Should You Use ProRes RAW on the iPhone 17 Pro_

Technical Sea
259 followers
So I got the iPhone 17 Pro
and I tested all the different video codecs
so that you can see the actual difference
between let's say the ProRes RAW
and the normal H.265 in various shooting scenarios.
The first thing I wanna talk about
obviously is ProRes RAW.
With the iPhone 17 Pro,
you now have the ability to record RAW video
to an external drive.
Now, what is RAW?
In essence, RAW footage saves all the information
your sensor captures and therefore lets you change things
like exposure and white balance after the fact
without losing any image quality.
Let me show you an example.
Here, I deliberately overexposed the image by a lot
as well as I also used a completely wrong white balance.
And as you can see, the image is way too bright and cool.
And while that would be great attributes for a human,
not so much in this case.
But here lies the real benefit of RAW video.
In most production, in this case, in DaVinci Resolve,
I can just use the RAW settings and dial down the ISO
after the fact as well as set the right color temperature
and ta-da, we have a perfectly exposed image.
Now, when we try the same thing in the normal ProRes
or the non-RAW, and even though it was shot in log,
which is already a flat image profile designed
for maximum flexibility in post-production,
there's absolutely no chance of recovering anything.
And I can try as much as I want.
I won't get the detail, the texture in the watch dial back.
So that pretty much sums up the appeal of shooting in RAW.
In essence, you can mess up while shooting,
but save everything later or put more professionally.
You have more artistic freedom to have the final product
look exactly the way you want it to look.
Now, if you want to shoot RAW with your iPhone 17 Pro,
you need a few things.
First of which is a fast SSD to capture video too,
because it only allows you to write the RAW
directly to an SSD.
And I have this SanDisk SSD here,
which you may have seen in the thumbnail.
And I use that because I already had it.
But if I wanted to buy something new today,
I would probably go with a more elegant solution.
There are these SSDs out there that attach
to the MagSafe of the iPhone magnetically.
And so there's nothing dangling around, which is not ideal.
Something like this one here from Alexa, for example.
Okay, and then you have to use
either the Final Cut Camera app or the Blackmagic Camera app
because you cannot access ProRes RAW
within the normal camera app.
Both of them are free to download,
and in addition come with many useful professional features
like complete manual exposure, focus peaking,
histograms, LUT preview, and so on.
And so here within the Final Cut Camera app, for example,
you can just switch between the different codecs
and shooting modes.
And when you choose ProRes RAW here,
you can see that you can either use 17 by 9 or Open Gate.
And this Open Gate thing
is the second big feature of shooting RAW.
With Open Gate,
you basically get everything the sensor captures.
Camera sensors come typically in a four by three
aspect ratio, and the video we take
is then usually only a part of the sensor.
But with Open Gate, you get everything
and gain a much taller image while not losing any width.
This, of course, can be hugely beneficial
if you want or need to use one recording
and make clips out of it in different aspect ratios.
16 by 9, for example, for YouTube,
and then something in portrait orientation for the socials.
Now, especially when you don't need
the Open Gate functionality,
shooting RAW is not useful in every scenario, of course.
Like when you have controlled lighting like this shot here,
it's not really, there's not really a benefit to it.
Let me show you.
Every clip you see here
was filmed with the exact same settings,
and that is ISO 500,
color temperature set to 5,400 Kelvin,
which matches my key light here,
and the shutter speed at 1 150th of a second
at 25 frames per second.
And I used the main wide angle lens in each shot.
So from left to right, we have ProRes RAW,
ProRes, and H.265.
Each was shot in Apple Log 2,
and then in Final Cut, I added a simple conversion LUT,
which converts it to Rec. 709 by Taylor Stormann,
as well as some exposure correction and contrast,
but no sharpening or denoising was done.
In essence, I just, you know,
turned them into something I like
and I'd use for YouTube, for example.
Now, speaking of YouTube,
they obviously compress the files a lot,
so I'm not sure whether you can spot
any differences at all here,
because I had a very hard time
to notice anything on my monitor.
And at most, I see a tiny, tiny bit more detail
in the ProRes versus the H.265,
but not really anything significant
between the ProRes RAW and the ProRes.
But that is also to be expected,
as in a controlled setup like this here,
the RAW has virtually no benefits,
as I obviously didn't have to change the white balance
or the ISO afterwards.
Indeed, I converted it from RAW straight to Apple Log,
and applied the same lot and corrections
as on the other clips.
And while in this scenario, it doesn't have any benefits,
it does come with one big downsize,
and that is file size.
With the ProRes RAW,
we look at a little over one gigabyte of data
for 10 seconds in this clip you see.
And the normal ProRes, non-RAW,
is 700 to 800 megabytes per 10 seconds,
and the H.265 is just 38 megabytes per 10 seconds.
So, this is obviously a huge difference
and surely one of the reasons
why you can only write ProRes RAW to an external SSD.
Because let's say, on average,
for a 10-minute YouTube video,
with all the times I make mistakes
and stumble across my words and so forth,
well, I would probably let the camera roll
for about 30 minutes.
That would equate to a whopping 200 gigabytes of data
in the ProRes RAW.
Now, that's obviously quite cumbersome
and also costly in the long run.
And that's why for a controlled environment like this here,
the H.265 with Apple Log is sufficient
and way easier to handle.
Now, as a bit of a different direction,
in the video where I compared the iPhone 17 Pro
with my more professional camera, the Fuji X-H2,
which is filming me right now,
I said that ProRes footage from the iPhone
looks nearly as good as from the Fuji,
minus the blurry background.
So, somebody pointed out
that I should try cinematic mode, which I did.
Right off the bat, we see that the colors
and exposure is completely different
compared to the graded log footage before.
And that's because you access cinematic mode
via the normal camera app.
And it essentially is the normal non-fancy iPhone video
with an added artificial background blur.
And very similar to Apple's portrait mode still photography.
But yeah, having no control over the image whatsoever
is obviously not ideal.
And it also comes with this typical nasty phone look
with lots of over-sharpening and not really much detail.
And while it does blur the background
and the blur itself looks quite natural,
the transition looks horrible in my opinion,
and not at all professional.
I mean, compared with the H.265 filmed in log
and then graded, that looks way better in my opinion.
And that had roughly the same file size.
So, while I do think that there will come a time
when we will have something like cinematic log in ProRes,
for now the bottom line is that if I had to use the iPhone
for my YouTube talking head,
I'd most definitely use the H.265 and Apple log.
I think for a scenario like this,
it offers the best value in terms of file size to quality.
Okay, now let's have a look at low light performance.
And here I made the room completely dark
and the only light source is a candle
that illuminates the face of my girlfriend here.
And this is a real stress test for a phone camera
with its tiny sensor, because while ISO 2000,
which we have in this case here,
might not be a big deal for a mirrorless camera
with a full frame or APS-C sensor,
for a phone it is a lot.
Let's start with the ProRes RAW versus the normal ProRes.
And of course, with the RAW,
we again have the ability to go crazy
with exposure and white balance,
which might be helpful in a situation like this,
where it's really hard to get it just right in camera
or in phone in this case.
But provided you don't need to completely change everything,
I think that again,
there's not really a noticeable difference
between ProRes RAW and ProRes.
Maybe again, a bit more difference
between the ProRes and the H.265,
but also nothing really major
and probably not enough to be visible on YouTube
for you guys.
And just for fun,
I also added my Fuji into the mix as a comparison.
And while it is obviously a lot cleaner,
the iPhone holds up surprisingly well,
especially when you add just a small amount
of denoising and sharpening.
I mean, for a phone that's really good.
And again, we are on ISO 2000 here,
so that is impressive in my mind.
Then I also tested how the normal camera app would look like.
So this is non-lock,
just the normal H.264 in this case,
straight out of the camera app.
And while it has a lot less noise
than the ProRes and ProRes RAW, for example,
because it does have heavy noise reduction
already in the phone,
it also has a lot less detail
and it looks like very boxy, chunky, not very pleasing.
So it's, there's not a lot of detail.
So the bottom line here for me would be
that for critical low light shooting,
I'd obviously choose the ProRes RAW,
especially when you have the ability to denoise it in post.
It just gives you the most data to work with.
Finally, let's look at slow motion
and the iPhone 17 Pro,
as well as the 16 Pro for that matter,
offer you the ability to shoot up to 4K 120,
120 frames per second in ProRes to an external drive.
If you want to have even more slow motion,
you have to go to the normal camera app again
and use this dedicated slow motion feature
where you can go up to 240 frames,
but that is only 1080 and H.265, I believe.
And yeah, it looks horrible.
Just have a look at this side by side
of this leaf in the rain.
The ProRes 120 really, really looks stunning,
whereas the slow motion mode is not usable in my opinion.
I also made this very cinematic shot
of this weird peanut candy, I don't know what it's called,
falling into this bowl of milk.
And the difference is less extreme
because it is far less complex
in terms of patterns and depth and so on.
But still, I don't think that the 240 is really usable.
But in general, man, I cannot stress enough
how good the 4K 120 looks,
especially in this macro-like closeups
where we have shallow depth of field
with nice out of focus area that is 100% real.
It's just really nice.
I mean, remember, this is a phone and not a proper camera.
So bottom line for slow motion,
use the ProRes 4K 120.
It is really, really excellent.
All right, so what are my final thoughts?
Well, first and foremost,
the video quality coming out of this iPhone is amazing.
Second, if you want to do anything remotely professional
or you just want to get the most out of your iPhone,
you need A, an external drive to record to
and B, you need to stay far, far away
from the default camera app
and instead do everything either in the Final Cut app
or in the Blackmagic Video app.
So you can have manual control over your settings
and access all the good stuff in terms of codecs.
Speaking of codecs,
my third point is shooting log in H.265
is a good quality compromise
for probably most shooting scenarios,
especially when you have control over the light,
like a YouTube talking head video, for example.
Then between ProRes and ProRes RAW,
I would actually go for the RAW most of the time
as the size difference is not that big.
I mean, both are enormous,
but yeah, RAW is only like 20% bigger.
So, but the thing is, of course you gain open gate,
which is helpful for all the influencers,
social media stuff, for example,
and some sort of peace of mind
that you can fix your exposure and white balance in post.
Just be aware that with the ProRes RAW and open gate,
you lose stabilization
and you'd need to do that in post as well.
All right, I think that's it.
That was a rather long video.
Thank you very much for watching.
If you enjoyed it,
please give it a like and consider subscribing
and yeah, see you in the next one.
Bye bye, cheers.
