החוקים למניעת הטרדה בקליפורניה משמשים כעת אוניברסיטאות ציבוריות במדינה כדי לאלץ סטודנטים לאמץ את האידיאולוגיה הטרנסג'נדרית, אחרת, הם עלולים לאבד את זכותם ללמוד במוסד.
כך למשל, "ההדרכה למניעת הטרדה מינית ואפליה" באוניברסיטאות אלה מגדירה סירוב להשתמש ב"כינויי המגדר" של אדם טרנסג'נדר או התנגדות לנוכחות גברים טרנסג'נדרים בשירותי נשים כיצירה של "סביבה עוינת".
כתב NTD דניאל מונהאן שוחח עם ארין מרסינו, עורכת דין למשפט חוקתי המובילה תביעה לבית המשפט העליון של ארה"ב נגד הנחיות אלה.
California's harassment prevention laws are now being used by state universities
to compel students to affirm transgender ideology. In some more sobering news,
or they may risk losing access to their education.
That's right. NTD's Dana Monahan spoke with a constitutional attorney,
Aaron Mercino, about this controversy. Have a look at that.
Under new state mandates, students must complete an online sexual harassment and
anti-discrimination course that broadens the definition of harassment. The University of
California's version known as SHAPE, for Sexual Harassment Anti-Discrimination Prevention and
Education, defines refusing to use transgender pronouns or objecting to males in women's
restrooms as creating a hostile environment. Students must answer quiz questions consistent
with those views. Those who fail cannot register for classes the next semester.
And so it makes a person who believes in following, you know, biology and the
biological distinctions between a man and a woman, it puts them in the position where
they're being accused of sexual harassment for this training.
Chief of Supreme Court litigation Aaron Mercino says there's strong Supreme Court precedent
dating back to the 1940s that makes this kind of compelled speech unconstitutional.
West Virginia versus Barnett is really the quintessential case on compelled speech.
And in that case, students were being required to stand up and recite the Pledge of Allegiance.
And it was against their beliefs. And the Supreme Court said that students cannot be required to
stand up and engage in compelled speech that is different than what they believe.
At the heart of the issue, Mercino says, is that the state cannot decide what ideology
people are allowed to hold.
This ideology is correct. This one is harassment. This one is violence.
When what we're talking about are beliefs, political beliefs and religious beliefs.
And here, the state of California is requiring good shape training, compelled speech.
Mercino says university campuses should be a beacon of academic freedom.
But here, it seems like they're just telling students
what they must believe instead of giving any sort of dialogue
to the different political beliefs or religious beliefs that are truly in place here.
Mercino says many professors who disagree stay quiet to protect their jobs.
The attorney says there is a clear line between promoting inclusion and infringing on free speech.
So I think the line is when they require people to adopt a certain ideology in terms of
gender identity and requiring people to adopt certain political beliefs and religious beliefs
and to state something that is against their own beliefs. So that's really at the heart of
compelled speech is when the government forces you to say something that you don't believe yourself.
Mercino says the weight of freedoms is on everyone's shoulders,
and it's increasingly falling on the shoulders of young people.
In the shape training, one required question reads,
my name is Mona and I am transgender. Jane continues to call me James
and objects to me using the women's restroom. What type of prohibited conduct can this be?
The only accepted answer, hostile environment.
Shape was developed in response to AB 2608,
a 2024 law requiring all students to undergo updated sexual harassment and discrimination
training based on broader definitions. Daniel Monaghan, NTD News.