Beyond Cher: The True Story of The World's Loneliest Elephant 🐘 How Kaavan Was Finally Rescued

Elephant
89 followers
15 Video Views·Nov 17, 2025
The rescue of Kaavan the Asian elephant - nicknamed 'the loneliest elephant in the world' - made headlines around the globe when American superstar Cher backed the campaign to free him. But there is so much more to this incredible story than that, and today we're taking a deep dive into the full life story of Kaavan, from his birth in the rainforests of Sri Lanka to his life now in a Cambodian sanctuary, the inspiring tale of his rescue, and the legacy his case has left behind.
Comments are disabled for this video.
You may well have heard of Carvin the Elephant before. His plight in Islamabad Zoo made international
headlines when the campaign to free him was picked up by Popstar Shire, before he was finally granted
his freedom in 2020. But there is so much more to Carvin and his story, and I'm so excited today to
be able to share that with you. Carvin was born in 1985, or potentially 84, and the details of
know that he was born a wild animal in the rainforests of Sri Lanka, before being gifted
to Pakistan at one year old to bolster relations between the two countries. The official narrative
has always been that Carvin had been kept in an elephant orphanage prior to going to Pakistan,
having supposedly lost his family somehow. However, it seems to be pretty strongly suspected
that he was actually captured from the wilds with the express purpose of being used as an
international diplomacy gift, that he was deliberately stolen away from his mother.
Of course, I can't say for sure whether or not that's true, but you'll probably see as we get
further into this story that this isn't the only time those in power have allegedly lied to cover
up the mistreatment of animals. Regardless of the specifics though, Carvin was formally gifted to
General Zia-ul-Haq, who was the country's leader at the time, and was moved into the Islamabad Zoo.
Islamabad Zoo had only opened seven years prior in 1978. It was originally intended to be a wildlife
sanctuary, before gradually transitioning over into being a more traditional zoo, with animals
from around the world. For the next six years, Carvin lived alone at the zoo, growing up without
any contact from his own species, until 1991 when Sri Lanka gifted a second elephant to Pakistan,
this time a female named Sahili. Even less is known about Sahili than Carvin,
other than that, like him, she was only a year old when she arrived at the zoo.
But if we're going to believe that Carvin was stolen from the wild, rather than being orphaned
and rescued, then I think it's safe to assume that Sahili was too. At long last, Carvin finally
had the companionship of his own kind, and although his life had improved in that respect,
the care he was receiving was still far from ideal.
For a start, the zoo didn't really have a proper enclosure for the elephants.
They had their own area, but the fencing wasn't strong enough to contain them,
so they spent increasing amounts of time with their legs chained up.
The elephants were also being fed an improper diet, and seemingly weren't provided with any
form of environmental enrichment, aside from the times that they would be made to perform for money,
using their trunks to beg visitors.
Zoos tend to be a controversial topic amongst animal lovers at the best of times.
You have some who think that well-run zoos are vital for education and conservation,
while others see them as nothing more than abusive institutions that use animals solely
for the entertainment of humans. Regardless of which side of the fence you fall on,
there's one thing that most people can agree on, and that's the fact that certain species
of animals simply can't be kept in captivity without suffering, and elephants are probably
the best example of that. In the wild, they can walk for miles in a single day,
their paths sometimes spanning across entire countries.
Elephants are also highly intelligent in a way that's comparable to the great apes,
including humans, and they live in complex social structures with rich emotional lives.
Providing an elephant with the space, enrichment, and community they need to truly thrive
is pretty much impossible in captivity, and this goes for both Asian elephants like Carvin
and their African cousins. That's one of the reasons why zoos tend to struggle breeding
elephants in captivity, because an animal that's constantly under physical and psychological stress
isn't typically going to be up to reproducing. The knock-on effect of this is that elephants in zoos
often have very little conservation value, because it's hard to maintain a robust international
breeding program the way most endangered species have in zoos. Even in the best zoos in the world,
elephants still tend to do poorly, and unfortunately for Carvin and Sahili, Islamabad Zoo was
certainly not one of the best. I can't speak on what things are like now, but as of only five
years ago, there wasn't a single zoo in all of Pakistan that was a member of the World Association
of Zoos and Aquariums, which is a governing body that presents minimum standards of care for
different species, all based on the latest science. Without the WAZA's oversight, there's no one
to ensure that animals in Pakistani zoos aren't being neglected or mistreated. As well as this,
the keepers working at Islamabad Zoo typically had no relevant qualifications or experience,
which meant that even if their hearts were in the right place and they genuinely did love these
animals, they often just didn't know how to properly care for them, and they received little
in the way of guidance from the zoo's higher-ups. In fact, apparently the whole business and
management side of the zoo was corrupt, with the BBC alleging that business mafias were involved.
Because of all of this, the zoo had a high mortality rate that went unaddressed by
management. Animals would seemingly just disappear without any explanation.
But there were also darker rumours swirling around. That not only was the zoo's high
turnover of animals the result of neglect, but also of some animals being deliberately
slaughtered for wealthy people's dinner parties. It sounds obscene, I know, but apparently there
is some evidence that this is exactly what was happening to some of the zoo's black bucks.
Black bucks are a species of antelope from India. They were actually also native to Pakistan at one
time before going extinct, and sadly it seems that even in captivity they weren't safe.
Despite how corrupt the zoo was, and despite the lack of proper care the animals received,
it was still a popular spot for locals, especially families,
and the elephants were their star attractions.
Unfortunately, having companionship didn't do much to alleviate the effect Carvin's neglect
was having on him. In the late 90s he began showing signs of aggression towards his keepers,
which just resulted in him being chained up for longer and longer periods of time,
often with chains on each of his legs. According to an article from the LA Times,
Carvin once killed one of his zoo keepers by trampling on them, and Smithsonian magazine
report that Carvin was actually responsible for the deaths of two keepers, but all the rest of
the reporting on him, including more primary sources, make no mention at all of any human
fatalities, so I don't really know what's going on with that. But regardless of whether or not he
actually claimed any lives, Carvin's changing behaviour would have been the direct result
of the mental and emotional distress he was in due to the way he was being kept,
and sadly that would only worsen after he lost his only companion.
Saheeli passed away in 2012 at the age of 22, very young for a species that can live to be 60
years or more in the wild. While it's true that elephants in zoos have much shorter lifespans due
to the toll captivity takes on them, Saheeli's passing was still abnormally young. Apparently
the official explanation the zoo gave at the time was that her cause of death was a heart attack
brought on by the extreme summer heat. However, it seems to have been widely accepted that her
death was actually the result of a severe infection from wounds inflicted either by the chains the two
abound with or the tools that were used to control them and make them perform for the audience.
These tools are what's known as an elephant goad or bull hook. They're pretty brutal instruments
anyway, but the ones used by the keepers at Islamabad Zoo had nails in them to inflict even
more pain. After Saheeli's death, the zoo didn't bother trying to replace her, and so from then on
Carvin was kept alone. He was the only Asian elephant in all of Pakistan. There were four
other elephants in different zoos in the country, but they were all African,
and it was this that led to Carvin receiving his nickname of the world's loneliest elephant.
Without Saheeli by his side, Carvin's mental and physical health deteriorated further.
He was kept chained almost constantly, and with nothing else to do he would spend hours just
standing in one spot and swaying from side to side. This kind of movement is known as
They're repetitive actions that are only seen in captive animals who are subjected
to things like inadequate space, a lack of enrichment, or a social species being housed
alone. When an animal is displaying stereotypic behaviours like Carvin's swaying, it's an external
symptom of severe and ongoing psychological and physiological stress. This is also sometimes
known as and it can sometimes result in physical injury to the animal. One example of stereotypic
behaviours that I think most of us will be familiar with is a hamster obsessively chewing on
the bars of a cage that's too small. Or if you've ever been to a zoo and seen an animal like a big
cat constantly pacing back and forth, that's another example. Stereotypic behaviours can
become so ingrained in an animal's psyche that even when they're moved to a better environment
they can still continue to display them, and it can take a lot of work for their caretakers to
help them overcome it. But in Carvin's case, it seems that no one on staff even realised what a
problem this behaviour was, and certainly nothing was done about it. With each passing day, his
mental and physical condition only worsened further. In 2015, a young woman named Samar Khan
was in Pakistan visiting family when she saw the state Carvin was in, and she knew she had to do
something. Having been born in Pakistan herself, Samar was now living in the US and trained to
become a vet. In the 45 minutes that she spent watching Carvin, he didn't move at all, he just
stood there swaying his head constantly. She said that he was in such a bad way mentally it looked
like he'd been drugged. After seeing the plight of Carvin, Samar launched a Change.org petition
calling for Carvin's release, and set up a Facebook page to help raise awareness.
Her campaign soon began to gain momentum, with the petition gaining tens of thousands and
eventually hundreds of thousands of signatures. And the online community that had grown around
his case organised to spread the word further. They would send emails to government officials
every day urging them to take action, and also held Twitter storms where they would tag celebrities
to try and get their attention. One of the celebrities they reached out to was Cher,
who you definitely don't need an introduction to. As well as her wildly successful singing
career, Cher is also an activist, having used her platform and wealth to support a range of
causes. Everything from medical research, to fighting poverty, to LGBTQIA plus rights,
and most relevant for this episode, animal rights. Cher learned about Carvin's story in 2016,
and was so moved that she immediately began doing what she could to help the fight.
In 2017, she even co-founded a non-profit called Free the Wild, which is dedicated to improving
the welfare of captive wild animals, rescuing those who are being mistreated, and helping
zoos transition to become more ethical, with an increased focus on animal welfare and conservation.
There was such a backlash that officials from the Islamabad zoo were forced to respond.
They protested that the claims being made online were false or being taken out of context,
and that chaining elephants for brief periods of time was standard practice in zoos around the
Unsurprisingly, people did not buy this, and the calls to free Carvin only grew.
The zoo maintained that Carvin was healthy and eating well, and released a video showing Carvin
walking around his enclosure with a keeper, seemingly unchained. However, the very same
day that video went up, a reporter from Newspaper the Tribune went to the zoo to do their own
research, and found that Carvin was still chained up. The only difference now was that he only had
chains on two of his legs instead of all four. So yeah, the zoo's feeble attempt at damage control
did nothing to stop team Carvin from fighting his corner. Oftentimes when Carvin's story is told,
most of the focus is on Cher and her contributions to the campaign. And while I don't want to downplay
her role because she was definitely an important part of raising awareness and fundraising,
a lot of coverage makes it seem as if she was the only person in Carvin's corner,
completely ignoring the contributions of Pakistani people, and honestly it feels kind of white
savioury. Not to say that Cher herself was approaching it with that kind of mindset,
because I don't think she did. But a lot of the media covering the story, especially in the West,
definitely seems to have some of those undertones, glossing over the work of people like Dr Samar
Khan, who was the one who started the whole campaign in the first place. And there was
The name makes it sound like they were supporters of the zoo, but they were very much on the side
of the animals, and they were a group consisting entirely of Pakistani locals. As well as
campaigning on Carvin's behalf, FIZ also conducted periodic surveys of the zoo, where they would
take note not only of which animals were there, but also the conditions they were in. It was them
who first properly documented how many animals were just mysteriously disappearing. And after
they spoke up about what was happening, they found that the animals were now just being quietly
replaced with new ones as if no one would notice. They also found out that the zoo had no medical
facilities at all. There was nowhere that surgeries could be safely performed, nowhere to quarantine
an ill animal to stop the spread of disease, and no medical supplies whatsoever. FIZ played a big
role in documenting the shady dealings and neglect going on at the zoo, and one of their volunteers,
Mohammed Bin Naveed, was vocal in the media about the group's findings, including their suspicions
about what really killed Saheeli. Apparently she'd been seen limping in the time leading up to her
death, which definitely supported the infection theory more than the heart attack one. The fight
to save Carvin lasted for five long years, and it was an effort that involved the work of countless
people from across the globe. Alongside Free the Wild and the Friends of Islamabad Zoo, there was
another organisation, Four Paws International, who were vital in securing a future for the world's
loneliest elephant. Four Paws International is based in the Austrian capital Vienna, but they
work across the globe to help animals in need by being involved in rescue efforts, campaigning to
change legislation, providing support and resources to other organisations, and helping educate the
public on issues of animal welfare. They run several sanctuaries around the world and also step
in to help with animals after natural disasters such as earthquakes and floods, and for the last
few years they've also been doing a lot to help animals in Ukraine. Essentially, if there's something
they can do to help animals in need, they do it, and so they were also quick to join Team Carvin.
They sent a team to Pakistan to investigate Carvin's care and compiled a report documenting
that Carvin's enclosure was only half an acre big, with the floor consisting entirely of compacted
soil and no loose substrate, with the only thing in it being a hut with a concrete floor that
didn't provide adequate shelter from the summer heat. There was nothing else in his enclosure.
No trees, logs, bushes, rocks, tyres, or anything else that could have provided him with any kind of
enrichment. In 2020, in the midst of the Covid pandemic, Carvin's case finally reached Islamabad's
High Court, the topmost legal authority in the country. The official ruling came on the 21st of May.
The 67-page judgment was penned by Justice Athar Manala, who found overwhelmingly in the animal's
favour. Justice Manala condemned the authorities who were in charge of Islamabad Zoo, saying that
they appeared to have no interest in the welfare of their animals, and declared that within 30 days,
Carvin must be rehomed to a specialist sanctuary, either in Pakistan or, if nowhere suitable could
be found, somewhere abroad. But he didn't stop there. Justice Manala also ordered that the zoo
close down entirely, that the management of it must change hands, and that every single animal
being held there must be rehomed somewhere suitable, and that if the zoo was ever to reopen,
it had to first prove that it was able to provide appropriate care to whatever species they wanted
to take in. And Justice Manala's ruling wasn't limited to just the zoo. It actually became a
Pakistan is, of course, a Muslim country, and in his judgment, Justice Manala included direct
quotes from the Prophet Muhammad, in which he stated that animals, just like humans, have rights.
Justice Manala also ordered for all schools to include the Quran's teachings on animal welfare
and animal rights as part of children's religious education. It should have all been smooth sailing
from there, right? Well, unfortunately not. There was an early tragedy when two lions,
a male and female pair, passed away while being transferred from Islamabad Zoo to a sanctuary in
Punjab. Things got off to a bad start when keepers decided to set a fire in the lion's enclosure to
spook them into the travel container. And it only got worse when the extreme heat and humidity of
the Pakistani summer led to both of them passing away in transit. It became clear that if they
were going to avoid other tragedies, then they needed the help of experts who specialised in this
kind of thing. And so the Islamabad Wildlife Management Board invited Four Paws International
to come back and help. Many of the animals, including wolves, monkeys and rabbits, were
moved to new homes within Pakistan. But for some animals, they had no choice but to go further
abroad. The zoo's two Himalayan brown bears, Susie and Babloo, moved to one of Four Paws' own animal
sanctuaries located in Jordan. Susie was in a particularly bad way as she'd had surgery to
remove a tumour, but because of the zoo's lack of medical facilities and equipment, she'd gone on to
develop a severe infection in the wound. However, I'm pleased to say that both of them went on to
thrive in their new home. The Four Paws team that was sent to Pakistan was headed by Dr Amir Khalil,
a vet from Egypt. Unsurprisingly, their biggest challenge was carbon. I mean, how do you safely
transport an animal that's over three metres tall and weighs nearly five and a half tons,
especially when that animal has a history of aggression towards humans?
Well, the answer was gradually and with kindness. Although the court order had declared that carbon
had to be rehomed within 30 days, that wasn't possible due to both the ongoing pandemic
and the challenges posed by safely transporting such a large animal for such a long distance.
Although the plan had originally been for carbon to be able to return to his native Sri Lanka,
that didn't seem to work out and they instead settled on Elephant Nature Park, a specialist
sanctuary that's based in northern Thailand, although they have a few different properties,
including one just over the border in Cambodia, which is the one that was selected as carbon's
new home. It consists of 25,000 acres of lush rainforest and was already home to three rescued
The sanctuary was over 3,000 miles away from the zoo carbon was currently living in, though,
and with the pandemic making international travel even more difficult than usual,
it was decided that the best way to move carbon was to do it by air. There was one slight hitch
with that plan, though, and that's that it's incredibly rare for an adult elephant to be
transported by a plane because they're just so big and heavy. And it wasn't something that
International had ever done before. Oh, and there's also the fact that the most direct route
to Cambodia would have involved flying over India. But Pakistani planes are banned from
Indian airspace because of the tensions between the two countries. So that was another complication.
Thankfully, though, India was willing to give them special permission to fly directly over.
So that was one problem taken care of. But there was also the fact that you obviously need a very
large aircraft to be able to carry both an elephant and the heavy metal crate that would
be required for him. This rescue mission was already a very international one, as you've
probably picked up, but it became even more so when they were offered the use of a Russian
transport jumbo jet. It was estimated flight was going to take seven hours. And so careful
consideration had to be taken when designing the crate that would house carbon during the journey.
It was made of solid steel and weighed in at four tons, meaning the weight of carbon and his cage
combined came into almost 10 tons. It also had a system built into it that could hold over 50
gallons of urine. However, there was still the issue of actually getting carbon into the crates
and making sure that he didn't get stressed out during the flight. But that was going to be
difficult because carbon still didn't trust humans. As it would happen, the key to carbon's
heart would be found quite by accident. One day, Dr. Khalil was standing by carbon's pen waiting
for the next stage of a health check when he started to sing to himself to pass the time.
He didn't think much of it because why would he? But then he realized that carbon was suddenly
beginning to show an interest in him. Dr. Khalil would later admit that he didn't have the best
singing voice, but carbon clearly thought otherwise. And through this newfound connection,
the two began to form a bond. Before long, the once aggressive and
also be true of animals. I've heard of animal sanctuaries that have musicians come in to sing
to the animals because they seem to really enjoy it. But Dr. Khalil had no idea when he started
singing that carbon would react to it at all, much less that it would be a major turning point in
gaining his trust. And if you're wondering carbon has good music taste. His favorite song was
apparently my way by Frank Sinatra. With their newly forged bond, Dr. Khalil and the rest of
the four paws team were pretty easily able to train carbon to enter his crate using positive
reinforcement. In November 2020, the team decided that carbon was finally ready to take to the skies
and start his new life in Cambodia. Before he could travel though, he had to go through a lot
of health checks to make sure that he was safe to fly. This included testing him for COVID-19
because you know 2020. When the football team had first arrived, they found carbon in a pretty bad
way. He was severely overweight because he was being fed an improper diet that seemed to consist
almost entirely of sugarcane. He also had conjunctivitis in one of his eyes and several
patches of reduced pigment on his lower legs, which was scars from years of being chained up.
His feet were also in a bad way, almost deformed with cracked nails and overgrown cuticles that
put him at risk of serious infection. As well as gaining his trust and training him to enter the
crate, their team had also spent the three months that they were there treating carbon's various
conditions, including helping him to lose weight, so that by November he was finally healthy enough
to make the journey across Asia. Carbon's flight was booked for the 29th of November. On the 27th,
Cher flew in from America to visit him. Despite how involved she'd been in the campaign to save him,
this was actually the first time they'd ever met in person. When she went to the zoo, she was moved
to tears and sang a song to him, although I like to think that he prefers Dr Khalil singing.
Cher also met Pakistan's Prime Minister at the time, Imran Khan, where they both thanked each
other for their involvement in securing Carbon's release. A farewell ceremony was held for Carbon
at the zoo, so that his fans could say one final goodbye to him and wish him well on his journey,
and he even had a special appointment with the then President Arif Alvi and his wife,
First Lady Samina Alvi. President Alvi condemned the practice of removing baby animals from their
mothers and thanked those who had been involved in the campaign to rescue him.
And then the big day finally arrived. Carbon was given a mild sedative and coaxed into the crate,
which was then lifted by a crane onto a lorry, which drove him to the Islamabad airport, flanked
by a special military convoy. He was then loaded up onto the jumbo jet. Dr Khalil was with him
throughout the flight, as was another vet, Dr Frank Cortes, who's the head vet at the
Lieben's Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research. There had been concerns from some that the lengthy
journey would be too much for Carbon and that he'd become so stressed he could injure himself or worse,
but according to Dr Khalil, Carbon was relaxed throughout the journey,
grazing on the food they'd bought with them and even having a nap at one point.
After a seven-hour flight, including a brief stop in New Delhi to refuel,
the plane came into land in the Cambodian city of Siem Reap, where he was greeted by a welcoming
party that included a group of chanting Buddhist monks. From the airport, Carbon then travelled
by road to the sanctuary, where he was finally allowed out from his crate. After 35 years in
captivity, 14 of which had been spent in isolation, Carbon was finally free. It wasn't as if he could
just be released into the wild, though. After a lifetime of living in the zoo, there was no way
he would ever be able to look after himself, but specialist sanctuaries like the Elephant
Nature Park are the next best thing. Spanning thousands of acres of their natural habitats,
these sanctuaries offer elephants enough space to roam and exhibit all of their natural behaviours,
while still being able to provide them with medical care and food.
For a while, Carbon was kept in a slightly smaller enclosure at the sanctuary to allow
him to acclimate to his new home and get to know the other elephants there from a safe distance.
After living such an unnatural life for 35 years, it was going to take time for him to learn to be
an elephant again. Before too long, though, Carbon was out roaming the rainforest, finally able to
truly exist as an elephant for the first time since he was stolen from the wild as a baby.
Five years on from his rescue, Carbon is still living at the sanctuary, and by all accounts,
he is absolutely thriving, healing from his traumatic past and living the kind of life
he always deserved. When Carbon first arrived in Cambodia, Cher followed him to watch him settle in,
and her part in the fight to save Carbon was immortalised in the documentary Cher and the
Loneliest Elephant. Back in Pakistan, the Islamabad Zoo is yet to reopen. It was completely taken over
by the Islamabad Wildlife Management Board, who were renovating it with the intention of one day
reopening it, but not as a zoo. Instead, they intend for it to become a wildlife sanctuary
and conservation centre, with a focus on Pakistan's native species, much like it was
supposed to be when it first opened. The goal is to turn it into somewhere that will actively
benefit the natural world and the animals that call it home, and I wish them all the best in that.
In September 2021, Pakistan's High Court announced a ban on importing elephants into the country,
specifically to ensure that no others will suffer in captivity like Carbon did.
I mentioned earlier that there is a small group of African elephants in a different zoo in Pakistan,
but assuming they all pass away without breeding, there won't be a single elephant in the entire
country. It's a landmark ruling for animal welfare, and the kind of thing that I would love to see
echoed in other countries moving forwards. In the ten years since she launched the campaign to save
Carbon, Samar Khan is now a fully-fledged vet with a doctorate, working at Peninsula Pet Hospital in
California, and Four Caws International and Free the Wild are both continuing to campaign for higher
welfare for captive animals, as well as rescuing those in need. Carbon absolutely didn't deserve
any of the awful things that he went through, but at least the changes that have been brought about
because of his case mean that countless more animals will be spared from that same kind of
suffering. Ultimately, Carbon's story is one of hope, and a beautiful demonstration of the changes
that can be made on a societal level when enough people stand up and demand justice.
I wanted to end this episode with a quote from Dr Khalil, because I think it beautifully
encapsulates what makes Carbon's story so powerful.
I'm not a political person, but to have people from different countries and religions and
backgrounds saying let's do something good, I love that so much. Carbon united so many
people worldwide with his positive message of hope and possibility.
Thank you so much for listening to this episode of the Animal Nerd Podcast. If you want to show
some love to any of the non-profits that were involved in Carbon's story, then I'll have links
to Four Caws International, Free the Wild and Elephant Nature Park in the show notes.
They're all doing incredible work and could really use your support. And if you enjoyed this episode,
then it would mean the world to me if you could also support the show in any way that you can,
whether that's by leaving us a review or rating in your podcast player, sharing the show with a
or if you're listening via YouTube, liking the video and leaving a comment.
And of course, subscribing to the show if you haven't already so that you never miss an episode.
As well as the links to the organisations involved in Carbon's rescues, the show notes is also where
you'll find the sources used for this episode, as well as our email address, social media handles,
all that good stuff. I really hope I didn't sound too much like a haversaul throat in this episode.
I recorded literally the entire thing and then went to stop the recording, only to find that
somewhere along the line, something had malfunctioned and I lost all of it, the entire
thing. But this is like my only chance to record if I'm going to get this episode up on time.
So I then had to immediately record the entire thing again. I've been sitting here talking for
well over an hour. My throat is so sore. So I really hope you can't hear that too much of my
voice. But what else can you do? But yeah, thank you again so much for listening and I will see
you in the next one. Stay wild, friends!
