Hanfugirls Talk Episode 2: The Song Dynasty Tea Whisking Challenge

Ancient Costumes And Life
21 followers
1 Video View·Nov 12, 2025
Eustacia and I decided to try whisking Song dynasty tea ourselves, without guidance from our tea Sage Kenny, just to see if we can make it on our own. No pain, no gain.
Okay, so today right, I'm gonna unbox this Song Dynasty tea set
which I have also bought, but it might not be here yet.
First up, I need to show you.
I actually added a little bit more accessories because it's part of the autumn season.
I added a little leaf pole thing and also a bit more of the flowers
to denote the idea of seasons.
Because we're doing this like tea recreation.
Actually, you want to say how welcome to episode...
Oh, oh yeah.
What should I say?
Welcome to episode 2!
Okay, welcome to episode 2 of Humble Girls Talk.
Today, I'm too excited about my tea set.
And then, so I'm gonna bring out all these items.
I'm going to open this with scissors.
I have scissors.
This spoon is more for Japanese tea because they use bamboo
whereas Chinese typically would have used like metal spoons.
But I've got one, but it's on the way.
So I think it's interesting and important to note that
actually a lot of what we consider as Japanese traditional tea matcha
would have been inspired by Song and Tang Dynasty tea practices.
So a lot of people who are reconstructing Song Dynasty tea
or the old Tang Dynasty tea,
they would be looking towards Japan actually for inspiration.
But at the same time, Japan has definitely modified it
to become part of their own culture.
The tea ceremony is now very Japanese,
but we can see a lot of similarities in how
originally in China, for example,
powdered tea was the norm rather than what we see now.
And that's also why when you look at this,
a lot of the things look very familiar if you like Japanese tea.
Okay, so I think we need to push this camera a little bit back
so I can see the whisk.
Well, the Chinese, I think they wouldn't have the original
whisk stand because the Chinese one would have been
the longer one, which is a bit like Okinawa,
the poku poku tea that you blocked out.
And I think from what I see, the original one would be
before they kind of curved it in,
so they just cut the bamboo and then used it.
So it's one set less when you're looking at a tower whisk.
But the Japanese one was a round one.
It wasn't a flat one.
Yeah, so they went through.
So what the brown one was just like this.
I can take a picture right there.
Then they take the whole bamboo and they cut it.
And then after that, they kind of refine it into this.
So I think it would have been one set before
and they continue refining it as their tradition evolves.
Okay, so I need some warm water.
I'll just pause the video.
I'll get the water ready.
So I'm going to warm the cup first.
I also warm the whisk so it's softer and can whisk better.
Well, it's my first time trying the Song Chi,
so we'll see how it goes.
First step is to scoop some tea powder.
I don't know how much I scoop.
I'll just...
You know, there's no real quantity that they mention in...
Like how much I should scoop.
Oh, there's no water.
So when everything's dissolved,
then that's when they say I should put in a bit of water.
Second round, so it's the second water.
That's when I need to start whisking.
It looks very tiring.
How much money for the egg?
The foam?
I should use thermomix or some machine.
The Daiso, the foam?
I was tempted to bring my egg white beater today to try.
But I couldn't find the beater.
Okay, I'm having...
Okay, I have to use my left hand.
You know, actually I think I'm a left-hander
because I like to dribble and everything with my left hand.
This is so hard.
Okay.
I don't know how Kenny does it, but...
I'm getting a bit tired.
Okay, I think I need a second bit of foam, water.
Okay.
Here we go.
So, Pam Pam, what kind of foam should this be?
It should be as thick as wax.
So it should be like a meringue?
Yeah, it's like a hard peak for the egg white when you beat it.
But except that instead of machine, you're supposed to use your hand.
Are you at the soft peak already?
I think I'm at a...
I don't know.
Later we will take turns to try and see who has better wrist control.
I am.
Yeah, see, I knew I was a left-hander.
After resting for like 5 seconds, I'm continuing.
I feel like after today, I can't go home and carry my kid anymore.
I don't want to paint something onto your phone.
No, no, no.
No peak!
No, even close.
No, I think I'm not getting it.
So this is like the 7, right?
6.
My mom wants to finish fast.
Yes, I think it's a very meditative experience.
But not for the first time.
It's just very agonizing for the first time.
Because my arm just can't feel anything anymore.
Okay, I'm just whisking the big bubbles into smaller ones now.
And I'm not getting the foam.
Okay, I'll just do the last one.
So the best kind of tea, right, you're supposed to have the foam stuck to the side of the bowl when you twist, when you move it around later on.
And then when you pour it onto a plate, it should only dissipate after like 20 minutes.
So that you can make art, you know, tea art on top of the foam.
Do you think the tea they use was the kind that we're using now?
Oh, I asked Kenny that day.
He said that there's no way we can ever recreate the entire experience.
Because the way we make tea is so different from the past already.
They no longer have that kind of tea, they no longer have that kind of process.
So everything is different.
So we can only try to emulate it, but let's not lie to ourselves that it's definitely not 100% recreation.
Well, the story still fits Impossible.
For the first time, but it looks decent to me.
It's not too bad.
Not bad.
But I feel like if it was stiff, then I cannot drink the tea.
I think you're supposed to just drink the foam.
Oh, yeah. Then it's very much like the Ochanawa Puku Puku.
Yeah, we'll let everybody else try for now.
Alright, so round two, it's me versus Pan Pan.
I'm very scared.
They say you're supposed to put the water at the top.
I'm sure it's because it looks nicer.
Yeah, do you want to like kneel up?
Yeah, we said that it's probably easier to...
And if people want to experience this for themselves, Pan Pan, where can they do it?
They can join us for the upcoming Yaji, which is on 24th of September.
And then we're going to have Kenny, who's like a tea expert, explaining to us about the history, the practices,
the overall macro environment, as well as the greater detail of the tea making.
You can come and prove that you're better at whisking than me and Pan Pan.
Yeah, and if you're a really hardcore tea enthusiast, you can actually buy a whole set as part of the experience
and whisk it on your own and bring it home and do it more.
And then see whether you can reach the soft peak and finally the hard peak.
I know what you mean about the hand peak.
Right?
Thank you.
Maybe I'm left-handed also.
You can try.
Maybe we're all left-handed after today.
Oh no, but it does feel easier to whisk with my right hand.
Right?
Oh, right hand ah?
Yeah, so I'm definitely right-handed.
Okay, okay.
I felt that it was easier for my left hand.
So you're left-handed.
Yeah.
For sure.
And you're supposed to just do front and back, so apparently you're not supposed to turn round.
I'm speedrunning this because my hand is tired already.
Maybe you can take a rest.
We could.
I'll try to keep up.
You notice that there's a bit of a white colour when you pour water in, right?
So apparently that's how the tea art works, in that when you pour water inside, it dilutes the froth a bit,
so it becomes a bit of a whitish colour.
And then they use water to paint on top of the froth to have this white colour painting on top of the darker colour froth.
And if I'm not wrong, the other alternative was to use powder right on top of the froth.
Yeah, so I was asking Kenny.
Okay, Kenny is the expert, right?
So he said that in the records, they have white froth.
So how can you get white froth to have any colour?
If you add more water, it's going to get whiter.
You're not going to see any painting, so you're just going to use tea powder to do it.
You kind of mix it into a paste, like a paint, and you just paint over it.
I'm also not getting the soft peaks.
Right?
I think I did it three times already, right?
Yeah.
It's not starting full yet.
You know, I spoke to a guzheng player the other day.
She said that, oh, she practices guzheng a lot, so it's more natural for her to use her wrist to whisk.
So I think maybe if you have a background in Chinese instruments, such as guzheng,
where you're required to do a lot of finger wrist movement, it's probably easier for you.
Time for you to send your child to guzheng lessons.
Which tea for you have you drunk?
Don't you feel that you're feeling very warm now?
Yes.
I think it's good exercise.
It trains your core.
Core, arms, triceps, everything.
After one month of whisking tea every day, I think you can go off sleeveless anywhere.
But you must work both arms.
You're just like right arm, right?
Then one arm is tone, and the other arm is like flaps.
Two flaps.
In a way, asymmetrical.
Asymmetrical tops.
Yeah, I really cannot do that part.
Let me say, she probably has advantage.
She can use both hands to whisk.
Yeah, but it's not aesthetic, right?
It looks like you're just trying your best to whisk a tea.
This really reminds me of when I was trying to whisk the buku-buku cha in Okinawa.
And I think one thing they said was that it also depends on the water hardness.
Like whether it's hard water or soft water could influence whether the peaks appear and how they stay.
So we can try with different water types.
So we use like mineral water, right?
No, now it's tap water.
Oh, tap water.
Okay, maybe we can try with mineral water later.
Maybe it will be different.
And then, you know, I was reading about song tea yesterday.
And they said there was this thing called living water.
So water that's alive.
From the springs.
Yeah, and then when you boil it, you're not supposed to over boil it.
So when you boil it, you know, the bubbles appear, right?
So I think it's about 80 degrees.
So it's to prevent all the oxygen from leaving the water properly.
Oh, so that's the reason.
Because if it's living, I assume if it's a running water, then I think it should be oxygenated.
And they would want to prevent it from all escaping.
Oh, so maybe it's harder to whisk if it's overboiled.
Maybe.
Because we probably boil the water.
That's why they say the temperature control kettles are really good.
This is my fifth.
Interesting.
I bought one that's on the way.
We can try next time.
Kenny also has the pure silver kettle.
So he says the water tastes really good from there.
Oh, yeah.
So I also read and asked Kenny.
Apparently, in the past, they used like silver spoon to whisk.
Can you imagine?
I cannot even do this with a whisk.
I cannot even use a whisk to whisk.
Can you use a spoon?
We give everyone at the Yachty a silver spoon.
We'll be there the whole day, whole night.
You can try the silver pot first.
Like me.
Yeah, maybe they can practice beating egg with forks at home first.
And then you come to whisk the tea with the spoon.
Really, I'm not going to get the peaks.
Yeah, we're not going to get the peaks.
There's a hole but no peaks.
Yeah.
I really don't know how people do it.
I think maybe we should do it just every day and just try.
You get the hang of it after a while.
Oh, and someone did say if it's matcha, right, there's a study by Itoen and...
It's also Itoen.
I think it's one of the universities of maybe Tsukuba or something.
It says that matcha helps your social cognition so you can recognise people's emotions better
and you can have better sleep quality.
Oh yeah, I remember those benefits.
Yeah, it just came out.
They presented it to an Alzheimer's conference that they got people to take matcha capsules
so it's not even a placebo effect of having tea.
And they reported better sleep and they were better at recognising faces and emotions on faces.
But matcha itself, it's meant like grounded tea powder.
Yes, so the tea is normally shaded for, I think, 21 days and then it's grounded in stone mills.
Oh.
So there's a specific process to making matcha.
So does matcha mean green tea or white tea or what?
It's more of cha, so it's powdered tea.
Normally it would be green.
Yeah, so the study is about whether the texture of it is powdered or is it green tea?
They took matcha peels into capsules.
So they drink it.
Yeah, green tea.
Okay, so because I think this one is white tea, so does it...
That's true.
But I think the point was that because matcha, they are taking the whole tea leaf.
Whereas if you brew the tea, you leave a lot of things in the tea leaf itself.
So maybe the point is also like taking all the nutrients in the tea leaf will help you to...
And then you get physical fitness by whisking it every day.
I'm sure they don't whisk.
Not in the study.
We can get on our own benefits.
The Hanfu girl.
Yeah, maybe we'll all live to like 130 years old and then we'll all be whisking tea every day.
Can I say this is my last one?
Okay.
You've done your best.
This is getting white, right?
I'm waving the white flag.
The top, not the bottom already.
So it's the top.
So you're supposed to make the bubbles finer, such that you don't have the big bubbles appearing.
And if it sticks to the side of the bowl, it's a pass.
So we can tilt my bowl around.
Actually our tea looks very similar.
We're all at the same level.
Of course, we're like level 1.
We're aiming for B.
Wow, typical Asian right?
Want to get B on first try.
I aim for B.
Something like that, there you go.
Okay.
So no peaks, but let's tilt.
Yeah, I think we're about the same.
Yeah, there is some foam at the side of the bowl.
Okay, congratulations.
