A. Scott Bolden, former DC Democratic Party Chair, and NTD news contributor, and Chet Love, Republican strategist and founding partner of the Cornerstone Group, joined a panel discussion with Steve Lance, NTD Washington, D.C. bureau chief, and host of Capitol Report, to discuss President Donald Trump's response to six Democratic lawmakers encouraging U.S. military service members to defy the president's orders. The panel also analyzed socialist Mayor-elect of New York City Zohran Mamdani's Friday visit to the White House to meet with President Trump on Friday. They also discussed the Bureau of Labor Statistics report that the U.S. economy added 119,000 jobs in September, higher than economists' expectations, the president's use of tariffs as tools to get better deals for America, and how the current price increases are caused by shifts in the supply chains due to the war in Ukraine.
President Trump is calling six
Democratic lawmakers traitors. This
after they made a video which tells
service members that you can refuse
illegal orders. Joining us now to unpack
it all, we have a Scott Balden, former
DC Democratic Party chair and entity
news contributor and Chet Love,
Republican strategist and founding
partner of the cornerstone group. Uh
gentlemen, it's great to have you back
with us.
>> Good evening.
>> It's uh it's great to have you. So,
President Trump calling these six
Democratic lawmakers traitors. Uh, this
after the video telling the lawmakers
that you can refuse illegal orders.
Let's take a look at how the White House
press secretary responded. You have
sitting members of the United States
Congress who conspired together to
orchestrate a video message to members
of the United States military to active
duty service members to members of the
national security apparatus encouraging
them to defy the president's lawful
orders. Every single order that is given
to this United States military by this
commander-in-chief and through this
command chain of command through the
secretary of war is lawful. And the
courts have proven that there's
>> Scott. I think it's important to
highlight these weren't just any
lawmakers. These were lawmakers with
intel backgrounds, former CIA, former
military, naval officers. Were they out
of line? I don't think they were out of
line at all because what the press
secretary said, even your introductory
remarks is written were not exactly the
same and on point as what these
individuals said. They were all public
servants and they were simply reminding
um the the military members of the
military given the type of directive or
orders that they're getting what's
written in the military justice code and
that is anyone whether you're on the
battlefield or whether you're taking
orders here can refuse an illegal order
is that if as the press secretary says
if all of Donald Trump's orders are
legal and we know some of them have not
been legal and they've even tried to go
against and not follow federal orders
from courts. If they're legal, then they
must follow them. But if they're
illegal, right, it's right there in
writing. They're trained on this. Then
they don't have to follow that order.
It's a painful reminder, unfortunately.
And this administration drives this
negative narrative. But as my mother
said, a hit dog will holler, right? So
the Democrats hit the White House and
they're hollering right now, but they're
taking out of context and misquing what
that commercial was. and that was you
don't have to follow illegal orders.
>> Jed, I can see you want to jump in.
>> Context is everything and Democrats at
the end of the day, my dear friend
Scott, hit dogs holler, but when you run
the bus over them and ask for
insurrection, when you're asking for uh
the military members to not follow the
chain of command, what are you asking
about? And in the context, context
matters. What we've seen again and again
is Democrats have tried to create an
environment and a narrative in this
country that America's off the rails,
that it's a dangerous time. And yet here
and now you have Democrats, not
Republicans, not President Trump,
Democrats. Cuz if Republicans or Donald
Trump would have said something like
this during the Biden administration,
you guys would have been wallto-wall
screaming up and down about insurrection
and everything else. Just it it's
Listen,
>> I wish you could run the video over and
over again, point by point, and tell me
what bothers and scares Republicans
about what is written in the military
justice code. All they did was repeat
it.
>> They in the context.
>> Well, there's no context. The plain
statement, the plain reading, you can
put it up on the screen. The plain
reading of what they said and what's in
the military code of justice. Now,
what's really bugging you about it is
this that are these lawy are these
orders legal or illegal? Some of them
have been found to be illegal. And the
military members have to make a judgment
call, right? They've made movies about
these judgment calls when when you
believe that a commanding officer is
giving you an illegal order. Now, I
don't recommend
>> be fair, Scott, if they actually spoke
specifically to an issue.
>> That's what they said.
>> They did. No, they simply gave an
illegal statement with no context. But
we understand what's going on.
Immigration orders. We understand what's
going on in terms of the president
trying to do things uh to prevent
terrorist activity of Venezuela and
bringing drugs on. Those things are
absolutely legal. Those things are
completely right. And again, Democrats
are just off the rails. If a soldier
believes that it is illegal,
>> he can ignore those orders or not follow
those orders if he hold on. If he
believes that they're illegal, now he
better be right about it cuz he can get
court. No, he's got to be right about
it. But it's right there in the military
code of justice.
>> You want each individual
uh soldier to have to make some legal
determination about that? You're calling
for war. This is ridiculous and it's
irresponsible for Democrats.
>> We're trying to avoid war. We want to
stop the killing of V Venezuela farmers
and sailors. We want to stop the
military from walking the streets of
urban centers illegally. And federal
court orders have said it's illegal.
>> To Chad's point, though, how much
subjectivity is built into this?
>> Well, it's each individual soldier's
call, right? He's got to look at the
totality of the circumstances. He's got
if he's going to challenge an order,
then he's got the opportunity to
challenge that order if he thinks these
circumstances cannote illegality. right
now. He's got to be proven right because
he will certainly be brought up on
charges and so forth and so on. But this
is a constitutional this is a moral
issue that soldiers and sailors have to
make every day. You don't have to
blindly follow an order your commander
gives you if in your heart of hearts you
think it's illegal. That's the law and
it's written in the military code of
justice and they're trained on it. What
is bothering you about? There's no
context.
>> Asking your kids to make you and I have
the benefit of having gone to
Washington.
>> Why is it in the code?
>> Why is it in the code?
>> NO, THERE ARE CODES, THE MILITARY CODE
OF JUSTICE. BUT AT THE END of the day,
the issue fundamentally again is we
should not be asking our kids who are
going out and serving their country to
now try to make legal decisions about
whether something's legal or illegal.
that our commander-in-chief, who has
been struck down, several of his orders
have been struck down by the federal
judiciary, article 3 courts, shouldn't
be asking men and women of our military
to commit illegal acts or give them
illegal orders. All those Democrats did
was remind them, you have this right to
not follow illegal orders, and the
courts have said the same.
>> Sorry,
>> it bugs you, but the truth hurts. I
>> I've heard Democrats talk about dog
whistles before. Just saying. Uh, with
that said, another point of controversy.
New York City Mayor elect Zoran Mdani
uh, visiting the White House tomorrow to
meet with the president. President Trump
calling him a communist ahead of the
announcement. Scott, do you see any
common ground coming out of this to help
the people of New York? And what do you
think Mamani wants out of the meeting?
Well, I think both of them want peace in
the sense that New York is a very
important city, the largest city in this
uh country. Uh I think that uh the feds
a lot of federal dollars that go into
the state of New York that service all
Americans, not just Democrats or
Republicans or independents, all of
them. And so uh I don't think either
side wants data. They want certain
agreements. They want to be able to work
together. Maybe they cut some private
deals, but in the end they've got to
learn a way to work together. Donald
Trump is going to call him a communist.
I don't think Mandame cares whether you
call him a communist or a socialist.
He's a democratic socialist. He has some
socialist ideas. He's owned that part,
right? But what scares the Republicans
and what scares moderate Democrats most
about uh Mandani is that he has taught
you that affordability is the number one
issue and that Americans, whatever your
political affiliation, they don't care
what you label them. If he's going to
improve the quality of my life, if he's
going to make life more affordable,
especially in New York, then I'm gonna
not only listen to him, support him,
vote for him, and hold him accountable
for some of his ideas, but if he can
make education and healthcare more
affordable, if I can buy houses and
transportation and health care for my
kids more affordable, then I'm going to
give that guy a shot. And that was the
message from New York. Now, now in
Virginia, you got a moderate Democrat
that won, right? So this isn't some vast
socialist conspiracy that's sweeping the
country politically. Every race is
different. Every jurisdiction is
different. And you can see that the
Democrats, whether it's Virginia or New
York, is a big tent. May not like it,
but it's a big tent.
>> Chad, what do you see coming out of the
meeting tomorrow?
>> Well, I think number one is Mandami is
going to be looking for every single
opportunity he can to find excuses for
not delivering on his promises. And what
we know is that the thing that Mandami
is scared most about is that all the
things that he promised, he can't just
deliver as the mayor of New York. He's
really relying on the governor. She's
talking about free buses. He's talking
about all these different things. They
can't do that simply within New York on
their own. They need to be able to go to
the state capital. They need help from
the federal government in order to
achieve those goals. So I think
fundamentally what you're seeing from
him and and what he's doing is going to
try to use the federal government as a
scapegoat for why he's not able to
actually deliver on these promises. And
in due respect to my colleague Scott,
the reality is that Democrats are
socialist. The number one candidate
right now is AOC. And you got Bernie
Sanders who has taken over this party
now and he's gone around the country
with AOC criticizing Democrats. Yeah,
sure. Gavin Newsome, you know, is
polling really well, etc. But we know
right now that this party is being taken
over by the extreme left wing of the
party. You don't know who women are. You
don't you want to give free stuff away.
Sure, you do, but you're not running the
Democratic party right now.
>> Let me just say this. I've been I've
come on national TV on your show and I'
for the first time in my life I've been
called a socialist and I'm a former
chair of the DC Chamber of Commerce and
I have a huge law practice. But okay,
I'll take whatever label you want. If I
can better this country and I know you
want the best for this country. If we
can work with socialists and
conservatives and independents to make
America better and to make it more
affordable, I'll work with anybody.
Remember, Donald Trump is a can be very
charming. I don't expect a blowup with
their at their meeting. Whether they
open it up to the press or not, they
probably will. Uh I I believe he's going
to try to charm Mandani. I think Mandani
is going to try to charm him because
real politically and economically they
really do need each other. He loves New
York. He's cuz he's stuck with the the
new mayor of New York, right? They
certainly need federal funds. They
certainly need funds to make America uh
to make New York safe again. And so
there is some common ground. They may
never agree politically, but they're
going to have to work together. And I
think Donald Trump knows that and I
think Montani knows that.
>> And uh Chad to Scott's point, both of
their campaigns with the issue of
affordability. President Trump appealed
to the workingclass
uh Americans that you know the forgotten
American man and woman Mani very similar
messages but two polar opposites uh in
terms of how to get there. One is
through you know growth and capitalism,
the other through socialism. Do you see
a path for them to perhaps come out of
the meeting tomorrow with some common
ground?
>> Well, I think we all hope at the end of
the day regardless of political party to
what Scott's point is that we're
focusing on trying to make life better
for the average everyday working
American. And what we know today is
absolutely affordability is a major
issue and one of those issues is energy.
And so President Trump's policies around
drill baby drill and lowering overall
fuel costs have been successful and
we've seen that on average nationally.
That's gone down around the country. The
challenge we have still seen around
electricity rates. And so what we know
is that we need more electrons on the
grid. And so we hopefully we could see
more policies coming out of this meeting
to talk about putting things more on the
grid like solar, renewable energy, wind,
etc. Because in states like New York and
in cities like New York, they need as
many electrons as they possibly can to
help try to reduce or at least maintain
the cost of electricity versus going up
for the average American. And that's
where Mandami as well as President Trump
both have aligned goals.
>> Boy, if Donald Trump brings up clean
energy tomorrow and gets on the program
to to save planet Earth, I'll be a
monkeykey's uncle, if you will. But but
but hope springs eternal. Go right
ahead. We'll see.
>> I mean, the the electricity issue,
>> I agree with you conceptually. I do.
>> That that was a big one in New Jersey.
Yeah, we saw that perhaps propel the uh
Democratic governor there, Mikey Cheryl,
into office in New Jersey. Lastly,
there's the issue uh that hits home for
everybody, which we've been talking
about is the economy. Uh the United
States gaining 119 jobs in September.
That's more than double
>> 19,000,
>> excuse me, 119,000. Uh more than double
what economists expected. Um Scott, what
do you think ultimately attributed to
this number?
>> Uh we'll have to get behind the numbers.
you know, the the the Bureau of Labor
Statistics, I don't think they put that
that out, and if they did, that that
number is really late. Um, but you know,
we know Fortune 500 companies are laying
off people. But depending on the market,
depending on the industry, right, then
you can have some industries that always
benefit from economic slowdown or labor
slowdown and others that don't do as
well, like agriculture. Uh but let's not
forget that what's driving this economy
is the economic terrorism of Donald
Trump. Tariffs, tariffs, tariffs. You
just saw today where he pulled back the
tariffs on beef and coffee out of on on
the country of Brazil and he's pulling
back in some of the other South American
countries because he's it's clear his
economic advisors are telling them your
tariffs short-term or long-term are are
taxes and is being passed on to the
public. He promised to bring prices
down. He promised a stronger economy and
within a year he's being blamed for this
economy. He doesn't want to own it. He
wants to talk about Biden, but the but
the polls are showing that it's his
economy and he's not doing well. He's in
the 30s right now on approval,
especially with the economy.
>> Chad, I mean, tariffs in your opinion,
are they, you know, short-term pain for
long-term gain?
>> Well, yeah, because again, we have to
put this in context, and the American
people really need to to hear this.
Democrats are relying on people not
reading and understanding the facts. The
facts of the matter is that this 119,000
jobs that we saw, why was this late? Why
did it come out? Because Democrats shut
down the government for 41 days and no
one was there to be able to do the work.
And why did they not want these numbers
to come out? Because they were trying to
win this election in these few states.
and they ended up damaging America,
creating all this havoc for the just to
try to win with in New York and Virginia
and and a few other down ballot races.
What we know specifically is that these
119,000 jobs, they went into the private
sector. During the Biden administration,
we saw a lot of fake jobs where the
government was basically creating these
part-time jobs for people to create
better job numbers. What we see under
the Trump administration is these jobs
are actually going to Americans. They're
not going to foreign workers. They're
not going to illegal immigrants. They're
actually going to hardworking Americans.
And that's where the President Trump and
Republicans have a great story to tell.
And Democrats consistently are
misinterpreting the facts and trying to
lead America astray because they don't
have a message. They don't have a
strategy. All they want to do is simply
resist and block because they don't have
a vision for the party. Because again,
their party is being led by communists
who just want to give everything. voters
certainly now within a year of his
[clears throat] election believe it's
his economy. He's getting failing grace
for the economy. Nothing's more
affordable. He's doing just the
opposite. And the difference is that
he's driving that negative economic
narrative. His economic terrorism. He
voluntarily put these tariffs on every
country across the board. It was never a
plan. It was helter skelter. Which is
why you can't keep up whether you got a
country that's got tariffs or not. He
pulls them back. He uses them to
threaten countries and what have you.
And so there is no real economic plan
here. I know micro I know
macroeconomics. I don't know
microeconomics, but I can tell you macro
tariffs are taxes and tariffs make it
more expensive for those here if we
can't produce those products.
>> But my dear Scott, I went to college. I
have an MBA in economics. So I can tell
you about macro and President Trump has
used these tariffs as leverage tools and
he's negotiated better deals for
America. At the end of the day, yes, he
put tariffs on these different countries
and they've come back with better deals.
We've improved our overall trade
strategy across the country. It's not
killing the economy. That is a wrong
number. No, no, no. And again, this is a
mis this is a misstatement by Democrats
to say that tariffs are causing for
inflation inflation. No, because people
don't understand the because again
people are misinterpreting and
misstating the facts. The reality is in
America today, the increases that we're
seeing in prices have to do with supply
chains. The war in Ukraine and with
Russia that's causing for supply chains
with natural gas, the causing
fertilizers. No, I'm saying it that's
not having to do with tariffs, but the
supply chains have fundamentally
shifted. The actual tariffs in this
country impact less than 5% of the
overall increase that you American
family that
>> we do we do have to leave it there. We
did see the 1 trillion coming in
yesterday up from 600 billion to 1
trillion. Great discussion guys. Really
appreciate both of you joining.