According to a Financial Times report that cites an internal White House Memo, Chinese tech company Alibaba has provided technological support to the Chinese military, specifically the People’s Liberation Army (PLA), in operations “targeting U.S. objectives.” The White House declined to comment on the Financial Times story.
NTD discussed with Daniel Cochrane, a senior research associate at the Heritage Foundation's Center for Technology and the Human Person, and David Zhang, host of China Insider. -- 📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
Welcome back to NTD. Good morning. I'm
Carrie Dunst. Alibaba, China's
e-commerce giant, is facing serious
allegations of providing tech support to
the Chinese military. Support that may
be used in operations targeting US
interests. The company is also accused
of sharing sensitive customer data,
including IP addresses, payment records,
and Wi-Fi details with the Chinese
regime. This is according to a Financial
Times report that cites an internal
White House memo. And this isn't a
firsttime event for Alibaba. US
lawmakers have raised alarms with some
urging the Trump administration to take
tougher action against the Alibaba
group. So what does all this mean for US
national security and the broader tech
landscape? Well, joining us to break it
down is Daniel Cochran. He's a senior
research associate at the Heritage
Foundation and host of China Insider
David Jang, who brings deep insights
into China's tech and geopolitical
strategies. Welcome to you both. Thanks
for joining. Daniel, starting with you.
For those unfamiliar with Alibaba, it
would be helpful if you could give us
its scope in and outside of China as
well as highlight a little bit about
these recent allegations which are are
quite significant from a national
security perspective.
>> Certainly. Well, Alibaba is one of
China's largest tech companies. They
provide both cloud services, so similar
to Amazon here in the United States.
They allow for companies and individuals
to essentially host data um and also
engage in various compute functions via
servers that they host. Now the problem
is they're also providing AI tools. They
provide significant AI LLM and those
LLMs are being utilized by the Chinese
military against American interests as
the uh as as the memo highlighted. This
is really an interesting development
because we've also seen similar things
happen with American companies. So
specifically anthropic here in the
United States recently disrupted uh
attempts by Chinese state actors to use
their agentic AI claude against
highlevel American targets including
financial institutions, chemical
companies, even government targets. We
also know that Tik Tok has long been
collecting Americans data and that
companies like Alibaba and Tik Tok have
a obligation under Chinese law to
participate with the CCP to target
Americans and to profile us. It's a
really concerning uh threat to our
national security and our sovereignty.
>> Yeah, you make up you bring up a couple
great points there. one obviously we saw
Tik Tok getting transferred to US
ownership but Alibaba which uh about 20%
of online shoppers say that they go to
Alibaba so it its scale is quite
significant in the US and David of
course Alibaba now has denied these
accusations that they have any
cooperation with the Chinese military um
but in Washington they're not so
convinced so how deeply integrated in
your understanding is Alibaba with the
Chinese state and uh you know their
military capacity.
>> Well, Carrie, it's a very interesting
because for Alibaba, it's not like
somebody in China just goes to their
office and demands them to do certain
things, but it's a very systematic sort
of pressure and procedure to do so. So,
from the very beginning, the the
management behind Alibaba had to grow
the company through the influence of the
Chinese regime. So they've been sort of
tied together in the very beginning. But
obviously there's also data laws and
security laws in China that mandates
that Chinese companies especially tech
companies uh if should they require
their data that they have to share with
the with the Chinese government. But
also think about what the interest of
the Chinese government and its companies
really have. It is a total unrestricted
warfare against the United States. So
financial, cyber, and tech are part of
that. And so combining all of this, you
really see what's essentially an agenda
uh to compete against American
companies, but also at the same time
provide something called a civil
military fusion, which essentially
there's no real distinctions between a
civilian company or a military company.
So at any given moment, a company in
China could be weaponized, especially if
it is like somebody like Alibaba that
has so much data in its hands uh from
consumers, but also industry leaders
alike. And in those sense, you you
combine everything together. It's really
a comprehensive system that's at play.
>> Yeah, you bring up some very interesting
points, particularly around how when you
think of warfare, you think of tanks and
planes and and that's really not the
modern warfare system and especially um
with this unrestricted warfare where you
know potentially cyber attacks. Uh these
are all things that could be enabled
through these these fusions as you
described them. Uh Daniel, over to you.
What are the legal and then ethical
risks for US companies who do want to
engage with Chinese check tech giants
like Alibaba for commercial interests?
>> The risks have never been higher both
from an ethical and national security
standpoint. Look, especially when you're
putting your data on their servers. We
we had this with Tik Tok, too. All that
data is stored in servers in China. It's
accessible at any at any time by the
companies or the governments. And as
David mentioned, there really isn't a
separation between the companies in the
military. It's all integrated. Every
company is a potential weapon of the
Chinese Communist Party. And we know
that they've been very clear their goal
is to use the best technologies out
there, specifically AI to perpetrate
attacks against American targets. That's
includes crippling our critical
infrastructure. It includes as an
example hacking um systems like our like
the the system behind um our our flights
here in the United States the the the
aircraft here in the United States uh
that which can really create delays and
huge huge problems for our economy. So,
we got to understand this sort of the
civil mil civil military fusion that
David mentioned, but we also need to
understand that when you put your data
in an in an LLM or in a cloud service uh
hosted by a Chinese company like
Alibaba, you're basically just helping
the Chinese military create digital
profiles to surveil, censor, and control
American interests. It's really a
concerning development.
>> Yeah. Yeah, and as I had alluded to
earlier, probably a relief that Tik Tok
is being transferred to US servers, but
as you pointed out, they have years and
years of that data. Um, but we don't
have reciprocity. Obviously, Amazon
can't operate inside China, but Alibaba
able to do commerce here in the US. And
and David, we know that China has been
aggressively pursuing AI and tech
innovations. Daniel was talking about,
you know, those large language models,
which really are the underpinnings of uh
how AI functions. So does Alibaba fit
into China's broader strategy to advance
you know this this technological and
military fusion that you had been
describing earlier?
>> Yeah. So really uh for the average
it's really hard to understand how data
can be weaponized. And the key here
isn't necessarily tomorrow they're going
to come into your front door and demand
certain things from you, but it is a
building up through these uh machine
learning and now essentially AI
functional models that create almost
like a strategic plan uh assessments or
even a plan of attacks against uh
certain interest in the United States.
For example, it could be the
intelligence community. It could be your
power grid or infrastructure, water
lines, anything specifically that they
can do to the system to cause
fear and to demand uh even sort of a
ransom out of those attacks or to simply
temporarily shut down certain things uh
can be done. But also with data
specifically, this is where it gets
really tricky because it's almost like
they know more about us than we do about
them. And so in warfare, a lot of times
it's really about knowing your enemies.
But that's also another point where you
know it could be individuals as well.
For example, if you're a local
politician, uh they could formulate a
plan to how to better win you over to
speak on behalf of the Chinese
government instead. Or maybe, you know,
it could be certain things like learning
about that you have certain debts that
they can reach out to help you pay off
in exchange for say secret uh
intelligence files or whatnot. So
there's different ways that they can use
data. Uh, and so for the average
American, they think that well, we don't
have to care about our data being used.
Well, in the age of of I guess you would
call this a cyber warfare or technology
warfare, uh, it's a very much of a
broadscale attack and plan of collection
of of information that we should really
be worried about. And honestly, a lot of
times my fear is that the very data that
they're able to be given uh by the by
the average Americans are in turn used
to harm u other parts of America in the
same way.
>> Yeah. You're talking about this use of
th this sensitive data maybe one data
piece in isolation not that meaningful
but when there's data data points that
can be triangulated and then use those
AI tools to then do things at scale it
it can be activated and it and it is a
vulnerability to that point Daniel um
with Alibaba's AI capabilities what
security threats do you think it poses
to the US specifically
>> yeah well well actually picking up on of
its point I think it's critical to
understand and as you said look you can
take with AI you can take a bunch of
seemingly disperate data points and link
them together because AI is
fundamentally a pattern recognition
technology uh it's very good at taking
disperate pieces of data and then
creating digital profiles figuring out
what your vulnerabilities are whether
it's an at an individual level or an
institutional or even at a governmental
level and finding those vulnerabilities
is of high value to the Chinese. But in
addition to that and but going beyond
the sort of the pattern recognition and
and and and the uncovering of
vulnerabilities that AI can provide and
is to the Chinese, it's also giving them
advanced cyber hacking capabilities. And
we know this because the Chinese are
using and I mentioned I mentioned
Enthropic which is an American company
and they they disrupted this attempt but
it was an attempt by Chinese actors to
use advanced LLM capabilities to hack
American basically American critical
infrastructure. I believe there was
something like over 30 targets. So we we
we know that they're using the AI not
just to parse data but also to
perpetrate attacks on our on our
critical infrastructure. So it's sort of
that it's that that two-part um that
two-part challenge. But I'll add a third
element and we saw this with Tik Tok. Um
and and we and the reality is that the
Chinese still control enormous amounts
of our tech stack. Other other
applications like Teu and we we know for
example that Tik Tok's algorithm was
designed to to to surface the most toxic
content that is a strategy to rend
America's social fabric. So AI in that
context in the cont context of of say AI
chat bots could be used strategically by
the Chinese to disrupt America's social
fabric. that's just as effective in some
way as hacking our critical
infrastructure and it's far more diffuse
and harder to combat.
>> Yeah, absolutely. That's a really
interesting point about how any division
in society, anything that stokes uh
chaos is in line with the unrestricted
warfare that David had been alluding to.
But, you know, marketers use this data
to try to figure out who they should be
their likely converters for, you know,
products they're selling. the platforms
use this, the social media platforms to
create engagement. So, David, as we
start to wrap up, I'd just like to get
some understandings of different other
use cases that the CCP might be trying
to, you know, mix these data sets,
consumer data sets with military
objectives with um, you know, uh, sort
of PR or publicity type objectives that
serve its greater goals,
>> right? And Danielle summarized it really
well with those three key uh, points.
And I just wanted to add on top of that
one additional one I think worth for us
to know is market uh caps, right?
Because the more that you see Chinese
products, the more that you see Chinese
content, the more you see things coming
out of China being in not just in the
United States but in other countries as
well, the more reliance you create. When
you have reliance, it's a long-term uh
dependence on something that you really
cannot get rid of. For example, with the
5G infrastructure or the 4G
infrastructures in the United States,
it's taking the country a very long time
to replace and swap out those uh
equipments. And those equipments when
they're in place, you're rely on them
for the communications, but also they
provide those surveillance capabilities
and potentially spying uh on say a key
military base nearby. So, it just shows
you that once you get these things into
the system, it takes a long time for
them to go away. With the digital
fentinel like Tik Tok, that goes a step
further. it's implanted into a
teenager's brain for certain types of
algorithm based uh content that they
like or desire. So, it's almost like
you're creating a a base for relying on
things coming out of China that
eventually serve a um very harmful
long-term effect uh to those in America
and other countries as well.
>> Yeah, if the term digital fentanyl
doesn't set off alarm bells, then you
really are asleep at the wheel. Such a
fascinating and important conversation.
and Daniel Cochran and David Jong, thank
you for joining me this morning. Thanks,