Why Repeating Crossbows not common in history

Crossbows Legacy
11 followers
102 Video Views·Nov 13, 2025
I'm sure many of you have already seen York's various instant legolas devices,
but was the instant legolas used in history? The short answer is no. For this specific device,
we have no historical evidence, but there were similar rapid arrow shooting devices
used throughout history, such as the Chinese repeating crossbow or the Greek polybolos.
So even though we have historical repeating devices,
whether it's Chinese repeating crossbows or artillery repeating devices that shoot arrows,
why did they not become popular? I have four reasons. Firstly, the bow is simpler and cheaper
to make. It's cheaper to make and that by itself is very valuable. Secondly,
many professional soldiers had armor or shields at the time, so a light poundage bow would not
be very useful. Sure, you could put a heavy bow on these devices, but then you could be
decreasing your rate of fire. It takes a lot of force and time to be drawing these bows,
and keep in mind it's going to tire soldiers a lot more quicker. The English and various
cultures such as the Manchus used heavy bows above 100 pounds, which are more suitable to
penetrate shields and medium armor, but they required a lot of strength to use.
Certainly, there would be situations where rapidly shooting arrows could be useful,
such as shooting at unarmored people or animals, prisoners, flanking maneuvers to shoot at the
unshielded sides, or for reducing the enemy's morale. The third reason why these repeating
archery devices were not common is because other ranged weapons may be more suitable.
Throwing axes, which can be thrown really rapidly, or javelins. None of these require
complicated mechanisms. Eventually, at point range, you're going to need to switch to a melee
weapon, and a throwing axe is pretty good for being used as a melee weapon. And finally, my last
point. Archers can shoot speeds similar to the instant legolas. Here is me, who is not Lars
Anderson, speed shooting five arrows very rapidly. This is a more common and more reliable draw style,
the Mongolian thumb draw. Just look how fast Altan shoots, even though he is pulling the arrow
from the quiver, one by one. So, these are some variants of speed shooting, which I would like to
discuss in the future, but my point is, you can shoot very fast already without a device. The time
difference between this and repeaters is negligible. Also, keep in mind, arrows were not cheap to make.
Often, you would want to make sure each shot counted, so many archers would take the time
shooting each arrow with heavier draw weights, especially during sieges. So, in summary, the
concept of the instant legolas did exist in history in various forms, but the four main reasons why it
was not popular is that it was more complicated, more difficult to shoot heavier bows, it is
replaceable by other ranged weapons such as javelins, and most importantly, archers could
shoot similar speeds compared to an instant legolas. Thank you very much for watching.
My name is Jack Fan, and this is Historical Archery. Please like and subscribe.
