Day 1, Part 1: PTAC Public Meeting | Using Data to Empower Patients PCDT Presentation | September 8, 2025 | 1/8
The Physician-Focused Payment Model Technical Advisory Committee (PTAC) held a 2-day meeting on Using Data and Health Information Technology to Transparently Empower Consumers and Support Providers. This video includes: · Welcome from Abe Sutton, JD, Director, Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMS Innovation Center), and Deputy Administrator, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). · Preliminary Comments Development Team Overview of Using Data and Health Information Technology to Transparently Empower Consumers and Support Providers. (Timestamp – 18:33) Playlist of PTAC’s Developing and Implementing Performance Measures (Videos 1-8) https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrl7E8KABz1FOmtfEBRtI2A4gK794HPZN
Good morning and welcome to this meeting of the Physician-Focused Payment Model
Technical Advisory Committee, known as PTAC. My name is Dr. Chini Palluru, and I'm one of
the co-chairs of PTAC, along with Dr. Lee Mills. Since 2020, PTAC has been exploring themes that
have emerged from stakeholder-submitted proposals over the years. Previous PTAC theme-based
discussions have focused on topics such as reducing barriers to participation in alternative
payment models and supporting primary and specialty care transformation,
addressing the needs of patients with complex chronic conditions or serious illnesses,
encouraging rural participation, and improving management of care transitions.
At this public meeting, we have brought together various subject matter experts to gain perspectives
on using data and health information technology to transparently empower consumers and support
providers. We know that this topic is also of interest to the CMS Innovation Center.
Before our first session of the day, we are honored to have opening remarks from Mr. Abe Sutton,
the Director of the CMS Innovation Center and Deputy Administrator for the Centers for Medicare
and Medicaid Services. Mr. Sutton previously served as the principal at Rubicon Founders,
where he co-founded two health service companies, Honest Health, which focuses on enabling primary
care physicians and Evergreen Nephrology, which focuses on enabling nephrologists.
From 2017 to 2019, he also served at the National Economic Council, Domestic Policy Council,
and the Department of Health and Human Services. In these roles, Mr. Sutton coordinated health
policy across the federal government with a focus on value-based care, increasing choice
and competition in health care markets, and updating the federal government's approach to
kidney care. Welcome, Abe. Thank you for having me today, and good morning to all the members of
the Physician-Focused Payment Model Technical Advisory Committee. In March, I had the opportunity
to join you all for a public meeting where I delivered some of my first remarks in any setting
in this role. In that conversation, I got to preview at a high level some of our strategy
before we came out with it. Since that time, we came out with a public-facing strategy describing
how we were approaching our portfolio at the Innovation Center and what new models to focus on.
I'd like to take the opportunity today to speak in a bit more depth about that strategy now that
it is public. One of the exciting things for me leading the Innovation Center has been to see
the PTAC show interest in our strategy and to see the alignment between the themes the PTAC
is focused on and where we are focused as a center. Our strategy focused on evidence-based
prevention, empowering people to achieve their health goals, and choice and competition in
healthcare markets gets at the core of the changes necessary to transform the healthcare system into
ones where people are empowered to live healthier lives and to truly make America healthy again.
So, to get started on that, our first strategic pillar is focused on evidence-based prevention,
where we're really working model-by-model to embed prevention within each model,
taking a deliberate view on primary prevention or disease prevention to tertiary prevention,
the focus on managing chronic diseases. We are also focused on driving choice and competition
in our third pillar, namely through reducing administrative burden for independent physicians
engaging with our models, simplifying and standardizing our portfolio choices to make
them easier to navigate, and creating more predictability in our models through standardizing
quality metrics. It doesn't make sense to report things six different times to CMS,
so they show up in different payment structures. If we could access the data once and then do the
customization required to put in forms or even use the same exact measure, because we want the
same incentive facing people in clinical practice, that would make things easier to navigate.
But today's conversation will mostly focus on our second pillar, patient empowerment. When we
think about patient empowerment at the Innovation Center, we really mean that we want patients to
be in the driver's seat for their healthcare outcomes, which means they have the resources,
information, and incentives to achieve their health goals. That means we're working through
our future model tests to equip patients with the information they need at their fingertips
to make informed decisions, to make the right choice, and have it presented in a clear format
where they're positioned to understand their health status, to set goals, and to make decisions
with their providers, engage more actively in their care. In terms of what patient empowerment
means for our models, in a more concrete sense, it could be different approaches to data sharing
or new CMS apps and reimbursement structures for them or testing wearable devices in the
context of our rapid cycle innovation program. It could mean finding new payment flexibilities
to activate patient engagement in their health and promote healthy living. Very often in the
center's model design experience, we think about the driver of behavior and the driver diagram
that is involved, and we think about this often from the provider experience. We're very focused
on how providers engage with our models, the experience they have, what incentives they have
to act in different ways. Taking that same perspective and now applying it to patients
is the core of this pillar. Well, what is the patient experience? What are the choices they
are presented with at different junctures, and how can we engage with them to empower them?
Looking at their choices and what they face, there are a couple of things that we can do to shape
them. We could shape the provider's incentive to engage with them. We could open up markets for
people to go and engage with patients, and we could also think based off that about partnerships
with industry and community advocates to promote awareness and uptake on different opportunities,
flexibilities, technologies, as they're made available to patients in Medicare and in Medicaid.
In the months to come, we expect to be able to share more about work coming out of this pillar,
and so I'm very excited for today's conversation, which will help bring it to life for us,
bring examples to the floor, and spark innovative ideas. As I said in our last conversation in March,
I want to emphasize that this new strategic work focused on empowerment, prevention,
and choice and competition is aligned to the Secretary's vision to make America healthy again.
To close, I want to thank the members of the PTAC for their commitment to creating this forum
for robust discussion, where we hear from those in the field directly about their ideas
and concerns for how to deliver high-value care for Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries.
This independent expert committee is a critical resource as we develop the way forward to achieve
Secretary Kennedy and Administrator Oz's vision and accomplish our goals as a center. So, thank
you, and I look forward to today's conversation. Thank you for sharing those remarks, Abe. We
appreciate your continued support and engagement, and we look forward to continuing collaboration
with the CMS Innovation Center. For today's agenda, we will explore a range of topics using
data and health information technology to transparently empower consumers and support
providers that include, first, approaches for improving data infrastructure and interoperability
to support patient empowerment and provider decision-making, then effective digital tools
for equipping patients with information about their health care, third, emerging strategies
for promoting shared decision-making between providers and patients, fourth, data-driven
approaches for enabling patients with multiple chronic conditions to take control of their
health care, and last, payment models and benefit design improvements to enhance patient empowerment.
The background materials for this public meeting include an environmental scan
will be posted online on the ASPE PTAC website's meeting page.
Throughout the meeting, you will hear from many esteemed experts with a variety of perspectives,
including a previous PTAC proposal submitter. I also want to mention that tomorrow afternoon
will include a public comment period. Public comments will be limited to three minutes each.
If you would like to give an oral public comment tomorrow but have not registered to do so,
please email ptacregistration at NORC, N-O-R-C dot org. Again, that's ptacregistration at NORC
dot org. The discussion meetings and public comments from this public meeting will inform
a report to the Secretary of HHS on using data and health information technology to
transparently empower consumers and support providers. Over the next two days, the committee
will discuss and shape our comments for the upcoming report. In July, we posted a request
for input on the ASPE PTAC website to give stakeholders an opportunity to provide written
comments to the committee on using data and health information technology to transparently
empower consumers and support providers. To date, we have received five responses that the committee
may consider during their discussion today. Lastly, I'll note that, as always, the committee
is ready to receive proposals and possible innovation approaches and solutions related
to care delivery, payment, or other policy issues from the public on a rolling basis.
We offer two proposal submission tracks for submitters, allowing flexibility depending on
the level of detail of their payment methodology. You can find information about submitting a
proposal on the ASPE PTAC website. At this time, I would like my fellow PTAC members
to please introduce themselves. Please share your name and organization if you would like. Feel free
to describe any experience you have with our topic. First, we'll go around the table, and then
I'll ask members joining remotely to introduce themselves. I'll start with myself. Hi, I'm Chini
Palluru. I'm a family physician by trade having practiced for about 15 years. I led a large
medical group in clinical operations, Duly Health and Care, the largest multi-specialty
independent group in the country. After that, I found my way to Walmart, where I led the
expansion of Walmart Health and their clinical operations nationally, including integrating
their telehealth platform. Currently, I serve as a co-founder of two organizations, the founding
CMO of an agentic healthcare AI company that enables patients and choice, and a genetics
company as well. I work also as fractional chief medical of stellar health, which is a value-based
care transformation platform. Lee? Thank you, Chini. I'm Lee Mills. I'm a family physician.
I am chief medical officer at No Better Health of Oklahoma, one of the state's three contracted
managed care Medicaid organizations. I've spent my career in starting out in rural primary care
in central Kansas, and then worked up through multi-specialty health systems and multi-specialty
medical groups, leading practice transformation, clinical informatics, and into value-based care.
I've had the pleasure of practicing in and or leading operations through five or six different
CMMI models over the years. Hi, I'm Jay Feldstein. I was a practicing emergency medicine physician
for 10 years, and then spent 13 years in the health insurance industry in the commercial
and government space running Medicaid plans in five states. And for the last 11 years,
I've been the president and currently of Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine.
Hi, everybody. I'm Krishna Ramachandran, chief information officer for operations and expedience
for UnitedHealthcare. I've been in healthcare for 23 years in payer, provider, and tech perspectives.
And so the topic we're covering today on using technology and data to empower consumers and
support providers is work I've done. It's been my life's work, and I'm excited to
dig deeper into this topic today.
Good morning. I'm Lindsay Botsford. I'm a practicing family physician in Houston, Texas,
where I continue to care for patients and serve as a medical director for the Midwest in Texas
with One Medical. I started in large health systems and multi-specialty groups and graduate
medical education as residency faculty before transitioning in 2019 to join Iora Health as we
expanded to Texas. We are now part of One Medical, where I support our practices across the greater
Midwest in Texas. Good morning. I'm Walter Lin, the founder of Generation Clinical Partners.
We're an independent practice that serves frail Medicare beneficiaries in senior living settings,
nursing homes, and assisted living. We are also involved with a variety of value-based programs,
including MSSP, PACE programs, as well as institutional special needs plans.
Now we'll go to PTAC members joining us on Zoom. Lauren, please go ahead.
Good morning. I'm Lauren Hardin. I'm chief integration officer for HC2 Strategies.
I'm a nurse by training. I've spent the better part of the last 30 years in model innovation
and development, originally in hospice, children's hospice and palliative care,
which is deeply focused on informed decision-making and partnering with patients,
and then moved to CAMHNA Coalition to help start the National Center for Complex Health
and Social Needs, innovating models and development for those with the most complex
needs, and also deeply partnering with clients, including establishing programs like Consumer
Scholars, truly informed policy and implementation. And now currently with HC2, work across the
country on model implementation and partnership with patients in the dual eligible and Medicaid
programs. Larry? I'm Dr. Larry Kozinski. I'm a retired gastroenterologist.
I practiced for 35 years in private practice of GI in suburban Chicago and was one of the
founding partners of the largest GI group in Illinois, the Illinois Gastroenterology Group,
which is now part of the largest GI practice in the country, the GI Alliance.
Ten years ago, I entered the value-based care space and founded a company named SonarMD,
which brings value-based care solutions to the GI space. It started as a PTAC proposal.
Currently today, I am the chief medical officer of Jonah, which is an AI-powered microbiome
solution. I also recently founded my latest company, Botnomics, which is a company built
around a wellness product that uses AI to enable people to monitor their soluble fiber intake
in hopes of controlling their weight. I've been on the committee for four years. I'm
sorry I'm not there in person, but I will participate remotely.
Josh? I'm an internal medicine physician by training and a professor and distinguished
chair of the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center. Over the last 10 to 15 years
I've spent time, whether through research, advisory, leading operational and strategic
programs in population health, value-based care, and many delivery and payment topics salient to
this issue of physician-focused payment models. Increasingly over time, data and technology
factor critically into this issue. An increasing research pillar in our work, as well as advisory
pillar, focuses on how do we, within a regulatory and policy framework, deploy technologies and
solutions, many of which I think we'll talk about today, to improve health outcomes,
et cetera. Those things relate to remote patient monitoring, wearables, et cetera.
Excited to be here on the topic for this meeting. Thank you. Now let's move to our introductory
presentation. PTAC members, you'll have an opportunity to share any comments or ask any
follow-up questions after both presentations. First, four PTAC members served on the Preliminary
Comments Development Team, or PCDT, which has collaborated closely with staff to prepare for
this meeting. Krishna Ramachandran was the PCDT lead, with participation from Larry Kuczynski,
Josh Lowe, and Jim Walton. I'm thankful for the time and effort they put into today's agenda.
The PCDT will share some of the findings from their analysis to set the stage and the goals
for this meeting. Now I'll turn it over to Krishna. Thank you, Ginny. As Ginny mentioned,
I'll provide an overview of the work that the team had done there. Topics we'll cover are five
key objectives, and Ginny shared some of them as well in the opening comments. One is on improving
data infrastructure interoperability, largely to support patient empowerment and decision making.
Two is on effective digital tools for equipping patients with information about their healthcare.
Three, examining emerging strategies for promoting shared decision making between
providers and patients. Four, assess data-driven approaches for enabling patients with multiple
chronic conditions to take control of their healthcare. And most importantly, given the
charter of the committee, discuss payment models, provider incentives, and any benefit design
improvements to enhance patient improvement. Additional context, so PTAC has received 35
proposals for physician-focused payment models, and as you would imagine, nearly all of these
proposals addressed patient choice and health information technology. Specifically, 25 out of
the 35 proposals met the criterion for patient choice, and 22 met the criterion for health
information technology established by the secretary. And we found that four proposals
provide specific strategies to support patient choice, and three proposals describe approaches
to health IT as well. And in the rest of my presentation, I'll cover these four topics,
provide more background on the themes that we're going to be talking about today and tomorrow,
including data infrastructure, patient-provider-facing digital tools,
as well as the empowerment, particularly in the context of alternative payment models.
And so what we've seen in our research is there are many terms that are used to describe
patient-centered care. And so the definitions, you know, have varied and have some overlap,
but the key terms are patient enablement, activation, empowerment, engagement,
involvement, and participation. And conceptually, these cover, you know, a few areas. One is on
patients' knowledge and skills, their confidence and motivation, and their actions and behaviors.
And so you'll see the two central themes we will focus on in this presentation are
patient empowerment and patient engagement.
And so from a working definition perspective for empowerment, we've come up with empowerment as
the process and state whereby a patient acquires and has the ability, so knowledge and skills,
and motivation, so desire and confidence to control and make timely decisions regarding
their own health and healthcare. So takeaways, our patient has ability and motivation. And so we'll
keep using this in the context of this meeting, and I presume we'll evolve this thing as we get
more feedback from our experts as well. And then the second concept is on patient engagement. So
the definition we've come up with is the process and state by which a patient actively communicates
their health status, healthcare needs, and healthcare wishes, makes informed decisions
regarding their healthcare treatments, and participations, shared decision-making regarding
their health with their providers. And so the takeaways are patients communicates actively,
makes informed decisions, and participates in shared decision-making with their provider.
We've also come up with this conceptual framework, which I thought was helpful
to tie all these topics we have together. And so this framework is from existing literature.
On the left side of the framework are the inputs into the empowerment system. So think
health data, health information, provider support, as well as organizational and societal context.
And the middle section is really the empowerment system, which touches on knowledge and skills,
patient empowerment, as well as engagement. And they're meant to be circular in the sense that
they're self-reinforcing behaviors as well. So having the knowledge and skills can make the
patient feel empowered, and feeling empowered can motivate the patient to seek out more information
as well. And the right blue box are the important outcomes that we want to achieve. And so these
include things like patient satisfaction, improved financial health, and clinical health as well.
And so we'll use this framework in the course of my overview presentation, as well as
touch on topics that are the next two days. And so as I dig into the framework some more,
three areas where a patient can be empowered to make informed decisions are, one,
choice of health insurance and their providers, two, use of the healthcare system,
and three, their own health conditions and treatments. Obviously, given the topic,
the ability for patients to obtain and comprehend data is critical to their making informed
decisions. And there's, of course, various factors, which I'll click on some more in
the upcoming slides, that can influence the empowerment. From a factors perspective,
we want to introduce five factors that can influence patient empowerment.
Patient factors, which include things like education, literacy, beliefs, and experiences.
Provider factors, like structure, goals, training, incentives, and business models.
Three, organizational factors, like policies and procedures.
Four, cultural factors, so things like norms and values and communication styles,
language barriers, and conflicting information sources. And four, the five societal factors,
such as state, local, and national policies and programs.
The next three slides walk through key areas where patients can be empowered to make informed
decisions. First area is choosing a health plan and providers. And so there are many,
many tools that are available to patients to make decisions about their choice of health plans. So
Medicare Plan Finder is one example, as well as brokers that can give patients information on
plan choices that meet their needs. As many of you know, in the commercial space, the system
actually limits choice because most of them, most beneficiaries and most people get choice,
get their coverage through employer-sponsored health plan, which we've seen only about 54%
actually have more than two choices. The other choice is on providers, which CMS provides a
variety of tools for selecting providers, including online comparison tool, consumer assessment
tools, as well as other factors like provider proximity and experience with the provider
themselves. The other aspect is on empowering patients to navigate the healthcare system.
And patients can be provided a different choice, particularly around
virtual options like telehealth and online appointment scheduling as well to help them
navigate the system. Patient empowerment, the third area I wanted to cover is empowering
patients to make informed decisions about their own health conditions and treatments.
We believe shared decision-making is a key concept and it's important to engage a patient
in their own healthcare journey. This involves three steps, patient awareness on the need for
decision and choices, patients discussing options in a two-way conversations with their provider,
so the emphasis is on aligning their medical conditions with patients' personal goals,
and then patients are supported by their physician in making an informed decision.
We also think supporting providers is key to empower patients, and this could be in engaging
the patients in shared decision-making. This could be in encouraging and supporting providers to
focus on patients' overall lifestyle choices, so think exercise, social activities, nutrition.
Engaging in emerging concepts like social prescribing in addition to prescribing
drugs and therapies, and using asynchronous communication to engage the patient outside
of regular visits, so using a patient portal so that the patients can submit questions and
doctors can review and go back and forth with their patients beyond their scheduled appointment
times, as well as using emerging tools like artificial intelligence to review the large
amount of collected information from remote monitoring, as well as using that to engage
patients in communications as well. From an impact perspective, we think there's limited
but promising evidence showing patient empowerment can be improved, particularly we're focusing on
three types of outcomes, improving patient experience, so higher quality provider interactions,
more frequent communications, improving patient reported outcomes, so quality of life,
self-efficacy, as well as clinical outcomes, so lower blood pressure, fewer emergency visits,
and hospitalizations. My next topic is on data infrastructure, the challenges and opportunities.
You'll see we'll follow similar conceptual diagrams and lighting up certain areas
that are relevant to this section, so health data information is lit up,
as well as use of digital health tools and digital health literacy.
From health IT types, there are three kinds that we think can promote patient empowerment.
One is information that's part of the patient's electronic health record.
Two, information that helps patients interpret their electronic health record,
or provides patients directly with information about their health, so wearables, mobile apps,
that we think should be integrated with the EHR so that it's a cohesive comprehensive
information there. And then three, AI and emerging technologies that we think can
further assist providers and patients, so chatbots and more patient monitoring tools.
Interoperability is essential to make sure we can really optimize the value of health IT,
so we think being able to collect the patient across various domains is important, and we think
interoperability is a key foundation enabler. We think it's also powerful to be able to share
that data and integrate that data into many systems as well. As many of you know, there have
been many shared regulations and initiatives on interoperability over the last 15 years. We have
some examples of them. Obviously, we had a recent pledge as well that CMS led with just improving
interoperability through the healthcare tech ecosystem, and we want more such initiatives to
continue the promotion of interoperability to further sort of data liquidity between the
stakeholders there. There are a number of challenges related to interoperability that
I wanted to highlight today. One is on lack of standardization. Two, on lack of integration
of patient-reported data into the electronic health record. And three, just like resources
and cost demands. Of course, there are multiple efforts and opportunities well underway to improve
the data interoperability, so whether it's promotion of HL7 FHIR standards, using APIs
to integrate patient-generated data, or furthering our incentive programs to promote healthcare IT
adoption. Patient use and access of data also has some challenges and opportunities. One is on
just general health literacy itself. Two is on barriers to accessing technology. Three is issues
with having real-time access to data. And four, patient privacy and confidentiality. We think,
as with all these challenges, there are opportunities to improve patient-related
use and access barriers. And some of those are tailoring patient education materials to specific
needs of the patient, designing technologies in a simple and organized and clear manner,
determining the balance of real-time data for patients, as well as ensuring clinical
interoperability before the data gets pushed out. And more importantly, ensuring patient control
over their health data. My next topic is on patient and provider-facing digital tools.
Similar to our previous sections, here are the sections of the conceptual diagram that get lit up.
We've produced a few classifications there. We've used a framework from the Digital
Therapeutic Alliance and Health Advances to classify digital health tools across
sort of the journey of their use in the patient care process. So first classification is just
health and wellness tools. And so these constitute the bulk of digital health tools we're seeing.
These then do not be regulated. They're aimed at preventive health care. So think
wearables and apps focused on diet, exercise, sleep, and other wellness factors.
Two other type of digital health tools are used to help diagnose a patient condition. So these could
be health system clinical software. So think about clinical documentation, imaging, clinical decision
support, or telehealth tools. Primarily clinician-facing and involves diagnosing a patient.
And a second category is digital diagnostics tools, which are considered medical devices
and highly regulated. My other section is on tools that are in the treatment and self-care
categories. So these include care support tools that can promote patient self-management of their
conditions, includes tools like medication trackers, physical rehab apps, and educational
tools, as well as therapeutics. So which tend to be again highly regulated, provide medical
therapeutic intervention to the patient. So think like sensory stimuli. Finally, we have two types
of digital health tools targeting a phase during which patients and providers monitor the patient's
conditions. One is on patient monitoring tools. So remote tools that can help both patients and
physicians monitor the condition, as well as tools that are in the health care clinical systems as
well. So documentation, imaging tools that document things like patient telehealth visits,
which can be used by clinicians to facilitate ongoing monitoring of the patient's condition.
We think digital health tools can really promote shared decision-making,
specifically in the care support and patient monitoring categories that educate patients to
encourage their engagement, as well as tools that allow patient disease management data to
be reported back to the provider, promoting a two-way engagement between patient and provider.
Care support tools can include apps that aid in disease management, decision aids that facilitate
education, and monitoring tools as well, so that active dialogue can happen between patients and
providers and encourage the patient in participating in the health care journey.
From effectiveness, we're seeing limited but promising evidence that's showing that digital
health tools can increase patient empowerment and improve clinical outcomes. For example,
we're seeing some evidence around patient knowledge being improved, as well as activation.
And some studies have also shown that tools can affect clinical indicators, such as
hypertension, pain management, and depression as well.
My last topic is on these tools and how it relates to the primary charter of P-TECH
on alternative payment models. Again, I'll follow a similar conceptual diagram
on highlighting the areas. These could be incentives to empower patients,
as well as incentives from a provider perspective as well.
And so, I want to share some examples where active empowerment of patients is being incorporated
into payment models. And so, I have some examples here, not intended to be exhaustive,
on innovation-centered models where these patient empowerment and engagement is incorporated.
One is this transforming maternal health TMAH model, which launched at the start of the year.
Which encourages providers to actively listen to their patients to promote
greater patient empowerment over the birth experience.
And the recently announced ambulatory specialty model, scheduled to launch in 2027,
targets specialists and includes components that promote patient engagement and interaction,
such as discussion of lifestyle-based interventions. We expect patient empowerment strategies in
innovation-centered models to continue to increase. As you heard from Abe, it's a key
pillar in the innovation-centered strategy as well. We've also seen patient empowerment in
Medicare Shared Savings Program. As you are aware, that's the largest program in Medicare
related to alternative payment models. We have 480 ACOs covering 608,000 clinicians
and nearly 11 million Medicare beneficiaries. So, it's a pretty big program.
The Shared Savings Program includes patient empowerment in the models by
promoting patient-centered care, involving patients in the decision-making process.
It also aims to improve communication between patients and providers,
allowing patients to choose their providers. The Shared Savings Program is a prime opportunity,
we think, to promote and test patient empowerment strategies.
From a total positive care, these models, we feel, provide opportunities for patient
empowerment in a few dimensions. One, for providers, we think it has financial incentives
to encourage patient empowerment, including waivers that can allow providers to offer
patient-to-patient incentives. And from a patient perspective,
education elements to promote participation in total cost-of-care models, as well as benefit
design improvements that we think can incentivize patient empowerment as well.
With that, you'll see in the next two days, we will focus on the key topics that I shared,
infrastructure, availability and effectiveness, data strategies for shared decision-making,
data-driven approaches for enabling patients, particularly with chronic conditions, to
enhance secondary prevention, as well as payment models and benefit designs. And so,
you will hear from our subject matter experts nationwide. I hope it's an enlightening discussion
in the next two days. Thank you all for joining us. Ginny, I'll give it to you.
Thank you, Krishna. Next, we have Kaushik Ghosh, an economist with the Office of Health Policy at
ASPE, who will share the results of an analysis of patient-reported health outcomes and experience
measures. Kaushik, please go ahead. Thank you. Good morning, everyone. This presentation
draws on new evidence from OECD's Paris survey, which is focused on patient-centered outcome
and experience measures. So, Paris is an OECD initiative that focuses on people aged 45 and
older with chronic conditions. The survey collected patient-reported outcomes and experiences across
21 countries with the goal of generating comparable data to improve primary care performance and
highlight patients' perspectives on health outcome and care experiences. In the United
States, participation came through a special segment of the Medicare current beneficiary
survey. It focused on beneficiaries 65 and older living in the community and surveyed in winter
of 2023. The sample included 4,200 beneficiaries, representing more than 50 million Medicare
beneficiaries nationwide. The Paris survey asked a structured set of questions that fall in three
broad domains. Together, these domains capture health outcome, how people manage their health,
and their experiences with the healthcare system. The first domain is self-reported health with 15
questions. This covers areas like general, physical, and mental health, as well as social
functioning and overall well-being. In this presentation, we will focus on two key domains
of the survey related to patient empowerment and provider decision-making. First, managing health
and healthcare. This focus on people's behaviors and engagement, things like confidence in managing
health, health literacy, and shared decision-making with providers. The second is experience of
healthcare. This focus on survey questions related to usual source of care, care coordination, support
for self-management, and person-centered care. This slide provides an overview of the
characteristics of the U.S. beneficiaries included in the Paris survey. 74% of the beneficiaries are
either enrolled in a Medicare Advantage or an alternative payment model like an MSSP or an
Innovation Center model. Roughly 28% have a high school education or less. 28%, 22% live in rural
areas. 70% of the beneficiaries are either overweight or obese, and 80% of the beneficiaries
live with two or more chronic conditions. So overall, the U.S. Paris sample broadly represent
the elderly Medicare population residing in the community. So let's start by looking at,
let's start by looking at some of the key findings on how Medicare beneficiaries
are managing their health. When it comes to lifestyle, there are some areas of concern.
Nearly 30% of Medicare beneficiaries report getting no weekly physical activity at all.
Dietary habits also raise concerns. About one in five beneficiaries report eating fruits and
vegetables only once per week. We also see potential issues on how often these activities
are addressed in clinical settings. Around 60% of beneficiaries say they talk with the provider
about physical activity, but only 40% report conversations about healthy eating. So this
clearly indicates the potential for improvement in nutrition and exercise counseling. On the
side, most beneficiaries express confidence in managing their health. About three quarters say
they are confident in identifying medication side effects, knowing when to seek medical help,
and managing their overall well-being. However, the confidence in managing health is significantly
lower for beneficiaries with Alzheimer's and dementia at 32%, kidney disease at 62%, and
diabetes at 66%. Most beneficiaries report being engaged and proactive about their health. 93% feel
they receive enough support from the providers, and nearly all 97% say they try to understand
their personal health risk. About three quarters of the beneficiaries actively engage providers
with health information, and the majority feel they are working with the providers to manage health
and raises concerns when needed. However, there is heavy reliance on providers to make
right health decisions. Over half of beneficiaries, about 54%, rely on them to make the right decisions
to manage health, and 53% depend on providers to supply all the information they needed to manage
health. Again, health literacy continues to be a challenge. About 22% struggle to understand health
information, and 17% say most health issues are too complex to follow. Reliance on health
professionals is especially high among certain groups. About 70% of the beneficiaries with high
school education are less, and those aged 85 and older report depending heavily on providers to
make decisions. Difficulty understanding health information is also concentrated among more
vulnerable groups. About 41% of those with high school education and less, and 38% of females
85 years and older, they struggle with understanding health information nearly
double the average rate. Finally, perceptions of complexity mirror these disparities. About 34%
of those with less than high school say health issues are too complex to follow, compared to 17%
overall. Now turning to care coordination and patient experience, two-thirds of beneficiaries,
about 67%, report having some help coordinate their care across services, but that still leaves
about one in five who do not have this support. In addition, about 20% report having to repeat
information that should already be in their medical records, pointing to persistent challenges
in record sharing and care coordination. Encouragingly, most beneficiaries feel included
in care decisions. About 74% also feel they are treated as a whole person, not just as a patient
defined by their condition, so this shows progress towards more patient-centered care. About 65% say
they often always get enough support from providers to manage their health, but formal care planning
is less common. Only 28% report having a care plan that considers well-being, so this suggests that
while providers offer general support, there is room for improvement in structured care planning.
So overall, beneficiaries report high levels of engagement with providers. Most surveyed
beneficiaries reported they participated in shared decision-making, were motivated to understand their
health risk and feel confident they are getting information to manage their health. There are
potential areas of improvement. Many Medicare beneficiaries, especially oldest adults,
those with lower education and people with multiple chronic conditions, struggle with
understanding health information and rely heavily on providers for decisions and often lack a useful
care plan. So the focus of the two-day meeting will be technology, infrastructure, data, and
incentives, and that will empower patients by enhancing patient-provider engagements, providing
better information to patients for managing health and improving health literacy. So important
takeaways from the meeting will be the implications for designing alternative payment models that
resource and incentivize these elements of patient empowerment. Thank you for joining.
Thank you, Kaushik. Before I open it up to the full committee, do any of the PCDT members have
something to add? I would be happy to start this piece. First of all, we were very fortunate to
have Krishna with his expertise to lead the PCDT. It was a pleasure to work with him on this team.
I just would like to emphasize the challenges. Integrating structured patient-reported
outcome data into the EHR is a significant challenge. And integrating data from,
structured data from wearables is a significant challenge. We really can't promote
proactive eye-touch care unless we can accomplish this. We also need to convert our EHRs from a
one-patient-at-a-time structure to more of a population health structure. And then finally,
we have to figure out how to incorporate all of this into alternative payment models
that incentivize, that brings information to the patients and intelligence and appropriate
incentives. I look forward to the discussion in the next few days. Thank you, Larry. We have about
10 minutes prior to break, but I would love to open it up to the committee for questions. So,
PTAC members, do you have any follow-up comments or questions for Krishna and the PCDT or for
Kaushik? To indicate you have a question, please raise your, flip your name tent up on its side for
a virtual committee as well. And on the screen, if you have questions, please raise your hand.
I'll actually start with the question to Krishna as well as the PCDT members.
And anybody on PTAC, please weigh in. You know, part of the struggle here is equity in the sense
that anytime we bring in data infrastructure or patient empowerment tools that are based on
technology, you do run into the fact that large parts of this country don't have broadband access
or don't have access to the technology that's needed in order to make these solutions work.
So, from your perspective, how do we bring forth these solutions and in parallel solve
for some of these challenges? Yeah, great question. I think for me, yeah, this is the
tensions of technology. How do we continue to advance and move forward while still making sure
that, you know, sort of disparities are sort of bridged in the process there? So, I think
my perspective, I think continuing to emphasize some of the incentives that are available so that
we can increase adoption, I think would be key, whether it's a base technology adoption,
core infrastructure adoption, to ensure that both providers and patients have access to the
technology would be important. Because otherwise, we're going to be creating, just expanding the
divide that we already have in technology adoption in our country. Lauren, I believe
you have a question. I was going to ask exactly the same thing today. We covered it. And Lauren,
I'd love if you have perspectives on, yeah, ideas you think we should do as well to bridge.
I know this is work you've done as well, Lauren. I'd love, yeah, your perspectives as well. I think
it's a really important question to consider because there is so much promise from all of
these different ways of engagement. And that can be so helpful, especially in rural when you think
about telehealth or wearables and just the ability to access a high level of care without needing to
have transportation and drive and really go long distances. But where the investment in that
infrastructure comes from, I think is a key question in advancing patient choice and patient
engagement in this sector. So I've seen different statewide initiatives, but I'm curious for both
you and Kashik, if anything came up in recommendations in the incentives or in who should invest in
building that infrastructure? Yeah, I think it, I mean, as with most of these incentives we've seen,
has to be sort of cross stakeholder, cross functional there. I do think, I think the
particularly states that have invested in infrastructure, I think certainly have benefits,
particularly on like, one of the things that has come post pandemic, at least for me, was
the ability of virtual care to really expand access in rural parts. It's like quite remarkable
to see the power of technology. But I do think that the core infrastructure has, you know, the
investments have to be made as well to even, you know, get broadband access to and get access to
virtual care. Obviously, it's a cross functional effort there. I would love to see just more
leadership in, you know, from the states as well on that. I do think there's a regulatory component
as well. So I work nationally, and my company's in California, but I live in Kentucky, in a rural
area. And in our local town, the person that has control, the company that has control over
internet access is a much lower delivery or much lower capacity than is actually available.
But because of political control in the area, higher levels of bandwidth and higher levels
of access, it's not an option to put it in place even though it's actually technically available.
So there's the investment and then there's also the regulation of how that gets rolled out.
We have time for one more question. So if anybody wants to ask a question,
I'll ask a question again. Sorry, I was trying to get someone else to ask this. But
Kaushik, in your presentation, you spoke a lot about caregivers. And, you know, what I'd love
to hear from the team is how do you feel that given what patients that were surveyed were
saying about how important caregivers are, how those incentives need to be aligned in order to
move the needle on using technology and using data services?
I think that there should be strategies that focus on specific age groups who are most vulnerable,
like people with lower education and elderly, because it looks like the survey says that
they are struggling with even getting information from the doctors. And so I think any policy that
has to be tailored towards specific groups, and there cannot be just one thing, standard strategy
for everyone. So it has to be a tailored strategy for a specific population.
Krishna, do you have any thoughts on caregiver alignment using technology?
Yeah, I think, particularly for app developers out there, I think factoring in the fact that,
you know, the patient themselves may not be able to use it, that we'll need to have
abilities for the record to be shared with caregivers, whether it's to translate information
or to engage in communication. So I think just factoring that sort of stakeholder into the mix,
I think, will be key. I do think this provides opportunities for caregivers to have just a
better view of the health information. So I think in terms of making the data more liquid
and available to people that are taking care of that member, I think there's definitely some
power there. So I'm excited for the opportunities that come with it, assuming these features are
actually enabled. The key would be just identity management, of course, the consent process,
and feature enablement from that perspective.
Great. Thank you. Thank you, Krishna, and the rest of the PCDT team, as well as to Kaushik.
Those were wonderful presentations and invaluable background information for our discussions over
the next two days. We now have a break till 10.40 a.m. Eastern time. Please join us then
as we welcome a great new group of experts for our first session on improving data infrastructure
to empower patients and providers.