A single photo has shaken Beijing. Xi Jinping and Zhang Youxia sat shoulder to shoulder as equals — not by accident, but by design. From the seating gaps to the Fujian carrier irregularities, this episode uncovers the hidden signals behind their reunion — and what it reveals about who truly controls China’s military.
Let me first share with you a picture. Remember this picture? Yes. Ever since this viral photo
back in April, when Xi Jinping walked off stage at the annual two sessions and General Zhang
Youxia turned his back on him, the power struggle between Xi Jinping and Zhang Youxia has been one
of the hottest debates among China watchers. Then, just two days ago, in what looked like a rare show
of unity, Xi Jinping and Zhang Youxia appeared together again, this time sitting right next to
each other. But the picture is loaded with hidden messages about their relationship. Have the two
really reconciled? Or is that picture sending a completely different signal, one that tells us
who truly controls China's military? So let's dive in. Now, after CCP's fourth plenum last month,
Xi Jinping has been busy. His first overseas trip was to South Korea, where he met with U.S.
President Donald Trump and attended the APEC summit. After returning home, Xi Jinping immediately
began a domestic tour, so heading south first to Hainan Island, where he attended the commissioning
ceremony of the Fujian aircraft carrier, and then continuing to Guangdong to attend the opening
ceremony of the 15th National Games. So two days ago, on November 9th, Xi Jinping met with
representatives of national sports organizations and top athletes. It was there, in Guangdong,
that Xi appeared at the same event with General Zhang for the first time in almost two months.
They met with sports delegates and took a group photo, with Xi and Zhang sitting side by side.
This picture, if you look closely, carries a strong political message. Now let's take a closer
look. Let me make this bigger so it's easier for you. The gaps between the chairs are visibly
uneven. Xi Jinping sat in the center, flanked by Zhang Youxia on his right, and Vice Chairman of
the People's Congress Li Hongzhong on his left, with about two and a half seat width between them,
marked here in green. And then Zhang Youxia's distance from State Councilor
Ms. Shen Yiqing, the female official in the picture, seated to his right,
is also about two and a half seat. It looks as though Xi Jinping and Zhang Youxia and the two
individuals next to them are evenly spaced, with a noticeably wider distance. But on Xi Jinping's
left, Li Hongzhong's seat is only one and a half seat away from the next official,
and that distance is marked in blue. And that same tighter spacing repeats across the rest
of the row. The same pattern appears on Zhang Youxia's side. Ms. Shen and the man beside her
are just one and a half seat apart. You can't see the man, but I'll show it to you in the next
picture. It's a little blurry, but you kind of get a better sense. I marked the name. The picture
was taken from the video. So it shows that Xi Jinping isn't positioned as the sole center of
the group. Instead, he and Zhang Youxia share the center, placed side by side, visually equal.
Now, if Xi Jinping were the undisputed centerpiece, then the gap between Zhang Youxia and Ms. Shen
would be much narrower. The one I circled, the problem is the distance between Zhang Youxia and
Ms. Shen, the one I circled. That does not equal to the distance between Li Hongzhong and the
official to his left. And here's another picture that makes it clear. I added, because the picture
is really small, I kind of added a vertical column above their head, trying to show you
the spacing. You can see that Xi Jinping and Zhang Youxia are aligned as joint focal points
in the center, equally prominent in the photo. Now, in CCP politics, seating charts are never
random. They are carefully choreographed and carry deep political meaning. The party is obsessed
with this kind of symbolism. For people in democratic countries, this might sound trivial,
so what if the chairs are spaced differently? But in the CCP system, even half a seat difference
between a leader and a subordinate is an absolute red line, a sign of rank, hierarchy, and
untouchable status. Under normal circumstances, only Xi Jinping, the person in the center,
is entitled to a visibly wider space on his two sides. The extra gap is his privilege,
a visual reminder that he is the one and only. Let me show you an example by looking at their
previous appearance together, which is on September the 17th. So this was a picture taken
on September the 17th. It was the military parade debriefing meeting. Notice the extra distance
around Xi Jinping. To his left was Cai Qi, to his right, Foreign Minister Wang Yi. Both had
wider gaps, highlighting Xi Jinping's supreme status. Zhang Youxia, by contrast, sat two seats
away on Xi Jinping's left. This is what the seating should be like if Xi Jinping is the sole
center. But two months later, after the fourth plenum, the picture changed. It looks something
like this. Now, Zhang Youxia sits right next to Xi Jinping, equally centered. So that shift
sends a powerful political signal, which is that Zhang Youxia now stands on equal footing with Xi.
There's no dispute about that. Equal space, equal status. If all the rumors that we've heard are
true, that Xi Jinping lost real control of the military after the third plenum last July,
and that the PLA is simply maintaining his title under pressure, then the seating chart tells
the whole story. It wasn't so obvious two months ago, before the fourth plenum,
but now it is very clear. Okay, so this is the first event I want to show you. Now let's move
to the second event, the commissioning of the Fujian aircraft carrier, one of Xi Jinping's
proudest military projects. It was on November the 5th, about a week ago, a little less than
six days ago, the Fujian carrier was officially commissioned into service. Xi Jinping attended
the ceremony, as expected, because after all, he is the head of the military. That's part of his
job. But this time, the ceremony itself broke several longstanding CCP protocols, and that's
what set off alarms among military insiders and online commentators. So actually, the rumor about,
or rumors, that the Fujian was about to be commissioned had already spread across Chinese
social media days earlier. Military bloggers posted AI-generated images, but Beijing's state
media neither confirmed nor denied the news. Strangely, they didn't even bother to censor it,
because the Fujian's hall number is 18. Many people expected the ceremony to be held on
November the 8th, since the CCP, and especially Xi Jinping, is famously superstitious about the
number eight. But on the afternoon of November the 7th, Xinhua suddenly announced that the
ceremony had already taken place two days earlier, on November the 5th, at a naval base in Sanya,
Hainan, and she attended the event. So that created the first irregularity.
Why delay the announcement for two days? Now let's compare. When China's first two carriers,
the Liaoning and the Shandong, were commissioned, Xinhua broke the news immediately,
front page with full fanfare. Each event was celebrated as a national milestone. In 2012,
the Liaoning entered service, China's first carrier ever. In 2019, the Shandong followed,
the first one built domestically. And now the Fujian, the first allegedly electromagnetic
catapult carrier, or the first carrier with electromagnetic catapult. So it signals China's
leap into advanced naval technology. State media called it personally strategized and pushed by
Xi Jinping. Even the name Fujian is symbolic, because it's Xi Jinping's political home base,
and the ship is aimed squarely across the Taiwan Strait, right, meant to project strength against
the US Navy. So under normal circumstances, such a signature achievement should have been received
more publicity, but instead it was quiet and delayed, is the first red flag. The second
irregularity was the lineup of senior officials. According to Xinhua, the one accompanying Xi
this time was the newly promoted vice chairman of CMC, Zhang Shenming, who's the second ranking
vice chairman, and he presided over the ceremony. But if you compare that to the event that Xi
presided over in 2019, when the Shandong was commissioned, it was Zhang Youxia,
the vice chairman in charge of military operations, who hosted the event. By military protocol,
that's how it should be. And if you look at the histories in 2012, the Liaoning ceremony was
attended by then party chief Hu Jintao, and both vice chairmen in charge of operations,
Guo Boxiong and Xu Caihou, one in charge of military operations and the other in charge
of political work, both were present. And in 2019, it was Zhang Youxia, again, the operational
commander who hosted the event. This time, Zhang Youxia was replaced by Zhang Shenming,
who oversees political discipline, not combat. The third irregularity is that almost every senior
military officer was missing. So in 2019, when the Shandong was commissioned, at least six top
commanders stood beside Xi Jinping. This time, none of them appeared in state TV footage. Some,
like Navy Commander Hu Zhongming and Southern Theater Commander Wu Yanan, are reportedly
under investigation. The Navy's political commissar Yuan Huazhi has already been removed.
Two who are still in office, Joint Staff Chief Liu Zhenli and Southern Theater's political
commissar Wang Wenquan, also didn't show up. And it wasn't just the military. The civilian lineup
was also dramatically downgraded. When the Liaoning was commissioned in 2012, Premier Wen Jiabao
and another state councillor, Ma Kai, attended. And in 2019, Vice Premier Liu He, He Lifeng,
and Xi Jinping's top aide, Ding Xuexiang, were there. This time, only Cai Qi, Xi Jinping's chief
of staff, and the third-ranking vice premier attended. That's Zhang Guoqing. Where's Premier
Li Qiang, right? Where's Ding Xuexiang, the executive vice premier, and He Lifeng? They're
all absent. And the fourth irregularity was even more symbolic. At previous ceremonies,
both Hu Jintao and Xi Jinping reviewed the naval honor guard. This time, Xi Jinping didn't.
The speeches from the ship building chairman and the navy commander were also cancelled this time.
And in 2019, about 5,000 officers attended the ceremony. This time, it said only 2,000.
So this was the photo that Xi Jinping took this year, or at least official Xinhua released. This
time, state media only showed Xi Jinping surrounded by just 20 carrier pilots and deck crew.
And finally, the most striking part is Zhang Youxia himself. Given his position, he should
have been there. In fact, showing up would have helped silence the talk of a rift between him and
Xi if that were the case. But he chose not to go. So here's the question. Why skip the Fujian
ceremony, a military event, but show up at the national games in Guangzhou? Well, the reason
is clear, or at least clear to me. General Zhang didn't want to endorse Xi Jinping's brainchild
project, his Fujian carrier. Had he gone, he would have been forced to play Xi Jinping's assistant,
standing behind him as a prop, hosting the event. So General Zhang refused.
But the Guangzhou event was different. The PLA team is one of the strongest in the national
games. Zhang Youxia attended as the military's highest representative,
cheering on his soldiers, not as Xi Jinping's subordinate. He didn't have to play second fiddle.
In that group photo, he even enjoyed equal status with Xi Jinping, standing side by side.
So that kind of arrangement doesn't happen by accident. It was deliberate, carefully planned.
Also notice this, the physical distance between Xi Jinping and Zhang Youxia is far wider than the
distance that Xi Jinping enjoyed from two months ago. It's a perfect reflection of their political
distance. They're keeping each other at arm's length. This new image once again shows how
China's political system and its military power are disconnected. They're like two engines running
on separate tracks, making an effort to look united, but clearly not.