Life isn't equal, and neither are incomes. But is government redistribution the solution? In this episode of Cash Course, teens dive into the economics of fairness with playful illustrations that show what happens when the government tries to spread wealth around. Learn how such policies affect incentives, the free market, and why redistribution often comes at a steep cost.
Before we start this episode, here's a
quick preview of what's coming. Ready to
take charge of your finances and master
the art of money management? Cash Course
is your ultimate guide to financial
literacy from personal budgeting to
macroeconomics. Check out more episodes
at prageru.com.
We all have different skills. Some can
sing really well. the O and
love.
Some are skilled at math.
[Music]
>> But having one skill sometimes means not
having another.
[Music]
>> Skills aren't distributed equally, and
the same goes for income.
Yep, it's unavoidable. From the freest
economy on earth to the most controlled
and restricted, income inequality is
everywhere. There will always be a mix
of people with a lot of wealth, some
with a little bit, and some with well,
not that much. This spread in a whole
population is called the distribution of
income. Any distribution of income comes
with inequality and many governments see
this as a huge problem. Some try to
close the gap between rich and poor and
smooth out that distribution with
policies to redistribute wealth. The
most common way to measure income
inequality involves plotting a Loren's
curve. I know. I know. That's a graph
that shows how much wealth is owned by
what portion of the population. A
straight 45° line means that wealth is
equally distributed. Then you plot the
wealth distribution of a country. Throw
in a little calculus and voila, you get
a number between 1 and zero. What are
you talking about?
Uh, don't worry about it. What's
important is that number between 1 and
zero called the genie coefficient. Zero
means complete equality and one means
complete inequality where one person
owns everything. The US sits in the
middle of that spectrum with 0.42.
>> Hi there, I'm from the government and
I'm here to help. This help mainly
involves collecting taxes from higher
earners to fund programs that usually
consist of transfer payments.
Transactions where one group gives money
or services to another group but
receives nothing in return. Programs
aimed at helping people with lower
incomes by groceries, health care, or
basic everyday needs are all transfer
payments.
>> See, I told you the government was here
to help.
>> Those who support redistributing income
to address inequality claim it has
potential upsides. They argue that
taxing high earners more and using that
revenue to fund transfer payments will
help those in financial trouble. They
also claim redistribution will prevent
the social unrest that might happen when
wealth appears to be concentrated in one
small group. These arguments assume that
empowering the government to
redistribute wealth is an overall
positive.
>> I mean, what can't the government do? Am
I right? Unfortunately, government
redistribution comes at a high cost and
it rarely changes the distribution of
income in any lasting way. Unlike the
fastmoving market where buyers and
sellers deal directly with each other,
transfer payments require going through
a third party, usually the government,
and the government tends to be slower,
more wasteful, and less efficient.
>> Yeah, I'll get right on that.
The real downside, however, is that
redistribution disincentivizes work. If
people know they'll receive money
regardless of how hard they work, or
even if they don't work at all, they
won't be motivated to improve or be more
productive. And with no extra rewards
for hard work, fewer people will put in
the time and effort to be surgeons,
singers, or mathematicians in the first
place. History also shows that raising
taxes for redistribution programs risks
wealthy individuals taking their
productive capital elsewhere. If enough
of them leave, an economy could suffer,
losing important resources for everyone
and leaving even less wealth to
distribute. Finally, many people think
it's plain unfair of governments to take
money from one group and give it to
another. Just as income inequality can
lead to social unrest, heavy
redistribution policies can trigger
envy, division, and even well, social
unrest. Why did you get money? Because
I'm special. I can do math. You produce
useless research. Oh, like singing is so
useful.
Countries handle income inequality
differently. For example, Sweden and
Denmark blend a free market with high
taxes for a strong social safety net. In
contrast, the US has relatively lower
redistribution, lower taxes, and greater
income differences, but offers higher
social mobility. Millions move here
yearly to work hard and advance based on
personal choices. Learning new skills,
taking tough jobs, and seeking
opportunities can significantly increase
income over time.
>> 2 * 6 is 12. 2 * 7 14. Yeah. Then there
are command economies with their
promises of equality. That might sound
enticing, but everywhere this kind of
redistribution has been tried, it
concentrated wealth in the hands of a
few people with government connections
and left everyone equally dirt poor.
Inequality is a fact of life. Any
economy will always have people who are
much wealthier than others. Government
may attempt to flatten inequality by
redistribution, but in reality, those
attempts tend to be expensive,
inefficient, and cause all sorts of
social problems. Whatever the
government's doing or not doing, it's
important to understand the cause and
effect of wealth redistribution on your
country, your community, and you.
Brilliant.
Watch more at prageruids.com.
And parents, don't forget to subscribe.