Why You Shouldn't Buy Physical Gold And Silver

Profit Playbook
12 followers
Nov 12, 2025
Why You Shouldn't Buy Physical Gold And Silver
Imagine buying into a once-in-a-generation gold rally.
Prices at all-time highs,
only to discover months later that you're down.
Not because gold fell, but because you bought the wrong form of gold.
In 2025, gold set repeated records as investment flows surged
and central banks kept adding to their reserves.
But for many buyers, especially those who bought physical coins,
the system's hidden costs swallowed their gains.
In this video, we'll map out that system.
Who sets prices, who takes spreads,
and why the same ounce of metal can perform very differently,
depending on how you own it.
We'll also compare the real-world costs of coins vs. ETFs,
using current prices, typical dealer buybacks, taxes, and storage
to show where the numbers lead.
Let me start by saying this.
If you like the feel of owning physical metals, gold and silver, in your hands,
you can keep it.
This isn't a moral judgment.
It's an efficiency test.
Where do premiums, sales tax rules, storage, and dealer incentives
quietly erode returns?
And what is the most efficient way to add gold and silver to your portfolio?
And by contrast, where do ETFs' low fees and tight spreads actually shine?
Let's start by zooming out,
and then drill into the pipeline from refiner to you,
and finish by modeling a $10,000 purchase across the two paths.
My goal isn't to tell you what to buy.
It's to show you how the system behaves, so you can decide with eyes open.
And let me make it clear.
I do hold and have held gold and silver in my portfolio for quite some time.
Even when I made that video that many of the viewers of this channel watch,
where I talked about why you shouldn't buy physical gold and silver.
And many of those people assumed that I'm saying you shouldn't own it at all.
But that's not necessarily the case.
I'm a believer in having a very small amount in physical gold and silver just in case.
But I'm also realistic about the fact that the day that I need it will likely never come.
So then the question becomes,
is owning physical gold and silver about waiting for the apocalypse?
Or is it having a hedge in your portfolio that allows it to grow faster and safer
with less ups and downs?
And for most people, owning gold and silver is about hedging a portfolio,
not about owning this fancy metal that will probably or maybe go up in value
and in all likelihood at some point will definitely collapse just like it always does.
And this is for those people who are getting caught up in the excitement of owning physical gold and silver
because even Costco sells it now.
And really shining a light on who actually makes the most money
when you buy it physically from a gold dealer, or for that matter, Costco.
Let's start by talking about how gold bullion actually reaches you.
The US Mint doesn't sell bullion eagles directly to the public.
Instead, it sells it to a small network of authorized purchasers
who distribute to wholesalers and then to retailers.
This structure, just like every other business, is designed to create profits for the people who sell it.
And there's a premium to pay at every single level,
meaning that the gold that you are buying has been marked up, then marked up, and then marked up again.
And when you go to sell it, it works in exactly the opposite way.
You end up selling it for less so that the dealers and the retailers and everybody else can make their profits.
This structure is designed to create a two-way market,
but it also inserts intermediaries, each adding a small margin.
That means the coin you see at a dealer is the end of a long pipeline
that already carries distribution costs before the dealer markups begin.
And you can verify all of this by going to usmint.gov.
The market price anchor is the LBMA gold price,
an auction benchmark used by ETFs and dealers alike.
It's not the only price, but it's the common yardstick,
underlying spot quotes, and the prices that ETFs pay.
In other words, everyone references the same base.
But how you access that base changes your total cost,
and that ultimately affects your returns.
The more intermediaries that are involved, the more the margin is increased,
and the less returns you as an investor actually experience.
On the ETF side, costs are explicit and small.
Some ETFs, for example, charge 0.1% annually for storage and management.
And this gives the ETFs a unique advantage.
The trading spread is typically pennies.
So if you're buying and selling gold and silver in order to hedge your portfolio,
the overall friction can be lower by buying it through an ETF
than buying it one point at a time and paying a premium.
Now, in 2025, central banks have helped push gold to record highs
because their behavior is affecting the liquidity and the sentiment.
Right now, everyone believes that gold is the thing you need to invest in.
Just like in 2006, everybody believed that housing was the thing you needed to invest in,
and in 1999, everyone believed it was tech stocks.
As a result, net official purchases are staying elevated,
and that's reinforcing price momentum,
arguably leading to what very well could be a bubble.
That ultimately affects the cost of gold and silver,
and the volatility in your portfolio if you own it.
So let's take a look at the system at work.
Start with a one-ounce American Silver Eagle.
A typical advertised retail price recently hovered near $59 to $62 per coin,
even when spot silver traded at the low 40s.
Part of that gap is all of the margins that are added by all of the intermediaries,
the mint, the wholesalers, and the dealers.
And part of it is also the demand for eagles specifically.
Those layers produce a premium that buyers pay up front.
Now, let's flip the trade.
If you sell that same eagle back to many dealers,
the buyback price can be $8 to $12 lower than what you paid,
even if it's the exact same day and even if the spot price hasn't moved.
One public buy price we checked was $49 per eagle when retail offers were about $59,
meaning you took almost a 20% loss the day you bought it.
It's almost as bad as buying a brand new car and driving it off the lot.
That double-sided spread approaches 16 to 20% before taxes and shipping.
Now, in most cases, you aren't going to pay taxes, but it does happen.
And if you're buying from a dealer that isn't local, you will definitely pay shipping.
That spread is the most important number that most buyers never see until they sell.
They get caught up in buying, but they never think about,
what happens when I want to offload this?
Now, in times like today where gold, for example, has gone up 49% a single year,
you might look at those premiums and go, no big deal.
But over time, and the larger your portfolio gets,
the more it actually hurts your return.
And on a big portfolio, we can be talking tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands,
even millions of dollars if the portfolio gets big enough.
Now, gold eagles tend to carry smaller percentage spreads than silver eagles.
But the same logic applies.
Retail prices for common one-ounce gold eagles recently sat at around 42 to 42.50,
reflecting both gold's record levels and coin-specific premiums.
A buyer still needs a favorable move in spot or a long holding period to overcome that friction.
Then, when you add logistics, many dealers provide prepaid labels for larger sell-to-us shipments.
But smaller lots often bear insured shipping costs and time risk.
Coins also need secure storage.
I mean, yeah, you could bury it in your backyard or keep it in your house under your mattress.
But the reality is, you probably want it to be safe.
And safe deposit boxes run tens to hundreds of dollars per year.
Now, a lot of gold dealers will dismiss whether or not these are necessary,
probably because they want you to buy it and realize that you can hold it without having expensive carrying costs.
But let's call a spade a spade here.
A house that gets broken into or gold that's buried in the yard that gets found,
or where you completely forget that you even buried it there or you forget where you buried it,
can be a very costly mistake.
And professional vaults charge anywhere from half a percent to 1.5 percent of the value,
depending on the segregation.
So in other words, if you want it so you always get your exact gold back, it costs more.
And if you don't mind it being part of a bigger pool, well, it's maybe a little bit less.
But it's still significantly more than the cost of holding it in an ETF.
And the reality here is that you don't really need to hold it
unless you think you're going to have to use it for something one day.
And if you're carrying a large percentage of your portfolio in gold,
well, there's a really high likelihood that it's not in your best interest to actually hold it physically.
Not to mention that these storage costs, they're recurring costs, not one time.
Now, a lot of dealers, they'll tell you that gold is one of those things that you can hold tax-free.
But that's not necessarily true.
And in the event that you do try to avoid paying the taxes on it,
it can often mean that you're doing effectively tax evasion.
In many U.S. states, bullion and coins are exempt from sales taxes, but not all of them.
A patchwork of thresholds and exemptions apply.
And several states actually changed the rules in 2025.
Florida expanded the exemptions,
while Maryland and Washington moved towards repeal in specific timeframes.
This creates a map risk where the same purchase has very different upfront tax costs
depending on the location.
And when you sell at a profit, U.S. tax treatment matters.
Precious metal ETFs are grantor preps,
so long-term gains are taxed as collectibles up to 28 percent,
different from the 15 to 20 percent rates many expect for stocks.
Physical holdings can fall under the same collectibles umbrella.
It isn't a blanket, there's no tax on physical gold and silver policy.
You have to plan accordingly,
and you have to be wary of the risk if you don't disclose your purchases and your sales.
And quite often, the after-tax results can surprise people.
By contrast, ETFs minimize spread and storage noise.
The 0.1 percent fee is smaller than a typical Silver Eagle buy spread,
by a factor of almost 100.
Even an ETF like GLD at 0.4 percent or SLV, a 0.5 percent annual fee,
plus tiny trading spreads are usually trivial next to physical premiums and shipping.
This doesn't make ETFs better in every way,
just more cost-efficient for price exposure.
So if you're purchasing gold purely to have it as a hedge against your portfolio,
and you just want to be exposed to the potential run-ups in prices,
ETFs are actually a significantly better option.
Now, if you're buying it because you think you may need to use it to be able to purchase bread one day,
that's a whole different story.
So let's take a look at a few case studies.
Silver Eagles versus the ETF SLV.
Suppose you spend $10,000 on Silver Eagles at $58.84 per coin.
That's about 170 coins.
If a common dealer buyback is $49.31,
your immediate round-trip loss, the day you buy it, is 16 percent.
And that's before tax and shipping, depending on what state you live in.
If silver spot rises 10 percent,
your coins might still sell below break-even because the spread hasn't changed.
In other words, you need a larger price move just to claw back the original investment.
For the same $10,000 in SLV, the ETF,
you pay a brokerage commission, often $0 at many brokers,
and a spread near 0.02 percent.
Then there's a small management fee of 0.5 percent over the years.
If silver rises 10 percent, most of that move actually reaches you.
You can get in and out quickly and still reap the returns based on the elevation of price.
The ETF still carries collectible taxes,
but the path to break-even usually requires a smaller price move than with high-premium coins.
Then if you look at gold eagles versus an ETF like GLDM,
at $4,200 to $4,250 for a one-ounce gold eagle,
a $10,000 budget buys approximately two coins.
Spreads on gold eagles are typically narrower than silver eagles,
but they're still meaningful.
With GLDM, the all-in cost is largely the 0.1 percent annual fee and a tiny trading spread.
When gold moves, ETF holders capture the change with minimal leakage.
Coin buyers not only need the move, but they need an additional move to cover the premium.
Now, let's talk about when the dealer is the edge.
The SEC's 2025 Final Judgment against Safeguard Metals
documented average markups of 64 percent on silver coins sold to retirees,
orders of magnitude above normal bullion spreads.
The point isn't that every dealer behaves this way.
It's that information asymmetry lets bad actors exploit anxious buyers.
And there are a lot of anxious buyers out there,
ones that aren't doing their research and don't understand the basic fundamentals of how dealers work.
And this is especially true around IRAs.
Policies exist, but enforcement is after the fact.
In other words, the SEC doesn't come to the rescue until somebody has already basically stolen your money.
Then there's the sales tax surprises.
A Texas buyer might pay zero sales tax on qualifying bullion.
A Maryland buyer after mid-2025 may owe 6 percent.
Same asset, different out-the-door price.
Over large orders, tax becomes the single biggest upfront premium.
And not only that, the map can change with legislation.
So the circumstances that you've purchased the gold and silver under today
can be substantially different than what you sell it for down the road.
Then there's the liquidity benefit.
So if you need cash on a Tuesday afternoon,
you can sell an ETF instantly and at transparent prices.
With coins, you're literally at the mercy of the dealer,
the shipping, and the settlement time that it takes in order to ship and sell them the gold and silver.
And the crazy thing is, is they get to make the rules.
Not only that, but there's also an authentication risk.
The gold and silver that you bought, you may think is real, but it may not be.
And the dealers have to authenticate this.
And many people find that what they think is worth $4,000 or $5,000
is actually worth no more than pennies based on the actual metal that is in it.
And there's a hidden mechanism to this whole process, this whole dealer world,
and it's incentives.
Authorized purchasers and wholesalers, they make really thin margins on large volumes.
Retailers end up earning more profit per unit.
As a result, retailer marketing pushes buyers towards high margin products,
graded slabs, proofs, limited designs, where spreads can balloon.
Some IRA specialists sell collectible coins with opaque pricing.
And I'm not saying don't ever buy those.
What I'm saying is know that the premium is not the metal.
It's often the brand.
Taxes are another mechanism.
The IRS treats long-term gains on bullion and on grant or trust ETFs as collectibles,
capped at 28% for individuals, which is different from stock ETFs.
Many investors only learn this at filing time.
If you plan for 15% to 20%, your after-tax return may be lower than expected.
And by the way, after you pay all the premiums and everything else,
you may end up with a way smaller return than you ever thought possible.
So that 40% to 50% return that you thought you had might only be a 20% or 30% return.
And then you've got to pay taxes on that if you're playing ethically and fairly.
Finally, volatility transmission differs.
ETF spreads tend to remain tight, so you feel price moves directly.
For coins, spreads may widen in busy periods when there's high demand,
making it harder to monetize gains quickly.
When 2025 prices surged, some retail coin premiums rose too.
But buybacks didn't always keep pace.
That basis risk is real.
And here's the reality of it.
As the gold dealers, they want you to buy it from them at whatever the market price is,
but then they also want to buy it back from you at significantly lower prices.
That's how they make the profit.
And by the way, a lot of people argue that gold is one of those things
that protects you from money losing value.
But keep in mind, gold dealers are often very willing
and have a vested interest in trading you their gold and silver.
Or your money that you think at some point is actually going to be worthless.
So you really have to consider this.
Is your gold pure price exposure?
Or is it having something that will protect you
if everything goes to hell in a handbasket and there's an apocalypse?
If it's about exposure, if it's about having the returns of gold, ETFs win hands down.
They win on cost, they win on liquidity, and they win on transparency.
The drag from the fees, it's known, it's transparent.
And the spreads are tiny compared to that of retail gold.
Over three to five years, compounding fee differences of 0.1% to 0.5%
are generally overwhelmed by physicals larger upfront spread.
Even moderate price moves often translate better via ETFs.
In fact, they almost always translate better via ETFs.
So if it's about collecting the returns,
it makes a lot more sense to buy it through your stock portfolio
than it does to buy it through a dealer.
If your goal is emergency portability or hobby collecting,
coins definitely make sense, but only with eyes open.
And it's important that you buy low premium bullion from reputable dealers
and you keep purchase invoices.
Because if and when you get audited, you're going to need them.
You also need to make sure you're comparing published buyback quotes before buying
so that you know with eyes wide open what the spread is the day that you buy it.
And you should also be aware of the tax issues.
And if threshold exemptions apply.
So for example, if you own over $500 in some states,
it may be treated differently if you own less than $500.
If you already hold coins, track the exit prices, not the spot values.
Write down the current dealer buyback quote and compare it monthly to spot.
That simple habit converts mystery into breakeven numbers that you can actually plan on.
And it often motivates investors to use ETFs for incremental exposure going forward.
So you get your base physical gold, the stuff that you think you need in case things go bad.
And then any additional gold that you want to add to your portfolio,
you buy using ETFs so that you can reap the rewards of the lower costs.
So let's look at this one last time, side by side.
$10,000 into Silver Eagles at $58.84 versus $10,000 into SLV.
If silver rises 15% in a year, SLV's fee and spread might leave you with a 14.4% before tax profit.
Eagles could still show less because you must cross the spread.
You have exactly the same metal exposure, but you have completely different returns
and a different pathway with different types of friction.
With gold, if you take $10,000 and you put it into one ounce gold eagles,
you'd get basically two of them versus GLDM where you can buy exactly $10,000 worth.
And a 10% gold move could net you in the ETF a 9.9% before tax return.
Coin outcomes, again, are going to depend on the premium you paid and the buyback you'll receive.
Even if you avoid sales tax and store cheaply,
the ETF's structural efficiency will almost always win for pure price tracking.
So I need to make this really clear once again.
This isn't anti-gold. It isn't anti-silver.
And it isn't an anti-coin argument. It's a systems argument.
In 2025, the world's biggest gold buyers, central banks, kept accumulating.
And ETFs saw powerful inflows.
Those forces can support the metal's price.
But at the consumer level, distribution, spreads, taxes, and storage still decide whether you capture that price.
If your goal is exposure, if it's returns, the ETF route is designed to deliver it.
If your goal is possession, understand the trade.
You're paying for form, not just metal.
The takeaway is simple.
Decide why you want gold or silver, then choose the instrument that aligns with that why.
If it's price exposure, ETFs win.
If it's a hobby or a hedge you literally want to hold, coins can be fine.
But only if you can buy them at low premiums from reputable dealers with exit quotes you track.
Either way, understand the system and make it work for you, not the other way around.
Oh, and if you want to see my whole story that summarizes pretty much why you shouldn't buy physical gold and silver,
and why most people are not equipped to do so, make sure you check out this video right here.
