The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Disclaimers:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
These vidoes are intended to represent the law at the time of recording to the best of my ability. If there are any updates and/or mistakes, I endeavour to make sure these mistakes are corrected. Where you find a mistake, comment under the video and I will check and make the appropriate amendments.
The reality of law is that it is an ever changing and deeply complex subject. As such, mistakes and updates are inevitable. I feel that this it the best approach for this kind of educational content, given its static nature.
Image(s) Copyrights: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Hello everyone and welcome back to the Jurisprudence Podcast with me Alex.
And me Charlotte.
And Charlotte, what are we talking about today?
So we're going to do a little deep dive into the history of the English trial.
Okay, now my first question is, because this is the thing that you've been doing
all the last couple of weeks, this is your first one.
What is the reasoning for doing a history of the English trial?
What's the why behind this?
Well, first of all, I wanted to be a bit self-indulgent and talk about the criminal trial.
Also, the sort of influence for me doing this
comes from someone that I've been reading quite a lot in my PhD, Anthony Duff.
Okay.
And that also brings me into the second reason that
him and a few other criminal theorists, scholars in the field, did a trilogy of books
doing a deep dive into the history of the, well, not just the history, but the criminal trial itself.
Yes.
And the kind of principles that influence it, that make us value it so much in terms of
what it means for justice and why we centralize it within the criminal justice system.
So in the third book, they do a similar thing that I wanted to do today, which is to do a
historical account of how the trial came to be.
And that was really justified by this idea that things that we have,
like institutions, like the government, and the trial, and police, and things like that,
we sort of take them for granted and assume that they've always been there,
they've always served the same purpose, and they've always been supported by the same kind
of ideals. And they look back into the history of the criminal trial in England and Wales,
and kind of basically in search of the foundations of these principles that we've imbued into
the criminal trial, and sort of brought to attention that these have developed over time
as we've seen the function of the trial develop as well.
So yeah, that's a...
Does that answer your question?
That does answer my question, exactly. So there is this growing, this idea, this perception that,
especially because as people who've lived in England and Wales, you grow up
hearing about the idea of the trial in sort of common parlance and sort of colloquial understanding.
Well, we get called to jury service.
Exactly. Yeah, we do jury service and all this kind of stuff. And it's sort of like a thing
that is, like you said, imbued, not just in terms of the legal system, but it's sort of imbued in
the culture of English society. And people would be quite surprised how recent the adversarial
trial actually is in terms of its development, given now how long the history of England has been.
The adversarial trial is relatively recent. Now, my next question then is, if we're going to be
doing a history of the English trial, we're going to be doing specifically a history of
the adversarial trial. What is the adversarial trial? What do we mean when we say the adversarial
trial?
So this will come out a little bit more as we talk about the history, because
I wanted to point out this distinction as well as we go further back. The adversarial trial is
named as such because it highlights a difference in legal tradition. So here we have an adversarial
trial, and on the continent in Europe, they have the inquisitorial trial. And the difference
between the two, broadly speaking, is the way that the trial is structured. So on the continent,
you have a judge that, basically, the process of investigation is imbued into the trial. So
over here, we have the police that conduct the investigation, and then they charge the defendant,
and then that goes to trial, and the evidence on both sides is weighed up. On the continent,
the investigation and trial process is merged, and then you bring all of the evidence together
into one, they call it a dossier, and the one judge, and sometimes in the presence of a jury,
sometimes not, it's not as central as it is here, the one judge will adjudicate on law and fact.
That's a very interesting point. One of the first things that you will learn in doing either
criminal law or criminal evidence in England and Wales is that there is this distinction between
law and fact, in the sense that there are factual burdens that are presented at trial,
and then there are legal burdens presented at trial. The judge often, at least traditionally
in the adversarial trial, is somebody who is tasked with essentially doing a lot of the legal
adjudication, and then the questions of fact are left to the jury. And it's supposed to be the case
that those two don't cross over, but there are some examples where it's a little bit of a crossover
point. But the idea here is that the jury of lay people, the jury of individuals who are
obviously not trained in legal specialisms or whatever, are going to be the people that are
basically just going to determine the facts of a particular case, the factual outcomes,
the legal questions, things like the admissibility of evidence, the things like hearsay, all that
kind of stuff, the really complicated legal stuff is done by a judge. And it's less the case, you say,
sorry, in the civil law tradition in Europe. Yeah, so here you'll broadly hear a judge saying
if on this evidence you find that such and such occurred, this means that the
legal criteria for such and such offence is satisfied, you must find him guilty. Yes,
that's what the function of a jury direction is. It's directing the interpretation of fact
towards satisfying legal criteria. And that sort of makes the judge and the jury work in tandem,
whereas on the continent, it's a little bit different that it's just the judge that's
assessing. Yeah, for the most part, yeah. And I think the main difference, though, is the
function of evidence, which I also think is quite important as we look into the history a little
bit more. Yeah. So should we start doing that then? Should we start with the history? Yes.
And you want to do it in a chronological sense, obviously, because we don't want to confuse
people. Yeah. And really, the first point of call that you want to talk about is the Roman law,
because, of course, the Romans didn't invade England, they were in England. And so we do
have to mention the Romans and Roman law and their traditions, even if they are not as influential
as they are on the continent, as it is here. Yes, it is still particularly important. So,
okay, so you mentioned to me before that one of the things that made you want to dive into the
Roman law is because Duff doesn't explicitly speak about the Roman law when they talk about the
trial. Yeah. So in trial and trial trilogy, they don't go that far back because it's not
an investigation into legal history. Yeah. But I thought it'd be quite interesting for
this episode to briefly touch on the sort of influence of the Romans in Britain. Yes.
Also, because it was quite interesting in the fact that they,
their influence is still seen today in terms of, like, the formal language of law. Of course,
we still use Latin, for example, for most things. Yeah. So you say that one of the things that
really is a byproduct of the Roman law and Roman traditions is this idea of disputation.
Yes. So this idea of legal questions being oral, so a tradition of orality in developing the law
and settling disputes. And this was really a source of the sophistication of law in the Roman
period. So they had jurists which talked about and sort of ruminated about the law and answering
legal questions. And not a lot was written down at this time. So there's not the same sort of
strict adherence to textual legal principles as there is now. And arguably, in the sort of
post-classical Roman period, where they moved more towards a standardized trial-esque procedure,
there was a transition from the formulary procedure to the cognitio procedure,
where they involved a magistrate in the adjudication of cases between individuals.
There was a shift towards sort of textualism, and that meant that there was more of a
one-size-fits-all approach to law. So there was less of this kind of fluidity and sophistication
of legal ideas and more of a rigid application of law for pragmatic purposes. Brilliant. Okay.
That's interesting. And so really then, there are some basic principles that we start to see
from the Roman law. And then there are some key points throughout the history of the common law,
throughout the history of law in England and Wales, that we can start to see how the trial
develops. So while this isn't necessarily a history of law in England or a history of English law,
this is specifically about the trial, there are points at which we see how the trial starts to
take shape, especially when it comes to this idea of justice and a conception of justice. Because
the point that we spoke about earlier is that we have this sort of weird conception, and we're
going to talk about it more, I reckon, in the conclusion. We have this weird conception that
what we've arrived at now is the enlightened process by which law takes place. This is the,
we are the correct, we are providing a rule of law, we're providing due process,
we're providing everything. And it was these barbaric, horrific practices that we've strayed
away from that essentially, we've seen the light and we have seen how... You're alluding to the
ordeal there. I'm alluding to the trial by ordeal, which we'll get to in a second. But
one of the points she wants to make is that in their own weird, fantasistic ways, they are
actually presenting what they believe to be a just outcome, even if towards it's very barbaric.
Trial by ordeal. Yes. So with a shift, then, to the Romans left. Yeah, the Romans leave.
The Romans leave, and this withdraw from Britain leaves a gap where we need to adjudicate for
ourselves and figure out our own customs and stuff. Exactly. And I would like to make a little
side note that in that, there were still quite a lot of Romans in Britain, but they were used for
their legal knowledge and Germanic tribes were quite happy to have Roman jurists write their
texts and stuff because Latin was still viewed as the legal... The language of law. Yeah, exactly.
And so the Romans leave and then you have the Angles and the Saxons and then you have the
Vikings, sorry, they start to appear. We have the Heptarchy that exists with Wessex and Northumbria
and all the others. And then you start to see through the reigns of Alfred the Great,
his son, whose name eludes me, and his son, Aethelstan, the consolidation of England. Edward
the Elder, that was his name. And so we start to see... Firstly, also, we start to see the influence
of religion, Christianity. Of course, Christianity begins during the Roman times and is eventually
adopted by the Romans and then spread across all of Europe. And so Christianity starts to
take a greater role, not just in England, but also in the rest of Europe. Yes. And so... It's
approached quite differently, as we'll get to in a second, but that brings us nicely onto the
idea of the ordeal. Yeah, the idea of the ordeal and the trial by ordeal. Yeah, so it is stressed
in Trial on Trial that they wanted to talk about the ordeal not necessarily because it's seen as
the birth of the adversarial trial as we know it, but it demonstrates that we have still a formal
approach to assessing the accused. Yes. So as you said before, there's this idea that the ordeal
itself is a barbaric practice, which is described as an irrational mode of proof. So it's...
Because it's so... It seems like it doesn't come from rationality. No, it seems so barbaric.
Yeah. Maybe we should explain what the trial by ordeal is to people who don't know.
It's essentially a situation where, if you want, we'll get into each of the different stages,
if you want, the idea of an accusation. Well, explain the ordeal first. Yeah, the point of
the ordeal and why it's called a trial by ordeal is essentially you go through an ordeal. Yeah,
it's horrible. And go through something that's horrible and it is seen as God judging your guilt
or lack thereof in a particular situation. So these are often commonly described as... And
you learn about these when you're younger, if you live in England and Wales.
The one such example is a hot iron. You have to carry a hot iron in your hand as it starts to
burn your hand and it starts to scald your hand and it starts to blister and you have to walk a
certain number of steps or something. And the idea here is that they would then bandage the hand up
and then after a week or so, if it is healed or if it has become infected, that's a sign from God
that you are either guilty or not guilty of a particular act. And the idea here is that
essentially the clergy or a religious individual would essentially bless the hot iron such that
if this person was innocent, they would not blister and they would not get infected if they
were guilty, then God would reveal that guilt in that way. And then another example is the idea
of putting someone in water. If they sink, then it is conceived that they are innocent because
the idea here is that an individual who is guilty is an individual who has sinned and the water
repels sinners. So if you floated, you were being repelled by the holy water and so therefore you
are guilty and then obviously vice versa. So these are the kind of ordeals that people talk about.
And that might sound familiar if you have ever read about the witch trials. Yeah, exactly. Witch
trials, which had a very similar kind of system. So it's described in
Trial on Trial as a relatively formal judicial procedure and that's why they kind of point to it
because this idea of distancing ourselves from our past of legal procedure isn't necessarily
helpful because you can trace a distinct development of kind of understanding this
idea of criminal responsibility, how that translates into law and procedure throughout
the ages. So it's not just that people back then were crazy and that they were leaving it up to
God because they didn't really have an understanding of what it meant to have a formalized
assessment of proof and understanding evidence and that kind of thing. They were actually trying
to construct a formalized procedure for dealing with quite complex issues.
It just doesn't look that way because now we've developed quite a lot and we've come to
imbue the trial with things like human rights and etc etc and there's
an international context now but anyway. There's a few points though of
reference though. So there is generally a presumption of guilt rather than a presumption
of innocence in these trials by ordeal. So it starts with the accusation where
the person aggrieved, they have to bring a prima facie case against the wrongdoer
meaning that it speaks for itself. So let's say I've stolen your goat in medieval
England and you go well he lives next door and my goat's missing. There you go, that's
a prima facie case against the wrongdoer. And then you have to have a body of witnesses
to establish that. So my other neighbours saw him with a goat. Carrying a goat, it looks a lot like
my goat. It looks a lot like my goat. And then there's also a strong presumption of guilt like
you mentioned earlier. So you've stolen other people's goats in the past. Yes, I'm a famous
goat stealer and so therefore all of these things together come to a conclusion that
you've probably done it. So there is enough evidence or there is enough of a case
to allow a court or to allow someone who adjudicates to then determine an ordeal.
Yeah, so then next there should be attempts to settle or mount a defence. So at least you get
to speak for yourself and maybe exchange money and say let's set this aside, I'll give you money
for this supposed missing goat. Otherwise then the court determines what the ordeal would be,
what the form of proof would be. Yes, and that's how the ordeal was sort of viewed, isn't it? It
was viewed as a form of proving something or something else, essentially. If you have blisters
on your hand, if it got infected, that is proof of your guilt rather than anything else. In
absence of being able to dust for fingerprints in the barn, there would be no other way of gathering
evidence and it's sort of a way of filling this gap of not having any sort of, you know,
you don't have CCTV back then or anything like that. There's a gap of evidence that needs to be
filled that is more persuasive than just a bunch of people saying that you did it. So it's trying
to settle my word against yours in some kind of way and if God can say it then that's good enough
for them. Exactly, and I think it's not particularly fair to speak a bit as barbaric and
how stupid were people back in the day when we did this because there wasn't DNA, there wasn't
CCTV, there wasn't a police force, there wasn't any of this and there was also a very strong
conviction that God existed and that God was imminent in people's lives and that God was
somebody who would be able to make determinations. So where there is basically a void of evidence
and where there is a void of being able to ever come to a determination on the basis of
sort of mortal humans being able to come to a determination about what happened, then of course
with no evidence and a strong belief in God it would make perfect sense that they would
find a way of essentially getting God involved in the process. It's just that the methods by
which this happens is a little bit barbaric, definitely questionable. But then I would also
like to heavily emphasise the fact that there's this strong presumption of guilt that underlines
it. And this runs throughout the history of the trial actually in either the way that the process
is done or the way that evidence is produced or evaluated or indeed the way that the laws are
applied and criteria are met. So where there are examples of bad character, so if you are considered
a thief, it is more likely that you will have done it and the mode of proof will then be decided
based on your character and your social standing. So it's not, it is quite sophisticated but then
there are also very problematic elements. It's not just that every person is put before God
in the same way, which I would argue now with developing due process, there's more of a rule
of law and equal... Of course there is, yeah, definitely. Well you would hope so. You would
hope so, definitely, yeah. And so this brings us nicely to the end of the idea of the trial by
ordeal and the beginning of a jury. Yes. This takes place surprisingly early, this takes place in 1219.
Yes. The beginnings of the jury trial and, well, what do you want to say about the jury trial?
So there was a move away from the ordeal and this left a gap of being basically
filling the gap of a lack of evidence and on the continent they rediscovered the Roman canon. Yes.
And this is where the inquisitorial trial developed and unfortunately back then there
was a heavy emphasis on torture evidence as filling the evidential gap. Yeah, well exactly.
So if there was a confession that was seen as the gold standard of proof. And I guess it probably
was also perceived that every time we do this torture people tend to confess. Yes. So they
sort of made one link to the other. Yeah. And concluded that well it must be just this system
is very useful in getting confessions. Yeah, exactly. And not questioning whether or not
the confessions are valid or not valid. Well yeah, there is a truth-seeking question there
that obviously you want the truth in a criminal trial but it's not necessarily the case that
confessions are going to be truthful. No. Especially if you're being tortured. Well exactly,
yeah. But anyway, in England the jury trial replaced the trial by ordeal and we were more
inclined towards this. It wasn't necessarily called the adversarial process because
this principle of equality of arms wasn't quite imbued into the trial yet. Which we'll get to. So
they called it the altercation trial. Okay, yeah. So the altercation trial is really a period that
sort of sits between the sort of 1400s and 1700s. Yeah, roughly. Something around there.
And what is the main purposes or the main ideas of the altercation trial system? What are the
sort of things that are features of this system? So I alluded to it being sort of a transitionary
hold between the ordeal and the adversary. So we have juries, we have a defense,
we have the prosecution which is a representative of the crown. Just like it is today. Just like
defense was basically on the back foot the whole time. Yes. So the defense didn't have counsel.
Yep. They couldn't subpoena witnesses so they couldn't make them come into court. So they were
basically relying on the goodwill of a witness to defend them in the altercation trial. Yep. So
witnesses had to come voluntarily and they were not allowed to give evidence under oath. So it
wasn't seen to be, there's still this like presence of God in trial. Yes. That the prosecution
witnesses give evidence under oath and they are therefore gold standard truthful. Whereas defense
witnesses not only are they representing the case of the defense which is quite shunned already,
but also the fact that they're not giving evidence under oath means that it can't be held to the same
standard. Exactly yeah. And it's interesting that fundamentally the distinction between these two
trials, the altercation and the adversarial trial, isn't necessarily the features, the sort of actual
things that are there. There's a jury there in both cases, there's a prosecution which represents by
the crown similar to how we have it now. There is a defense, you have a sense of defense at least,
a perception of defense and you have witnesses. So it's very very similar in terms of the features
but the thing that is different is this thing that you mentioned a second ago which is this
equality of arms. Yes. This idea here that even though all the features are there the balance is
massively in the favor of the prosecution and so it makes you question what the actual purpose of
the altercation trial really is which is more to just say we basically know you've done it or we
don't care if you've done it or not. Yeah. We just want to hear what you say before we go and hang
you. Yeah. Is essentially the point. Yeah so while there are juries, the jury deliberation wasn't
private like it is today. They didn't go into a separate room and discuss. They also had to return
a unanimous verdict. Okay. Which is still roughly the case now. Yes. And the sentence would be
decided basically on the spot and then proceed and usually that was hanging. Yes. So they were
very quick trials weren't they? They were very quick. It was like 20 minutes. Yeah. Which is
completely different to now which trials can take upwards of days, weeks. Days,
months. Yeah. The O.J. Simpson trial took a very long time. Yeah. So I lost my train of thought.
You lost your train of thought. You were talking about the differences between the two.
The between altercation and everything. Yes. Yes. So the altercation really
began this idea of calling to account. So it's not just a mode of proof now but also this kind
of theatrical procedure that we go through in order to hold the accused in front of his peers,
be tried by his peers and see what he has to say for himself. Exactly. So it's this idea of calling
to account and addressing wrongdoing publicly. Yeah. And it was only later that the idea of
equality and due process was sort of imbued into that. So really the main distinction between the
altercation and adversarial trial isn't that they introduce new things per se in terms of we're now
introducing a situation where we now have a jury. Yeah. That all existed already. The system
basically existed already. But the idea was to essentially imbue a sense of balance. Yes. Or a
greater sense of balance between the prosecution and the defense. Yes. And as you mentioned earlier
to me that to sort of professionalize the trial to imbue this idea of an equality of arms. Yeah.
And so the point that you made earlier was that the idea of an adversary is not just somebody who
is opposed to you. It is that they are equally opposed to you. Exactly. Yeah. So and you know
if it wasn't if there wasn't this sense of equality you wouldn't be called an adversary.
You'd be called an enemy. Yeah. You know what I mean? Yeah. Exactly. So the idea of an adversary
is not necessarily just someone who's opposed but opposed on equal footing. And you mentioned this
idea that the distinction then is that there is an equality of arms. Yeah. There is a prosecution
that has a certain degree of authority. And then there is also a defense that has a certain degree
of authority. Yeah. And it's not one sided anymore. Or it's supposed to be not one sided anymore.
It's becoming more equal anyway. Exactly. Yeah. So when did the adversarial trial begin?
Well interestingly I can't find the year but it's roughly the 1800s. Okay. So.
And that just goes to speed by the way from our point that we made earlier on the idea that this
idea of the trial by jury or just the idea of the adversarial trial in general is something that
existed from time immemorial is not actually true. We had a jury for we've got a jury system for quite
a long time since 1219. But the idea of an adversarial trial has only existed in the sort of
1800s. Yeah. In the Victorian age basically. Well this development of the trial also came with
a period of great legal reform. Yes. Criminal law. Yes. So we had the police. Yeah. Robert Peel
did a lot of reform before he introduced the police. Yeah. And this really it was almost
like whiplash like reading about it because there's this great influx of criminal law reform
which tried to imbue the process with a sense of integrity and justice that we see today. Exactly.
So it's not just about fulfilling this function of accusing people and calling them to account
but also having a formalized process in doing so and restricting the strong arm of the law
through these more formalized actors and introducing the lawyer into the trial which is
another really important step and that's really when it shifted from altercation to adversary.
Yeah. Is when defense were allowed to have counsel. Yes. And I think this period is
basic because we've talked a lot about how the structure of the trial shifted but I think it's
less so now about how the structure is changing and actors within the trial but more about the
substance and what goes behind the formal procedures. Yes. So now that there's this
sort of professionalism and equality of arms it's also about evidence laws and
what evidence is admissible at trial. The kind of reduction of capital punishment. Yes. So I
mentioned here that the establishment of full defense by counsel in felony trials and the
collapse of the bloody code in the 1830s occurred at the same time. The bloody code,
by the way, was basically the institution of capital punishment for basically everything.
Yeah. And it's interesting that it's unfortunate that it will take a major event to happen in
Europe for there to be the more modern human rights conceptions to be applied in these
jurisdictions. Obviously you have the second world war and then you have the European convention and
then you have the universal declaration and things like the twin covenants and all these different
kinds of things. So it takes a huge thing like that to actually lead to the full final abolition
of the death penalty in England and Wales. But it's interesting just how many things change
in the 1800s. Yeah. We sort of see like a very slow and gradual transition out of capital
punishment and a more a shift towards like a more fair treatment of defense. One thing actually that
I forgot to mention was with the advent of the jury, jury nullification was quite important in
addressing capital punishment. And that's part of the reason why they got rid of it because
the institution of capital punishment was directly impinging on the ability for
the criminal trial to be this truth-seeking procedure. And just for the audience,
what is jury nullification basically? Basically, based on the evidence that is provided,
the jury ought to have found a guilty verdict and yet they return a not guilty verdict
because they feel that it's morally correct to do so. Exactly. So a situation where even if the
correct therefore sentence would be something like the death penalty, especially back then
when everything was the death penalty, but the jury would say, well, they're guilty.
We don't want them to die. We don't want them to die. So we're going to return a nullified jury,
basically. Yeah. So this also changed the dynamics of the courtroom in that the jury was now less
concerned with the preservation of the defendant and more concerned with actual fact-finding.
Exactly. Which is their proper role. Yeah. Their role shouldn't be to have any kind of
moral considerations about what happens to the person. It should just be, did the person do this
thing according to you? Yes. Do you think they did this thing? You need to agree. Do they do it? Yes
Based on the evidence presented. Based on the evidence and based on the standard that we have
explained to you. Yeah. What jury instructions did this person do this thing? Yeah. So then there's
kind of a transition from the public being concerned in the preservation of the defendant
and that role is now placed in the state and the agents within the criminal justice system.
So then our final kind of mold of the trial is an institution where
people are accused of wrongdoing and they're placed on an equal footing where they are able to
present exculpatory evidence. Evidence that they are innocent and then their accuser is able to
present evidence why they're guilty. Yeah. And they're then tried by their peers. Exactly.
Guilt is determined on that basis. Yeah. Absolutely. So that's how we basically
arrive at where we are today. And so in sort of wrapping up then, thinking about a sort of
conclusion, what would you take from this development in history and this development
of the trial? Firstly, it's interesting. Yeah. Oh, definitely. And I hope everybody has been
interested by this episode. But what else would you say is interesting about the development of
the trial? Key takeaways that you would think about? Well, I think the main takeaway was the
main influence on this episode, which was, well, I studied criminal theory and
Duff is the main proponent of centralizing the trial as the form and function of the criminal
law. And I don't know if I've done a good job of this, but I wanted to place emphasis on how
the trial isn't just about process, but it's also about the substance of the law. And the
substance of the law can really drive how the procedure plays out and the different actors
within that process. Yeah. So you have an assessment of the accused and the trial
does that, but the law also does that as well. And the way that the law is applied
can have an effect on the, what am I getting at? Can have an effect on the outcome?
On the perception of the person within the trial. The perception of the individual,
the accused. Yeah, exactly. How they are viewed. So it's not just about process, but it's also
about the law itself. Exactly. Yeah. I mean, in terms of, I think that I would take away from it
is that there is this idea that you mentioned that it is somehow that today internet, sorry,
today domestic justice is seen as the end goal. It's almost like we've had a teleology of
the criminal trial and it's gone from barbarity to injustice. And we've finally arrived at this
end goal of the perfect criminal trial. And the reason why I said international justice,
because I would draw on an interview that was done by Jeffrey Nice, who was a prosecutor in
the international criminal tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, who tried Slobodan Milosevic.
And he was asked once that what he would change about the ICTY. And he very much wasn't a big fan
of this idea of essentially importing into international justice, this, these, these
conceptions of the basic common law idea of the trial. And because it's often quite slow or it's
often something that has just been imported by the US and the UK as a, as a way of basically
presenting that, putting it on show and sort of imbuing its popularity. And he said that that was
something that was not good for victims of these crimes in international law. So there are
definitely critiques of this system, critiques that have been levied. And so the idea that this
is the perfect system that we have is obviously something that is a bit naive, generally anyway.
Yeah, that's actually quite interesting that you mentioned
victims in the international stage. At the domestic stage,
victims also complained that because they are being represented by the crown,
they don't actually get a say in the outcome of their trials either.
Of course, no, they are reduced to that of at most a witness.
Yeah. So in, in a way, in order to put people on an equal footing in the adversarial trial,
the victim is taken down and the defendant is sort of propped up to meet that, that footing.
Which doesn't seem to be, at least,
perceptively doesn't look right.
Yeah.
But it's interesting that that's how the system tends to, tends to work.
I think that it really, it flows from the, the investigative procedure, like I mentioned
earlier. So in the international trial, it's, it's more inquisitorial because they have this
centralization of evidence. Whereas here, it's very much a separation of investigation and...
Yeah, there's no world police.
Yeah, exactly.
No world CPS that does the charging and all these different kinds of things,
which is interesting. Absolutely.
Yeah.
Well, I think that nicely wraps things up.
I think it does, yeah.
Anything else you want to say?
I don't think so.
Brilliant. Okay. Well, if you've got any questions and if you've got any suggestions for new episodes,
do let us know in the comments down below. I hope everyone's enjoyed this episode and has
learned something about the history of the adversarial trial and some of the interesting
points that we can make about it. And I'll see everybody, we'll see everybody in a couple of
weeks time when we talk about another topic in law.
And it'll be your turn.
It will be my turn, exactly. So look forward to that.