There's Something MUCH Bigger Than Yellowstone. And It Will Happen Again.

Nature Unleashed
48 followers
3 Video Views·Nov 16, 2025
Yellowstone seems to pop up in the news every few years
with the same terrifying headline.
It's a supervolcano that could end civilization.
There are pyroclastic flows
that come shooting out of the caldera
and that'll wipe out everything.
This ash would travel across the world.
There might be several degrees of coolant.
It would really feel like the end of the world.
But is that just fear-mongering?
Is Yellowstone really that bad?
Or could it even be worse than the headlines make it sound?
If there's something else that can cause
90% of the species to die out,
I'd like to know what that is, man,
because it could happen again.
Yellowstone might destroy America.
But there's something else out there
that almost definitely would.
And not just America, but maybe civilization altogether.
This is what led to the creation of Yellowstone
in the first place.
And they've been behind nearly every mass extinction
in Earth's history.
And they could tell us a lot
about what we might be facing today.
Like so many creators,
Weathered was hit hard by Congress's decision
to defund public media organizations.
But we're not going anywhere.
If you believe in independent fact-check storytelling
about the impacts and solutions to climate change,
the best way to support us right now
is by grabbing some stylish Weathered gear.
So follow the link below to our store.
And now, back to the show.
For many people in the U.S., especially the Northwest,
Mount St. Helens was the biggest volcanic eruption
they've ever known.
It was the largest ever recorded in the continental U.S.
and created the largest landslide ever recorded on Earth.
But it's far from the biggest eruption
our planet can create.
The 1991 eruption of Mount Pinatubo
was 10 times bigger than Mount St. Helens
and by many estimates cooled the Earth
by up to one degree Fahrenheit.
The Mount Tambora eruption of 1815
was 10 times bigger than Pinatubo
and led to the infamous year without a summer and famines.
Then 10 times bigger than that,
or a thousand times bigger than St. Helens,
was Yellowstone.
My name is Michael Poland.
I'm the scientist in charge
of the Yellowstone Volcano Observatory.
The last three big explosive eruptions in Yellowstone
occurred about 2.1 million years ago,
about 1.3 million years ago.
The last really, really big event in Yellowstone
was about 631,000 years ago
and it formed Yellowstone Caldera,
which really occupies the central part
of Yellowstone National Park.
Lava and debris flowed from the fracture zone,
hardening into layers hundreds of feet thick
and sulfur aerosol and ash encircled the globe,
likely cooling the planet for years.
So what happens if Yellowstone erupts again?
These large explosive eruptions
have a tendency to collapse under their own weight.
The ash plumes are so big and so heavy
that they fall apart
and that creates these dense plumes of hot gas and ash
that can rush across the landscape
and they really just scour the area clean.
That initial shock wave and pyroclastic flows
would kill everything near the blast.
Then there's the ash fallout.
Alexa modeled what the ash plumes
from a future eruption could look like
and it's pretty shocking.
So what we can see in these bullseye color zones
are different amounts of ash fall
that would accumulate on the ground.
So the densest portion here
represents more than a thousand millimeters.
So the area well beyond Missoula into Canada
and down into Colorado and Utah
would all see extremely devastating effects of ash fall
to the point where it would be dark
in the middle of the day.
This ash would travel across the world
and encircle the globe multiple times.
Unlike wildfire ash, volcanic ash is made of rock
which means it doesn't biodegrade.
It never goes away.
Just the magnitude of ash cleanup
would be really tremendous.
Seeing and breathing would be a challenge.
Communications would be disrupted or shut down.
Ash would cover fields across the bread belt,
devastating crops and resulting in famines.
And it probably wouldn't just erupt once.
There's rarely just a single event.
Imagine dealing with the aftermath of this size eruption
and then having another one happen a couple weeks later
or even years later.
When do you recover?
How do you move on?
But those cataclysmic impacts
aren't even the worst part of it.
We don't know exactly how much global cooling would happen
but possibly several degrees Fahrenheit and quickly.
The global consequences would be huge.
So you might be surprised to hear
that you probably shouldn't worry about any of this.
I guarantee Yellowstone will not erupt tomorrow.
Prior to any eruption of Yellowstone,
we would be seeing really dramatic changes.
We would see huge numbers of earthquakes.
The ground would be swelling, possibly by many, many feet.
There'd be park-wide changes
in hot spring and geyser activity,
changes in the amount of heat
that was coming out of the ground,
changes in the amount and the composition
of the gases were coming out.
Right now at Yellowstone, we're not seeing anything
that indicates that this magmatic system
is particularly active.
And despite what some headlines would have you believe,
it probably wouldn't be the end of humanity.
These explosive eruptions are probably
not long enough in duration, big enough in impact
to cause global extinctions.
There are volcanic eruptions, though,
that do have that potential.
And so while Yellowstone is really big,
hundreds of cubic kilometers,
there's actually even larger events
that we know about in Earth history.
And those are associated with what are known
as large igneous provinces.
Large what?
It turns out there's a geologic force
much bigger than any of the volcanoes we've talked about.
And somehow no one's talking about it.
We're here at Wakulla Falls in the Columbia River Gorge.
And at the end of this trail,
even though we're 600 miles away from Yellowstone,
there are some geologic clues
to the origin of the Yellowstone hotspot.
To understand Yellowstone,
you sort of have to take a step back
and understand a little bit about
how the solid Earth works.
It's conceptually similar in some sense
to what happens when you put a pot of water on your stove.
It's heated from the bottom and cooled from above,
and the hotter fluid is less dense,
so it rises, right, and it circulates.
And so that's what's going on in the solid Earth
under our feet all the time.
And the upwelling limb,
the sort of buoyant plumes that are coming up,
are one of the primary drivers of plate tectonics.
And those mantle plumes are these sort of blobs.
It's rising from deep in the Earth,
perhaps even at the core mantle boundary.
Once it gets to the surface, it starts to melt.
It starts to push up the Earth's crust.
And that melting produces a tremendous amount of magma
that previously wasn't there.
You have the potential for truly enormous eruptions,
possibly up to 10,000 cubic kilometers
erupted in a single event.
And so that will happen repeatedly
over the course of a large Igneous province event.
These lava flows that blanket the Earth,
and they travel for hundreds of kilometers,
single lava flows.
The flow rate is so high that they are not cooling,
flooding the landscape, filling in topography,
and forming a stack of basaltic rocks
that can be kilometers thick.
The most recent such event happened in the Northwest U.S.
starting about 17 million years ago.
It's called the Columbia River Flood Basalts.
Wow, look at this.
So you can see there's a whole stack of lava flows here.
The columns in the middle there
are where the lava flow cooled nice and slow.
And then you've got a break,
and then there's another set of lava flows.
So there's a whole stack of lava flows sitting right here.
There was a huge outpouring of lava
that occurred all along Eastern Washington,
Eastern Oregon, Western Idaho.
And lava flows from those eruptions
flowed all the way across the states
and into the Pacific Ocean.
Right here in the Columbia River Gorge,
these cliffs all around us are made of lava flows.
It would not have been a very fun thing
to be alive during that time.
The deepest parts of the Columbia River Flood Basalts
are over four kilometers thick.
That's a lot of lava.
And surprisingly, Yellowstone is evidence
of this massive, large igneous province event.
It's a hotspot, essentially an opening in the Earth's crust
following the massive eruption
that hasn't quite closed up yet.
The hotspot is more or less stationary, right?
And the crustal plates that make up the surface of the Earth
move across this stationary plume.
This is expressed really well in Hawaii,
where you see this chain of volcanoes that get older
the farther away you get from the Big Island.
The same thing's happening in Yellowstone.
The youngest volcano is right there
in Yellowstone National Park.
And then as you go to the southwest,
you see a chain of volcanoes that's getting older and older
the farther away you get from Yellowstone.
These large igneous province events
happen every 10 to 30 million years
and will continue to happen.
The Columbia River Flood Basalts is the most recent event,
but it's far from the biggest.
If we want to look at the largest of the largest,
these things are, for example, the Deccan Traps,
the Siberian Traps, the North Atlantic Igneous Province.
These events are associated with the emplacement
of millions of cubic kilometers of magma
in a short amount of time.
The theory of plate tectonics wasn't widely accepted
until the 60s and the large igneous provinces
weren't fully recognized until the 90s.
And their discovery has led to breakthroughs
in our understanding of life and death on Earth.
For a long time, geologists ignored mass extinctions
because they couldn't explain them.
And so they didn't pay any attention to them.
But then in 1980, when the Alvarez Group at Berkeley
discovered evidence for that asteroid impact
at the time of the dinosaur extinction,
66 million years ago, right?
Now people became more interested in mass extinctions.
And so people began to think, well, okay,
now their asteroid impacts could cause a mass extinction.
What about something terrestrial?
What about something from inside the Earth?
And a couple of people pointed out
that if you look at some of the mass extinctions
that we knew about then,
and looked at the time of large igneous provinces,
that the dates, which weren't that well known,
but they seemed to match up.
And for the past three decades,
Mike has been piecing this story together,
getting more and more accurate dates
for mass extinction and large igneous province events.
And lo and behold, they match up exactly.
There are probably 14, 15 mass extinctions
in the last 600 million years, right?
Almost all of them match up with the ages,
the dates of these large igneous provinces.
These events are catastrophic regionally,
but how could they cause global extinction?
Well, you guessed it, climate.
Initially, we have a huge outpouring of lavas.
These are the largest volcanic eruptions on Earth,
and they produce a tremendous amount of volatiles.
CO2, sulfur, and so forth.
And what we think is that there's so much carbon dioxide
released in these eruptions
that they warm the Earth significantly.
Almost without exception,
after large igneous province events,
there are these local hothouse climates
where you have intervals of abnormally warm temperatures
globally that lasts a few million years.
The onset of these events is often quite abrupt.
And we can think about that initial pulse
as providing the really rapid changes
that are necessary to cause mass extinctions.
After that initial pulse of gases and warming,
the Earth continues to warm for some time, but slowly.
And while that quick pulse of warming
can cause mass extinction,
the slower gradual warming
actually can lead to a diversification of life
over millions of years.
Rapid perturbation leads to widespread death.
The longer-term forcing,
say over the next few million years,
is slow enough that species can recover.
Our Earth is incredibly good at adapting,
just not quickly.
Does that sound familiar?
Some scientists think we're now headed
towards a sixth mass extinction.
But this one isn't coming from outer space
or erupting magma.
It's from us.
Paleoclimatologists have studied
the extreme global temperature spike
that happened 56 million years ago
in order to better understand anthropogenic climate change.
The Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum
was triggered by rapid emission of greenhouse gases,
likely caused by a large igneous province event.
Global temperatures spiked by four to six degrees Celsius
and the world experienced dramatic changes.
But the rate of CO2 released then
was still four to 10 times slower
than what we're causing today.
These massive volcanic eruptions will happen again,
but probably not during our lifetimes.
But what is happening now is anthropogenic climate change
and there's so much we can do about it.
So I'm curious,
do you think we're headed towards another mass extinction?
Or can we slow warming down enough
to adapt and even thrive?
As always, I'd love to hear from you in the comments
and thanks for watching Weathered.
We will see you next time.
Before you go, we wanna hear your feedback.
Every year PBS Digital Studios sends out an audience survey
which we use to help understand what you enjoy on YouTube
and what you will want to see us make more of.
You also get to vote on new show ideas.
So it'd be great if Weathered fans
were well represented in the polls.
There's a link in the description.
Thanks in advance.
