Why do people take jobs, shop at certain stores, or move where they’ll pay fewer taxes? Incentives. In this cold-case episode of Cash Course, a detective investigates how everyday economic motivators drive decisions—and how even the best intentions can lead to costly consequences. High school students will learn how incentives influence behavior and shape economic outcomes on both a personal and national level.
Before we start this episode, here's a
quick preview of what's coming. Ready to
take charge of your finances and master
the art of money management? Cash Course
is your ultimate guide to financial
literacy from personal budgeting to
macroeconomics. Check out more episodes
at prageru.com.
[Music]
My editor said you have another cash
story for me. What is it? Stocks?
Unemployment?
>> Incentives?
incentives. That's not going to sell.
>> Easy, darling. Any factor that can
reward one person but punish another is
one you don't want to mess with.
Fortunes rise, empires fall, wrapped in
a thousand incentives. They're always
lurking, often buried underneath a
mountain of good intentions. By the time
consequences show up, and they always
do, it's often too late to change
course.
>> Fine, I'll bite. What are incentives?
>> An incentive is any factor that pushes
people toward one behavior instead of
another. Take monetary incentives. We
all need to earn and save some dough. If
there's one factor that pushes people to
work certain jobs, shop at certain
stores, or live somewhere where they'll
pay fewer taxes.
>> Oh, yeah.
>> It's that monetary reward.
>> So, incentives are money.
>> You wish. time, convenience, gifts, and
perks. Any reward that motivates people
can be an incentive. And there's the
opposite, disincentives.
A good way to discourage people from
doing something is by attaching fines,
penalties, and other punishments to
certain behaviors. A parking ticket, a
tax audit, a foul that gives the other
team a free throw. All disincentives. H
>> any interesting cases?
>> Plenty. But three stick out in my mind
like white on rice. All involving
someone named Mr. Good Intention.
Recognize this?
Yeah. Honest trade coffee. Some poor
coffee farmer gets a higher price for
his product. So what?
>> I'll tell you what, incentive, son.
Yes, paying farmers an above market rate
for every bean will increase their
income in the short term,
>> but artificially high prices create
another incentive. They motivate more
people to become coffee farmers.
>> Yeah. Okay.
>> In the long term, this can make a
country's economy dependent on one
activity.
>> Oh,
>> more people choosing to be coffee
producers can mean fewer people becoming
doctors, teachers, or engineers. Not
good for a developing country with a
shortage of these professions.
>> That wasn't the intention.
>> That's exactly the problem.
>> What's wrong with good intentions?
>> Nothing except the perverse incentives
that they can create. A perverse
incentive is a reward that backfires and
achieves the opposite of what you
intend. Perverse incentives reward
people for lying, cheating, for doing
other things you don't want, like
breeding snakes.
recognize this British India, city of
Delhi. You remember?
>> Yeah. There was a cobra problem, but it
was taken care of.
>> Was it though? Story goes that British
officials paid a bounty for every cobra
head the locals brought in from the
street. It worked at first, but after a
while, more snakes started to show up.
Turns out the very people the bounty
intended to help were breeding cobras.
Motivated by generous financial reward,
they had every incentive to help keep
supplying them and never solve the snake
problem. A classic case of perverse
incentives.
>> That was never our intention.
>> After all that intentions again,
>> some people never change.
>> A potato.
>> Last story. Soviet Russia 1936.
[Music]
>> The ES for Bush.
>> If you want choices, you should think
about incentives.
Russia was a command economy back then.
The government set the targets for
agricultural production, including
potatoes.
Farmers were expected to meet those
targets, and if they didn't, well, bad
news. This lack of choice and economic
freedom meant they spent their time and
resources producing what the government
wanted rather than what the marketplace
wanted. The result, lots of potatoes and
not much else. And the farmers couldn't
even sell them for a profit. This
control of production happened across
the entire Soviet economy where all
rewards and monetary incentives that
motivate people in a free market economy
were non-existent.
And anyone who complained was punished.
>> Hold on. We were trying to make society
fair and equal.
>> It was equal. All right. Equally poor
and unmotivated.
>> No choices, nothing to gain. Where's the
incentive to work hard and grow a
variety of food for people?
>> Exactly.
>> So that's the story. Incentives are what
matter, not intentions.
>> You got it. Chasing intentions might
seem noble, but incentives are the
bottom line. Understanding them, how
they motivate people, and guide their
decisions is the key to having a free
and thriving economy.
>> Any last words?
>> Cobra.
>> Cobra. Is there more to the story?
>> No. No, it's a cobra.
>> Watch more at pragerukids.com.
And parents, don't forget to subscribe.