Something Weird Is Happening in California

Finance Phoenix
9 followers
45 Video Views·Nov 23, 2025
California, the US's third largest state, ranks as the world's 4th or 5th economy all by itself. With an output over $3.5 trillion, Californians are among the globe's top producers. But despite its growth, the state faces challenges: global pressures, population decline, and social problems.
Comments are disabled for this video.
This is California, the 3rd largest US state home to just under 40 million people and some
of the most influential industries in the world. California alone is the 4th or 5th largest economy
in the world, beating out every other country in the world apart from China, Japan, potentially
Germany, and of course the USA itself. Measuring the exact output of the state is always up for
a little bit of debate, because the regular international organisations like the IMF or
the World Bank that usually document national output figures don't do it for California,
because well, California is not a country. Even still, by the most conservative estimates,
the golden state has an output of over 3.5 trillion US dollars, which means on a per
capita basis the average Californian has an output of almost 100,000 dollars, making them
amongst the most economically productive people on the planet. Only really falling behind true
outliers like Monaco, Lichtenstein, and Luxembourg. These other countries, despite being independent
countries of their own, are still far smaller economies with far smaller populations, and a
good part of their reported economic success is simply due to nuances of how economic figures
like GDP per capita are calculated. On top of its sheer scale, California is also doing something
that a lot of large and highly advanced economies fail to do, it's growing, and it's on average
growing at a faster rate than the rest of the united states, which itself is doing quite well
by global advanced economy standards. But of course, California is not without its issues,
or its challenges. The industries that have made the state what it is today may be starting to get
as big as they possibly can, all while facing more pressures from around the world in a range
of different ways. In recent years, California's population has been declining for the first time
in its history, with record numbers leaving for states like Texas, Nevada, Idaho, and Oregon,
citing over-regulation, the highest personal income taxes in the country,
rising housing costs, and some pretty overt social problems.
That could be bad, not only for a state simultaneously dealing with a lot of internal
issues, but the rest of the US as well, and to understand why, we need to as always answer
What is it that makes the economy of California so special on a state, national, and global level?
Has the state just been lucky, or is there a method behind the Californian madness?
And finally, will its long list of current challenges see it lose out to other rivals
within and outside of the USA? Once we have done all that,
we can update California's spot on the economics explained national leaderboard.
Whether you're a startup founder in Silicon Valley, or you're starting your first site hustle,
getting your own website to represent yourself online is an absolute necessity.
That's why we've partnered up with HubSpot and their fantastic drag and drop website builder
that can help you show off your latest project with a beautiful webpage.
I've had my fair share of site hustles before economics explained really took off,
but building a website back in the day felt like a real chore,
because I didn't know the first thing about web design or coding.
With HubSpot's drag and drop editor, there isn't any coding required,
and there are tons of templates and inspirational examples of how to use this powerful tool
to make a great website to grow your business, show off your fashion photography,
or even just your personal blog.
This builder works just as well for enterprises with hundreds of employees
as it does for an individual, and scales with the size of your organization
and what you need the website to do.
Having a beautiful website that shows people what you're all about
can help you turn your garage business into your new career.
You can get started for free at our link in the description,
so you can put your work out to the world today.
When exploring a complex economic issue like what made California so economically prosperous,
it's nice when there's one simple underlying reason and everything else is built on top of it,
like fantastic geography, a clever economic policy, or even just natural resource discoveries.
Having one simple takeaway normally makes for a memorable lesson and an enjoyable video to watch.
So you have to trust us when we say that unfortunately,
there's no silver bullet that got California to where it is today,
just a series of lucky breaks that the state has capitalized on well throughout its history.
That also means that Californian economic dominance is not guaranteed,
and unlike a sovereign national economy, there are certain advantages,
but also some serious risks that California faces
purely because it's part of a union that is the United States.
The state as we know it today really got started before it was officially a state,
when widespread gold deposits were discovered
around what would go on to be San Francisco, San Jose, and Sacramento.
Before this time, the area was sparsely populated,
because there was nothing driving settlers from the more abundant plains of the midwest,
or the industry and civilization of the east coast.
The area had also only just been acquired by the United States as a territory a year prior.
But once gold was discovered, there was a reason for people to make something of the place.
In its most basic form, this is the concept of comparative advantage in economic output.
When considering the factors of production, land, labor, and capital,
the region that would go on to be California basically sucked in every metric.
Its land was not much better than the abundant land that was available closer to the east coast,
and its total labor pool was measured in the tens of thousands.
There was little capital to make any of this better, like railways or factories,
because there was no reason to invest out there when there was so much space available
everywhere else.
A situation that is particularly ironic given the state's problems these days.
This means that everywhere else had a comparative advantage over the region
in the production of everything.
But that change when gold made the land of California incredibly lucrative,
giving it a comparative advantage in the production of precious metal.
As soon as there was a reason for the economy to exist, it quickly developed around this industry.
Within two years, the population more than doubled,
and people were moving not only to dig for gold,
but also to build businesses to support the people that were digging for gold.
The development of the region's economy was so rapid that just two years after being acquired
by the US, California was able to successfully apply for statehood,
and receive the representation that came with that on a federal level.
Now, resource-rich economies eventually face major problems if they become
overly dependent on just that one industry.
For a long time, California ran the risk of losing its gold,
and then losing all of the businesses that had sprung up to support it.
Now, obviously gold mining in California is today basically
completely inconsequential compared to its other world-leading industries.
So we know that it was able to successfully transition its economy away from resources,
but that was far from guaranteed.
Today, a lot of countries and even other regions within the US are struggling to
transition away from resource economies, and the California lesson can teach us a
lot about how to successfully make that switch.
But it's also important to recognize that it had a few advantages that a lot of resource-rich
economies today don't.
One of the biggest things that it had going for it,
was just how hard it was to get to and get back from.
Before air travel, or even railroads, the options for getting to California were
horse-drawn wagons along sparsely populated land routes, or going the entire way around
South America through some of the most perilous oceans in the world in a ship from the 1800s.
Basically, once people had moved to California, they were pretty committed to making it work.
Fortunately, the region is also very arable, so farming quickly became self-sustaining,
and as transport infrastructure developed,
it became possible for the state to trade more actively with the rest of the country.
It must be remembered that really, before the mid-1950s, global trade,
and even trade between regions within physically large countries like the USA,
was far less intense than it is today.
As soon as food production was sorted and local industries sprung up to support the
existing population, there was little pressure to be globally competitive, because it was just
easier to make basic consumer goods of the day locally than it was to transport them on
small ships or early rail networks.
Fortunately, however, that did not mean that the state became complacent.
From its resource boom, the state made heavy investments into education,
pioneering universal higher studies, and founding universities like Berkeley
and the University of California.
It was a wise investment at the time, but the policy makers probably had no idea just
how much of an impact it would have on the state a century down the track.
The isolation from the rest of the economy also had some advantages.
Motion pictures using new technologies invented on the east coast were becoming a big deal,
and California became a popular destination to produce these movies, as they would go on to be
known.
The location was no accident either.
It was easy to transport films once they had been made, but early studios could use film
cameras without paying licensing fees to the companies that produced them on the east coast,
because it was unlikely for inspectors to travel so far.
This almost quaint industry of course went on to build Hollywood,
today one of the most economically valuable industries in the world.
In the aftermath of the second world war,
technology to create films had advanced significantly, and given that Europe had
been bombed to rubble, it was really only Hollywood that could produce high quality
movies for the entire world.
Movies were easy to transport, and basically cost nothing to replicate once the film itself
had been shot.
Today we take value adding products like this for granted, but back then making something
that cost the producer the same amount of money to sell something as many times as they wanted
was an extremely big deal, and California had become the de facto home of this new
economic innovation.
Beyond just providing the growing economy with the ultimate export,
it gave it something arguably even more important.
Influence.
Today 50 of the top 50 highest grossing films of all time were produced in Hollywood.
There have been the occasional hits from other countries, but nothing really comes
close to matching the entertainment industry in California.
This creates jobs for millions of people that on average pay quite well by US standards,
and extremely well by global standards.
It also makes especially English speaking countries quite in tune with American norms
and customs.
Now from the perspective of a rational economist that only concerns themselves with quantifiable
data points, that may not seem like a huge deal, but it's a major piece of the puzzle
as to why the US, and in particular California, are as successful as they are today.
The US is a magnet for investment and skilled workers.
If people around the world are moving somewhere to start a better life, it's normally the
USA.
The average US worker is significantly more productive than the average worker from other
economies because US companies invest more into making them make more stuff.
The reason they can make those investments is because money pours into the USA from around
the world because people want to invest in their industries.
I personally, as an Australian, feel a sense of familiarity with the US market,
despite not having been to the country in over a decade.
If I was to move somewhere else to try and get a real job as an economist,
it would probably be the USA.
And California, with its high paying job opportunities, would be a logical destination.
Skilled migrants that on average make above average contributions to economic output,
move to California more than any other state in the US, which creates a chicken than egg.
Skilled people move to California because there are world-leading industries there,
and world-leading industries can operate in California because that's where all the skilled
people are.
The same goes for making investments, and the entertainment industry centered in California
is a big driver of this global recognition.
Now these days, an industry that is arguably even more influential in entertainment
is tech.
And no country even comes close to the USA, and by extension, California.
The universities that the freshly founded state of California funded in the 1800s
just so happened to attract researchers working on
thinking machines and semiconductors in the early 1960s.
In economics there is a principle called agglomeration,
which means all other things being equal, industries run more efficiently when
Early technology companies were built by students from Berkeley in particular.
As people were figuring out what these new machines could do,
it became easier to find experts and suppliers and investors and also customers
by being centered around the region that was becoming known for this technology.
Technology is a multi-trillion dollar industry,
and some of the most valuable companies in the world have been created in Silicon Valley.
Apple alone is as of the time of making this video,
worth more than every public company listed in Australia
combined.
These companies have achieved this success because,
like the entertainment industry that was built before it,
they create value from practically nothing.
Even Apple, it does still deal primarily in physical products with material costs,
adds a significant markup to the raw materials something like an iPhone is made out of.
Better still, the company outsources the entirety of the manufacturing supply
chain to other countries, so the economy of California is only left
with the highest paying jobs that come from this industry as a whole.
If the entertainment and tech industries weren't already enough by themselves,
California has also taken this highly value-adding approach to other,
more traditional industries as well.
California still has a major agricultural sector, but they have a focus on high-value crops.
In particular their wineries are world famous,
and the vineyards that produce a $50 bottle of wine are adding a lot more value within
their business than a farmer who grows commodity crops like corn.
If nothing else, the Californian economy shows that economic success
is rarely if ever attributed to just one lucky break.
The state would not be the 4th or 5th largest economy in the world today if it didn't capitalise
on multiple gold rushes, not just one, but it also isn't without some serious problems.
California by many accounts is a state in decline, its population is shrinking,
the companies that have made it so successful in recent decades are expanding beyond its borders,
or simply moving out, and the industries themselves are starting to struggle as
there's not much room left to grow after they've effectively dominated the global market.
In many ways, California today has the same problems that it had 170 years ago,
and the same thing that many other countries around the world have as well, Dutch disease.
Now Dutch disease is normally associated with resource-rich economies, California does have
that, but as we explored earlier it's only a minor component of its economy today.
But that doesn't mean that it can't have the same problems.
There is nothing inherently wrong with having a lot of natural resources,
of course all other things being equal that can be a great benefit to the economy,
but it does come with some serious side effects which need to be carefully managed,
or else the economy can end up worse off than it started,
as is the case with dozens of resource-rich economies around the world today.
The first side effect is an over-dependence on natural resources, which means economic ups and
downs become determined by commodity prices which are inherently unstable,
so they make the economy unstable as well.
The second side effect is crowding out of other industries for investment and labour.
When one industry is bringing in practically unlimited revenue,
investors are going to want to put their money into that industry,
neglecting any promising businesses in other industries.
Workers are also going to seek out high-paying jobs in that industry,
often forcing other businesses to raise wages to compete, or reduce their output due to lack of
staffing. Highly compensated workers also have more purchasing power, which when combined with
constrained supply pushes prices up beyond the reach of people that are not working in
the natural resource sector. Both of these forces in turn make the economy even more
dependent on the one industry bringing in revenue, which again creates a very unstable economy.
Now this is most commonly a problem with natural resources,
but there's no reason that it's exclusively a problem with natural resources.
The tech and entertainment industries in California represent a significant
portion of the state's economy and have caused exactly the same set of problems.
Cost of living is high, and people working regular jobs can't afford to live there anymore,
which reduces the supply of regular goods and services, further harming cost of living.
The big difference today is that people are not stuck in California anymore.
Moving is cheap and easy, and since a lot of people working in these industries came
from out of state or out of the country, they're no stranger to moving where there are better
opportunities. And unlike a sovereign nation, there are fewer restrictions to moving elsewhere
within the US as well. The economically advised best course of action for a country dealing
with dutch disease is to ensure that the whole economy benefits from the export industry through
taxes that are then used to support the whole country. The problem for California is that it's
not a country. And unlike natural resources, tech companies don't need to operate in an area where
they dig stuff out of the ground. Major employers have already shown that people can work from home,
or in extreme cases, the entire operation can be moved to states with looser business
restrictions and fewer taxes. Now nobody can predict the future, least of all economists.
But California is almost certainly not going anywhere anytime soon.
But today, more than ever, it's facing international and domestic challenges,
and it needs to present a compelling reason to maintain its industries.
For a long time, the assumption that California was just the place that people went to develop
tech and produce entertainment was good enough, but it probably won't be forever.
Okay, now it's time to put California on the economics explained national leaderboard,
which we have done before, but that was over two years ago, and a lot has changed since then.
Starting as always with size, California has an estimated GDP of 3.4 to 3.6 trillion dollars,
making it comparable with the 4th or 5th largest national economy in the world,
if it was to be counted as its own country.
Of course, it's not, so these figures are less accurate than regular world bank figures,
because things like imports and exports, which are major components of economic output,
are harder to measure over state borders, where unlike international borders,
almost no records are kept of what is coming or going.
Even still, the state gets a 9 out of 10.
Taking those GDP estimates and spreading it out over California's population of 39.2 million people
means that the state has a GDP per capita of just under 90,000 dollars,
which puts it in line with countries like Norway and Switzerland.
So it gets a 9 out of 10, only really falling behind the true outliers with 6-figure GDPs.
Stability and confidence is both helped and hurt by being part of the largest
and most influential economy in the world.
Helped because it uses the global reserve currency,
it has a huge domestic market for its products,
and it has the protection of the US federal government if it finds itself in trouble.
But it's also hurt because it has to compete for talent,
investment and spending with other states that have some unfair advantages,
like Texas with its lower taxes subsidised by natural resources.
Its focus on a few huge industries has caused social issues,
and they may cause economic issues long term as well, but for now the state gets an 8 out of 10.
Growth has been strong and consistent,
only shrinking after the 2008 financial crisis and the global lockdowns of 2020.
It's also maintained a growth rate above the US average,
which itself has outpaced most advanced economies.
California gets an 8 out of 10.
Finally, industry.
There isn't much to say here.
California is home to more world-leading companies than every other country on earth,
apart from the United States itself.
Not only are the companies massive, they are also in highly technical industries
that don't rely on extracting value from limited resources.
California gets an easy 10 out of 10.
Altogether, that gives California an average score of 8.8 out of 10,
a marked improvement from two years ago, considering it had a great score back then too.
If you liked this video, you will like the one that we did recently on areas inside the US
that are shrinking even faster than California.
You should be able to click to that on your screen now.
Thanks for watching mate, bye.
