A Look Ahead To 2025 - Part II With Rich & Mark | Hodinkee Radio

Charm Diamond
62 followers
#watch, #luxurywatch, #wristwatch, #timepiece, #watchlover, #watchcollection, #watchaddict, #fashionwatch, #menswatch, #womenswatch, #smartwatch, #vintagewatch, #automaticwatch, #chronograph, #swisswatch
Welcome back to another episode of Houdinki Radio.
Today's episode of the show is sponsored by our friends at
Berklotty, the award-winning whiskey from Isla, who we have
partnered with here at Houdinki for the last couple of years.
Stay tuned for an update later in the show on what we're up to this season.
Hello and welcome to another Houdinki Radio episode.
It's actually our last episode of the year and the fourth in our year-end series.
So we did two looking back at 2024.
We did two looking forward to 2025.
I've already recorded and you'll be able to see the one with Malaika and Tantan.
Check that out on YouTube.
We're certainly on the site, but check out the previous episodes for sure.
And now we've got the final episode of the year and I've got editor and
photographer Mark Koslerich and editor Rich Forden joining me today to chat all
about kind of what we think of 2025, what we're excited about, what we're kind of
concerned about, where we think things are going.
Guys, you know, we spent the last episode with you two really chatting about what
it looked like, the trends had been for the last year.
I'm interested in what you, what your sort of predictions are, even at sort of a
broad level, if there's something from this year that you think won't work next
year, something we'll see more of next year.
If there's a play that feels, you know, I feel like the playbook for the last
several years has been vintage inspired design for a lot of watch brands.
Does that playbook still feel relevant?
Do we think there's a new one?
Where do you guys land on this?
Maybe, uh, Rich, you want to, you want to take it away?
Yeah.
Thanks, James.
Um, I had a lot of questions in there.
I think the, I think the topic on, on vintage re-releases or inspiration, um,
we're seeing things that have a bit of into just inspiration already,
but are moving things forward.
Um, I think the industry as a whole is lacking in new designs and some of the
smaller brands are coming in with vintage inspired things that feel very, very new.
So it doesn't have to be like an RM or some crazy Hublot to be a
new, fresh design to the watch world.
I mean, there's a lot of like open space to run in when you look at watches.
So, um, I would expect continual tying to heritage product with
brand story and product story, but offering something that's truly
different and trying to move things forward.
Um, which I think the watch world could use a lot of.
How about you, Mark?
What do you think?
You feel similar?
Yeah.
I mean, you asked, you asked what I was concerned about.
Um, I don't know that we have enough, enough time for that.
And I don't know that it's on topic for this podcast, but at the end of the
year, this could also just be the airing of the grievances, let's, let's just get
into it now, um, I like to cigarette.
Um, no, I mean, I, I have similar sort of general concerns.
I don't know that Rich framed them as concerns, but like there's,
there's so much repetition.
And, um, you know, I think a lot of people might be surprised at the number
of, um, you know, pulled emails and pitches and messages to my, uh, Instagram
and messages to my personal email, which I specifically, the only place it's
listed, I specifically say, don't send watch pitches to this email,
but people still do it anyway.
And I would say like 80% of them look the same.
It's, it's hard to imagine that when we see things like burner on or other
brands coming out with creative things.
And I think that's great and necessary, but it's so hard because you don't
want to be mean to people that are trying really hard and doing something
new, but it's hard to, for me to sit and look at somebody and find a way to
say like your dive watch that looks like everybody else's dive watch isn't
maybe necessarily the thing that the market needs right now, or might not be
successful.
I do have a concern as we talk about like the trends of the market economically
and a lot of like hemming and hawing about downtrends and prices going down.
I'm a little worried about, um, how many micro brands, smaller brands like
this brands that aren't bringing something unique to the table will
survive in 2025.
Um, so not to start out or end the year on a depressing note, but that's
something that I've been thinking about for a while.
I think that's a, that's an interesting concern.
And I think there's a couple examples here of like things that I predicted
years ago, but of course I was just like dead wrong.
I thought that we would have been totally tired by the vintage trend now.
And instead we have a major brand relaunching, you know, universal Chanel.
Clearly we're not tired of this, uh, as, as a whole, maybe it works better
with UG cause they're, they straddle the line with some sporty elements,
but very dressy as well versus, you know, a purely sort of mid-century
sport watch brand.
And then at the same time, I think I also said that, yeah, probably 2018,
2019, I thought it was going to be a pretty tough time out there for micro
brands, especially those in the, you know, the budget categories, the
Kickstarter brands, things like that.
And it feels like they've also enjoyed quite a bump in the, in the resulting
years from, uh, the increase in attention during the pandemic, but then also into
what we've seen post pandemic with, uh, kind of a lot of price sensitivity,
bringing more focus to these brands that are able to make a watch that people can
be excited about for 1500 bucks or less, something like that.
Yeah.
Now, now that price sort of that, that price point has moved up a little bit.
I think, you know, it's, it is harder to keep things under $1,500.
We were, we were talking about this for year end recaps is, you know, give me a
couple extra hundred dollars and I can find something pretty good, but that
budget mark is, is harder to meet.
I do have, I have a question for Rich actually, as somebody that pays attention
to the vintage market, secondary market, um, these sort of revival brands and stuff.
I assume that 2025 will finally be the year of Urban Jurgensen.
Um, we've been waiting for a while.
We missed, I think the 250th anniversary.
I still see a lot of them come up for market.
A lot of dealers asking about them.
Carol posting Urban Jurgensen all the time.
A collected man just posted one.
Is that a sign that there's still demand?
Is it people trying to get ahead of hype by like gathering
resources and holding onto them?
Or do you think Urban Jurgensen is going to actually have like a pretty
successful launch when it happens?
Yeah, I think it gets into its output of like how brands are doing re-launches
or Urban Jurgensen is a vintage inspired brand whenever Pari decides to come out
with it, which you will never hold him to a date as we've learned, but what I like
to think of for vintage inspired brands, and this gets into UG as well, is that
like the lawn jeans playbook from 2014, 2015 is been played and does not work
anymore.
Like they did a great job.
They were probably the best big brand to bring back a heritage line that was super
inspired by things and make it a little bit bigger, make it wearable, make it
palatable to their customer, which is a more consumer level customer, but also
draw in the attention from enthusiasts who maybe can't find that vintage thing
or think it's a bit too small.
I think that playbook's done.
I don't want UG to do that playbook.
Nobody does, but it's still a very, very fine line to walk.
We'll see what UG does.
Obviously, they've already done one watch, which is in very low quantities, which is
more of that one-to-one playbook, but I understand that's not the direction going
forward, which I'm almost, I'm glad to hear, you know, I'd rather you see that
name be used as something to move watches forward with a great heritage to tie to
rather than just say, you don't want to go on eBay and buy a UG, you can walk into
the store now.
How about that?
Like, I don't want that.
Nobody wants that.
On the Urban Jurgensen topic, you know, interest is still growing.
Rose gold reference three just did, I think, 65 at Philips or Sotheby's in New
York, which is a really good number for that watch.
I think that's the number they should sit at.
It's a perpetual calendar.
It's really, really amazingly finished from the dial, hands, and taste
perspective, but I think there's a bit of speculation going on.
The interesting thing about your Urban Jurgensen to me is the man that owned or
was very involved in brand, he didn't own it, Peter Baumgartner did, but his best
friend was Dr.
Helmut Kraft, who is still very active in the watch scene.
I was in Geneva.
The first night I was there, I was shown by someone who actually works for a
collective man, what was told to me as a unique white gold reference three, which
is when you find them in white metal, it's most often platinum.
And he was showing it to a couple of people around this party I was at, and I
was like, that's really cool.
I wrote a whole story about reference twos and threes, never saw one in white
gold before, ran into Helmut Kraft the next night and he's like, oh yeah, we
made like 10, 15 of those.
I don't remember exactly how many, but definitely not unique.
So it's interesting when vintage collecting gets this point of like,
when, whenever we think about truths in vintage collecting, it's always like in
this distant past, which you can never know, it's almost like archeology, but
with urban Jorgensen, but the guy who bought the backstop and all the archives
is like still around.
So you can ask him, which I think actually can kind of hurt a brand when
information is super set in stone like that, or, you know, whether he's willing
to give it or not, it was just to me in conversation, he might not even like me
sharing it here.
But, um, as a collecting sort of community, I think it's better for the
market when things are a bit more like Rolex than they are Patek where it's
like, yeah, you know, this case and this dial come from the same year.
Let's accept that that's correct.
Whereas Patek it's like, if it's not on the extract, that's not your dial.
Um, which urban Jorgensen should it sort of mature a ton that style of collecting.
Um, it's probably more towards the Patek side of things where we know what the
watches were when they were first made.
Um, when I look at Kari's relaunch, I tried to get information out of him when
I wrote that article, I think it was about a year ago.
I've tried many times, so don't, don't worry that you didn't get much, even so
much as like, are you going to use the same lugs, which are very unique on urban
Jorgensen's from the nineties that I love so much, like the very small, like
turtle lugs, but super, super tiny teardrops.
And he was like, I won't even say that much.
So, I mean, we'll see the direction, uh, the guilloche dials that were in urban
Jorgensen made by Derek Pratt and his team probably will be carried through to
Kari's iteration because that's, you know, also his specialty, but beyond that, I'm
just waiting and seeing, and I'm not going to, I'm not setting a calendar,
um, reminder for that one.
We'll see.
Again, special thanks to our partners at Brooklaty for the support of Houdinki
radio this holiday season.
We've partnered with Brooklaty on a special giveaway that you can learn all
about in the link in the article below or in the notes for this episode, you might
be surprised at what you see and you most definitely don't want to miss it.
And now back to the show.
One thing that we touched on, uh, while getting into the urban Jorgensen line,
there was pricing of watches these days.
Do you guys think that there's a pricing problem?
I think we definitely see it in the comments where pretty much any watch comes
out at almost any price and the pushback is like, Hey, I'm interested in this, but
like, why this number?
And there's a new level of price sensitivity that comes from the level of
inflation and other things we've been experiencing outside of just watch
pricing, but I think it also has an effect on watch pricing.
And I think that in many ways it feels as though pricing has kind of outstripped,
uh, the normal kind of growth that pricing can go through over a period of
time.
Where do you guys land on, on pricing?
Cause value still feels okay, but there's definitely examples of stuff
that feel real spicy.
It's tough to say because, uh, there's one watch in particular that I talk
about a ton.
I, every time I look at their website, it seems like, Oh, we can get an extra $500
out of you.
You can get another $500 out of you.
And I like, I look away for two seconds, I come back and it's $500 more.
Um, and that's not really how it is, but when you set in your mind like, Oh, this
was good at, you know, 10,100 and then it's 10,500 and then it's 11,000.
The last time I looked at, uh, this watch and it was the SLGW003, the manual
line, Grand Seiko, that's crept up and it literally just came out this year.
So I was a little, I was a little surprised at that, but then there's also, I
think the hardest thing maybe for some people, first of all, like understanding
that your frame of reference for what a watch is worth is formed when you start
looking at that watch and maybe if the watch or that framework of watches,
whether it's Speedmasters have been out for ages, and some people have been
looking at Speedmasters for 10 years and thinking, Oh, you know, Speedmaster
should be X price and now it's X plus two or $3,000.
Um, you're going to feel that, that hit for the pricing a lot more.
And then the other side of it too, is when you compare against other people
on the market or even within the brand, I think it becomes very easy to become
very price sensitive and a little surprised.
Um, I, I mentioned maybe to you James the other day, but I was going through the
Rolex catalog and I did not realize that there's only like a $600 Delta
between a date Submariner and a GMT.
And that starts to feel a little strange as well.
Like shouldn't the GMT be significantly more complicated and to be, I don't know
if it's a GMT should feel more expensive or a Submariner should feel more like a
more entry level budget option or something like that, a little more value
in there, but, um, I think people are paying a lot of attention to all of
those little things and any little movement, any little thing that you can
pick up on in terms of pricing feels really big lately.
We're also just seeing new watches come out at what feels like more than they
would have come out at just a couple of years ago.
So it's not just the progressive percentage added on to a line
of successfully working watches.
It's like new watches come in and you go like, well, okay, I guess that's the price.
Like the Speedmaster that, uh, I wrote about the pilot Speedmaster.
I think people were sort of surprised at the price on that.
And it's what I, it's sort of what I was alluding to when, when you're used to a
Speedmaster of some sort being worth, you know, maybe say under $8,000 and a new one
comes out and all of a sudden it's significantly more than that, even though
there's nothing, uh, you know, that you can do a direct one-to-one correlation
for a new model, even if there's small changes, like mechanical, this one's an
automatic, it has a hundred meters of water resistance or whatever, but you,
you've sort of already framed your expectation of what a Speedmaster can be.
And even though those have now crept up over $8,000, you know, something that's
getting closer to 10 just feels really sort of outside, um, what you're used to,
whether or not it's a good value for the specs or whatever.
Rich, what do you think?
Yeah, I think on the modern watch side, obviously is what we're talking about
here, where the brands let me down a lot of times is that I, I do not think that
these large modern brands are hurting for margin.
Um, so yes, you can give them excuses of inflation costs being higher.
Um, and they just pass those right on to consumers without wanting to, I mean,
with wanting to sort of maintain their previous margins, which we don't know
for a lot of brands, but I know they're, they're very healthy, right?
Like I would like to see a bit more respect of price bands by the brands to
not push themselves out of something just because costs are rising,
given macro economic factors.
I can come to this question from, I used to work on the shop side and be more on
the merchandising and buying side.
And I can give credit to a former colleague, Saori Omura here.
Um, she was a master at pricing when we did our vintage drops and we would have
conversations all the time of this is a great wash.
It has to be under seven because once you creep over seven, even if it's $7,200
that you're asking, you're asking someone to spend 10,000, you know, if there's
certain barriers in watch pricing, where it starts to become feeling like you're
spending more and if you keep it under those barriers, it feels like you're
spending less, for example, like 38 is way closer to spending three grand than it is
to spending five grand mentally, even though you're spending five grand, like
after tax, after everything, um, there are these certain, and excuse me if I'm
getting a bit too high minded, but we used to think about it a lot is like,
what is the psychological process of somebody clicking that buy button?
And if we can move the price couple hundred dollars and make someone feel a
lot better about their purchase, then that's not a return.
That's also a happy customer.
You know, like there are certain things that you can do specifically on the, we
would do that work on the buy side with the seller and say, Hey, can we knock a
hundred bucks off this price?
We want to keep it under here.
So it sells quickly and we have a happy customer brands can do that too, where
they say we're going to give up a hundred dollars, $200 of margin to make our
customer feel a bit better by keeping it a speedy, what is it under seven grand
instead of a little bit over, like that's a big barrier.
Am I right there?
I think last time I checked speedy pricing, but
plus or minus a thousand, I think, but yeah.
Yeah.
I mean, the same cycle, like psychology can apply to the difference between seven
and eight, you know, those, especially when you're under 10 grand, it's very,
very sensitive, even a couple of hundred bucks.
Um, and I would like to see brands respect that further.
I don't think they need to, I don't think they will, but I'll just call it out and
say something I wish they cared more about.
No, I, and I like, I like the position of like making the recommendation
essentially, like you, you, this is something people should be focusing on.
I just think, you know, there's eras.
Everything's a push and a pull, right?
The swing of the pendulum and there's areas where price
sensitivity is very low, 2021, 2022.
And there's areas where it's quite high.
And I think, you know, a lot of us can remember even like 2015, 2014.
Uh, we saw like a lot of kind of adjustments to the market in terms
of pricing and that sort of thing.
And I I'm, I'm definitely curious to continue on this trend of like how we
might approach these sorts of things.
So like, just for fun for 2025, you're going to be, we've got a handful of
brands I've got on the list here, the CEO of a brand, what would you do to kind
of like fine tune something that feels like it would be a good move for 2025?
Why don't we kick it off with like a brand that absolutely
crushed it in 24 with Tudor.
If you guys were, if you guys were going to be in charge of Tudor
for the year or whatever, would you just carry on the same?
Is it more formula one?
Is it less formula one?
Is it more Pelagos, which has definitely been in the playbook
for the last year, or is it less now that that line's quite broad?
Uh, what do you guys think?
I have some hopes and Tudor is an interesting one because I feel like
every once in a while they give you exactly what you want.
Um, I think the black Bay monochrome was kind of that, and it was sort of proof
that it's okay for them to run into Rolex a little bit, I think there's been some
the last few years of, of Tudor being like, we don't want to come too close to
giving you a perfect version of the Rolex you can't get.
Um, so let's give you something that has a little bit of oddity or variety.
We still saw that this year, the black Bay 58 GMT is something that I would
have probably immediately bought.
Um, if it had the, you know, styling of the black Bay GMT with the Pepsi
bezel and, you know, or even, even if they had done the white dial version of
that, you know, but the guilt and everything like that, I think turned a
good number of people off of that watch.
And sometimes that feels like what they're trying to do.
Um, you know, making sure that people think long and hard about what they want,
whether it's, you know, do you actually want the Rolex or are we going to give
you a budget of something that budget pick of something that's going to compete with
Um, I think, you know, I heard the feedback from the FXC GMT.
I don't really, again, I don't necessarily see that as botina.
I see that as a design choice.
Um, but I also see a world in which like, if that was just a black watch with a lot
less color and stuff, it would have been a mass of a much more massive hit with
people.
So if I was, you know, in charge of tutor, which would probably make me, I don't
understand their corporate structure, but it would probably make me in charge of
Rolex as well.
So I guess it's a cop-out, but I would, I would, I don't want to use the word
confidence because I think they're doing a lot of really bold things and confidence
makes it sound like they're not, but like have the confidence to say like, look,
we're not going to be competing necessarily for the same market share.
And so if I'm doing the budget version and I'm giving people exactly what we
want, we are doing the best thing for our customers who probably aren't going to be
buying a Rolex every day.
Anyway, I think the overlap is not as big as they are afraid it will be.
Um, so that, that would be my pick for tutor.
All right.
Rich, you feel any differently, a different strategy in your mind?
I actually feel quite similarly.
Um, tutor does annoy me with their use of color and botina and on products that if
used in a much more toned down color palette would be better products almost
unanimously.
And I think that gets into the Rolex now wanting to compete with Rolex thing and
wanting to give people an option that's lower price point and has a bit more
color is more of a unique sort of motif, I guess it would be.
But, um, I, this Mark's thoughts actually brought me back to a vintage story that
I've heard.
Um, when, when Rolex switched from hollow folded and link oysters to solid and link
oysters, they updated the tutor Submariner as well, which at that time was the same
watch just with a ETA movement.
And it was all black, you know, there was much more similarities between tutor and
Rolex at that point than there are now.
Um, but they updated the tutor oyster to be solid link as well.
And they saw a decrease in Rolex Submariner sales.
I mean, this is of course just a story.
I don't know the actual numbers, but, um, you do see as you move further into the
nineties, they actually revert tutor back to a folded link oyster to make it feel
cheaper and to sort of drive more people towards the Submariner from Rolex.
Um, which I think gets into a lot of the psychology of what tutor and Rolex mean to
that larger brand or foundation, however it's set up now.
Yeah, definitely at the time.
I think, I think that philosophy, I think that the connection between the two brands
is quite different than it was 20 years ago.
Um, but I guess, you know, following the relaunch in the U S to sort of tie up that
point, I think tutor and Rolex are more split now than they were ever in terms of
where they're thought of in the market.
I think when somebody is new and into watches, they might say, Oh yeah, tutor is
the sister brand of Rolex.
And that's why people sort of start to get interested, but I think their customer
bases are so different now, um, that tutor could do more to release products in more
Rolexy colors like the black bay monochrome and not be so afraid of stealing market
share from Rolex, which is just not happening.
Like if you look at the colors Rolex uses, which are very, very toned down, very mass
market, the Pepsi and the Batman and Sprite.
I mean, the Sprite feels crazy.
Even it's just green, you know, like, um, I think tutor could use some of those more
mass market colors and be more successful while also not stealing any, you know,
market share from Rolex.
Yeah.
I would agree.
I would agree if I was put in charge, I would say, let's just try and do a couple
more really conventional watches.
Uh, you know, I think they have such a strong lineup of options.
And then even though that's strong and it's, you know, they, they, they garner a
huge amount of attention in the industry and the rest of it, then they launched
something like the, what we all call the monochrome, the four, the 20, 24, 41
millimeter, uh, black bay.
And you just go like, yeah, but this is, this is the one.
Like it took them however many years of 12 years or whatever, uh, to kind of dig
into that.
And, and I think that they just made a great thing and I would love them to take
that formula and apply it to the GMT and apply it to the 58 in general and the 54
and all this sort of stuff and just kind of keep iterating in that space.
And, you know, hopefully we, we can, we continue to see some cool kind of
avant-garde thinking in the FXD space.
I think it's like the FXD being a sub-brand of the Pelagos gives them some
room to play around, whether it's a, you know, cycling chronograph or, uh, or
something as wild as, as like the, uh, the proper FXD, um, GMT and that sort of
thing.
So I think there's lots of good, uh, on the horizon for them and I'm excited to
see it.
And I mean, obviously we can parlay this right into Rolex.
We've got a handful of brands, so I'm going to say you got two or three
sentences.
What would you do with, uh, Rolex this year?
Mark Daytona, single tone sub dials.
No, yeah, no.
I mean, that's, that's for me that that would be it.
I mean, look, they only did one steel sports watch last year, uh, at watches and
wonders, which I think really people didn't process.
Um, yeah.
Steel Daytona, like the Le Mans with the, the single tone sub dials, um, is
basically, I think everything that anybody's been asking for.
I don't care about the lollipop indices on the sub dials or any of that.
I don't need the red on the bezel.
Just give a classic looking Daytona back to the market.
And, um, I mean, Rolex is printing money already, so I guess I could say they'll
be printing even more money, but, um, that would be it for me.
So thanks, Rich.
Yeah.
I think there's a few small tweaks that Rolex could make to already
existing products like the Submariner.
And I just think of it because Jeff Hilliard is always complaining about the
clasp on his new Submariner in the office.
Rolex like still leans into wanting to create a professional product for this
imagined consumer that's diving deep with their watches, um, or doing the
exact thing that you're supposed to be doing with their professional models.
Um, which is the reason why that clasp is so big and long because of dive
extensions and wanting to, you know, feel like a very stout product for
that, honestly, imaginary consumer.
I I'm sure people are diving.
There's a handful for sure, but it's not, not to the extent that
the Submariner is made.
That's two, two very different numbers.
I don't think you lose much of that consumer or that wearer and a big part
of your brand identity by making the small tweaks to make a watch like the
Submariner a bit more comfortable for everyday life.
And I think that sort of thinking can be trickled down throughout their whole
catalog for those professional models.
Like, Hey guys, we don't have to be so, so professional anymore.
You're making a watch.
I think mass market for the most part, and, uh, debatably luxury according
to some of our team members, but, um, yeah, I think that is long gone for
Rolex, you know, and they're not making a watch for scuba divers anymore.
And, uh, they could do a few small.
I would also say like within the world of Rolex's lineup, they also have the
pro the pro pro diver in the sea dweller.
So I think they would have room to actually make the sub a little bit
more cushy, if you will.
Uh, I, I would love, I would love to see what the next eventual
evolution of the Explorer two is.
Uh, you know, we haven't seen a new, like a fully new take on
that model in quite some time.
Um, but I'm, I'm not playing that.
The guessing game.
We'll get to that in March or whatever, when we run that story with all the
Photoshop's, but I think, I think it's an exciting time, you know, with you guys
on the call, I would love also like, uh, again, try and keep it, keep it tight.
So we can get to a handful of these, but what about the tech?
Is there something you would just, maybe, maybe we go this route.
Doesn't have to be the CEO thing.
What's just something you would love to see from Patek, you know, in a recent,
um, in a recent video that Ben did for the UBS thing, he spoke about wanting
a really genuinely high end take on a time only Patek, something with the
finishing from the higher level models in a, in a very tech forward movement
and that sort of thing is that would you guys just pair it like, is that
something that's kind of universally felt among the tech's fan base?
I would just say simplify for Patek.
Like that's all they really need to do is, um, they have for, for brand that
makes so few watches in a year, they, they have a lot of models they can
simplify, you know, also simplifies maybe some of where they're drawing
inspiration from in their history.
And, you know, look, if I could, if I could have anything, if I could do
like a slightly smaller QP, a chronograph, um, with like a V shape case,
you know, that's not a very, it's a complex movement, but it's
not a very complex demand.
Um, forget like triple step cases or whatever, but just like simplify and
give sort of a little bit more of a classic taste and short, a little bit
less, you know, what do you think?
Yeah.
I think Ben's call out is basically you want Patek to make a
retch up or something on that level.
Um, I would want a similar looking and feeling product, but at the
other end of the pricing spectrum, I'd love to see Patek come out with a
viable, um, less than 38, 39 millimeter Tala Trava that you could enter the
brand with, they just don't have that product right now.
They don't have the entry level.
This is what Patek is time only watch.
Um, which I think is desperately needed.
Okay, cool.
I agree with those for sure.
What about, uh, what about Cartier?
I know certainly Rich, uh, you just did a great story for the magazine
volume 13, a reference points on the tank LC.
Well, what would you love to see from, you know, we had a party at Cartier last
year, we were all in the room, it was a very busy day and they had a lot of
watches, what would you guys love to see, you know, come March, April from Cartier?
Cartier does a lot of what I've already wanted to see, to be honest.
I think of modern brands, they respect their heritage, maybe the best.
Um, that being said, they respect their heritage the best at
the high price point CPCP stuff.
I would like to see that level of thinking and that level of care and,
um, honestly sizing and like case thickness, the effort that they put
towards that CPCP level product is for the consumer, like me, who is really
knowledgeable about their history and understands how those vintage and even
like even from the nineties cases feel and how they wear on your wrist.
Um, I'd like to see that trickle down to, uh, the more commercial product,
like a Sontre that you don't have to spend 80 grand to buy would be amazing.
Mark, what do you figure for Cartier?
That's about what I would say.
I think again, like they, they do a lot of really respectful
things with their heritage.
I, every year they come out with something really interesting.
I think it was the Toussaint that was like the watch that you
could press and it would move.
And, you know, it was, that was kind of a scary thing to witness in person,
this like watch that you could just compress the case, like a pillow and
you can push on it, but it's set with diamonds and stuff like the most
expensive Tide Pod I've ever held.
Just like, this is terrifying, you know, then they do, they do their, you
know, rewind this year, which I think a lot of people thought that they were
crazy for, um, when it came out.
And now it's like in a lot of people's picks for, you know, I think GQ mentioned
it as one of the best watches of the year.
I think a lot of people have come around to it as a crazy idea.
Um, I think that kind of thing, but maybe make it slightly less
limited, slightly more accessible.
Um, I also like, this is a really random thing and maybe they're doing
it or like high-end clients and I don't know, but bring, bring back the
super wild 1920s Cartier mystery clocks.
I don't know who wants them.
I don't know, like who wants to spend a million dollars on a Jade mystery clock,
but I want to see that like sitting in the center of the watches and wonders
display and just be like, okay, cool.
They just brought back this thing that people are going crazy for on the auction
market and they're, I think they're very aware of what the market is, is doing.
So it would be kind of fun to see.
Absolutely.
Well, I got, I got one more for Cartier, um, Sapphire or blue
cabochons on white metal cases.
I just do not like the Ruby or red cabochons on platinum watches.
All right.
Interesting.
Well, there you go.
A few tips for, uh, for Cartier there.
Look, the next one is one of that.
I think is it's a whole different ball game than, than what we've been talking
about, but what about with swatch?
Arguably the kind of the impression brand on the internet of last couple
of years, thanks to moon swatch.
And then, uh, in some ways also scuba 50 downstream of that, what, uh, what
would you guys love to see from swatch?
I talked about this with Malika and Tantan and they had some ideas for.
Watches they would love to see be swatchified like in the same metric
as the moon swatch and the scuba 50.
If we're even dreaming outside of the realm of the swatch group, what brand
do you think would, would offer a really fun platform for that sort of
exploration and that sort of, um, move to bring a brain that we would know
as watch nerds down to a level where a lot, like a lot more people might be
interested in experiencing it and lining up for the product and all that kind of
stuff.
Yeah.
I don't know about like doing a moon swatch related collab or something like
that, but, um, one, I, I know that they've put some online.
I'd like to see them start putting more of these releases online for people.
Um, I think, you know, now that they've slowed down past the moonshine releases
being so frequent, I think the pace is pretty good.
Um, so yeah, I mean, I don't, I don't know what, what I'd like to see is more
options just in their general lineup.
I know they have a ton of, a ton of watches out there.
Um, but I went into a spot store with my mom actually a couple of weeks ago and was
looking for something that might fit her.
And just like, there weren't enough smaller options.
There weren't enough things that really did anything for her.
I was going to buy her one just as a fun gift.
And, and, um, you know, so a couple more options, a couple more fun things, a
couple more simple things, just continue expanding the lineup now that you've
got the eyeballs on the brand.
And again, like, look, you, they know what they're doing with the moon swatch thing.
James, you've said it like people ask us to stop covering it.
We'll stop covering it when they stop reading it, you know, um, the amount of.
Clicks and it's not all about the clicks, but that does show that there is a level
of interest when that comes out.
So who am I to say that we shouldn't cover that?
Rich, what do you figure?
Yeah.
On the collaboration question, I'm still trying to think, but, um, I don't know
why this one popped ahead, popped in mind, but, um, they've done a chronograph.
They've done a dive watch.
I'd like to see something a bit more interesting on the dress side.
Um, like a dressy swatch collaboration, I think would be cool.
I don't think it would be nearly as popular as something like a moon swatch.
And, um, but like, I don't know why this one, obviously it's in the group, but I
actually really like Harry Winston's aesthetic, the case that mimics the front
doors of, uh, their, I think it's their flagship boutique.
I'm not sure.
I don't even know what they call the name or this case these days, but it's
very like architectural.
And, um, I think they might sell four and three to me, but doing a moon or a
swatch collab with Harry Winston in that case, I think would be really cool.
Actually a Harry's watch.
Yeah.
It's got a ring to it.
Yeah.
And it's a totally different product than what we're thinking.
No, probably.
Yeah.
I, uh, yeah, I think it's a fascinating thing to kind of dream about other brands
that this could, that I think it could work on.
I think the craziest one in my mind would be Richard mill, like a
something that captured the case shape and the architecture, but rendered it
not in, you know, nanotubes and TPTs, but rather in, uh, in bioceramic, you
know, obviously the, the issue, there's some issue there with to really
replicate a Richard mill, you usually have some insane complication or
technical side of evolution or, or even just like skeletonization.
So some of that could be kind of difficult, but I do kind of like dream
of that, I think, I think Hublot would be an interesting partner for, for them as
well, like to do a little big bang or, or even something more wild, something
is like in a little bit more of a conceptual space could be really fun.
Uh, yeah, I, I, I don't think the idea is going away.
I think this would be a crazy time for them to like go, ah, we did enough.
It's all good.
I think we'll see more speedies.
I don't know if we'll see more block on.
I, but I'd be surprised if we didn't see more speedies down the road from them.
And I agree with Mark, the thing that I would be changing if I was in charge
I get like, if you just launched the brand new one and it's for a specific color of
the moon, sure.
Yeah.
It's it's store only for the first month or it's store only and they sell them out
and you don't have to put them online, but with anything that's not limited, like
just sell it online, let people buy it.
I have one last idea with this watch thing.
And I thought about it because I have this watch, um, from a retailer in Japan.
And I think it's something that they could maybe do, but, um, you know, you
said they've done other complications.
What about a like push button minute repeater?
Swatch, you know, get somebody to make, I have a quartz minute repeater.
It's so cool.
And it, what's the brand?
It's Shellman retailer.
Yeah.
Shellman in Japan.
And we'll put it in the show notes.
You guys have to see this thing.
It's good.
My jaw jaw dropped for not that much money when, when you showed it to me.
Yeah.
I mean, they're, they're harder and harder to find because they were made in the,
I think in the nineties, late nineties, maybe.
But, um, but you know, it's a Miyota movement.
It's a quartz movement and it has, it's a digital chime.
So it has that digital, like almost eight bit quality, but it kind of
when you leave the door open on your Chevy Lumina.
So, so why, why not do, do that at this watch?
Like, I'm sure it would maybe be a $500 watch, but I'm sure they could figure
out a way to make a, you know, a beeping sound out of a watch.
And then all of a sudden they've got some sort of a minute repeater.
I mean, that's a really fascinating idea because it takes, it kind of takes the
moon swatch idea and flips on its head where they're taking an iconic design
and like a cultural element and making it a swatch.
And with this, imagine if it was a Blancpain or a Breguet or something
like that, where you could really tap into the structure of some very
traditional watchmaking and introduce that as the platform for new enthusiasts.
I think that could be, that's actually, uh, that's cool.
I like that idea.
Uh, look, we are running the clock though.
So I just wanted to leave it up for the last five minutes or whatever we've got.
Anything else you guys are like looking forward to next year,
something you're excited about.
I'm kind of like, I'm stressed about it to be fair, but I'm also kind of excited
to see what Watches and Wonders is going to be like after last year.
I think it's going to be, I'm expecting some fireworks would be my guess.
Yeah.
I mean, I think we were sort of told going into Watches and Wonders last
year that this year was going to be kind of tame, um, or bilge or whatever.
Yeah.
And it was, you know, people, people holding back 2025, nice round number,
you get something interesting coming out.
I think that's fine.
Um, until the, you know, it's like you put off a deadline and all of a sudden you
have, you have 14 assignments that are due at the same time, like it's kind of
exciting to see and, and you hope that it's, it's going to happen.
But now I'm a little stressed about, you know, you've got 12 brands that
are going to have the biggest year.
You've got an anniversary for Vacheron 270th.
You've got an anniversary for AP.
So there, I think there's going to be a lot going on.
The other thing is, is when you say stuff like that, it, it does push
the expectations up a little bit.
Um, you know, and so it's, it's very possible that like it could be, you
could walk into Watches and Wonders and have the, uh, the like Christmas
day, uh, sort of situation where you open the package and you're like,
Oh, socks, you know, like, uh, you know, you got really excited.
You told people what you wanted and that's what you got, which I've
started to reach the point in my life where socks aren't a terrible gift,
but, um, but if you're expecting a yak back, the socks are tough, you know?
Yeah.
The only one on this call old enough for the yak back.
Understood.
Okay.
Fine.
So Rich, how about you?
Any, any final, final thoughts for 2025?
Um, I'm just thinking about my sort of what I called 2024, which
was the year of the shaped watch.
I think, um, 2025 might be the year of we're tired of the safe shaped watch.
Um, I'm just, I'm just thinking of, uh, the actual buyer and someone who's
interested in something like that is pretty thin and I, I sort of hesitate
with especially the larger brands.
Um, if they're shaped watches on the floor at Watches and Wonders, I think
we're in, we're in trouble, what sort of trouble I think people will just
get tired of that trend and revert back to round and like more
standard designs pretty quickly.
Um, I don't, I'm not calling it because I think there's something
else going on with the crash market.
But if you look at the way the crash has sort of trended downwards, it's
telling me that, um, the buyer for things like that at the highest
level is not a very wide market.
So, um, I think if, if micro brands continue to go into that space and look
into different shapes, although I'm all for it, I'll, I'll love them every time.
Um, I think sort of the mass watch world might sort of flinch if, uh, if brands
and smaller brands continue to enter into this shaped, uh, like interesting
design led, uh, markets.
Nice.
Yeah.
Good feedback and a good thought.
I had the shaped shaped trend on, on the list and we didn't quite get to it.
That's how these pods go.
I'm sure we'll have lots of fresh conversations in the new year, but I
wanted to thank both you guys for coming on and closing out 2024 with me.
Up in champagne.
Now, is this how it's fun?
Let's do it.
Yeah.
I don't, this will probably run like right around new year.
So one of us, somebody will be getting some champagne for sure.
I should have had like sparklers or something ready for the, yeah.
You guys didn't bring caviar and champagne.
We'll just have, we'll put all that in digitally.
It'll be okay.
We'll use the AI.
It'll be fine.
But yeah, thank you so much for listening and to you guys for coming on the show.
And if you're listening and want to get in on the conversation about what you think
2025 is going to be like, what your favorite parts of 2024 were major watches
releases you're hoping to see next year.
The rest of it hit the show notes and you'll find the comments just below
that on hooding key.com and certainly a great conversation over on YouTube as well.
So thanks so much for listening this year.
And we'll be back in early 2025 with more.
Take care.
