Rafa Honigstein on Spurs’ Big Signings: Xavi Simons, Kolo Muani & Kane at Bayern

Xavi Simons
7 followers
Nov 25, 2025
Join us for an in-depth chat with renowned Bundesliga journalist Rafa Honigstein as we break down Spurs’ summer window through a German football lens. We start with the headline arrival Xavi Simons (~£50m) — where he fits now, how he complements (or eventually replaces) Maddison, and why Leipzig were willing to sell despite his outrageous talent.
Delighted to be joined once again by broadcaster and journalist Rafa Honigstein.
Rafa, thanks so much for coming on again.
Absolute pleasure.
So a number of our summer window signings of Bundesliga connections,
but we're going to start with the biggest one, probably the most exciting.
After the Gibbs-White saga, the Ezeh saga, the massive hole in our midfield against Bournemouth,
we signed Xavi Simons for about 50 million.
What are we getting? What can we expect?
You get huge talent and huge versatility.
This is a guy who can play in a number of positions.
He's really a number 10, but if you play him on the inside left, on the inside right,
maybe even as a very attacking eight, he can do all these jobs,
maybe one day a force nine as well.
So it solves a lot of problems for any team looking for creativity,
for the ability to go past players opening space by himself, a great passer as well.
Absolute talent, absolute quality.
What's lacking is a little bit of consistency.
That's the reason why Leipzig were okay with the idea of selling.
I mean, they are a selling club at this level,
but I think in this particular case, they quite wanted him to be gone.
And there were one or two issues where stories were, I think,
planted or perhaps strategically leaked that bad-mouthed him a little bit.
But I don't think that should be too much of a concern.
He's 22 and there's a lot of progress still to be made,
a lot of development, both on and off the pitch for him.
And did we gazump Chelsea or was that a bit of a known story?
I don't know if it was gazumping in the sort of traditional sense that you outbid them.
I think it was more of a case that the proposal in the sporting terms was probably quite very clear.
There is, as you said, a big hole in Spurs' midfield and that creative area in the absence
of Maddison. And I expect that the pitch was from Frank, we need you to play that role.
Whereas at Chelsea, I think they would have found it harder to say to him,
you are in this position, you're going to start and you're going to be
the guy who's going to play the next 45 games for us because of the, what's the best word,
the abundance of Chelsea players. You can play in similar roles.
So I think it was probably more of a straightforward pitch to him.
But I wasn't part of the negotiation, so I'm just speculating.
You mentioned James Maddison there, obviously before his injury Spurs appeared to be looking
for a player of that kind of profile. Gibbs White obviously didn't end up happening.
We don't have the luxury of worrying about whether Simonds and Maddison can play together for a year
and it's a squad game, obviously. But do you think this is the kind of deal that was accelerated
because of Maddison's injury, because there wouldn't be a natural fit for the pair of them?
Or is there a world where the two of them could dovetail together in a team in a year's time?
I think this has to be looked at independently. I think Spurs were in the market for a player who
would either complement or eventually supplant Maddison in that role. Because I think you could
see Maddison last year, huge impact when he was on the pitch, but probably not quite able to
deliver physically every three days. So I think Spurs, independently of his injury,
were looking for somebody who could at least share some of the burden, if not take over from
him in a year's time. The fact that the injury might have made it a more pressing concern
played a role, but I think they were always in the market for that kind of player independently.
And I don't think it's at the forefront of their mind or of Thomas Funken's mind whether they can
play together or not. I think it's more a case of we need that kind of player and we need him
once every 10 days or until December and then energy might drop or we might worry that he can't
keep fit. We need somebody who can do this for the next three or four years. And I think that
explains both the Gibbs-White and the As It Pursued pursuit and the eventual signing of Simmonds.
Do you think he's physically up to it? All the Spurs fans have posted him robbing Declan Rice
in the Euro semi-final and smashing one into the top corner. You said he's versatile. Obviously,
Maddison's out. He's probably going to play 10 to start with. Do you see him as a winger as well,
or do you think 10 would be his best position? Well, first of all, I think physically he's not
going to be the bulkiest and biggest of players on the pitch. And I don't think this will change.
And I don't think you would do much of a service to insist that he should suddenly pack another
five, six kilos in muscle. I think he solves problems the way other technical players in the
Premier League fluent vids eventually. But I'm thinking of Bernardo and these kind of players
have done it for many years. It's just through skill and just by being quicker and being harder
to get the ball off. He's not going to necessarily, I think, fly into tackles, but you don't want him
to. That's not his game. But he can be very effective as a presser. I think in the right
context, he's a hard worker. The reason why perhaps there wasn't even a bigger market for him,
and by bigger, I mean, let's say Real Madrid or Bayern Munich. Actually, Bayern is a different
story because some people at Bayern wanted to sign him. But let's say Barcelona or this kind of club
in for him was because his form really suffered last year. And I think it suffered because Leipzig
as a whole suffered. And he wasn't able to swim against the tide and keep his performances at a
level that weren't impacted by the overall drop off in quality. And then his body language and
his kind of frustration boiled over at times. And I think maybe it might have scared one or two people
off. But the quality is there. And as I said, I don't think he's ever going to be a winger in the
sense. But if you play with players who come inside, who start in a wide position to drift
inside or start in the half spaces, he's your man. And I think he adds a lot of nuance and
creativity to what can be a little bit slightly sort of formulaic spurs attack at times. You don't
have that kind of player or you haven't had that kind of player for a while. And I think it's going
to be really good. Another player linked with Bayern but came to Spurs. This was on deadline day,
Randall Colomawane. He's not really found a home since he left Nantes. He had a really good season
in Frankfurt, went to PSG, had a loan at Juve. Hasn't really settled. What do you make of him?
Fantastic talent again. I think the move to PSG probably came slightly at the wrong time. He was
always going to be marginalised by other players, certainly Mbappe when he arrived. And
he couldn't do what he is best, which is to be, in my view, a number nine. He's not your number
nine target man, number nine, but he's a number nine that is incredibly quick, runs through the
channels, holds off the ball if he has to, but otherwise can play on the shoulder and can play
football as well. So I think that is actually a really fantastic signing. I think a lot of clubs
could have done with signing him. There was a lot of demand for strikers in the market,
and to get him without an obligation to buy at minimal risk is, I think, a real coup.
He needs to find his form again. He needs to find a bit of confidence again.
You need to play to his strengths. I think Frank might have to mix it up a little bit. I don't see
him being the right man for being too direct in the sense of going long and high early. You can
send him long diagonally, but I think he's better off when you approach as a unit and then play the
final pass with him making a run off the shoulder of the last defender or in between the defender
and the fullback. That's his game. But in terms of pure talent, in terms of finishing and all sorts
of stuff, a really, really good player. I think it's a really, really great signing.
Yeah, I only realised yesterday that he's an Emiliano Martinez shin pad away from being a
national hero and the match winner of maybe one of the best games of all time. I wonder if that's
emblematic of a lot of what he's had in the last few years, that he's just missing that moment of
being in the right place at the right time for it all to work, because the ability does appear to
be there. I suppose having a whole year at Tottenham might be the spark that can give him
the push on to the next level. Yeah, I think that's certainly the thinking on his behalf.
Spurs are banking on him to develop. I think it is going to be new for him. We've seen
with all the centre-forwards that have come into the league this year, there is a bit of a betting
in process. Even the ones who have scored goals look as if they're still a bit learning on the
job, especially if they're younger. I think centre-forwards, it's one of my pet theories,
take a little bit longer to mature anyway. I think it takes until they're 25, 26 before they
really become the fully formed version of themselves and real class players. There are so
many looking back who weren't quite at that level when they were 21, 22. I think a bit of patience
is in order, but I think there's a huge opportunity if Spurs look after him well and develop him.
There's always a slight danger that if you come in as a lone player, that even if it's just
subconsciously, you're not treated with the same kind of love and care as if you're
somebody who's under contract and the club is more directly invested in your progress.
You could argue if it goes too well, then Spurs lose out in a way because they have
no automatic way of keeping him, I think. I expect him to be a big role in what looks
like a very exciting team. I don't want to say all of a sudden, but I think the transfer window
has been very good for Spurs and I can understand why everyone's very excited, especially with a
new manager at the helm.
And two players have come directly from Bayern, Gio Pallinia, Matisse Tell, two players at the
sort of different ends of their careers, really. Talk to us about them. Pallinia, we've spoken
before to other journalists on here that it just didn't work out for him at Bayern. What about
Tell? Just too many good young players and he was one that just didn't make the grade?
Tell had a lot of backing and support within the club because he's such a
nice guy and he was so committed to Bayern. He's the kind of guy, I always tell that story,
who on his day off goes and watches the under-19, which is rare at this level.
Everyone absolutely loved him and wanted him to succeed. I think because his starting times
were a little bit limited because of the number, not so much of the young players,
but the number of wingers that were still there at that time. There was Sané, there was Coman,
there was Ulisse in his last year with Bayern.
Nabri as well, was he in the way?
Nabri, of course, and sometimes Muller would play wide. He was like the fifth or sixth starter
and up front Harry Kane played throughout. When they did try him as a number nine, when
Mane was still there, it didn't quite work out either. He lacked a little bit of the
kind of number nine killer instinct. Then when he came on, he always seemed to try a little bit
too hard. I think you've seen that at Spurs as well. He shoots a lot and looks very busy and
very dangerous, but sometimes makes the wrong decisions. I'm really sad that he's not picked
for the Champions League squad. It's a real shame that we don't see him develop further,
but I guess it just shows how good Spurs now are that they can leave somebody like this out.
I really hope that he can still make it, but I guess the biggest problem that he has,
he's a hybrid player. He's not really a centre-forward and he's not really a winger.
That is great for a lot of teams because he can play these roles effectively, but he can't
quite play either well enough to be an automatic starter at the really top-class team
at the moment. He might still become that player, but at the moment he can't displace a pure
forward and he can't displace a pure winger. Number 10, I don't really see him there either.
That's been his biggest issue, but I hope that his fortunes will change and that he still
fulfils his potential. Paulinho has a really interesting story because here's a player that
Thomas Tuchel went out of his way to get into Bayern. Thomas Tuchel was super political about
this and started his first full season in pre-season saying that all the existing
midfielders are not good enough to be a holding midfielder and none of them can play that role.
That's why we need Paulinho brackets. The effect was that Goretzka and Gnabry and Leimer all weren't
best pleased by Tuchel's public insistence that they couldn't play their roles effectively,
at least not in a defensive sense. And then of course, calamity, because on the last day of the
transfer window, with Paulinho already being at Bayern holding up the shirt,
Fulham said, no, the deal is off. So it took Bayern another 12 months to get him in,
at which point Tuchel had lost the dressing room and was no longer there. And the club felt,
having come so far with Paulinho, we should get him in almost to honour our commitment to him.
But the new coach, Vincent Kompany, finding very quickly that he doesn't need that type of pure
defensive midfielder because Bayern have so much possession and need everyone to be really
attacking in a sense that they think forward, pass forward, move forward.
And especially with the fact that they play a man-marking system off the ball, which makes it
then really hard for somebody like Paulinho to cover 60 metres running behind some other guy
who runs off him. He's a victim of the system, if anything, that Kompany has completely changed
from Tuchel, who was very reactive sitting back. And I can understand why in a different context,
in a much more defined, narrow role, he can be super effective. But at Bayern, that role doesn't
exist as long as Kompany is there. And at Spurs, I think it's a very different setup.
Frank is a much more pragmatic coach who wants to soak up pressure at times,
and Paulinho does a fantastic job being that ball-winner in front of the back four.
I suppose we can't have you on and not talk about Harry Kane. I think it's 91 goals in 100 games.
At the time, as Spurs fans, it felt like we were the only people in the world when he played for
us supporting him. Even England fans would look for any excuse to put Dominic Calvert-Lewin in
the team, which would have been an interesting experiment, I think, to say the least.
Has he surprised Bayern Munich supporters, officials or whatever, in just how good he's
been, particularly in taking on the mantle of replacing a legend like Lewandowski?
Difficult to say if they're surprised or not, but I think they're in awe of him. They're in
awe of him because his finishing is superb, we know that. His passing is ridiculous.
We tried to sell everyone.
Yeah, we did.
And this, I think, is the biggest thing. If Bayern, as they were 3-2 up at Augsburg on
Saturday night, and the opposition throw everything at them in a last-ditch effort to
get an equaliser, you see Harry Kane showing up in the left-back position, making a challenge,
diving in. And to see that from a centre-forward at this level is just incredible. He is so
important defensively as well as offensively, hugely influential by just simply being a role
model. He's not one for big, rousing speeches or knocking people over the head, but just
quietly shows everyone the kind of standard that you need to have at this level.
And I think what's often overlooked when people say, oh, you went to Bayern to win titles, is I
think he really went to Munich to be at a club where nothing but winning is good enough, because
I think that that is him. And of course, you're surrounded by players who have been brought up
and have the quality to win every single game they're playing at any level. And I think it's
lifted him, even though it's difficult to improve on his base level, which is already high, I think
it's lifted him even further. And as long as he's fully fit, and he had a few issues with his back
and didn't look quite right at the Euros, but as long as he's fully fit, he is just a marvel.
And the Bayern fans are incredibly happy that he's there. The one thing that's holding him
back for being in legendary status is the sense that I think they know he cannot be a Thomas
Muller who's going to be there for another six, seven years and speak Bavarian and wear lederhosen
on his day off. There is a sense that he's there to do a job, and then once the job is done,
he will move on again. So they're almost not allowing themselves to fall in love with him.
Just as they did with Lewandowski, where there was also a sense that Lewandowski was amazing,
but was there to score goals rather than to see Bayern win. I think Kane is different in the
sense that he thinks about the team first. You will not see him happy if he scores two goals,
but Bayern lose three too. A lot of centre-forwards would be, he's not, and they appreciate that.
But I think there's also a sense that this is not going to last forever. And therefore,
let's enjoy him, but not fall over, head over heels in terms of the emotional connection with
him. Well, that was going to be my next question. He has scratched the itch. Yes, he wanted to go
to a club where winning is everything and he's done it. He didn't want to be the best player
ever to never win anything. He's done it. When do you think it ends with him? And where do you think
it goes? Could he come back to Spurs, MLS? What do you reckon? Well, I never really got to the
bottom of it, but there are suggestions that there's a release clause that kicks in again
next summer for around 80 million, which is not cheap, but it's also not crazy money, especially
if the market continues the way it did. And it's down to him, of course, if he wants to go or see
out his contract. I don't see him renewing necessarily at Bayern. I think 27 is probably
going to be the day when he leaves. And then who knows? Very difficult to predict. I think
Bayern, he would have noticed that Bayern thought about bringing in a big center forward this year.
They thought about Benjamin Shashko. Of course, now at the very end of the transfer market,
even it's only a loan with an obligation that is unlikely to kick in.
It shows that Bayern are beginning to think beyond Kane. At this moment,
it's more of a replacement on the odd game that he misses or a chance for him to play maybe in
a deeper role at times when you need to freshen things up, especially as long as
not available. But there is nothing so far that suggests that Bayern are in any
hurry to move him on. And I think he's very settled and happy in Munich as well.
So from a buying perspective, long may it continue.
Looking at the Champions League now, we renew our rivalry or whatever it's called with Borussia
Dortmund, who we appear to face every two or three years as kind of a timeshare.
We've obviously seen a number of different Dortmund teams from the Flair and the sort of
Aubameyang teams and the Marco Reus teams. What can we expect from this current Dortmund team?
Because it seems that they're quite a different outfit to what we've faced in the past.
Yeah, it's hard to kind of pigeonhole it because it's still a team that I think is moving in the
kind of direction that Nico Kovac, the manager, wants them to be. They finished really strongly
last year to finish in the Champions League. They had a decent Club World Cup, but there's
still a question of whether his kind of more reactive setup, often with a back three and
hitting the front players quite quickly, is the kind of football that will help you break down
the smaller teams and have the kind of dominance that you need if you really want to be
at least a number two in German football. Dortmund so far have looked
underwhelming in those first few games. They've really struggled to open up teams.
I don't know. I think in Europe it probably will suit them better to be able to soak up the
pressure and then go long. They have real quality and pace, especially with Ademey.
He can deal damage and Guirassi is no slouch either, and the two of them can really hurt
any team, but it doesn't have the kind of dominance and awe factor around them,
especially in central midfield. They're a little bit prosaic, and this is not an all-time great
with the Dortmund team. This is also not a Dortmund team that has at least one superstar.
In the past, you would have said, okay, Dortmund is all about Jadon Sancho,
it's all about Erling Haaland, it's all about Jude Bellingham.
Now they have Joe Bellingham, but he's not quite at Jude level, and there is no one really
where you think this is going to be the next superstar in European football
who carries Dortmund over the next year or two. It doesn't quite exist at this point.
And what about Eintracht? No one silences the Eintracht crowd in Tottenham Hotspur,
but they've lost Ekotika, they've lost Marmouge. Is it another season of recycling for Eintracht?
Yeah, absolutely. They bought a lot of players who maybe move on now for a lot of money in next year
or the year after. Again, they've been very, very good in the market.
Marcus Kröscher, the Sporting Director, really one of the best.
Some great scouts that he worked with at RB Leipzig, he took with him into the Frankfurt job,
and they have a real eye for quality players. It's not going to be easy to make everything gel,
especially if you don't have time to train with the Champions League coming around so quickly.
It's hard to say how good they are. They've looked convincing so far in the Bundesliga
against the kind of opposition that you'd expect them to beat, but bigger tests are coming.
The Champions League is tough for them because they have really a pretty hard draw. But as you
know from, I think, having gone to Frankfurt, the crowd there is just absolutely amazing.
On a par with Dortmund these days in terms of noise and support, even away from home,
they pull huge numbers, and they will hope to create that same energy, to be bigger than some
of their parts. But I must say I fear a little bit for the German teams this year. Not so much
for Bayern. They have their first 12, 13 players available. They're going to be one of the
challenges, at least, for the title. But Frankfurt are in transition. Dortmund are
not yet fully settled on what they want to become or what Niko Kovac wants them to be.
And Dever Kuzn just fired their manager after two days of league football.
That's going to be difficult as well, with a wholly new team as well. Of the team that won
the double, I think you have three starters left. I think it might be a tough one for the German
teams this year. You mentioned the atmosphere over in Germany. We've got, we're laden with
cash in the Premier League. We all know that. We're cherry-picking players from all around the
world, whoever we want, whenever we want. But as a fan that goes to games, I think there's probably
never been a less enjoyable time to be a regular fan. The atmospheres aren't great, and I do think
people look enviously across the Bundesliga at the crowds and the 51% ownership from a fan
perspective. Is there any jealousy or envious eyes coming back the other way, where German fans
think, well, we'd love all that money? Or are they sort of happy with what they've got? It feels
like both could, would love to take a few bits from the other league to improve their own.
Yeah, I think if you ask the sort of organised fans, I think they probably insist that they
don't want it to be any different. They're fighting a fight to keep everything as it is.
It's quite a conservative movement, if you will. They don't want change. They don't want investment.
They don't want to lose that sense of identity. And if that means selling your best players, they
are, at this moment, happy to pay that price, rather than lose that identity and lose that
touch with the club. But this is because it's always been like that. And England has never
been like that, in a way. Because even the origins of football, going back 150 years, you had clubs
set up as companies, and they were owned by the local owner of the manufacturing business,
knitting skirts together. And he decided, with his investment, whether you were a good club or a bad
club. And people are kind of used, it's intrinsic in English football. In Germany, it's not, it's
still very alien. And the groundswell of opinion, I think, with the organised fans is they don't want
it to change. Now there are people who are sort of more neutral, or a little bit more detached from
the ultra group and say, look, it's a shame that the biggest economy in Europe plays football with
two arms tied behind their back of their own volition. If we were to open ourselves up,
imagine if both German industry and people from all over the world would come into the German
market, buying shares in Bayern Munich, Hamburg, and so on. They could blow a lot of leagues out
of the water. But it's not happening because nobody really wants it to happen. I think this
summer was a bit of an eye opener, just how dominant the Premier League is after maybe a
couple of years where people thought PSR seems to frighten everyone. Nobody seems to talk about
it much anymore, at least not for most clubs. And the Bundesliga are wondering, you know,
can we even keep our players a couple of years? We know that once players reach a certain level,
then unless you buy Munich, they're going. But now they only have six months of a good season,
in the case of Walter Marder with 12 goals, and suddenly he's at Newcastle for 90 million euros.
So that's going to make things a little bit awkward if that continues in the long run.
But as of today, I think the Bundesliga see the product as you will. The product
is really geared still in a greater sense towards their local customers. And the local customers are
king. And selling abroad and making it as most exciting for worldwide audience is just not at
the forefront of these clubs' agenda. Because again, 50 plus one forces them to pay real
attention to their local fans. Because if they don't, these guys can be voted out.
Again, it might really surprise your listeners. But even if by Munich, if the fans aren't happy
with the way things are going, in theory, it doesn't happen very often. But in theory,
they can stand up somebody else as a president, and the president who's there now has to leave.
Now, yeah, no club. Yeah, that creates its own issues. And sometimes makes clubs very political
makes them very hard to make the right sporting decisions because of the politics involved. You
have clubs like Schalke and Hertha who have exactly that problem that the members are almost
too involved, and makes it very difficult to find kind of longevity and professionalism behind the
scenes. But it is just a very different footballing culture. Rafa, amazing to talk to you as always,
tapping your expertise. And I think we'll talk to you in May before Spurs play Bayern in the
I do have one more actually, if you know, Munich's a beautiful city, great for football tourism,
if Spurs fans want to go and see Harry Kane, if they do, this is the real important stuff.
Is Spatenhaus still the number one Schnitzel in the city?
Spatenhaus is still very, very good, as you know, firstly, having sampled the local fair there.
It is a bit touristic because it's right in the centre of town. But the standard of Schnitzel
and there are one or two that are perhaps more undercover and more frequented by locals. But
if you're just coming in and you want your cast iron fantastic Munich Schnitzel experience,
Spatenhaus is like Harry Kane from the penalty spot. 99%
foolproof. I see an Adam Nathan Rafa Honigstein Echo of Glory Schnitzel special in Munich going on.
James, we're gonna get that sorted. Rafa, brilliant. Thanks so much for joining us.
