Finally swapping SCHD to this Value ETF (time for more gains)

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
SCHD has long been an ETF that I've loved,
and in the past it's been amazing.
But this year, and honestly the last couple of years,
it's obviously underperformed the rest of the market
pretty substantially.
The whole point to invest in SCHD is the safety
it provides in a terrible market,
of which we haven't seen yet.
So don't lose hope.
But I also found a substitute,
or at least something to add to SCHD
in your safer portion of the portfolio
that you should be very excited about.
For those of you that do invest in SCHD
and you understand why you should be investing in that,
but maybe wanna diversify a bit,
I've got a good one for you.
My name's Nolan Gobeya, my students call me Professor G,
and I made this channel to make investing simplified.
Remember that all investing carries risks,
so do your own research.
This is not financial advice,
and I'm not a financial advisor.
Now pretty much every serious investor and analyst agrees
that the stock market is incredibly overvalued right now,
specifically as it relates to technology and AI.
So the smart investors are moving a portion
of the portfolio to value,
which is why I love SCHD so much,
because it has very little tech,
and it's a good value play.
But let me introduce you to VTV,
which is the Vanguard value ETF,
and this year it's up 11.65%,
while SCHD is actually down negative 0.51%.
So it's similar between the two.
Both are U.S. large cap equity ETFs,
so they're exposed to big U.S. companies.
Both have relatively low expense ratios
compared to many mutual funds or actively managed funds.
For example, VTV's about 0.04%,
and SCHD is 0.06%.
Both are passively managed,
they track an index rather than being actively picked,
and since they both invest in large cap stocks
and they're both value-oriented,
they do have a little bit of overlap,
but you'll see in a second
that it's not as much as you think.
So that's how they're very similar,
but as far as differences,
this is what you should pay attention to.
VTV tracks the CRSP U.S. large cap value index
via Vanguard's value ETF.
SCHD tracks the Dow Jones U.S. dividend 100 index.
This is U.S. stocks with strong and consistent dividends
filtered for quality and yield.
VTV is basically more purely value
regardless of the dividend yield,
whereas SCHD factors in the idea of cash flow
while still having that value tilt.
VTV holds many more stocks, hundreds,
and is more broadly diversified
across large cap value companies.
VTV has over 300 holdings while SCHD has about 100.
SCHD's universe is more concentrated
and with criteria around dividends.
That means it's somewhat less diversified
compared to VTV's broad value tilt.
Now, as far as dividend yield,
which is very important to some of you
as far as why you'd want to invest
in one rather than the other,
SCHD tends to have a higher current dividend yield
because it filters for strong dividend payers.
At the time of this recording,
SCHD has a yield of around 3.8%,
whereas VTV has about a 2.1% dividend yield.
When we're looking at the different sectors
that they're invested in
and especially the different top 10 holdings,
this is where things get a little bit different,
which is actually very exciting for the portfolio.
Looking at the sectors,
VTV has a strong amount in financials,
industrials, healthcare,
and one of the most important things here is very low tech.
As far as SCHD, their top three are energy,
consumer staples, and healthcare,
but look here, also very low technology.
When you're looking for a true value ETF,
the whole point is to keep yourself safer
and to get out of those higher tech
or higher exposure to AI type ETFs,
and so we wanna make sure and look at the sectors
to make sure that technology is a lot lower in these
for that specific reason.
But looking at the top 10s,
let's look at the difference in companies they hold.
In the top 10 for VTV,
we have companies like JP Morgan, Berkshire Hathaway,
Exxon, Walmart, Johnson & Johnson, AbbVie, and Home Depot.
Looking at the top 10 for SCHD,
we have AbbVie and then Cisco, Merck,
Pepsi, Amgen, Coca-Cola, and Lockheed Martin.
Additionally, the overlap between the two funds is modest.
Only 12% of VTV's holdings by number are also in SCHD.
About 36% of SCHD's holdings by weight are in VTV.
VTV has somewhat lower volatility historically
compared to SCHD in one comparison.
So let's look at the performance, and this is a big thing
because right now a lot of people don't like
that SCHD hasn't been doing amazing.
So let's look at the difference between performance,
both short-term and long-term.
If we look at just the past six months,
there's a huge difference, obviously.
The green is VTV, and that tan color is SCHD.
Obviously, VTV's crushing it.
But the performance on a long-term basis,
look at the last 10 years, VTV versus SCHD, it's very close,
even taking into consideration this last couple of months
where VTV's been going crazy.
Short-term performance diverges
depending on market conditions.
Dividend stocks might lag or lead
depending on interest rates and market sentiment.
Now, just knowing how they're different
or similar is very good, but not the whole picture.
Let me explain what holding either of these
or both of them may look like in the portfolio
and how I'd invest in them in 2026.
First though, thank you to investing.com
for being the sponsor of today's video.
Investing.com is the go-to financial website
that many of us use daily.
When you subscribe as a member, you get access to ProPix
and more specifically ProPix Plus,
which is what I use personally.
This uses artificial intelligence to analyze the market
and gives you a list of the top investment opportunities.
What I love about ProPix Plus
is that it saves me a ton of time.
Instead of spending hours researching stocks,
I can now check their picks
and make informed decisions in minutes.
As an investing pro member,
you don't only get access to ProPix,
but a whole suite of other powerful tools.
For example, there's an ideas section
where you can look into and copy the strategies
of legendary investors like Warren Buffett.
They also have a stock screener
with over a thousand metrics you can filter by
to find exactly the stocks your portfolio is missing.
I use the ProPlus on investing.com,
which gives me 65 plus predefined stock screens,
1,200 plus premium metrics for stocks.
The ProPlus is for investors who want hedge fund grade data
and research capabilities to find strategic opportunities.
The best part, investing.com is running a sale,
but I managed to get an extra 15% off for you all.
This means you get the lowest price of the year
on an investing pro subscription.
Click the link in the description to subscribe
and start using ProPix today.
This offer is only available for a limited time,
so don't miss out.
All right, so I've shown you how both VTV or SCHD
are both great ETFs and ones that are probably
gonna be amazing within the portfolio.
So which one should we choose?
If your main goal is simply broad exposure
to US large cap value stocks,
so basically you believe value stocks will outperform
over the long horizon and you want broad diversification
and less focus on a dividend yield,
then VTV may be the simpler choice.
If your goal is more income oriented,
like you want more dividends,
perhaps you're in or nearing retirement,
you like the higher current yield,
then SCHD may appeal more.
But with the trade-off that you may have
less diversification and maybe different risks
slash return behavior.
VTV gives you a broad value tilt,
SCHD gives you a value plus dividend quality tilt.
So it basically comes down to what is it exactly
that you're looking for?
In general, right now, I would suggest that we look towards
trying to get a little bit out of growth
and getting more towards value.
I know that that seems kind of crazy
because everywhere you look, AI stocks
and technology stocks or ETFs are just booming like crazy,
and that's true.
I'm not saying totally exit fully your growth stuff.
I'm just saying if you have something like 30 or 40%
in growth, maybe take 10% off the top
and move that over to value and by doing so,
you might be able to further diversify
by putting it into two ETFs rather than just one.
Especially if you don't care about the dividends
at this point, VTV is a great option.
You should though consider the tax implications.
So basically, understand,
are you trying to put this in a brokerage account
or is this gonna go into an IRA, Roth IRA,
something like that?
Within the brokerage account,
you are being taxed as you get the dividend.
And so if you wanna keep taxes down,
you may wanna keep dividends down,
but you still wanna have value,
so your best bet there might be to go heavier VTV
in the brokerage account and maybe a little bit lighter SCHD
in the brokerage account.
But then if we're talking about a retirement account,
you're not being taxed on those dividends as you go anyways,
you'll be taxed later on within withdrawal,
depending on if you have a Roth IRA
versus a traditional IRA.
If you have a Roth IRA,
you don't have to worry about taxes in any way,
but that's a different video.
But within those retirement accounts,
maybe have more SCHD there where the VTV
is more so gonna be better suited in your brokerage account.
I like both in both accounts to be honest,
but if you're very worried about having too many dividends
or whatever the case may be,
or you just wanna diversify, it's a good option.
So if I were to pick one for the typical long-term investor
and specifically in a brokerage account,
if this person has 10 or 20 years investing horizon
and they have like a moderate risk profile,
but you're looking for growth,
you're looking for appreciation of the fund
and have like a little bit of income,
a smaller dividend possibly,
I'd lean a little bit more towards VTV
for that broader diversification,
it's probably gonna have a little bit higher
of just price appreciation,
but again, it's gonna have much lower dividends,
long-term and cashflow later on when you might want that.
But if the investor is very much like,
no, I care more about the income,
I want there to be a solid value,
I want it to be very low tech exposure
because I want my risk to be mitigated.
And very much if this person was saying,
well, it's in a retirement fund anyway,
so we don't have to worry about taxes,
then my favorite is for sure SCHD.
I personally still stick with the heaviest portion
of my value being in SCHD
and I will for the foreseeable future.
I've made many videos on why I love SCHD
and why I believe it's a long-term play.
Yes, in the short term, it's been underperforming,
but that's kind of normal for why the whole fund
was made in the first place.
When tech and AI start to die out or stall,
look to see SCHD come up,
especially as these rate cuts continue to get cut
and it's gonna be much more favorable
for people to put their money into something moderately safe
with a good solid cashflow return
of close to 4% in dividend.
There is a scenario where I add VTV
specifically into my brokerage to keep those taxes down
because I am trying to increase my amount of value
because value over these next five to 10 years,
I think is gonna be the play and that's where I wanna be.
To learn more, to keep you going strong
in your investing journey, watch either of these videos
and remember to keep investing simplified.
