Upzoning and SB 79 Coming to San Francisco

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
8 Video Views·Nov 26, 2025
State leaders want cities to allow far more housing near transit. Supporters see a needed shift while others question the practical outcome. In this episode we sit down with Tony Hall, former San Francisco supervisor, and Christopher Elmendorf, law professor at UC Davis. We look at what these changes could mean for San Francisco and how the policy meets the city’s real conditions.
San Francisco is looking to upzone for more housing. Also SB 79 passed which means a lot
more housing could be built in San Francisco. Today we sit down with Tony Hall and Christopher
Elmendorf who have opposing views on this upzoning plan. Every unique neighborhood that makes San
Francisco different than any other city in the country, the unique characteristic little
neighborhoods that people have put their life savings into, they're all going to be upzoned.
The major problems the city is facing right now are loss of enrollment in the schools and
declining transit ridership. So having more people would actually be very good for the
city's existing educational infrastructure and transit infrastructure. I'm Siamak Khorrami,
welcome to California Insider. We want to talk to you about your city San Francisco.
There is some upzoning happening. There's talks of upzoning and then SB 79 has passed
which means people could potentially build a lot of higher rise buildings like seven,
eight, six, seven, eight stories. Can you tell us what's happening? Senate Bill 79 overrules the
planning, the local jurisdictional planning department of every county, every city, every
village in the state. It's dictated mandate calls for two and a half million new dwelling
units. All this has been done without any consideration to the diverse communities in
California. You know that as well as I do. California is an amazing state because it's
got so many different lifestyles and diverse communities. I mean like night and day,
got everything in the world in California. No consideration at all was given to the diversities
or the lifestyles of those various communities. These are state mandated dictates that says you
shall build these number of dwelling units by the way all rental at this time. No home ownership
and you're going to do it by adhering to new planning and zoning laws SB 79 which says that
if you live within a half a mile of a transit quarter or a transit hub, bus stop, you know,
transit hub that you have to upzone. San Francisco has been given a quota of 82,000 new dwelling
units by 2030. 82,000. So in the next five years you have to build 82,000? Right and half of those
have to be affordable. What is meant by affordable? Well it has to appeal to the lowest income
renters in that community. The interesting thing about San Francisco and I'm pretty sure you could
find this about every community is every unique neighborhood that makes San Francisco different
than any other city in the country. The unique characteristic little neighborhoods that people
have put their life savings into building their homes. All the neighborhoods are surrounded by
transit quarters. So there are all those single family homes that make up those diverse little
neighborhoods in the most unique city in the country. They're all going to be upzoned. You
get a different feel when you go into absolutely and each neighborhood is different but they're
all surrounded by transit quarters. So the closer you get to the transit quarter the higher you can
go. Four, five, six, ten, twenty stories for development to satisfy this mandate of 82,000
new homes. 40,000 affordable. So the closer you get the more upzoning which means though all the
neighborhood single family homes will be upzoned to accommodate duplexes, triplexes, fourplexes,
whatever to meet this mandate. What does this do? Now let's ask ourselves why is this being done?
These units are to be built out at a cost and they admit this of a million to a million to a unit.
Who's going to rent those? Landlords are allowed to rent to cover their cost to cover their mortgage
if they build 10 units or at a million to a unit. They're going to have the rent has to
justify the cost. They're going to charge a rent to justify the cost of a million to a unit.
That's not low rent. That's not affordable. That doesn't even exist now. So flooding the market
with these high-end rental units there's no data to support that that's going to increase the rent
for all the renters. San Francisco has experienced a 10% drop in its population. Where are they getting
this figure that all these millions of people want to come in and rent in California by 2030
and we have to have the units ready for them? That's a bogus that's a bogus assumption.
People that are leaving San Francisco and leaving California are leaving for reasons
because they can't acquire a home. SB 79 and the housing element do not address one important thing
and that is the affordability concept. Builders are now expected in San Francisco and I'm sure
it's this way in other communities that up to 30 and 35 percent of what they build has to be
affordable. They have to absorb the cost of building the affordable units with impact fees,
inclusionary housing units that they have to build. There's all kinds of environmental impact fees.
The banks aren't going to loan builders the construction loans because they know it doesn't
pencil out. When you're going to build 30 units and 10 of them have to be low income you have to
absorb the cost and in San Francisco we make you build a park, we made you improve the streets,
we're going to try to get you improve the infrastructure. The poor builder, the developer,
the property owner who's who's hiring the builder is left with nothing. It doesn't pencil out. So
that's why there's not a lot of building going on because of these these restrictive laws that
we've imposed upon developers in the last 20 years. The inclusionary laws. So what you're saying is
when you say it doesn't pencil out it means that it will be so expensive that nobody would want to
buy. No savvy builder is going to want to get involved. That's why there's not more building
going on in San Francisco. My contention and I think I'm right when you know politics in San
Francisco in the state these guys are not stupid. When builders refuse to build because it doesn't
pencil out and banks refuse to loan because it doesn't pencil out they form what they're talking
about now municipal banks which are nothing but your tax dollars run by the municipality
and municipal banks will then employ selected non-profits to build rental housing
okay selected non-profits and if it's allowed to develop unchallenged it's already a done deal
it's been voted in if people don't challenge it through the courts it's going to destroy
the neighborhoods in San Francisco because of the upzoning it'll just it won't be good for the
tenants or the property owners so you're saying that developers are not going to be able to build
because of the the cost exactly and and as a result of it we're going to end up with non-profits
government kind of back non-profit and finance through municipal banks to come in and build
well first of all I don't think it's going to happen at all these are impossible mandates to
it doesn't address the affordability aspect it doesn't address the big kahuna which is the
infrastructure now in San Francisco this really means something the infrastructure the water the
sewer the electrical the the streets the paving the state mandate and SB 79 says nothing about
providing the infrastructure before they let people subdivide or build up zone that's huge
you know and so the dictates of supply and demand no longer apply so how hard is it to build the
infrastructure oh it's hard it's huge it's it's billions of dollars billions and billions of
dollars so it's water sewer well San Francisco as most older cities in the state have clay pipes
those clay pipes have a lifespan of maybe 50 to 75 years that city's 200 years old
those pipes are breaking down that's why we have sinkholes every winter the western part of the
city is all clay pipe infrastructure it's outdated it's old the streets are being dug up every other
year in most neighborhoods to lay the electrical new electrical to supply electrical needs which
are growing and then they dig them up again to supply a certain type of cable you know there's
the infrastructure is crumbled in San Francisco that's got to be fixed and to deny that is foolish
to deny the supply and demand when it comes to housing is foolish that's what they're doing
they're saying no we're going to create the demand because millions of new people want to come here
I don't think so it's California and San Francisco might be reaching the point
where the end is full let's try to preserve what we have and work towards satisfying the true needs
of what his studies have shown over and over and over again tenants really want and that's
homeownership a lot of people that support these laws on housing in California they have actually
told us that most people and can't buy a home in California and and this is the solution the
state has is like we need to build more do you think that these laws don't allow homeownership
or not at all they don't address homeownership these laws are talking about
82,000 new units being built in San Francisco that are rental units this doesn't address
homeownership at all this is flooding the market with high-end rentals that the average
mid-level income earner is not going to be able to afford forget about the low-income guys if
you're given permission to build 20 or 30 units 10 to 20 to 25 30 of those units have to be for
low-income people well it costs money somebody's got to pay so then you have to make the rest more
luxury more expensive yeah but then again if they're not rented because the average renter
can't afford it who's going to rent those house who's going to rent those units who's going to
rent them no one they're they're not going to be built seeing that they're not going to be built
it's a joke they're doing this to control the one thing that people need is housing
there's some really good news Shen Yun is coming back to California if you haven't seen Shen Yun
make sure to check it out this show is amazing it's showing what China used to be before communism
and I've been going to it every year it's reviving this ancient culture that's been lost if you have
heard something negative about the show just be mindful that the Chinese Communist Party has been
trying to shut them down since their inception they're showing what China used to be and they're
trying to revive the traditional culture of the Chinese people Chinese Communist Party has been
trying to eliminate this culture and now Shen Yun has been growing across the globe and they're
performing everywhere in a lot of different countries let me show you a quick trailer for
what Shen Yun looks like this year performance that truly matters each and every one of us
this is what you've been waiting for
Shen Yun get tickets now at ShenYun.com
now Tony what's your solution to this okay study after study has shown that
tenants 85 90 percent of the tenants the most important thing to them is is home ownership
trying to get home ownership and that goes a long way to creating a harmonious relationship
between property owners and tenants one way to do this in 2002 I tried it with the city and
county of San Francisco through an initiative prop r the solution is to allow owners of multi-unit
buildings 10 20 30 40 units to sell those units as deeded home ownership units voluntarily only
to the tenants that want to buy them to the tenants that are there now that exist now
they'll have the option of buying that unit as a deeded home ownership unit so how does this work
okay if you're the owner of a building and you've had that building for years you know that the
value of that unit as an apartment on the open market and this is proven because in the last
two years has been about five to six thousand apartment units sold through apartment buildings
the average cost is about 350 to 500 000 for an apartment the average cost for a condo in San
Francisco is about a million to a million two so if that unit can be sold only to the tenant that
occupies it on a voluntary basis and the tenant wants to buy it on a voluntary basis the tenants
getting a bargain the tenants able to buy that unit and it's a home ownership unit now what
happens well the whole concept of home ownership start to kick in you build equity on that unit
San Francisco property keeps going up as it does in most cities you're establishing equity you take
pride of ownership you want better streets better maintenance better schools you're also going to
pay taxes so it increases the tax base to the city to help satisfy its deficit budget it increases
the tax base but the whole concept of home ownership kicks in and it's a lot different than
rent slavery which is what they're creating with housing mandates and SB 79 they're creating rent
slavery I'm trying to create home ownership which builds people up the ladder so
tenants really make out under this deal the property owner makes out because they have a
long-term investment that now they can see we can get returns from that and put it in other
investments don't forget the property owners of these multi-unit structures are under tremendous
rent control punitive laws they can't do a darn thing with their property that rent control
doesn't dictate if they're allowed to sell those units at least they can get a return on their
investment and put it elsewhere it might make the difference between their end of life care
they're able to capitalize on their investment and it certainly makes a difference to the tenants
who cannot afford a mortgage on a million two condo or a single family home at a million and a
half to two so so essentially the way we work it will be a discount on a condo yes but to the
property owner because they can cash out each unit they can sell a bunch of these units that
it has value for them of course and for tenants if the tenant can buy it then they're gonna get
it at half the price oh yeah yeah and it's good for the property owner because right now their
buildings under rent control and they can't do anything with it they can't even paint it without
the approval of the tenants you know so it's a way for them to cash in on their investment
it's a win-win-win it's a win for the city because they get an increased tax base it's a win for the
tenant the tenant gets a tremendously discounted home ownership deeded unit that on the open market
would sell for two or three times it's a way to get a piece of the rock to share in the equity
that property owners by the way studies have shown that home ownership is provided about 40
times the wealth that tenants have through equity and i'm not i'm not a multiple unit owner i have
nothing to gain by this this is a plan that i along with several other people developed in 2002
in san francisco and it wasn't the tenants that defeated it the tenants love it property owners
love it it's a win-win-win at the anti-poverty anti-home ownership anti-private property
advocates they're the ones that don't like it do you think california doesn't need more units or
do you think that the cost is too high to build well both both the cost is ridiculous today
building costs are very expensive i meet even gavin newsom and it's carrying out you know his
housing for the poor was estimating five years ago four years ago building costs at 750,000 a
unit it's now about a million a million two to build the average unit if you're asking the
builder to absorb additional inclusionary units for less affordable people it doesn't pencil out
that's why it's not going on yes we need housing but we need the right type of housing and the
right type of housing is housing that provides an eventual path for home ownership absolutely
but there's no evidence to support two and a half million new upmarket rental units being built no
there's no evidence so what you're saying essentially is that the cost of the housing
that we're building is already too high and that's not gonna change the affordability if
we build a lot more yes cost of labor in california is very high cost of materials is
very high you can't expect these builders to do it for nothing yeah we need new units but we need
home ownership that's why people have left the state that's why people are leaving san francisco
i've got children that have moved to nevado because they can't afford a house in san francisco
they may have been able to afford the apartment that they were living in if someone was allowed
to sell it to them and then they could use that as a starter home if it was a deeded unit but no
they go to nevada they go to santa rosa they go wherever where the housing prices are are less
would they be interested to to own a home like that oh absolutely that's the goal of 85 to 90
percent of the tenants in california is to own a piece of the rock let's give it to them let's
work for it let's not give them more high-end rentals that they can't afford people choose to
live in certain areas because and your your house it's most important investment you're going to
make is an average blue-collar worker teacher fireman your house is your biggest investment
of your life along with that comes where you're living you want to live in a nice neighborhood
preferably california historically is the preferred single-family neighborhoods with
good schools that are safe well home ownership goes a long way to to working towards that
rental rentals don't you mentioned that this housing is is rental but the state hasn't specified
they said we want to be interesting interesting that they haven't specified it since they know
so much about housing and they want they're willing to say you you have new zoning laws new
planning laws we're overriding all that since they know so much about that why aren't they
talking about that why aren't they talking about affordability why aren't they saying
well of infrastructure since they know so much why aren't they talking about our infrastructure
needs we're getting older our infrastructure is getting older cmac you can't address these
problems without addressing the the root causes the root things that stop it affordability is a
big issue infrastructure big issue it says nothing about that all it says is we're going to allow you
to build more units we're going to allow you if you're neither a transit stop you can go up four
stores five stories whatever it's not right it's one shoe fits all throughout the state do you
think people in la jolla carmel monterey they're going to like this they've got eight different
jurisdictions have filed suit against this housing uh mandate element the housing element
mandate they're not getting anywhere the only way to to mitigate the damage now is to file suit
uh the mayor of san francisco i heard him talk uh just about a week and a half ago
nice guy very nice guy well-meaning says we can get hit with damages big big damages
they're going to keep transportation money away from us they're going to keep school money to
keep this if you don't do the up so if we don't because the cities are getting punished by the
city's going to get punished if they don't follow this i don't think so uh mayor lorry
mr newsom's running for the white house he is not going to punish his hometown of san francisco
san francisco has the lowest ratio of homeowners of any city in the country
now we go to christopher elmendorf who thinks that san francisco needs more housing
sp79 changes pretty dramatically uh what is allowed to be built near transit stations
so transit stations are defined as as railway stations or a bus operating in a dedicated lane
if you're within a quarter or a half mile of the transit station the cities have to allow a lot
more housing on those sites and senate bill 79 takes effect in a staggered fashion so it will go
into effect uh on july 1 of next year but cities have the option of delaying how much new housing
is allowed under sp79 if they've already done some regulatory reforms to allow housing near transit
so if san francisco passes what is now being called the mayor's family zoning plan
that will allow san francisco to delay implementation of sp79 in some areas
there is some concern from people that this kind of upzoning will impact the communities in san
francisco and san francisco will not be the same because if there's a lot of developments these
unique neighborhoods will change what are your thoughts on that i mean i think it's correct
that neighborhoods will change gradually they're not going to change overnight though and most of
the change that will occur is going to occur along commercial boulevards on larger parcels
i don't think we'll see much change in lower density residential neighborhoods largely for
two reasons one there are very stringent restrictions on redevelopment of any site
in which there is rent controlled housing or a lower income tenant second on sites where there
is an existing single family home those single family homes are incredibly valuable as single
family homes and so developers just can't make much money or there's no reasonable prospect of
developers making much money by tearing down single family homes and turning them into apartment
buildings so you think the math is not there to develop these buildings at this point no
is it because of the cost of construction you mentioned the cost of the land well there's a
couple of things one cost is the value of the existing use so if you're talking about an old
garage on a commercial corridor the value of existing use is very low so that's a prime site
for development if you're talking about a single family home in a fancy neighborhood that's worth
four million dollars tearing down that existing use is is an incredible loss and so the developer
would have to be able to make up that loss with the new project and there's just not much prospect
of doing that at this at this point so in your opinion there's not going to be much development
even despite all of this upzoning and sp79 well if you look at the city economist report
the city economist report forecasts that the mayor's plan the mayor's rezoning plan would
lead to something like 14,000 new homes over 20 years and that's a far cry from
80,000 new homes over six years now is the mayor's plan legally sufficient i think there's a lot of
doubt about that at this point and the city may have to do other things to reduce the cost of
development the city has a real estate transfer tax which falls very heavily on new apartment
buildings so the city may have to repeal or reduce that transfer tax the city also depending
on what part of the city you're in charges very high fees on new development some of those fees
may have to be reduced and finally the city has what it calls inclusionary zoning requirements
that require developers to set aside a certain percentage of the units and new projects as
housing that will be sold or rented at below market rates and that's effectively an in-kind
tax on the project right it's not a tax the developer pays in money to the city but it's
a tax the developer pays because they lose a lot of money on those so-called inclusionary
or affordable units and so they have to be able to make a lot of money on the other units for
the project to tensile out what about the infrastructure we heard that this could put a
toll on the infrastructure of the city is that a concern so i have not seen anything that suggests
the city doesn't have adequate infrastructure the major problems the city is facing right now
as i see it are loss of enrollment in the schools declining school enrollment so that's infrastructure
namely schools that is underutilized and declining transit ridership which is infrastructure trains
that are underutilized so having more people would actually be very good for the city's existing
educational infrastructure and transit infrastructure in terms of the housing costs we have heard from
some people that the population of the city has dropped if that's true why does the housing cost
not go down in san francisco i think that indicates there's very high demand to live in san francisco
the population of city went down during the pandemic when a lot of people were working
from home and my understanding is that as people have returned to work in the office at least
part-time the population of the city is rebounding how should the city solve this problem because the
housing costs are significantly higher in san francisco compared to the incomes like it's
very high how could the city solve this problem okay so a couple of points first the fact that
housing prices are high relative to incomes is in some sense a indication of the success of
the city's rent control program the city's rent control program has allowed long-time residents
to remain in the city if they stay in their existing units despite their incomes being
not enough to afford the current market rents second point is that the housing shortage is not
a san francisco specific problem it's a regional problem so san francisco is not an island the
south bay the east bay marin it's all a connected region and so for housing prices to come down
every part of the region needs to allow more housing to be developed and the point of the
regional planning framework or the point of state laws like sb 79 is not is to say we're not going
to just change the rules in one city at one moment in time we're going to change the rules across the
region and if everyone does their part then that will help to moderate housing costs so do you
think other regions are going to develop or do you think they have the same issues as san francisco
does with the you mentioned the housing the cost the transfer tax and does the math work in other
areas around san francisco or do you think they have similar well i think changes are needed
and i think changes are coming some of the changes may come as cities implement their
housing plans other changes may come from the state legislature so we've heard several state
legislators say now that we've changed zoning we need to attack the cost of building and what will
be coming from the legislature to attack the cost of building i don't know yet but i think that's
certainly an issue that the legislature understands is important and will be addressed so when we talk
to some of the critics of what's happening with upzoning and sp79 their criticism came from the
fact that they know that there's not going to be development but they they're concerned that
non-profits will come and then this will become a non-profit like kind of like social housing type
development what are your thoughts on that i think there will be some some non-profit development
i think that is very likely to happen i have not seen that publicly stated as a major concern i
would certainly be interested to see who is saying that i mean you just mentioned tony hall as one
person but the reality is that it would cause billions of dollars billions and billions and
billions of dollars to develop social housing at scale and i just don't see california putting
that kind of money into it you shouldn't look at this reform in isolation from everything else
i think we will see this reform followed up by changes to the transfer tax i think we'll see this
reform followed up by changes to the affordability mandates possibly changes to impact fees
i also think we're seeing a lot of growth in the artificial intelligence sector that's pushing up
rents that's going to make more market rate development economically feasible how do you
think the next steps will go from here the mayor's family zoning plan will come to a vote at the board
of supervisors in early december it does not look like it is a sufficient plan to comply with the
city's rezoning obligations so according to the city economist report a city economist projects
that it's going to yield 14,000 new units over 20 years under an optimistic assumption about
the course of of rents so there may be litigation over whether the plan is sufficient there may be
some kind of communication from the state housing agency indicating the city has to do
more and then the city may do something more like i said to make development more economically
feasible and i certainly think anybody who is concerned that there'll be too much social housing
and not enough market rate housing developed should turn their attention to the question of
what is it in terms of the city's regulations that is making market rate housing economically
difficult to develop but if you step back from a moment it's a strange thing to be in a city that
has something like the third highest rents of any city in the country and for developers not to be
able to make money building market rate housing right that's peculiar isn't it let us know what
you think about the upzoning and sp79's impact in san francisco you can always comment or email
we read all of your emails and comments i'm siamak korami this is california insider we'll see you
next time
