to
provide 57 ships. Each ship had to have 20 men and one boy, interestingly, but that's what it says
in the records, between all of them. It appears that Dover and Hastings had to provide 21 ships
between them. I would guess, given that Dover was bigger than Hastings, that Dover had to provide
11 and Hastings 10 and all the others had to provide five ships. These weren't big ships
though. These were your standard sort of trading medieval cog. They weren't particularly big boats
by modern standards at all. They were quite substantial. They could carry a big cargo,
that's really what they were. They were quite big bellied. They're known as cogs if you're
interested. Some of them had high forecastles and sterncastles because the principle of naval
fighting was very much they transposed the land battles to the sea, a bit like the Romans did,
to a certain extent. What you try to do is you try to engage the other person's ship.
There are no cannon, of course, in these days. There's no real strong way of taking a ship out
from a distance. So what you needed to do, you needed to board the other ship with more men.
And if you had a high part on the front, the foxhole and the stern, the forecastle, literally,
and the sterncastle, literally, those were often raised up. Now that, of course, brings the centre
gravity of the ship quite high. And medieval ships had a horrible habit of sometimes turning
turtle, especially in bad weather. They weren't designed in the same kind of way that Viking
boats might have been. Even though the Viking boats had a very low, they were quite low to the
ocean, they were designed to sit high up and not sink deep into the waves at all. So the water
dynamics of medieval boats are not particularly sophisticated. But they were good. They would
chug along and carry quite a lot. So in warfare, the idea was to effectively sail up to somebody
else. You weren't ramming at all, because you might damage your ship as well. But these aren't
the ancient triremes, for example, of the ancient battles. These were more or less big boats you'd
run alongside, and then one side would jump over the other side, and hatchets, axes, swords, spears,
longbows from high up, crossbows, presumably, anything you can do. Fire was potentially to be
avoided, though, if you think about it, because if you set somebody's ship on fire, and you're stuck
on their ship, you're going to burn both of your ships as well. So they didn't tend to use too much
in the way of fiery munitions, unless it was total war, unless they were going for destruction. And
the secret to Greek fire had been forgotten a long time ago. But I suppose you could chuck
burning coals onto the other side. But fire was an omnipresent danger for any kind of ocean-going
vessel made of wood. In actual dimensions, the boats are typically around 24 meters long by about
8 meters wide. It varies hugely. They're all handmade. They're not really made to a mechanical
plan at all. They're just made by shipwrights of about the right size. 24 meters is what, 25 yards,
something like that. And 8 meters is 8 yards, 9 yards-ish. Yeah, so not particularly big, but
substantial, known as cogs. And they were the standard ships of the day. Now, I bet that the
pirates had a whole variety of different types of ships. But there were unlikely to be much,
much bigger ones than that. Or occasionally, the odd one might be really big, I suppose. Later on,
we hear that, for example, the Mary Rose was much bigger. But that comes in post-medieval,
in the time of cannon. So it was built to have cannon on deck as well. But the medieval ones
weren't. They were built to carry people and longbows, crossbows. If the king really needed
it, he was allowed to arrest them. So he could arrest a ship, literally a ship, and make them
work for him. Now, the sink ports were required to work for 15 days a year for the crown. That's
all. It's not very long. Basically, what is that? Two weeks, really. Two weeks at sea. The king could
request them to fight longer, but he has to then start paying the wages and paying the rent for the
boats. So very similar to other forms of service on land that the king might expect. The feudal
service was 40 days on land. But on the sea, it appears that it's actually only 15 days. So it's
quite a short period of time. I guess long enough to fight off an invasion, perhaps, or to land your
troops on somebody else's coast. So not really designed for long-term campaigns at all, unless
you're willing to pay. And the crown is always short of money. I think it's therefore quite
likely that people, for some of the time, were working for the crown and acting for the forces
of law and order. But then when they're no longer on the clock for the crown, they would do ordinary
merchant type of things, transporting goods to and for, but also engage in a little bit of private
enterprise and private piracy. It's quite possible that one week, somebody was fighting for the king
of England and law and order, and then the next week they suddenly became a pirate and were robbing
other people. It sounds a bit chaotic to me, but that seems to be how it was. There weren't that
many boats on the ocean, and some of them were used sometimes for good, and other times would
spin around and be used for bad. So it's quite chaotic. So the idea of somebody being a full-time
pirate, with the exception of Eustace and perhaps a few others, I think it's very likely that the vast
majority of people were weekend pirates, or Saturday pirates, or whatever you might want to
call it. They had legitimate jobs, but also chose to be a pirate when it was convenient.
Around 1350 to 1400, John Hawley of Dartmouth becomes quite notorious. He was a wine merchant
and wool merchant, and he raised his own fleet. He had his own fleet, and he was very involved
in the Hundred Years' War. He was very involved in ferrying men and horses to and from across the
channel. But he occasionally appears to have accidentally, on purpose, captured neutral ships,
as well as those of the French, and got into trouble. He was actually sued a few times for
capturing somebody's ship, who wasn't an enemy of the Crown. It appears he paid them compensation.
Not quite sure what actually happened, whether that was the whole value of the
ship or not. Whether he actually captured the ship, or stole the cargo, and then sank the ship. I think
it's very likely he captured the ship, and kind of integrated it into his own fleet. I mean, after all,
that's what people did in the golden age of piracy, and quite frankly, it's what the Royal Navy did.
If you captured a ship in the Royal Navy, it was sold as prize money, and that prize money was split
amongst the officers and crew, in a certain way, via the Admiralty. So this tradition of,
not necessarily sinking other people's ships, but taking them over, sailing them back to port,
and then selling them, meant that ships changed hands. So a ship that you thought was French,
might actually turn out to be now owned by the English, or owned by the Dutch, or whatever it
might be. They would be a fluid shipping market, much the same way there is today. A lot of ships
have flags of convenience, and it appears that the medieval ships had a very similar thing going on.
They were ships of convenience too. Of course, piracy in the medieval period, around medieval
England, isn't just on the south coast, but that's a place I've done the most research. But obviously,
the Irish Sea and the North Sea, absolutely hotbeds of piracy in a different way, different
sets of people. Can't forget the Vikings doing that. But piracy was there in the Middle Ages,
it was there in the ancient world, and it's there these days, literally. We have pirates, they just
operate vessels that are powered by engines, not by the winds or by oars. So piracy,
we may think of tricorn hats, and bottles of rum, and the Caribbean, and of course,
that is the golden age of piracy. But pirates have existed in the medieval period. But they
weren't full-time pirates, they were opportunistic coastal communities. And
somebody's pirate one day, might be somebody's saviour the next.
