Meet The Press NOW | NBC News NOW A federal judge dismisses the cases against former FBI Director James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James, ruling that the prosecutor was unlawfully appointed. Rep. Mike Kennedy (R-Utah) joins Meet the Press NOW to weigh in on the ongoing health care debate. The Pentagon opens an investigation into Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.), citing “serious allegations of misconduct.”
00:00 Judge dismisses cases on Comey and James 12:37 Trump administration refines its message on affordability 22:29 One-on-one with Rep. Mike Kennedy (R-UT) 30:58 Pentagon launches investigation into Sen. Kelly after video telling troops to refuse illegal orders 35:31 U.S. and Ukraine meet in Geneva for peace talks 40:32 Panel discussion on James Comey, Letitia James, Zohran Mamdani and Majorie Taylor Greene
Hi there, welcome to meet the press now. I'm Ryan Nobles in Washington and we
begin with breaking news and a major setback for the Justice Department's
prosecution of two of President Trump's political opponents. A federal judge
today dismissing the cases against former FBI Director James Comey and
current New York Attorney General Letitia James. U. S. District Judge
Cameron Curie ruling that the government's top prosecutor in those
cases, acting U. S. Attorney Lindsay Halligan, who was a former personal
attorney to Donald Trump, has been serving in her post unlawfully. That
means the indictments that Halligan secured against the New York AG for
mortgage fraud and against Comey for allegedly making a false statement to
Congress and obstructing a congressional investigation are null and void. Both
Comey and James pleaded not guilty to their charges. The White House saying in
a statement that the facts of the indictment haven't changed and moments
ago, vowing to appeal today's dismissal. Lindsay Halligan was legally
appointed and that's the administration's position. I know
there was a judge who is clearly trying to shield Letitia James and James Comey
from receiving accountability. Uh, and that's why they took this unprecedented
action to throw away the indictments against these two individuals. But the
Department of Justice will be appealing very soon. And it is our position that
Lindsay Halligan is extremely qualified for this position, but more importantly,
was legally appointed to it.
Comey also responding, acknowledge acknowledging that his legal fight is
not over while maintaining his innocence. I'm grateful that the court
ended the case against me, which was a prosecution based on malevolence and
incompetence and a reflection of what the Department of Justice has become
under Donald Trump, which is heartbreaking. But I was also inspired
by the example of the career people who refused to be part of this travesty. I
know that Donald Trump will probably come after me again, and my attitude is
gonna be the same. I'm innocent. I am not afraid. And I believe in an
independent federal judiciary, the gift from our founders that protects us from
a would be tyrant.
Leticia James, meanwhile, said in a statement, quote, I'm heartened by
today's victory and grateful for the prayers and support that I've received
from around the country. I remain fearless in the face of these baseless
charges as I continue fighting for New Yorkers every single day. Joining me
now, NBC News legal affairs reporter Gary Grumbach, NBC News White House
correspondent Yamiche Alcindor and defense attorney and NBC News legal
analyst Misty Maris. All right, Gary, let's start with you. What was the
basis for Judge Curie's decision? So this is all about something called the
120 day rule. So there's 120 days between the time that a U. S. Attorney
is appointed and the time they must be confirmed by the U. S. Senate or they
have to get out of the job if they're not continued on by a district court
judge. With Eric Siebert, he was the original person that was put in the
position by President Trump when he first took office in January. He left
his job after not wanting to prosecute people like James Comey and Leticia
James, and the president appointed Lindsay Halligan. That 120 day rule
does not restart with Lindsay Halligan, and that is what this judge found
today, that it continues and that she was unlawfully appointed on September
22nd, and therefore her indictment James Comey on the 25th is unlawful. So
that does seem like a technicality. It's not necessarily about the merits of
the case, but kind of the process. What happens now? Are there more options for
the Department of Justice here? So as you saw Caroline Levitt say just
minutes ago, they are going to appeal this. It does. It does seem. But what's
interesting is that we went back and looked at some of the court records of
all the indictments that Lindsay Halligan has brought since September
22nd, and it turns out there are only two where she was the only person who
signed it. It was Leticia James and James Comey. So there are several other
indictments that she's made in the past few months that are signed by other
people in the office, which means they also agreed with the indictment and
those charges, and those will continue on. It's the two people that we're
talking about today that won't. So how does the appeal play itself out? So this
goes to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, and so this will be heard on the
merits. I'm sure sometime tonight we'll get an emergency stay to that Fourth
Circuit. Of course this could potentially end up in the Supreme Court. And of
course there is this statute of limitations, which was really just days
before when the charges were handed down, the statute of limitations was
about to expire. The fact that this indictment's been thrown out, does that
prevent them from being able to bring another indictment against? So there's a
real technicality here. It's called U.S. Code 3288, which if you're not familiar
with that, you'd be forgiven. It says in part, quote, whenever an indictment or
information charging a felony is dismissed for any reason after the
period prescribed by the applicable statute of limitations has expired, a
new indictment may be returned within six calendar months of the dismissal of
the indictment. So that means six calendar months from today, an indictment
could be brought. This is something that is absolutely going to play out in the
courts, because this is not something that happens very often. So this is
certainly a novel legal theory, and one that we'll see what happens over the
next few months. Okay, what could this mean for the broader, big picture of
several of these indictments that appear to be political motivated? So you're
seeing this across the country with the U.S. attorneys that have been perhaps
unlawfully appointed. You're seeing it in New Jersey with Elena Haba. You're
seeing it in Nevada, in California, all over the country. And what happened here
is going to be used as an example in those other states. Okay, Misty, let's
bring you in now and talk about it from the perspective of your legal expertise.
Both James Comey and Letitia James have other pending motions from their cases.
They argue that they were selective and vindictive prosecutions. Will those
motions still stand even if these dismissals are overturned? So these
motions at this point are actually moot. They have no bearing, because the
basis of this decision is that Lindsay Halligan's appointment was invalid, and
therefore those indictments are void. So from a technical legal perspective,
those motions don't exist because the case doesn't exist. I would expect that
if the case is resurrected, remember, this was a dismissal without prejudice
and Gary laid out some of the potential paths, the appellate path, as well as
potentially attempting to refile in that six-month window, those motions are
likely to be resurrected at this time. But at this point, there's no way the
judge is going to decide them, since technically those indictments do not
exist. They are voided by the fact that Halligan's appointment was invalid. And
talk to us about the significance about the fact that the judge dismissed them
without prejudice. What does that mean? So that means it leaves a door open. If
this has been with prejudice determination, the case is over, it's
done, it can never come back. But because it's without prejudice, it leaves an
opening for the Department of Justice to try and number one, potentially cure the
issue. So this would be what they're saying is a procedural issue, the 120 days
expired, but that Halligan is in fact qualified and therefore her appointment
should stand. So this would be the issue on appeal. Now, if they were to be
successful on that point, the question then becomes whether or not they're
barred by statute of limitations when it comes to Comey, refiling when it comes to
Letitia James. So all of these things are going to be at play. But because
it's without prejudice, that is absolutely a critical factor here. There
are avenues to continue to pursue these cases against Comey and James. Okay, but
what about Lindsay Halligan? If a judge is saying that she was unlawfully put in
the position as acting U. S. Attorney, can she continue to serve in that
capacity? She cannot. So her appointment right now is invalid. And what the court
order says is that it's now up to the Eastern District of Virginia. It's up
to the court to appoint that interim U. S. Attorney. So there will be a lot of
decisions to be made because one of these factors is while this appeal
plays out, this case is going to be in legal limbo. But we know that before
this case was ever brought, reporting indicates that other prosecutors did not
want to bring the case that they did not feel there was enough evidence. So will
we see a situation where in their prosecutorial discretion they choose
not to bring it? It really depends on which path plays out. You know, right
now we expect to see an appeal. You're going to see that stay. You're gonna see
that appellate issue likely asked to be expedited and potentially reaching the
Supreme Court. But as of now, the authority to appoint an interim
attorney, a U. S. Attorney lies with the court, not the executive branch. And
Gary raised a good point here. If you were representing a client being tried
in the Eastern District of Virginia right now, and there were a number of
cases that were being filed under Halligan's purview, would you be filing
a motion to have your case dismissed right now? Would you have any standing
there? Definitely, because your argument would be that her appointment was
invalid and therefore the exact same conclusion that the court came to in
this case is that the indictment itself was void. So I know Gary said there's
only two indictments where Halligan was the only U. S. Attorney that is going
to be the cases that will be at issue. The ones where she was the only one
presiding. Now, any case around the country, and I think there's several U.
S. Attorneys who are under the same scrutiny as far as process for their
interim appointments, like Alina Haba. This is another case that bolsters that
taking action on that front in any jurisdiction in any federal federal
jurisdiction where that issue is at play. Okay, Misty, thank you for that.
Obviously, a very important day in the courtroom. Let's turn now to you.
Misha was at the White House. Uh, you mean we got the the legal response to
all this? Let's talk about the political response. What's the White
House saying? The White House is really doubling down on these indictments. And
of course, we should all remind folks that they came after President Trump
publicly pressured Attorney General Pam Bondi to go after what he views as his
political enemies, naming a number of people, including Leticia James and
James Comey. So the White House officials I've been talking to have
been putting out this idea that these cases are not changing, that they do
expect to appeal, that nothing has changed other than the fact that they
have to redouble their efforts. I think, as Gary and Missy pointed out, this is
dismissed without prejudice, which means that the federal government can bring
these charges again. So the White House here is feeling like they're still on
firm ground to be able to bring these charges. And in some ways, they're going
after the judge. You heard the White House Press Secretary Caroline Levitt
say that she that the White House believes that Lindsey Halligan has been
appointed rightfully and legally. So they are going to absolutely be going
and going forward with an appeals process. If they said, though, how soon
that could happen and at what point would we expect this? And also, are
they going to fight to keep Lindsey Halligan in that role?
Those are good questions. We're not exactly sure of the timing, but White
House Press Secretary Caroline Levitt says that this is gonna happen pretty
soon. So we should imagine maybe today, maybe tomorrow. The White House has
been pretty fast when it comes to appealing decisions that it does not
like, including going to the Supreme Court if needed to appeal decisions. So
I imagine that that's what they're gonna do. And I also imagine that
Lindsey Halligan, who is, of course, also a former personal attorney to
President Trump, someone that he knows, someone that he handpicked to be in
that office, that he's gonna want to try to keep her in that position if he
can't, right? Okay. And Missy, let's go back to you quickly before we go. I
mean, how does the statute of limitations apply throughout all of
these cases? So this is really important, especially when it comes to
Comey. Remember, that indictment came in just on the eve of when the statute
of limitations was going to expire. So Gary referenced this rarely used law
that allows for prosecutors to bring the case back within six months. That's
generally used in the rare instances where there's a procedural defect.
Comey's team is arguing this isn't a procedural defect. It is void. So this
is a bit of a different argument that they will be raising when it comes to
the impact of the statute of limitations to say, even if Lindsey Halligan is
reinstalled as U. S. Attorney, even if the appeal is successful, that the
Department of Justice still under no circumstances can resurrect these
charges against Comey, a novel legal issue that will see play out in this
case. Okay, there is a lot of moving parts related to this that is gonna
have to play out here over the next six months or so. Yamiche, you're gonna
stick around with us, Gary and Missy. Thank you both for getting us started
on this breaking news. But coming up, we're gonna dive deeper into the
political fallout for the president and Republicans to the dismissal of these
indictments as the party also struggles on affordability issues. And
the president again lashes out at a group of Democrats calling for their
imprisonment. You're watching meet the press now.
Welcome back. It is the beginning of Thanksgiving week and gobble and waddle.
The turkeys who will be pardoned by President Trump have arrived here in
Washington D. C. But while the Trump administration is trying to paint a
rosy picture of the economy ahead of the holiday, many Americans are
feeling the pinch at the grocery store and facing sticker shock on health
insurance, with Congress yet to find a solution to the expiring Affordable Care
Act subsidies. I'll meet the press this weekend. Treasury Secretary Scott
Besson previewed a coming health care plan from the administration and argue
that the White House is making progress on all those all important issues
surrounding affordability.
Now we're starting to see the affordability way. The prices get
better. We had a very big October for home sales, energy prices, gasoline is
down. We saw, um, we believe health care is gonna come down. We will see an
announcement this coming week on that. And so across the board, prices are
starting to come down. And, Kristen, the one thing that we're not gonna do
is do what the Biden administration did and tell the American people they
don't know how they feel. They are traumatized and the over the Biden
inflation. We have slowed inflation, and we are working very hard to bring it
down.
But new polling suggests voters have a different view. 60% of Americans say
that President Trump describes prices and inflation as better than they
actually are, according to a new CBS News YouGov poll, with 65% saying his
policies are making the price of food and groceries go up. Nearly the same
percentage also disapproving of the president's handling of the economy.
Overall, rising food prices are just one piece of the puzzle. As you heard
the Treasury Secretary Besson, Republicans are working on a plan to
blunt the political impact of the rising cost of health care, potentially
looking to extend the ACA tax credits that were at the center of last month's
historically long government shutdown and incorporate a way to provide some
of those funds directly to enrollings. Joining me now from outside the White
House once again is NBC's Yamiche Alcindor, and on Capitol Hill is our
senior national political reporter Sahil Kapoor. Yamiche, last week,
President Trump posted that the only plan he would support would be one that
would send money directly to Americans. What's being floated now doesn't seem
to directly mesh with that. Has something changed, or are they still trying to
figure this out? They're still trying to figure this out, which is remarkable
because it has been almost a decade since the president has been going after
the Affordable Care Act and saying that he wanted to repeal and replace it. Today,
the White House press secretary said that the topic of health care comes up
quote, very frequently and very robustly around the White House and that the
president is very involved in that. But when she said, when she talked about the
details of that plan, she said she was going to leave that to the president to
discuss. And we know the president during a debate with former Vice
President Harris at one point said he had concepts of a plan. But so far,
there has not been a concrete plan. There's been some votes and reporting
floating out there about a possible plan that the White House might be
putting out at some point. But so far, we just have not seen any details,
which is again just remarkable when you think about this issue, Ryan. And does
the administration see health care closely tied to this larger issue of
affordability? That's what it sounds like. When you talk to White House
officials, I've talked to a number of them about this. They talk about health
care as, of course, being one of the most expensive parts of Americans lives.
So many people in this country, um, they are fearful about getting sick
because that could bankrupt families that we've heard so many horror stories
of insurance companies that don't want to pay for health care through our cost
of denial series at NBC News. We've heard through so many other situations
where people have lost their homes and other things just trying to get health
care. Um, that being said, the president, because he doesn't have an
exact plan, it's it's hard to say whether or not he sees that as sort of
connected to his promise to bring down costs, even though, of course, the
president was elected on that big promise of making America more
affordable to Americans. So White House officials in some ways connect these
issues, but also because there's no planet, it's hard to say whether or not
the president really sees this in the same vein as he sees gas prices or
grocery prices, Ryan. Yeah, and we did hear Secretary Besant say that they're
not going to repeat the mistakes of the Biden administration. But in the
face now of several weeks of bad polling on the economy, is there anyone
at the White House urging a shift in messaging around affordability? It's an
interesting one because at one point you did hear the Trump administration,
the second Trump administration sounding a bit like the Biden
administration when they were essentially trying to tell Americans
no, things aren't as bad as you think they are. Ignore the numbers that we're
seeing, even though we have concrete evidence that the cost of living in a
number of fronts has gone up with Americans and gone up for Americans.
That being said, the messaging right now at the White House is we're gonna be
working on it. Give us a little bit of time. But they're not, I think, at the
point where they're saying, don't believe your eyes anymore. But I think
that messaging shift is also sort of changing day to day because the
president in some is changing his mind day to day when he's looking at numbers
and polling. I'm also just thinking about sort of waste the messages to his
biggest supporters, right? All right, let's go to the other side of
Pennsylvania Avenue. Now, Sahil, what has been the reaction to these reports
of a health care plan on Capitol Hill? Some republicans have been against the
extension of these subsidies. Does this suggestion coming from the
administration ease their concerns? Well, Ryan, it was President Trump who
famously said in 2017 that nobody knew health care could be so complicated.
Eight years later, he is still struggling on this issue. Now, first
things first, Republican leadership on Capitol Hill was not expecting a policy
drop from the White House on health care. At least they weren't told that
it was coming. So this is a very fluid situation still. And no, nobody's
concerns are really going to be eased until they see what the White House has
in mind here. One of the reasons that the White House is struggling so much on
this issue is that Republicans are deeply divided about what to do on
health care with this cliff emerging. There are some Republicans who want to
unravel the ACA entirely, move the entire pot of funding, hundreds of
billions of dollars, toward other matters. There are others who say just take the
expiring funds, about thirty five billion dollars a year, and move them into things
like flexible savings accounts or HSAs. Yet other Republicans say do a one-year
extension of the ACA funding, maybe a two-year extension of the ACA funding,
maybe with strings attached. You've got President Trump saying do direct cash
payments, which is not going to be viable to a number of Republicans out
here. This all comes in the context of them knowing for an entire year that
this cliff was coming at the end of December. And they will be facing sharp
premium hikes, or dealing with Americans rather, who are facing sharp premium
hikes all over the country if they don't have a solution. They said it was not a
September problem, when it was a September problem, because that's when
insurance companies were setting rates. So it's been a struggle up and down the
board here, in terms of figuring this out. And Ryan, there is no leader, policy
leader here on Capitol Hill, who has the juice to really bring the the party
along, and make these difficult trade-offs that they have to make in
order to settle on a solution. But this also puts Democrats in a bit of a spot,
right? Because they made subsidies, the extension of these subsidies, the center
of their shutdown demands. If the president's willing to give on this a
little bit, aren't they forced to come to the table? Yeah, absolutely. I think
Democrats are in wait-and-see mode, in terms of, you know, what, if anything, the
White House is going to put out here. Take a look at this statement from
Senator Maggie Hassan, the New Hampshire Democrat, one of the most moderate in the
chamber. She would be the tip of the spear for any deal. She initially did
vote with her party on shutting down the government, but then voted to reopen it.
She says that they're waiting to see what exactly the president will put
forward. And she says, quote, while I have significant concerns about some of the
ideas reportedly in the president's proposal, it nonetheless represents a
starting point for serious negotiations, end quote. Now, she does say that she's
worried about any issues about repealing the ACA and its protections for
pre-existing conditions. You're going to hear a lot about this, Ryan, from
Democrats, because what the Republican proposals do is take some money out of
the ACA and send them directly to people, some kind of, you know, flexible savings
accounts or HSAs. But a lot of those people, especially if they're young and
healthy, could just take that money and not buy insurance. They could get out of
the risk pool, which would mean costs go up for sicker people and older people.
That's where you're gonna hear Democrats saying it's gonna indirectly harm
pre-existing conditions. So there's a big fight coming down the road if this
happens. Last point on this, Ryan, a Democratic aide I spoke to reminded me
that we reported at NBC News just a few weeks ago that many Republicans on
Capitol Hill are demanding stricter abortion restrictions on ACA funding in
order to have any kind of extension. That's not going to fly with Democrats.
That's one of those things that could make the entire concept a non-starter.
I mean, Sahil, under the best-case circumstances, this sort of dramatic
health care overhaul takes years, not just weeks. Is there any way they can get
this done before December 31st?
Any way procedurally, yes. You write a bill, you put it on the
floor, and you pass it. You can do that in a matter of weeks. But realistically,
practically, to get a major health care solution done, I've been following this
issue up here on Capitol Hill for 15 years, Ryan. That would be by far the
fastest I've ever seen anything come together and get to the floor, let alone
pass. The big thing Republicans have to figure out here is how to balance the
three C's of health care policy, cost, coverage, and care. They have not settled
on a theory of the case that they're willing to put policy on and, you know,
stand on business with politically. Democrats have that. It's the ACA. They
want to put everyone in the same risk pool, spread coverage as wide as
possible, and try to lower costs for the people who need it the most, the
sickest and oldest, essentially have the young and healthy subsidizing them. But
Republicans, as I keep saying, are all over the map here. They have not come up
with a theory, and I would be extremely shocked if they managed to figure that
out and put a bill to paper that can pass by the end of the year.
Okay, Yamiche, Sahil, thank you both for that. Let's talk to one of these
decision makers right now. Joining me, Utah Republican congressman and someone
who uniquely is aware of how health care works in this country because he is a
physician, and that is Congressman Mike Kennedy. Congressman and doctor, thank
you so much for being here. I want to first start with these reports that the
White House is set to announce its own health care proposal. Have you or any of
your fellow Republicans on the hill seen those details?
CNN has a story. I haven't seen those details yet, Ryan, but thanks for
having me on, and I'm eager to see those and work through this important issue.
The reality is Obamacare has been over the past 15 years, uh, disaster
financially. We saw with the Schumer shutdown one and a half trillion dollar
demand associated with the Affordable Care Act, and it's obviously not the
Affordable Care Act. It's the unaffordable Care Act. So so I'm eager,
along with my Republican colleagues, including Brett Guthrie, who's the
chair of Energy and Commerce Committee, which is a big part associated with
health care debates to analyzing what the president has to say and working
that through the Congress in the way that we do in transparency and
committees and debates. Okay, so you have made it clear that you're
not a fan of the Affordable Care Act. If the president's proposal does
include an extension of the A. C. A. Subsidies for maybe two years but would
do things like capping eligibility or provide an option for part of that tax
credit to be distributed to health care, health care savings accounts. Is
that at least the beginning of a framework that you could get behind and
negotiate around?
I'm a big fan of health savings accounts. The reality is when people
are in control of their own money and also in control of their own health
care, then they make better decisions. I've sat in the office as a primary
care doctor with people that are on high deductible plans that have H. S.
A. S. That their employer contributes to or, in this case, the government
would contribute to. And these people ask me if the requesting the blood
tests, the stress tests associated with hard testing. They asked me questions
about how much it's going to cost prior to engaging in these tests. And I,
with them, we have a cost decision making process, and I tell them, Well,
this is a test that's essential, and this is estimated how much it will
cost. And this test is maybe not as essential. And in bringing them into
that conversation, I think is a vital part of cost containment. It actually
allows good quality health care, too. Because imagine when you're interacting
with your doctor and your insurance company and you're incentivized to get
a $50 donation or contribution to your health savings account and for doing
things like mammograms or colonoscopies, which it's hard to do these
preventative care things where you get $100 H. S. A. Contribution associated
with coming in for your preventative physical that puts the patient in charge
of their own health care instead of waiting for some government bureaucracy
to say that this is how we should go about things. So so I'm eager to see
what kind of policies we can put into place that are going to incentivize
people to not only care about their own health care and have the right sort of
incentives associated with their own health care, but also the costs
associated with that health care. When you have a third party pair and the
people, the doctor and the patient are disengaged from that cost process.
That's why we have $1.5 trillion demand associated with the Schumer shutdown
and these Obamacare subsidies, which are not. There's so much waste, fraud
and abuse associated with what's happening right now. So I think there's
a key part of what you described there, though, and that is that the folks that
would take advantage of these health savings accounts would also still be a
acceptable plan. How concerned are you that someone has given this benefit
from the government to put in an HSA and then just chooses not to buy any
sort of health care and therefore is not contributing to the overall risk
pool? Couldn't that drive the cost of health care up even more? Should there
be something to compel them to actually still have some sort of backup
insurance plan?
I see those people as well. And those people actually come into my office and
their fee for service. They pay at the time of the visit. They use their
health savings account. And Ryan, you and I both know through the insurance
process that there are ways for us to work on that high risk pools, low risk
pools. These young people, many of whom have been signed up for plans, they
don't even know what are in there. We estimate there's 35% of the people that
are on these Obamacare subsidized plans that are actually not even accessing
health care at all. It's either because they don't want to. They don't even
know that they have these plans in some cases, and many of them are young and
healthy. And the idea that they are the only ones that should have double and
triple deductibles and premiums so that they can subsidize older and sicker
folks is is one of the problems associated with Obamacare. So a high
risk pool would take care of that. It's an insurance program where where we
would put people with higher subsidies associated with that into the high risk
pools and allow those people to receive the high quality health care that they
need associated with their ailments. Well, the younger and healthier
individuals who may not even access health care as their younger and in a
better physical condition that those people pay lower premiums and lower
deductibles, which would reduce costs for those people. But what you're you
are talking about is kind of a fundamental shift in the way health
care has been provided in this country for quite a long time. Not to say that
the policy is bad or good, but right now you're up against a deadline here at
the end of the year where 22 million Americans could see their premiums
skyrocket. And I understand that you don't agree with the Affordable Care
Act is an underlying policy program, but there needs to be a fix to this
immediately, not a long term plan. How concerned are you that what you're
discussing, what the White House is discussing is too little too late? And
how do you solve this immediate problem of that huge pool of Americans that are
going to see their premiums hike?
Thanks for the question, Ryan. It's an important one for you and your
listeners and viewers to attend to. You said 22 million, and we estimate
there's about one million people that are going to be subject to these
possible premium increases. So the reality is 93% of the people on
Obamacare subsidies will see no change or little change associated with their
program. So the vast majority of people are actually going to continue to
receive the Obamacare subsidies for 15 years that they've been receiving. That
7% or that one, I'm hearing numbers of 1.3 million people. We need to attend
to those people, the lower risk people. These are high deductible plans with
HSA contributions that come from the money that we may appropriate from the
federal government and the high risk individuals that may be associated with
that. Then we need to have a glide path to make sure waste, fraud and abuse are
rooted out. But in addition to that, that these people are still able to
access high quality health care that they need in the middle of. I've taken
care of these people. Diabetics, they have a lot of needs and they're very
expensive. Sometimes those needs and I want to make sure that those people have
excellent access to high quality health care, which I and people like me as
doctors have been delivering for many years in the Obamacare process. So
there's a way to make this happen. Last thing I'll say, Ryan is disappointing to
me as a preventative doctor is Congress often doesn't do anything until they
absolutely have to. So the fact that we've got an end of the year deadline
is kind of typical. It's midterms and where it's final exam time for a lot of
college students. I guess we're just gonna we got three weeks in December.
Thanks to the Schumer shutdown, we didn't have as much time as we thought
we'd have. But there are many good people working on this important issue
in a bipartisan fashion. I'm grateful to partner with my democrat colleagues to
find solutions for the people of America. Well, I don't disagree with you
that Congress waits until the last minute of someone who covers the place
every single day. But before I let you go, sir, I just want to be very clear.
You do not believe that these premium, these enhanced subsidies need to be
extended. You think that you can handle that without the extension of those
subsidies
now without serious reform. We have people reportedly $600,000 a year that
they make that are getting these premium subsidies. That is entirely
inappropriate. Those people can pay full freight for whatever plans that they
want. We have people that are 400% of the federal poverty level or less.
Those people need help, and we're happy. I'm happy to provide it. Okay, Dr
Kennedy, Congressman Kennedy, I appreciate you being here. Have a very
happy Thanksgiving, sir, and we'll see when you get back here to Washington.
Same to you, Ryan. Thank you. All right. After the break, the Pentagon now
investigating Democratic Senator Mark Kelly after President Trump called for
him and other Democrats to be thrown in jail for urging military members to
refuse illegal orders. You're watching meet the press now.
Welcome back. The Pentagon says it's launching an investigation into Arizona
Senator Mark Kelly for, quote, serious allegations of misconduct. Last hour,
White House Press Secretary Caroline Levitt said the White House was
supportive of the investigation. Remember, Senator Kelly was one of six
lawmakers, all of whom served in the military or as intelligence officials
who posted a video last week telling service members to refuse illegal
orders.
Our laws are clear. You can refuse illegal orders. You can refuse illegal
orders. You must refuse illegal orders.
Now, in the wake of that video, President Trump accused the lawmakers
of seditious behavior, arguing they should be arrested and put on trial. And
at one point, he also suggested their comments could be punishable by death.
The president this weekend also reposted this a I generated image of
the lawmakers from behind bars, with some in prison pinstripes. Senator
Kelly responded to the news of the Pentagon investigation today, writing in
a statement, quote, If this is meant to intimidate me and other members of
Congress from doing our job and holding this administration accountable, it
won't work. Joining me now is NBC's senior national security correspondent,
Courtney QB. So according to probably a lot of people confused by this, and
there's six lawmakers in the video. Why is it that only Senator Kelly is the
target? So he's the only one who actually retired from active duty. He
retired as a Navy captain after 20 years of service. The other served four of
them served in the military in various levels, lower level ranking officers for
the most part. And then Alyssa Slotkin, the senator from Michigan, was a CIA
analyst and then a D O D official. So he is the only one because of his status
who is eligible to be recalled. And for any number of reasons, he can be
recalled if there's a national emergency, if there's a war and they
need people to come back into service. Or in this case, he can be recalled and
brought up on uniform code of military justice charges, including conduct
unbecoming, whatever it is that they want to try to throw at him. And so
does the investigation entail? What's the practical reality of all? So this
is gonna be a tough one because the video that you just played there, he
repeatedly talks about not following illegal orders. Well, that's the law. As
an officer, you take an oath and essentially the easiest way to describe
it is you are supposed to protect essentially junior enlisted people from
carrying out illegal orders. So you're supposed to be able to say, Hey, what
we're being told to do here, that is illegal. We shouldn't do it. So by
repeating that by saying you should not follow an illegal order, that's
basically just repeating the law. Now, that being said, there are a couple of
sort of catch all things that they could try to charge him with. They
would have to recall him to active duty, and then they would have to refer
charges against him. Something like conduct unbecoming, maybe good order and
discipline, something like that. These aren't insignificant charges that he
could face. If, in fact, they were to go through with this, he could do jail
time. They could bump him down in rank. They could take away some of his
benefits. But the reality is here the investigation, it's gonna be hard for
them to find something that is enough for them to actually find charges. It
doesn't also matter here that he's a sitting United States senator. Aren't
there protections against what he says in public as a result of that? No, I
mean, he's what he is saying here in their capacity of every single one of
them identified themselves as former or retired military, so they seem to be
speaking in that capacity. But no matter what you could, he could be recalled if
he's in a government position like a senator. But I meant more about the
legal grounding they have there. I mean, the speech and debate clause, to a
certain extent, doesn't that protect the sitting senator in this capacity? It does,
but even still, what they are saying, I mean, I've spoken with a number of
JAGs and retired military attorneys, and, you know, what they're saying is
basically restating the law not to follow an illegal order. And the
word illegal is so key here, because when we've heard some of the Trump
administration officials and even some of the social media postings today
from the Department of Defense, they keep omitting the word illegal, and
that's what's really key here. Okay, Courtney, thank you for that. We
appreciate it. Coming up, pushing for peace. The president huddles with his
Secretary of State amid signs of progress in ending Russia's war in
Ukraine. We have the very latest next. You're watching Meet the Press now.
Welcome back. The White House and Ukraine are touting what they're
calling meaningful progress following high level talks in Geneva this weekend
to discuss a possible peace deal between Russia and Ukraine. According
to US and Ukrainian officials, the two sides drafted an updated framework to
the initial 28 point peace plan that had Ukraine making major concessions
to Moscow, such as handing over the Donbass region and shrinking its armed
forces. While speaking to reporters, Secretary Rubio appeared optimistic
that a deal could be close. It is probably the most productive day we
had on this issue, maybe in the entirety of our engagement, but
certainly in a very long time. But work remains. I can tell you that the items
that remain open are not insurmountable. We just need more time
than what we have today. I honestly believe we'll get there
in a post on social media this morning. President Trump also suggested quote
something good may be happening in those diplomatic efforts, but he
didn't provide any new details. Joining me now is NBC News chief foreign
correspondent Richard Engel. He is in Geneva. So Richard, do we know what
kind of progress was made during those meetings in Geneva? And what are the
outstanding sticking points?
Uh, two excellent questions. And this time the White House is keeping the
draft very close to its chest. If you remember, the initial 28 point plan was
criticized ferociously in Ukraine. It was criticized by European allies of
Ukraine, European governments, analysts, academics all said that what
President Trump and his administration were doing was effectively handing
Ukraine a list of Vladimir Putin's demands. A few you listed earlier that
Ukraine had to shrink its armed forces, that it had to remain neutral. No NATO
that it had to give up not just Donbass, but all of the provinces along the
for big provinces, including areas that Russian troops have been unable to
conquer. Now there is no longer a 28 page proposal. According to Ukrainian
officials, it is shorter. It has been somewhat streamlined after two full days
of negotiations between the American side and the Ukrainian side here in
The delegations have now left this city, and now President Zelensky will go and
discuss the outstanding issues. The proposal that seems to be have been
reached or close to being reached, according to Secretary of State Rubio,
directly with President Trump and President Trump will discuss it
directly with Vladimir Putin. So we don't know exactly what the new draft
says, but we know the Ukrainians are much more pleased with it and find it
much more acceptable than the 28 point plan that they were initially presented
with, with which many believed was complete, a complete capitulation to
Vladimir Putin's demands. So Richard, is the sense then that we may actually be
getting closer to negotiating an end of the war compared to these previous
diplomatic efforts? It's possible because even with the worst of the
drafts from Ukraine's perspective, the 28 point plan that they that they hated
so much and talk in Ukraine that the soldiers wouldn't follow it and that it
could be the end of the current government. And it might be the end of
the current government. It's not entirely clear that that Zelensky, as
popular as he's been throughout the course of this war, will survive the
next phase. He might end up being a Winston Churchill type figure, beloved
during wartime, not so much when the war is over. But even that plan, which
the Ukrainians found so troublesome and loathsome, was about ending the war. Now
they've refined that plan to something they think they can they can work with
or advance to the next rounds of negotiations, president to president,
Zelensky to Trump, Trump to Putin. Both of these are about ending the war. So it's
not that there's a third track here about talking about escalating the war,
but how long it takes I think is still very very much an open question. Maybe by
the end of the year, maybe early next year, but Vladimir Putin said that he
thought the initial 28 plan would be a good basis for solving the war.
Zelensky has now said that this plan has improvements and he's going to take it
up with Trump. So it does seem to be heading in the direction of finding an
end to this conflict, yes. Okay, Richard Engel on the ground force in Geneva.
Richard, thank you for that report. Up next, a perilous moment for the
president as his efforts to prosecute his political rivals faces a major
setback and one of his former top allies in Congress calls it quits.
All right, welcome back. Let's not waste any time and get right to our panel.
Daniela Diaz, congressional reporter for notice. Joel Payne, a democratic
strategist who served as the senior aid to the Hillary for America campaign and
served as press secretary for force for former Senate Majority Leader Harry
Reid. Mark Bednar, a republican strategist and the former head of
communications for the former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy. So Daniela,
let's start where we began our show and that's with the dismissal of both the
criminal indictments against James Comey and Letitia James. Is this a
significant blow for the president? Major for the president. I mean, this
even the administration is still saying that they plan to continue these
efforts. Caroline Levitt saying just momentarily, this is not over. We're
planning to continue fighting this. But it's very significant that an effort
from this prosecutor was dismissed by another judge because it is a clear
effort from the administration to fight back on, you know, people who have
opposed Trump's administration and it's being just even what we saw the
Pentagon dating Senator Mark Kelly for a separate issue that you were talking
about early on in the show. This is a continuing pattern that we're seeing
from the Trump administration and it's unclear where they can really hold the
line on what their efforts to for their their people that oppose their
politics. Right. And Mark, what's significant about Halligan's
appointment is that it went outside of Congress, right? She was appointed to
this job without congressional input. This isn't the first Trump appointed
U. S. Attorney whose appointments been deemed unlawfully appointed. Does the
White House need to change their strategy here? And should they be going
with U. S. Attorneys that can actually be confirmed by the United States
Senate? Well, ultimately you talk to Republicans on the Hill or the
administration like there's still major questions. Did Letitia James, did she
conduct more mortgage fraud? Did James Comey lie to Congress? These are
reasonable questions that a lot of Republicans, a lot of American citizens
are concerned about. And so if there's procedural fouls or procedural mistakes
or kind of confusion here or there, that does not address the underlying
questions about the legality. But wouldn't a solution to that then finding a U. S.
Attorney that believes it should be investigated and have that U. S. Attorney
confirmed by the Senate? Well, we'll see what how D. O. J. Approaches with
the next steps here, like whether the appeal process, how they how they go
about it. But the underlying questions about these two potential defendants
that those still remain. Okay, so Joel, how serious do Democrats or just people
who are the president's political enemies need to take these threats? It
seems pretty clear that the president just isn't gonna give up on this if he
has a couple of legal setbacks. Oh, sure. They're gonna be relentless. They're
gonna continue to weaponize government as they have been. And look, it's
interesting if Donald Trump's whole beef here is I was targeted with
prosecution that was that was not serious and that was pretty arbitrary
to turn around and do that to other folks actually doesn't seem like he
actually is applying the political lesson that he should have learned.
Second thing, anything Donald Trump is doing to weaponize government to
politically persecute people isn't making life cheaper, isn't making life
more affordable for people, isn't attacking the core issues that people
actually responding to when any time anyone ask anything related to public
opinion in the country, nobody wants them to focus. I'd like your take on
that. Are Republicans focusing on the wrong things, especially ahead of what
is going to be a very competitive midterm election? Well, what the outcome
of the legal issues with James and Comey, that's not going to decide the
midterm elections. That's not gonna decide who controls Congress. It's
gonna be all about all about the economy. And of course, once one big
beautiful bill results kind of set are set into place for the course of the
next year, that's when republicans can really regain the high ground on on the
economy. You know, wages are outpacing inflation. That's a good thing. Uh, as
far as like money coming back to the car, it's a reshoring of jobs. This is
gonna be really important for the republican message going forward. Okay,
let's shift gears Daniela and and talk about the last 48 hours where we saw a
gracious mayor elect Zoran Mondami in the Oval Office and then a more
combative mayor elect Mondami with Kristen Welker on Sunday. Take a
listen to this exchange. So Mr Mayor elect, just to be very clear, do you
think that President Trump is a fascist? And after President Trump said that, I
said yes. And so you do. And that's something that I've said in the past. I
say it today. And I think what I appreciated about the conversation that
I had with the president was that we were not shy about the places of
disagreement about the politics that has brought us to this moment. Do you
still believe President Trump is a threat to the democracy? Everything
that I've said in the past, I continue to believe. And that's the thing that I
think is important in our politics is that we don't shy away from where we
have disagreements, but we understand what it is that brings us to that table.
I think a lot of people were shaking their heads about the way that those
two men were so agreeable in the White House. Is there part of Donald Trump
that appreciates how direct he is and can Mondami continue to work with this
White House while not upsetting his base at the same time? I mean, I think
we can all agree that what we witnessed on Friday was a very charmed Donald
Trump. I mean, he recognized who mom Donny is in his charisma. Clearly
someone who is a good speaker. Great for TV. Those are all things Trump very
much appreciates and understands. He even was okay with mom Donny calling
him a fascist, saying interrupting. Go ahead. You can go ahead and say it. And
it's obviously we were gonna see that just one meeting with the president was
not gonna change the mayor elects opinion of the president. But it's
clear he when he was going into this meeting, he said, I'm just here to
really deliver on New Yorkers. Trump is New Yorker. He probably understands
that. It's still such a mind boggling meeting what we witnessed. But we all
had our predictions for how that was gonna turn out, and that was certainly
one of mine. But, Joel, there is a difference between campaigning and
governing, right? Was this and the president recognizing that they're
gonna have to govern together on some level? I think these air to iconoclast
who were sizing each other up in who were seeing a lot of honestly similar
qualities in each other. Donald Trump, independent political power pace
separate of the establishment, his party. So our mom Donny independent
political power base separate of the establishment of this party. Many other
things that these two men share in common beyond the obvious, right? And I
actually think it's not too surprising to me that Donald Trump was actually
able able to see some things about our mom Donny that he admired. I think
where mom Donny will be tested here is not on all the rhetoric politically
that he's been able to use in his campaign and up till now, but how he's
gonna govern. And part of his strategy was to figure out how can I govern
effectively with Donald Trump breathing down my neck from the White
House? But on the other side of this mark, you have congressional Republicans
in districts in Wisconsin, where you're in Iowa in Texas that are tying the
Democrats to Mondami. If you have this optics of the president bear hugging
him in the Oval Office, how do you effectively send this message that, you
know, Democratic Congressman X in Iowa is gonna come and turn your
state into a socialist haven? Well, I think everyone around this table can
agree that the sort of the Kumbaya moment that we saw in the Oval Office
that might not last throughout the duration of this election cycle. And so
Republicans throughout throughout the country, they're still gonna be able to
find their shots to be able to exemplify Mondami's policies as something that
they don't want their districts to turn into. So I think that, you know, this
that will that moment will dissipate and they'll get right back into campaign
mode. I'm just gonna say real quick, I think we're gonna talk about Marjorie
Taylor Greene. We're contractually obligated. I was just gonna say really
quickly, part of the beef that she was talking about in her exit video talking
about resigning from Congress was this idea that Donald Trump kind of did not
really come true on all the things that he talked about when he talked about
America First and the MAGA. And I actually think the conversation we're
having here is maybe a little bit what she was getting at, is that you campaign
and you talk so negatively about these things that I think that we believe in,
and then you actually don't act on that. You go and get crypto money. You go and
kiss up to foreign nationals and put American service people in harm's way.
And it didn't line up to what Marjorie Taylor Greene's understanding of a MAGA
was. And I actually think that the Zoran meeting, it's a very interesting, you
know, kind of cross section of what she's talking. All right, Danielle, I'm
gonna let you have the last word on MTG is, is this sending shockwaves to
Capitol Hill? Are people not surprised? I mean, she is somebody who often will
make impulsive moves like this. This is the most grand impulsive move. Is she
exiting the stage or we're not seeing the last of Marjorie Taylor Greene? I
don't think we've seen the last of Marjorie Taylor Greene. I mean, it's
clear that she plans to be a voice in whether it's the Republican Party,
because she hasn't been really sounding like a Republican lately. Even
Democrats are trying to find a way to work with her because of how she's
taken the stance on the Affordable Care Act subsidies, fighting against Trump,
the Epstein files. But it's clear that she's truly trying to be her own,
sorry to use this word, maverick voice in this party. And you were not
surprised, Ryan. You spoke to a ton of people who are not surprised. I
remember your reporting and I was surprised, but I don't think she's going
anywhere. All right, quickly. 10 seconds. What do you have for Thanksgiving?
I love mashed potatoes, mashed potatoes. No, I'm told not to talk about it.
Stop. Keep that for tomorrow. We'll be back tomorrow with more. Meet the
press. Now we're out of time. Anyway, there's more news ahead on NBC.
We thank you for watching and remember, stay updated on breaking news and top
stories on the NBC News app or watch live on our YouTube channel.