Why Almost Nobody Moves To New Mexico

Geography
22 followers
New Mexico is the fifth largest state by area, yet it remains one of the least populated in
the country with only 2.1 million people. It's a place of profound emptiness,
surrounded by neighbors that are booming. Texas, Arizona, and Colorado are magnets
for new residents, drawing in millions with promises of jobs and opportunity.
Yet New Mexico sits quietly, its population growth nearly flat between 2020 and 2024.
So what's going on? To understand New Mexico's population inversion,
we can't start with its economy or its politics. We have to start with the land it sits on.
If you were to ask someone to describe New Mexico, you would likely get a simple answer.
It's a desert, and with that, you'd picture vast, sandy flats stretching to the horizon,
dotted with tumbleweeds and sun-baked skulls, all tinted in the sepia filter of a Hollywood
western. It's the land of the show Breaking Bad, after all. A desolate backdrop for a desolate
story. But while that image isn't entirely wrong, it is profoundly incomplete. The first mistake is
thinking of it as a low-lying hot desert, like the area where Phoenix, Arizona sits. New Mexico
is neither low-lying nor flat. In fact, on average, it's the fourth highest state in the
entire country in terms of elevation, at 5,700 feet above sea level. Its identity is defined by
this altitude. This high, dry elevation dictates everything. The climate, the comfortability,
even the economy. And the state's northern edge isn't a desert at all. It's the dramatic,
conclusive end of the Rocky Mountains. The Sangre de Cristo Range, a jagged spine of 13,000-foot
peaks, spills south from Colorado, sheltering cities like Santa Fe and Taos. Here, the air
is especially not hot. It's thin, crisp, and smells of ponderosa pine. This alpine world of
deep forests and cold, mountain streams feels a thousand miles away from the sun-scorched
landscapes of its neighbor, Arizona. Of course, the state is still largely a desert, which means
it mostly relies on a single, vital artery that slices the state in two, the Rio Grande.
It's not the modest border river most imagine, but a massive continental feature. For millions
of years, this river has carved a deep rift valley through the center of New Mexico,
providing the single most important resource in the American West, water. Almost every major
city in the state, Albuquerque, Santa Fe, Las Cruces, is clustered along this thin, fertile
corridor. Here, the landscape is a ribbon of green with cottonwood trees that simply wouldn't exist
otherwise. But here's where it gets really interesting. This valley, which seems so stable,
is actually a sign of the continent slowly ripping apart. The Rio Grande Rift is a massive,
geological fault line where the Colorado Plateau is pulling away from the North American interior.
This subterranean violence has shaped the surface, littering the landscape with volcanic cones,
ancient lava flows, and geothermal hot springs that bubble up from the Earth's crust.
Move away from this central river valley, and the state splinters into radically different zones.
In the south, you find the Chihuahuan Desert, a vast and truly arid region. But even here,
New Mexico defies expectation. This desert is home to the White Sands National Park,
a stunning and surreal landscape. It's a 275-square-mile sea of brilliant white dunes,
not of sand, but of pure gypsum. It feels less like a desert and more like an alien planet.
Travel to the northwest, and you enter the Colorado Plateau. This is the iconic
Wild West of mesas, buttes, and dramatic canyons. It's a high, cold desert, a landscape of sedimentary
rock carved by wind and time. This is the home of Shiprock, a 1,500-foot volcanic plug that rises
from the vast plain like a massive spectral cathedral. To the east, the landscape flattens
completely into the High Plains, or the Llano Estacado. This is a sea of grass, indistinguishable
from West Texas or Oklahoma, a land defined by a colossal sky and relentless wind.
But it's this next part that completely changed how I think about the concept of
emptiness. You see, the common thread connecting these disparate landscapes,
mountain, valley, desert, and plain, is the sky. Because of the high altitude and dry air,
light in New Mexico is famously intense and crystal clear. It's why artists like Georgia O'Keeffe
were drawn here, captivated by the way the light saturates the colors and defines the horizon.
The sky is so vast and the land so empty that it creates a feeling of profound scale,
a silence that is both enchanting and deeply isolating. This is the land of enchantment.
It's a land of astonishing beauty and violent geological contrasts. But it's also a hard land.
It's a geography defined not by abundance, but by its profound lack of water.
Of course, this landscape existed long before any person arrived, and it would dictate the
terms of survival for every single group of people that has tried to call it home.
The way that landscape captivated artists is a powerful idea. Because telling a complex story,
whether it's about a landscape or a history, is a craft. And I'm always looking for ways
to get better at that craft. Which brings me to this video's sponsor, Masterclass.
Masterclass is a membership that lets you learn directly from the world's
best. And since my job is storytelling, I recently took the class on Masterclass
from LeVar Burton, one of my main inspirations and someone who literally read stories to me
as a child on his show, Reading Rainbow. His lesson on using rhythm, pacing, and pauses has
been transformative as a creator who is often trying to tell complex geographic stories. He
also talks about how to connect with your audience, which is exactly what I try to do
with geography. His advice directly influenced how I scripted this very video about why New Mexico
struggles in getting more people to move there. And that's just one class. There are over 200,
with new ones added monthly. You can learn negotiating from Chris Voss, or comedy from
Steve Martin, or even how to build good habits from James Clear. And plans start at just $10
a month. I just toggle on audio mode and listen like a podcast while I'm researching. It's a way
better use of my time than mindless scrolling. During this holiday season, you can get up to
50% off an annual Masterclass subscription. Just click the link in the video's description
or scan the QR code so they know that I sent you. And seriously, take that LeVar Burton class.
And a huge thank you to Masterclass. Now let's get back to the story of the original masters
of this landscape, the civilizations that thrived here long before any Europeans arrived.
Long before any European had ever dreamed of the New World, New Mexico was home to civilizations.
The earliest inhabitants were, of course, the ancestral Puebloans, who, starting around the
year 700, built one of the most astonishing and long-lasting cultures in North America.
In the northwest corner of the state, they constructed the Chaco Canyon Complex,
a massive urban center of multi-story great houses aligned with astronomical precision.
This was not a collection of rustic villages or scattered tents. It was the ceremonial,
economic, and political heart of a vast civilization, connected by hundreds of
miles of engineered roads. But here's the great big mystery. Around the year 1150,
Chaco was inexplicably abandoned. Whether due to drought, social collapse, or a crisis of faith,
the people dispersed. They migrated to new homes, primarily along the fertile corridor
of the Rio Grande. And when the first Europeans arrived, hundreds of years later,
they didn't find an empty wilderness. They found the descendants of Chaco, the Tiwa, Zuni, Hopi,
and other Pueblo peoples, living in sophisticated, self-sufficient adobe towns. They were joined by
later arrivals, the nomadic Athabascan-speaking peoples who would become the Navajo and Apache.
This was a land already full of nations, trade, and history. In the 1500s, as Spanish conquistadors
were pushing north from the Aztec Empire, which they called Mexico, they were fueled by rumors
of another great civilization in the north, the mythical Seven Cities of Cibola. They hoped there
would be another Nuevo Mexico, a new land as wealthy as the one that they had just conquered,
hence why the state is named New Mexico today. It was a mistake on the part of the early Spanish
conquistadors, but the Spanish never did find their desired Nuevo Mexico. Instead, in 1540,
Francisco Vázquez de Coronado marched north and found the Pueblo villages. He found farmers,
not gold miners, and there were no golden cities. Disappointed, the Spanish mostly left, but the
name stuck. It's crucial to know that New Mexico was not named after the modern country of Mexico.
Instead, both New Mexico and the country of Mexico were named after the same thing, the México,
or the heart of the Aztec Empire. In 1598, Juan de Onate arrived to establish the first
permanent European colony east of the Mississippi River. In fact, Santa Fe, founded in 1610,
is one of the oldest cities in the United States and the oldest state capital. This next part
completely changed the course of North American and New Mexican history. By 1680, the Pueblo
people had reached a breaking point. In a stunning, coordinated uprising known as the Pueblo Revolt,
a Tiwa religious leader named Pope united the disparate and often rival Pueblo villages. They
rose as one, killing over 400 Spanish colonists and driving the remaining 2,000 all the way south
to El Paso. It was the only successful expulsion of a colonizing power by an indigenous population
in the history of the continent, and for the next 12 years, the Pueblo people ruled themselves.
Unfortunately, the Spanish eventually returned in 1692, but the game had changed. They returned
with a lighter touch, a new respect, and a willingness to tolerate the native religion
alongside Catholicism. This compromise forged the unique cultural blend that defines New Mexico to
this day. A world where Spanish and Pueblo traditions coexist. But New Mexico wouldn't
stay part of the Spanish Empire forever. In 1821, Mexico won its independence from Spain,
and New Mexico became a remote, northern territory of the New Mexican Republic.
This period was brief, however. American expansion, driven by the idea of manifest destiny,
was pushing west. In 1846, during the Mexican-American War, U.S. General Stephen Kearney
marched into Santa Fe and claimed the territory for the United States without firing a single
shot. The 1848 Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo made it official. New Mexico was now part of the U.S.
But it was not a state. It became a territory, and for the next 64 years, it would languish in
political purgatory. This was the era of the Wild West, of Billy the Kid, and the Lincoln County
War. But its reputation for lawlessness wasn't the only thing holding it back. The United States
Congress was deeply suspicious of New Mexico's population. It was foreign. Its people were
overwhelmingly Hispanic and Catholic. They spoke Spanish, and they had deep cultural ties to the
indigenous tribes. Washington saw New Mexico as un-American, not ready for self-governance.
Finally, after decades of political maneuvering and proving its loyalty, New Mexico was admitted
to the Union as the 47th state on January 6th, 1912. It entered as a bilingual, multicultural
state, fundamentally different from its neighbors. This deep, complex, and often conflicted history,
older than the United States itself, has created a place unlike anywhere else. It's a land of
resilience, compromise, and deep cultural roots. But if people have been settling and living in
New Mexico since before the United States even existed, why, in an era of massive growth, does
New Mexico remain the land that so few people choose to move to? New Mexico's unique history
and geography set it apart from the rest of the country. But neither alone fully explains the
modern demographic puzzle. Why is New Mexico standing still while its neighbors are exploding?
Let's pull some numbers first, because it's quite stark. Between 2020 and 2024, New Mexico's
population grew by half of 1%. In that same time, Texas ballooned by 7.4%, Arizona by 6%,
and Colorado by 3.2%. These neighbors share its arid climate, its Spanish colonial history,
and its Wild West DNA. But they're pulling in new residents by hundreds of thousands,
while New Mexico grew by just 13,000 people. It's a staggeringly low amount.
The answer is not one single thing, but an intricate web of structural challenges that,
when combined, create a barrier to growth for the state. The first of which, of course,
is the economy. For example, while Texas boasts a diversified economy in tech, logistics,
and corporate headquarters, and Arizona thrives on advanced manufacturing, healthcare, and warm
weather tourism, New Mexico's economy is far less dynamic. In fact, it stands on just three main
legs, federal government spending, oil and gas, and a little bit of tourism. The first issue here
is that the federal government is the state's largest and most dominant employer. This includes
three national research laboratories, Los Alamos, Sandia, and the Air Force Research Laboratory,
along with several large military bases. While this creates a core of stable, high-paying,
and highly educated jobs, it also creates an insulated, top-heavy economy that doesn't easily
spin off into a dynamic private sector. The second leg, oil and gas, is concentrated in the
Permian Basin in the state's southeast. This industry is incredibly lucrative, generating
billions of dollars that flood the state government's coffers. But it's also a volatile,
boom-and-bust resource that is subject to global price swings and political wins. And critically,
it doesn't create widespread, sustainable, long-term employment for the majority of the
population, particularly because Texas, and most notably Houston, has cornered the market for being
the hub of all things oil and gas. This means that, short of oil extraction jobs, there are
few high-paying office jobs in New Mexico in this industry. This reliance on government and oil has
left New Mexico without the one thing that is drawing millions to its neighbors, a thriving,
diverse, private-sector job market for the average professional. In fact, the state is experiencing
a significant brain drain, where its most educated and talented young people, the very graduates from
its own universities, are forced to leave for cities like Austin, Denver, and Phoenix to find
opportunity. But a weak job market is only part of the story. For families looking to move, two of
the biggest factors are education and climate. In these categories, New Mexico struggles profoundly.
You see, for decades, the state's K-12 public education system has consistently ranked at or
near the very bottom of the nation. In 2024, the National Assessment of Educational Progress,
known as the Nation's Report Card, once again ranked New Mexico 50th overall in terms of
education. Despite massive state spending fueled by oil revenues, these investments have not
translated into better outcomes for students, particularly in its large rural and indigenous
communities. So, for a family with children, the decision to move to a state ranked last in
education is a non-starter. Alongside this, New Mexico's climate is not necessarily warm and sunny,
as one might expect. In fact, it can get very cold very fast. Unlike Phoenix, which can have warm,
sunny-degree days in the middle of January, or Austin with cool 60-degree days, Albuquerque,
New Mexico's largest city, regularly plunges to the mid-30s or low-40s. Most people who flee
the colder parts of the country for the warmer weather of the Southwest don't want to deal with
an equally cold region that they just moved away from. Finally, New Mexico's neighbors have
successfully built a brand of opportunity, growth, and optimism. Texas is the land of no-income tax
and endless jobs. Arizona is the haven for tech, manufacturing, and sunshine. Colorado is the icon
of outdoor lifestyle and healthy living. New Mexico's brand, meanwhile, has become one of
stunning natural beauty, paired with deep, systemic issues that are not easy to solve.
This is the Great Paradox of New Mexico. It is, by its own official nickname,
the land of enchantment. And its cultural and geographic beauty is so incredible,
it really can't be described. But, for the vast majority of people, enchantment alone
doesn't pay the bills, provide great education, or guarantee warm, sunny days. Which means,
New Mexico will likely remain what it has become, the beautiful, quiet land with very few people.
Speaking of dry, arid desert regions, this week I'm heading to Southern Armenia,
towards its complicated and strikingly beautiful borderlands region with Turkey and Azerbaijan.
And if you want to join me, then head over to my travel channel.
I hope you enjoyed learning all about New Mexico. If you did,
check out this video all about why Oregon is less successful than its sibling Washington.
Thanks for watching, see you next time.
